Abstract
Background Tobacco consumption is a leading preventable cause of disease and premature deaths. In India bidis are the most common form of smoking tobacco product. Bidi manufacturing is an agro-forest based cottage industry and is generally rolled at home. These workers are exposed to nicotine, tar and other particles through skin leading to occupational health risks in not only themselves but also in their families and communities. There are concerns on environmental risks of bidi manufacturing in home too.
Aim To assess the environmental risks and occupational health hazards of bidi workers and their communities in India.
Method We will conduct a scoping review to identify, map and analyse evidence around environmental risks and occupational health hazards in bidi workers and their families and communities. We will search in seven electronic databases (PubMed, EMBASE+EMBASE Classic, CINAHL, Environment complete-EBSCO, GreenFILE-EBSCO, Web of Science and WHO-IRIS). Screening will be done independently by at least two reviewers, with disagreements resolve by consensus. We will extract data for the included studies using a standardised data extraction in an independent fashion, with disagreements resolved by consensus. We will conduct a narrative synthesis.
Background
Globally, tobacco is the largest cause of preventable deaths, killing more than 8 million and many more suffer from other diseases conditions associated with it. India is the 2nd largest producer and consumer of tobacco products and tobacco is consumed in myriad forms ranging from smoked products like cigarette and bidi, and plethora of smokeless products. However, unlike other countries, where cigarettes are predominant form of tobacco being consumed, bidi is the most commonly smoked product in India. Bidis are an indigenous smoking tobacco product, made by tobacco flakes rolled in tendu leaves and tied with a thread. They roughly contain 0.15–0.5-gram tobacco per stick which amounts to one-fifth to two-thirds of the amount of tobacco in cigarettes. However, the concentration of nicotine in bidis is higher than that in cigarettes and it delivers higher levels of tar compared to cigarettes its smoke leading to potentially greater health risk.
On analysing the constituents of bidi, the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MoHFW), Government of India (GoI) monograph concluded that the low porosity of the bidi leaf wrapper and low filtration of bidis contribute to higher amounts of toxins released during bidi smoking1.
Evidence from epidemiological studies suggest that bidi smoking is associated with many health risks like severe respiratory impairment, increased risk of oral cancer and lung cancer, all-cause mortality, and adverse cardiorespiratory outcomes2,3. Apart from the adverse health outcomes among bidi smokers, bidi rollers are exposed to several occupational health hazards because of long working hours and unhealthy work environment4. Bidi manufacturing is an agro-forest based cottage industry and is generally rolled at home. These workers are exposed to nicotine, tar and other particles through skin leading to occupational health risks in not only themselves but also in their families and communities. Environmental effects of bidi manufacturing particularly in homes is also another cause of concern5. There is however no synthesises of the available evidence on the environmental risks and health hazards in bidi workers, their families, and communities to inform policy makers and other stakeholders. On request from WHO-India we sought to conduct a synthesis of evidence on this domain and develop a policy brief based on it.
Methods
Broad Approach
We will conduct a systematic scoping review of the available evidence on the topic of interest. The scoping approach is appropriate as the topic at hand is broad and there is no effectiveness or safety question at hand. Based on the scoping review, an evidence-informed policy brief will be created.
Eligibility Criteria
We will include studies and reports, which meet the following criteria
Population / problem – are on bidi workers (any role, function or type of enterprise), their families, communities in the working environment
Interest area - are on any of the following:
∘ occupational health hazards of bidi workers
∘ health hazards in families and communities of bidi worker
∘ environmental risk of bidi manufacturing /rolling
Setting – the study should be conducted in India
Study design - presents any primary data (qualitative or quantitative) irrespective of study design or peer-review status
We will include only English language documents. We will not include animal or laboratory studies on effects of constitutes of bidi.
Information sources
Electronic database search
The search strategy for PubMed has been developed and presented in Appendix 1. This will be adapted for other electronic databases.
We will search multiple indexed databases, from their date of inception
PubMed,
EMBASE+EMBASE Classic
CINAHL
Environment complete-EBSCO
GreenFILE – EBSCO
Web of Science
WHO-IRIS
All search strategies will be made available as appendix along with full report.
Other methods for searching
We will also use following additional modalities to identify potential studies from the grey literature
Through expert contact and citation tracking (from amongst those identified to be included by other means).
Hand searching websites of Ministry of Health and Ministry of labour of government of India, labour organisations, trade unions in India, and non-profit organisation working on tobacco control, or welfare of bidi workers in India. A full list of all websites searched will be presented with the full review.
Screening process and Data Collection
Two reviewers will independently screen title and/or abstracts from electronic database search and, disagreement if any will be solved by consensus. Full text evaluation will be done by at least two reviewers. We will collect data as per a standardised data extraction form which will be piloted and iteratively developed.
Synthesis of results
We will narratively synthesise the study without any additional quantitative analysis. Given the broad nature of question and substantial differences in context, narrative synthesis is the right approach for the process. Gaps in knowledge will be identified and presented. We will synthesise and report the occupational hazards, health risk and environmental risk of bidi workers, their families and communities into following sub-groups, if enough studies are available for each sub-type:
Male and female bidi workers
Child labourers in the bidi industry
Pregnant and lactating bidi workers
Full-time and part-time bidi workers
Directly employed and contracted bidi workers
Type of enterprise –
∘ Own Account Manufacturing Enterprises (OAME): A small manufacturing enterprise run in household of bidi workers, and that do not hire any workers on a regular basis (contracted out)
∘ Establishments: An enterprise which has at least one hired worker on a regular basis
Data Availability
All data related to the protocol is contained in the manuscript or accompanying supplementary material
Declaration of interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Funding
The systematic review is funded by the World Health Organizations (WHO) Country Office-India. The funder has commissioned the work and identified the need for a review to address the question. The funder has no other role in the conduct of this work, including in the decision to publish.
Author contributions
Jyoti Tyagi: scoping to inform protocol; search strategy; design search strategy; first draft protocol
Deepti Beri: scoping to inform protocol, review and edit draft protocol with sufficient intellectual input
Soumyadeep Bhaumik: conceptualisation; methodology; first draft of protocol
Guarantors: all authors