The unexpected 2020 October COVID-19 boost date in European countries correlated with the latitude, but not with the temperature

Introduction

Many European countries underwent an unexpected spectacular boost of the daily reported positive COVID-19 cases between 2020 September 20^th and October 25^th (Fig. 1), imposing in emergency new confinement rules in order to prevent hospitals flooding.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1:

Examples of reported European countries daily new COVID-19 cases (extracted from the Google home page when searching “covid”, homepage using itself Wikipedia data). All curves exhibit a clear boost of the growing rates between 2020 September 20^th and October 25^th.

The most common explanation provided by the European epidemiologist experts in the medias is the decreasing temperature. The aim of this data analysis study is to challenge this assumption against a pure country latitude impact.

Material and method

Results

Table 1 shows the fitting results (all the data and fitting process is provided in the supplementary xlsx file).

A common explanation provided in the European media is the decrease of temperature the weeks preceding the boost date. Fig. 2A clearly shows the weakness of this assumption. On the other hand fig. 2B clearly supports an impact of the country latitude.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 2:

COVID-19 boost date offset as a function of the country mean temperature during the 2 weeks preceding its COVID-19 boost date (A), and of the country PWC latitude (B).

Fig 3 clearly shows that the boost dates set on the theoretical daily insolation as a function of the latitude tends to be horizontally aligned rather than vertically. This supports an impact of the sun insolation.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 3:

Solid curves: theoretical total daily sun insolation under a clear sky corresponding to the 14 PWC country latitudes. Black circles: country boost dates positioned on their corresponding latitude curve. Black dot-dash line corresponds to the average sun irradiance threshold, i.e. ≈ 7 kWh/m²/day.

Discussion

Light scattering in the earth atmosphere quickly increases with its frequency, explaining why the sun becomes red during the sunset, the solar light having then to travel thousand km of atmosphere. That also explains why sun UV is mainly harmful for the skin in summer and within 2 hours range around the sun at noon. Due to the lower maximal elevation reached by the sun, the daily UV insolation in autumn decreases earlier in countries of higher latitude, as shown in Fig. 3 for the 7 kWh/m²/day threshold.

Comparing the covid-19 wave intensity between different latitudes has the drawback that this quantity is dependent on the safety rules followed in the considered countries, on the population density and also on the testing rate. In contrary the boost date is independent of those parameters.

Many observations support an impact of low vitamin D blood level [1], and also of low UV insolation [2], on the respiratory impairment in coronavirus or virus diseases. Many other observations were also recently reported for the COVID-19 pandemic [3]. Low vitamin D blood level could also be an additional factor explaining the higher COVID-19 respiratory impairment observed in aged people [4], in obese patients [5], in black people living in high latitude countries [6] and in diabetic patients [7].

The sun irradiance curve at 31° latitude versus the average sun irradiance threshold (Fig. 3) explains why low population mortality is observed within ±35° latitudes [8]. Due to the symmetry of the irradiance curves, European countries will get back above the sun irradiance threshold in end 2021 March.

The present study suffers from the limitation that the daily new COVID-19 cases were reported on a country base, country that can extent up to 8 degrees of latitude, such as Italy. It should be highly valuable to update this study using the latitude and daily new COVID-19 cases reported for the major European country cities or regions, if such data are available.

Conclusion

As the skin production using sun UVs is a major source of vitamin D for human, and that the half-life of the vitamin D reserve in adipose tissue is about 2 weeks, this study is an additional observation supporting the potential impact of low vitamin D blood level on the respiratory impairment in COVID-19 disease. This could thus open the possibility to reduce the pandemic severity during winter using preventive vitamin D supplementation for people at risk [9].