Abstract
ISARIC (International Severe Acute Respiratory and emerging Infections Consortium) partnerships and outbreak preparedness initiatives enabled the rapid launch of standardised clinical data collection on COVID-19 in Jan 2020. Extensive global uptake of this resource has resulted in a large, standardised collection of comprehensive clinical data from hundreds of sites across dozens of countries. Data are analysed regularly and reported publicly to inform patient care and public health response. This report is a part of a series and includes the results of data analysis on 8 June 2020.
We thank all of the data contributors for their ongoing support.
As of 8JUN20, data have been entered for 67,130 patients from 488 sites across 37 countries. For this report, we show data for 42,656 patients with confirmed disease who were enrolled >14 days prior.
This update includes about 2,400 new cases from France, and we thank these collaborators for this significant addition to the dataset.
Some highlights from this report The median time from onset of symptoms to hospital admission is 5 days, but a proportion of patients take longer to get to the hospital (average 14.6 days, standard deviation 8.1).
COVID-19 patients tend to require prolonged hospitalisation; of the 88% with a known outcome the median length of admission to death or discharge is 8 days and the mean 11.5. 17% of patients were admitted to ICU/HDU, about 40% of these on the very day of hospital admission.
Antibiotics were given to 83% of patients, antivirals to 9%, steroids to 15%, which becomes 93%, 50% and 27%, respectively for those admitted to ICU/HDU. Attention has been called on overuse of antibiotics and need to adhere to antibiotic stewardship principles.
67% of patients received some degree of oxygen supplementation: of these 23.4% received NIV and 15% IMV. This relatively high proportion of oxygen use will have implications for oxygen surge planning in healthcare facilities. Some centres may need to plan to boost capacity to deliver oxygen therapy if this is not readily available. WHO provides operational advice on surge strategy here https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/331746/WHO-2019-nCoV-Oxygen_sources-2020.1-eng.pdf
ISARIC (International Severe Acute Respiratory and Emerging Infections Consortium)
A global federation of clinical research networks, providing a proficient, coordinated, and agile research response to outbreak-prone infectious diseases
COVID-19 Report: 08 June 2020
Summary
The results in this report have been produced using data from the ISARIC COVID-19 database. For information, or to contribute to the collaboration, please contact ncov{at}isaric.org.
We thank all of the data contributors for collecting standardised data during these extraordinary times. We plan to issue this report of aggregate data regularly for the duration of the SARS-CoV-2/COVID-19 pandemic.
Please note the following caveats. This is a dynamic report which captures new variables and information as our understanding of COVID-19 evolves. Please observe the N of each result to note newly added variables with fewer data points. Information is incomplete for the many patients who are still being treated. Furthermore, it is likely that that we received more cases of severely ill individuals than those with relatively less severe illness; outcomes from these data, such as the proportion dying, must therefore not be used to infer outcomes for the entire population of people who might become infected. Some patients may be participants in clinical trials of experimental interventions. Many of the included cases are from the United Kingdom. Additional caveats are provided in the in the ‘Caveats’ section below.
Up to the date of this report, data have been entered for 67130 individuals from 488 sites across 37 countries. The analysis detailed in this report only includes individuals:
for whom data collection commenced on or before 25 May 2020. (We have applied a 14-day rule to focus analysis on individuals who are more likely to have a recorded outcome. By excluding patients enrolled during the last 14 days, we aim to reduce the number of incomplete data records and thus improve the generalisability of the results and the accuracy of the outcomes. However, this limits our focus to a restricted cohort despite the much larger volumes of data held in the database.)
AND
who have laboratory-confirmed or clinically-diagnosed SARS-COV-2 infection.
The cohort satisfying the above criteria has 42656 cases (98.19% are laboratory-confirmed for SARS-COV-2 infection).
The flow chart in Figure 1 gives an overview of the cohort and outcomes as of 08 June 2020.
Demographics and presenting features
Of these 42656 cases, 24691 are males and 17851 are females – sex is unreported for 114 cases. The minimum and maximum observed ages were 0 and 106 years respectively. The median age is 72 years.
The observed mean number of days from (first) symptom onset to hospital admission was 14.6, with a standard deviation (SD) of 8.1 days and a median of 5 days.
The observed mean duration for the number of days from hospital admission to outcome (death or discharge) was 11.5, with SD 12.1 days and a median of 8 days. These estimates are based on all cases which have complete records on length of hospital stay (N = 37696).
The symptoms on admission represent the policy for hospital admission and containment at that time plus, whatever the case definition was. As time passes for most countries these will change. The five most common symptoms at admission were history of fever, shortness of breath, cough, fatigue/malaise, and confusion. Frequencies of symptom prevalence vary with age.
Outcomes
Outcomes have been recorded for 34608 patients, consisting of 22949 recoveries and 11659 deaths. Follow-up is ongoing for 4411 patients. Outcome records are unavailable for 3637 patients.
ICU/HDU: A total of 7374 (17%) patients were admitted at some point of their illness into an intensive care unit (ICU) or high dependency unit (HDU). Of these, 2441 died, 1094 are still in hospital and 2950 have recovered and been discharged.
The observed mean and median durations (in days) from hospital admission to ICU/HDU admission were 2.8 and 1 respectively (SD: 6.1) – estimated from records on cases with complete date records on hospital admission and ICU/HDU entry (N = 6785).
The duration of stay in ICU/HDU had a mean of 10.8 days and a median of 7.5 (SD: 10.4 days) – estimated on only those cases with complete records for ICU/HDU duration or ICU/HDU start/end dates (N = 5574). Of these 7374 patients who were admitted into ICU/HDU, 2441 died, 1094 are still in hospital and 2950 have recovered and been discharged. Outcome records are unavailable for 889 cases. Approximately 39% of patients with complete records on ICU admission dates were admitted to ICU within the first day of hospital admission. The distribution of the number of days from admission to ICU admission is shown in Figure 11.
Treatment
Antibiotics were received by 29812/35914 (83%) patients, and 3185/35093 (9.1%) received antivirals. These treatment categories are not mutually exclusive since some patients received multiple treatments. (The denominators differ due to data completeness.) 27697/41187 (67.2%) patients received some degree of oxygen supplementation: of these, 6483/27697 (23.4%) received NIV and 4092/27697 (14.8%) IMV.
Of the patients admitted into ICU/HDU, 5549/5999 (92.5%) received antibiotics and 4470/8940 (50%) antivirals. 6710/7275 (92.2%) received some degree of oxygen supplementation, of which, 3547/6710 (52.9%) received NIV and 3965/6710 (59.1%) IMV.
A total of 6483 patients received non-invasive mechanical ventilation (NIV). The mean and median durations from admission to receiving NIV were 4.2 days and 2 days respectively (SD: 8.8 days) – estimated from records on cases with complete records on dates of hospital admission and NIV onset (N = 5025). The mean and median durations for NIV were 2.2 days and 0 days respectively (SD: 3.9 days) – estimated based on only those cases which have complete NIV duration records (N = 2977).
A total of 4092 patients received invasive mechanical ventilation (IMV). The mean and median durations from admission to receiving IMV were 3.6 days and 2 days respectively (SD: 7 days) – estimated from records on cases with complete records on dates of hospital admission and IMV onset (N = 3648). The mean, median and SD for the duration of IMV – estimated based on all 2819 cases with complete records on IMV stays – were 12.6 days, 10 days and 9.7 days respectively.
Patient Characteristics
Variables by age
Hospital stays and outcomes
Intensive Care and High Dependency Unit Treatments
Statistical Analysis
Background
In response to the emergence of novel coronavirus (COVID-19), ISARIC launched a portfolio of resources to accelerate outbreak research and response. These include data collection, analysis and presentation tools which are freely available to all sites which have requested access to these resources. All data collection tools are designed to address the most critical public health questions, have undergone extensive review by international clinical experts, and are free for all to use. Resources are available on the ISARIC website.
The ISARIC-WHO COVID-19 Case Record Form (CRF) enables the collection of standardised clinical data to inform patient management and public health response. These forms should be used to collect data on suspected or confirmed cases of COVID-19. The CRF is available in multiple languages and is now in use across dozens of countries and research consortia, who are contributing data to these reports.
To support researchers to retain control of the data and samples they collect, ISARIC also hosts a data platform, where data can be entered to a web-based REDCap data management system, securely stored, and used to produce regular reports on their sites as above. Data contributors are invited to input on the methods and contents of the reports, and can also contribute to the aggregated data platform which aggregates site-specific data from all other sites across the world who are using this system. For more information, visit the ISARIC website.
All decisions regarding data use are made by the institutions that enter the data. ISARIC keeps contributors informed of any plans and welcomes their input to promote the best science and the interests of patients, institutions and public health authorities. Feedback and suggestions are welcome at ncov{at}isaric.org.
Methods
Patient details were submitted electronically by participating sites to the ISARIC database. Relevant background and presenting symptoms were recorded on the day of study recruitment. Daily follow-up was then completed until recovery or death. A final form was completed with details of treatments received and outcomes. All categories that represent fewer than five individuals have been suppressed to avoid the potential for identification of participants.
Graphs have been used to represent the age distribution of patients by sex and status (dead, recovered & still in hospital), the prevalence of individual symptoms on admission, comorbidities on admission, the length of hospital stay by sex and age group and the distribution of patient statuses by time since admission. In addition, the number of cases recruited by country and site, as well as the case count by status, has been represented.
Using a non-parametric Kaplan-Meier-based method (Ghani et al., 2005), the case-fatality ratio (CFR) was estimated, as well as probabilities for death and recovery. This method estimates the CFR with the formula a/(a + b), where a and b are the values of the cumulative incidence function for deaths and recoveries respectively, estimated at the last observed time point. In a competing risk context (i.e. where there are multiple endpoints), the cumulative incidence function for an endpoint is equal to the product of the hazard function for that endpoint and the survival function assuming a composite endpoint. It is worth noting that this method assumes that future deaths and recoveries will occur with the same relative probabilities as have been observed so far. Binomial confidence intervals for the CFR were obtained by a normal approximation (See Ghani et al., (2005)).
To obtain estimates for the distributions of time from symptom onset to hospital admission and the time from admission to outcome (death or recovery), Gamma distributions were fitted to the observed data, accounting for unobserved outcomes. Parameters were estimated by a maximum likelihood procedure and confidence intervals for the means and variances were obtained by bootstrap.
All analysis were performed using the R statistical software (R Core Team, 2019).
Caveats
Patient data are collected and uploaded from start of admission, however a complete patient data set is not available until the episode of care is complete. This causes a predictable lag in available data influenced by the duration of admission which is greatest for the sickest patients, and accentuated during the up-phase of the outbreak.
These reports provide regular outputs from the ISARIC COVID-19 database. We urge caution in interpreting unexpected results. We have noted some unexpected results in the report, and are working with sites that submitted data to gain a greater understanding of these.
Summary Tables
Proportions are presented in parentheses. Proportions have been rounded to two decimal places.
Data Availability
We welcome applications for UK data through the ISARIC 4C Independent Data and Material Access Committee (https://isaric4c.net). Requests for access to non-UK data can be sent to covid19@iddo.org.
Acknowledgements
This report is made possible through the efforts and expertise of the staff collecting data at our partner institutions across the globe, and the ISARIC Team. For a list of partners and team members, please visit https://isaric.tghn.org/covid-19-data-management-hosting-contributors/.
Footnotes
↵∼ participants are listed at https://isaric.tghn.org/covid-19-data-management-hosting-contributors/