Abstract
Background In areas where Plasmodium falciparum malaria is highly seasonal, a dry season reservoir of blood-stage infection is essential for initiating transmission during the following wet season, bridging transmission seasons several months apart. Understanding infections during the dry season could thus inform approaches for malaria control.
Methods In The Gambia, a cohort of 42 individuals with qPCR positive P. falciparum infections at the end of the transmission season (December) were followed monthly until the end of the dry season (May) to evaluate the duration of detectable infections. The influence of human host (age, sex, haemoglobin concentration and genotype, and P. falciparum-specific antibodies), and parasitological (parasite density, gametocyte density and genotypic multiplicity of infection) factors was investigated.
Results A large proportion of individuals infected at the end of the wet season had detectable infections until the end of the dry season (40.0%; 16/40), with the majority of these infections also harbouring gametocytes (81.3%; 13/16). 22 infections were classified as persistent (detectable for at least 3 months), 17 were classified as short-lived (undetectable within 2 months), and 3 were treated (due to symptoms). At the start of the dry season, the majority of persistent infections (82%; 18/22) had parasite densities >10 p/µL compared to only 5.9% (1/17) of short-lived infections. Persistent infections (59%; 13/22) were also more likely to be multi-clonal than short-lived infections (5.9%; 1/17), they were most common in 5 to 15 year old children (63%; 12/19), and were associated with individuals having higher levels of P. falciparum-specific antibodies (p = 0.058).
Conclusions Asymptomatic persistent dry season infections in The Gambia were multiclonal with higher parasite densities at the beginning of the dry season, mostly occurring in school age children and adults with higher P. falciparum-specific antibodies. Screening and treating asymptomatic, malaria-infected individuals during the dry season may reduce the human reservoir of malaria responsible initiating transmission in the wet-season.
Introduction
In many endemic areas, malaria transmission is seasonal, with most clinical cases occurring during the wet season. Plasmodium falciparum infections acquired during this period can persist in asymptomatic individuals throughout the dry season, and if they produce gametocytes, can potentially contribute to transmission at the start of the next wet season, bridging transmission seasons several months apart [1-3]. These clinically silent infections can persist for many months or even years without treatment [2], and pose a significant hurdle for malaria elimination efforts [4]. Understanding how long infections persist in the dry season in The Gambia and identifying who carries them could inform targeted approaches to reduce the dry season reservoir of malaria and reduce re-introduction of malaria in the subsequent wet season.
Few studies have described in detail the asymptomatic dry season reservoir of malaria and the related parasite and host factors. Duration of P. falciparum infection varies by setting, with asymptomatic, genetically complex infections being more common in high transmission areas [5], but even in low transmission settings infections are known to persist for months or even years [6, 7]. The host specific response to malaria infection may play an important role by allowing the establishment of chronic infections. Protection against severe malaria is acquired very quickly, often after a single infection [8, 9], but the ability to control parasitemia at a sub-clinical level develops more slowly with age, following repeated exposure [10]. In Mali, individuals infected during the dry season had higher P. falciparum-specific antibodies and memory B cells than those who were uninfected [11, 12], and older children were more likely to be infected at the end of the dry season than younger children [13]. Both findings support the hypothesis that a certain degree of exposure and immunity (acquired with increasing age) is required to be asymptomatically infected. Interestingly, in Uganda, older children carried infections for a longer time than children under 5 and adults [14], suggesting host immunity may peak or plateau at a certain age, or there may be different mechanisms involved as immunity develops. The type of immune response associated with persistent asymptomatic infection may differ from that able to clear an infection, and this may also vary by age and exposure [15]. Moreover, it is unclear when parasite specific antibody responses contribute to protection [16, 17] or are simply markers of previous exposure [18]. In a recent study, responses to a panel of P. falciparum antigens indicated a higher level of immunity that allowed individuals to control blood-stage infections following controlled exposure to P. falciparum sporozoites [19]. Other host factors may also play an important role in the establishment of chronic asymptomatic infections. In Uganda, infections persisted longer in males than females, suggesting sex-specific differences in the host response may influence the duration of parasite carriage [14]. Host factors such as haemoglobinopathies [20] and anaemia [21] are known to be associated with the risk and severity of malaria, and may also be important factors in the duration of asymptomatic carriage [22].
Besides host factors related to chronic infections, parasites themselves may either be pre-programed or adapted to persist throughout the dry, non-transmission season. Being able to establish a clinically silent infection that does not activate the immune system may result in a slower clearance rate, a plausible evolutionary strategy for surviving the dry season and ensuring onward transmission. In Mali, where malaria transmission is highly seasonal, parasite populations collected during the wet and dry seasons were similar. Nevertheless, parasites sampled in the dry season appeared to adapt their phenotype, resulting in a longer time in peripheral circulation with increased splenic clearance, potentially a strategy to maintain a clinically and immunologically silent low parasitemia [11]. In this study, we identified individuals infected at the end of the transmission season in The Gambia, determined the duration of these infections during the dry season, and explored the related host and parasite factors.
Methods
Study design
Climate in The Gambia is characterised by a short rainy season and a long dry season. Malaria transmission follows the same pattern, starting in July or August and lasting until December, with little or no clinical cases during the dry season. In December 2016, all residents of four villages (Madina Samako, Sendebu, Njayel, Karanbada) located within 5Km of each other in the Upper River Region, eastern Gambia, had a finger prick blood sample collected and analysed by VarATS quantitative PCR (qPCR) for P. falciparum infection. qPCR-positive individuals were invited for monthly samplings (venous blood draw of 5 to 8mL), with qPCR and qRT-PCR performed from the end of December until the end of the dry season (May), or until they either, (i) they became symptomatic and received treatment immediately, (ii) cleared their infection (negative by qRT-PCR and/or VarATS qPCR two months in a row), or (iii) withdrew from the study (Figure 1a). Subjects with an axillary temperature greater than 37.5°C were screened with a rapid diagnostic test (CareStart) and positives were treated with artemether-lumefantrine, the first line treatment in The Gambia. Written informed consent was obtained from all participants; parents or legal guardians provided a written informed consent for minors (<18 years old). The study was approved by the Gambia Government/Medical Research Council Joint Ethics Committee (SCC 1318, L2014.67, SCC 1472).
Molecular detection of parasites
During the study, presence of P. falciparum was assessed using VarATS qPCR as described in [23] from fingerprick (start December screening) or venous blood samples (monthly end December to May). The parasite stages were determined by qRT-PCR assays specific for ring stage parasites (sbp-1), male gametocytes (PfMGET), or female gametocytes (CCp4) [24]. Samples were genotyped using P. falciparum merozoite surface protein 2 (msp2) [25]. Briefly, nucleic acid was extracted from 100 µl whole blood and 5 µl was used in a nested PCR specific for msp2 3D7 and FC27 allelic families followed by capillary electrophoresis to determine allelic size polymorphisms. Secondary PCR products were run on a 2% w/v agarose gel to check for bands within the correct size range (193 to 506 bp). Secondary PCR products were diluted and 2.5 µl per sample processed on an ABI 7500 fast (Applied Biosystem, UK) and resulting chromatograms analyzed using PeakScanner® software version 2 (Applied Biosystems). To distinguish between true peaks and background signal or stutter peaks, a cutoff of 200 relative fluorescent units (RFUs) was applied and fragment sizes must differ by more than 3 bp.
Haemoglobin quantification and genotyping
Haemoglobin density was measured in December using a haemoglobin analyser (HemoCue; AB Leo Diagnostics, Helsingborg, Sweden). Human haemoglobin S (HBs) and C (HBc) were genotyped using previously published methods [26].
Luminex
IgG antibodies against 17 P. falciparum antigens were quantified at baseline for each participant using a Luminex MAGPIX© suspension bead array [27]: Circumsporozoite protein (CSP), Erythrocyte binding antigen (EBA140, EBA175 and EBA181); Glutamate rich protein 2 (GLURP-R2); Merozoite surface protein 1-19 (MSP1-19), Merozoite surface protein 2 (MSP2-ch150/9 [3D7 family allele] and MSP2-DD2 [FC27 family allele]); Apical membrane antigen 1 (AMA1), Reticulocyte binding protein homologue (RH2.2, RH4.2, RH5.1), Schizont egress antigen-1 (SEA1), Heat shock protein 40 (HSP40), Skeleton-binding protein 1 (SBP1), and Early transcribed membrane proteins 4 (ETRAMP4 Ag2) and 5 (ETRAMP5 Ag1). Full details of all antigens are in supplementary table 1. These antigens are wither expressed during the asexual blood-stage (Etramp, PfSEA, HSP40, SBP1), involved in merozoite invasion (Rh, AMA1, EBA, MSP, GLURP) or localised on the surface of sporozoites (CSP). Serological analysis was conducted on serum samples collected in December, assayed at a dilution of 1:200. Secondary antibody was an R-phycoerythrin conjugated goat anti-human IgG (Jackson Immuno Research, PA, USA; 109-116-098) diluted 1:200. Data are presented as median fluorescence intensity (MFI) (median of individual bead fluorescence values for a given region/antigen specificity) adjusted for inter-plate variation in background reactivity as previously described [27]
Statistical analysis
Infections were classified as ‘short-lived’ if they were cleared within 2 months, ‘persistent’ if they remained detectable for 3-6 months and ‘treated’ if they became symptomatic and were treated. Data were analysed with Graphpad Prism version 9. A normality test (D’Agostino-Pearson) was used to determine if data were normally distributed. Kruskal-Wallis with Dunns multiple comparison test was used to compare 3 or more groups of non-parametric data. Spearmans correlation was used to analyse associations with non-parametric data and Pearsons correlation was used for parametric data. Significance was indicated when the value of p < 0.05 (*p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001).
Results
Malaria prevalence at the end of the transmission season (beginning of December 2016) was 8.0% (74/924), with children under 5 having lower prevalence (2.5%; 5/199) than children 5-15 years old (7.9%; 27/341) and individuals >15 years old (10.9%; 42/384). Complete follow-up data were obtained from 40 individuals, 2 did not complete follow up until negative by PCR, but were parasite positive for at least 3 months so were included in the categorised analysis only (Figure 1a and b). 41% (n=17) of the subjects had short lived infections (undetectable by January), 52% (n=22) had persistent infections (detectable by PCR for 3-6 months), and 3 infected subjects developed symptoms and were treated (7%, all children <15 years of age) (Figure 1b). 40% (16/40) of individuals infected in early December remained PCR positive until the end of the dry season, with most of these individuals (81.3%; 13/16) also carrying gametocytes at the end of the dry season (Figure 2a).
No association between the sex of the individual and the duration of infection was found (Table S2). Mean haemoglobin concentration at the start of the dry season was 11.31 g/dL (n=37). HbAA was the most frequent haemoglobin type (75.7%; 28/37), followed by HbAS (21.6%, 8/37), and HbSS (2.7%, 1/37). There was no association between haemoglobin concentration (short-lived= 11.35, persistent = 11.18, treated = 11.30) or type and duration of carriage (Table S2). Persistent infections were slightly more common in the 5-15 year olds (63%; 12/19) than in the other age groups (<5years - 0.0% [0/4], >15 years - 53% [10/19]) (Figure 2b). In persistent infections, asexual parasitemia and gametocytemia declined slowly over the season, with the median asexual parasitemia declining from 214,417 to 10,446 parasites/mL (Figure 2c) and gametocytemia declining from 1,237 to 289 gametocytes/mL (Figure 2d). The ratio of male:female gametocytes was female biased (0.20; CI 95%:0.16-0.23), similar to sex ratios observed in transmissible infections [4] and did not change over time (Figure S2).
At the start of the dry season, parasite density in persistent infections was significantly higher than in short-lived infections (p< 0.0001 Kruskal-Wallis with Dunns multiple comparison test) (Figure 3a), and duration of infection in months was significantly related to starting parasite density (Spearmans r = 0.86, p< 0.0001) (Figure 3b). Most persistent infections (82%; 18/22) and only 1 out of 17 short-lived infections had initial parasite densities above the theoretical limit of expert microscopy detection (10p/uL) [28] (Figure 3a). In the end of December samples (first monthly visit after screening), most short-lived infections (76%; 13/17) had only gametocytes, and 53% (9/17) had neither asexual parasites nor gametocytes detected, indicating these individuals had already cleared their infections in the first month. Whereas at the same time point, almost all persistent infections had both asexual parasites (20/22) and gametocytes (20/22) at densities that could be quantified by the qRT-PCR assays.
Complexity of infection (the number of genetically distinct genotypes within a blood sample) was measured throughout the dry season using msp2 genotyping (Figure 4a). In some samples, msp2 genotype could not be determined, likely due to parasite densities being below the assay limit of detection. At the start of the dry season, most infections had less than 2 genotypes (80.5%, 33/41) and the median per subject was 1 (range 1-8). Complexity of infection was significantly higher in the persistent than in the short-lived infections (p = 0.015, Kruskal-Wallis with Dunns multiple comparison test). Higher complexity of infection (>2 genotypes) was only observed in persistent infections; all short-lived infections were monoclonal, except for one with 2 genotypes (Figure 4b). The number of genotypes at the start of the dry season also correlated with parasite density (Figure 4c). In every persistent infection, there was at least one msp2 genotype detected repeatedly throughout the dry season, suggesting chronic infection with the same P. falciparum strain as opposed to new infections (Figure S3).
To assess the role of host immunity in the persistence of P. falciparum infection, antibodies were measured at the start of the dry season using a multiplex bead-based assay with a panel of 17 P. falciparum antigens. There was a trend for higher P.f.-specific antibody responses against 13 out of the 17 antigens in subjects who developed persistent infections compared to those with short-lived infections (Figure 5a and b). The three Rh family antigens (Rh2, Rh4.2, Rh5.1) were among the four most discriminatory antigens, with higher antibody levels associated with persistent infections, although only Rh5.1 reached statistical significance (p = 0.03). Of the other individual antigens, only PfSEA and GLURP (p = 0.01, p = 0.04, respectively) were significantly associated with subsequent duration of infection (persistent versus short-lived). Individuals with persistent infections tended to respond to more antigens (above background response) than those with short-lived infections, p = 0.058 (Figure 5c). The magnitude of total P.f.-specific antibody response to all antigens was significantly correlated with age, Pearsons r = 0.43 p = 0.017. (Figure 5d) and there was also a trend for increased breadth of response with age (Figure 5e).
Discussion
In this study, 40% of individuals infected at the end of the wet season remained asymptomatically infected until the end of the dry season, demonstrating the considerable silent reservoir of malaria that exists to re-start the next transmission season in The Gambia. Individuals with persistent infections had higher starting parasite densities, often with multiclonal infections, and higher P.f.-specific antibody responses, suggesting that prior malaria exposure is important to maintain the human reservoir of malaria. Targeting these infections may significantly reduce such a reservoir and thus the capacity of starting the next transmission season.
In areas of seasonal malaria transmission, understanding who maintains the parasite reservoir during the dry season may inform control interventions to reduce this reservoir and thereby the resurgence of malaria in the subsequent transmission season [1]. In our study setting, only 8% of village residents had detectable parasites at the end of the transmission season and towards the end of the dry season the prevalence fell to 3%. In our modestly sized study population, we aimed to understand factors that contribute to duration of infection. We observed no clear relationship between subject age and duration of parasite carriage, although all persistent infections were found in those above 5 years of age. In general, the number of children under 5 infected at the end of the wet season was low compared to the other age groups, possibly reflecting the levels of protective immunity, with younger children being more likely to develop symptoms when infected [7], or the impact of seasonal malaria chemoprevention [29].
Responses to the panel of 17 P. falciparum antigens tested were generally low [18]. Despite being currently infected, not all subjects had a response to all antigens above background. This highlights the generally low level of malaria exposure in the area (when compared to high endemic settings). Individuals with persistent infections tended to have higher and broader P.f.-specific antibody responses than those with short-lived infections, a finding consistent with previous studies. In Mali, a certain level of immunity was required for chronic asymptomatic parasite carriage when compared to uninfected individuals [11, 12]. Similarly, in another study in Mali, asymptomatic infected children had higher levels of P.f.-specific antibodies than children with clinical malaria [13]. Other studies have shown that age (and thus cumulative exposure) is associated with longer duration of asymptomatic infection in Malawi [30], and this relationship was seen particularly in children of different ages in Uganda and Ghana [14, 31]. In our study, we also observed a relationship between age and increasing magnitude and breadth of the immune responses, but this correlation was relatively weak, with some older individuals having poorer antibody responses. This supports earlier reports of marked heterogeneity in malaria exposure in The Gambia [3, 32]. In the context of our current findings, we hypothesize that this heterogeneity results in some individuals being more likely to experience repeated infections, resulting in higher levels of immunity and thus improved ability to sustain chronic asymptomatic parasite carriage. Due the heterogeneous nature of exposure, these individuals are more accurately characterised by responses to a panel of P. falciparum antigens than by age.
Each persistent infection had at least one unique genotype repeatedly observed at several time points, indicating infection persistence. High complexity of infection (multiple genotypes) at the beginning of the dry season was associated with longer duration of asymptomatic carriage, consistent with data from other studies [33, 34]. This could either be due to multiple clones being received from a single mosquito bite [35], or by the accumulation of clones over time in those who harbour infections for a prolonged period. Complexity of infection and parasite density were also strongly correlated in this study. This could be partly explained by the difficulty of detecting all parasite clones when density is low and falling below the detection limit of the assay [36]. Higher parasite density, multi-clonal infections were more likely to persist throughout the dry season. This could possible be because a higher parasite biomass in December would take longer to clear. However, this was not clearly supported by our data since parasite densities in persistent infections did not decrease dramatically during the dry season. Alternatively, parasites in persistent infections may be (epi)genetically programmed to survive longer, and/or genetically different from those in short-lived infections, potentially with a less virulent phenotype or slower parasite multiplication rate. This hypothesis is consistent with a recent study from Mali, where similar parasite populations were present in the wet and dry seasons. However, parasites in the dry season were transcriptionally different from those present in the wet season and they were able to adapt their phenotype to ensure longer circulation and less sequestration during each cycle, resulting in increased splenic clearance and lower but persistent parasite densities [11].
Our study was limited by the small sample size, largely governed by the decreasing malaria prevalence in the area [3]. However, we were able to demonstrate that the dry season reservoir of malaria is largely comprised of school aged children and adults who have likely experienced repeated infections. Importantly, persistent infections could potentially be identified at the start of the dry season, given that they were associated with higher initial parasite densities. Our findings confirm ongoing gametocyte production in chronic infections. Future studies may address the infectivity of these infections to mosquitoes and, more importantly for malaria control, determine whether clearing infections that are present at the start of the dry season results in a meaningful reduction in malaria burden in the next transmission season.
Data Availability
All data produced in the present study are available upon request to the authors
Supplementary Figures
Supplementary Tables
Funding
This work was supported by grants from the Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research (Vidi fellowship NWO 016.158.306) and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation (INDIE OPP1173572), the joint MRC/LSHTM fellowship, the French National Research Agency (18-CE15-0009-01).
Conflict of interest
Acknowledgments
We would like to thank Julia Mwesigwa and all fieldworkers for sample collection.