Abstract
One of the significant unanswered questions about COVID-19 epidemiology relates to the role of children in transmission. This study uses data on infections within households in order to estimate the susceptibility and infectivity of children compared to those of adults. The data were collected from households in the city of Bnei Brak, Israel, in which all household members were tested for COVID-19 using PCR (637 households, average household size of 5.3). In addition, serological tests were performed on a subset of the individuals in the study. Inspection of the PCR data shows that children are less likely to be tested positive compared to adults (25% of children positive over all households, 44% of adults positive over all households, excluding index cases), and the chance of being positive increases with age. Analysis of joint PCR/serological data shows that there is under-detection of infections in the PCR testing, which is more substantial in children. However, the differences in detection rates are not sufficient to account for the differences in PCR positive rates in the two age groups. To estimate relative transmission parameters, we employ a discrete stochastic model of the spread of infection within a household, allowing for susceptibility and infectivity parameters to differ among children and adults. The model is fitted to the household data using a simulated maximum likelihood approach. To adjust parameter estimates for under-detection of infections in the PCR results, we employ a multiple imputation procedure using estimates of under-detection in children and adults, based on the available serological data. We estimate that the susceptibility of children (under 20 years old) is 43% (95% CI: [31%, 55%]) of the susceptibility of adults. The infectivity of children was estimated to be 63% (95% CI: [37%, 88%]) relative to that of adults.
Author Summary One of the significant unanswered questions about COVID-19 epidemiology relates to the role of children in transmission. In this study we estimate susceptibility and infectivity of children compared to those of adults using households data. The data were collected from households in the city of Bnei Brak, Israel, in which all household members were tested for COVID-19 using PCR. In addition, serological tests were performed on a subset of the individuals. Using a mathematical model to fit the data, we estimate that children are about half as susceptible to infection as adults, and are somewhat less prone to infect others compared to adults. In addition, using the serological data we find that under-detection of children, compared to that of adults, is more severe, given the PCR testing policy employed. Thus, both low susceptability and under-detection of children may explain the world-wide observation that the percentage of young children within confirmed COVID-19 cases is low compared to other age groups. However, the role of children in the spread of COVID-19 is also affected by different contact patterns and hygienic habits outside the household, so that more intense contact and mixing among children, for example in schools, could offset the effect of reduced susceptibility and infectivity.
Competing Interest Statement
The authors have declared no competing interest.
Funding Statement
No external funding was received
Author Declarations
I confirm all relevant ethical guidelines have been followed, and any necessary IRB and/or ethics committee approvals have been obtained.
Yes
The details of the IRB/oversight body that provided approval or exemption for the research described are given below:
An exemption from institutional review board approval was determined by the Israeli Ministry of Health as part of an active epidemiological investigation, based on use of anonymous data only and no medical intervention.
All necessary patient/participant consent has been obtained and the appropriate institutional forms have been archived.
Yes
I understand that all clinical trials and any other prospective interventional studies must be registered with an ICMJE-approved registry, such as ClinicalTrials.gov. I confirm that any such study reported in the manuscript has been registered and the trial registration ID is provided (note: if posting a prospective study registered retrospectively, please provide a statement in the trial ID field explaining why the study was not registered in advance).
Yes
I have followed all appropriate research reporting guidelines and uploaded the relevant EQUATOR Network research reporting checklist(s) and other pertinent material as supplementary files, if applicable.
Yes
Footnotes
The major changes in the revised version are: 1. We now have the results of serological tests carried out on a subset of the households in our study (705 individuals). This has enabled us to examine the possibility of under-detection of infections in the PCR testing data. We did indeed find such under-detection, and moreover that the under-detection rate is higher in children (a possibility raised by the reviewers), a fact that can bias the estimates of the main parameters of interest in this study (relative susceptibility and infectivity). To address this and adjust our analysis accordingly, we used the serological data to estimate under-detection rates in children and adults, and have then used these estimated rates to repeat our previous fitting of the household model to the data, while performing multiple imputations in the PCR testing data, imputing a fraction of the PCR-negative cases as infected. The point estimates for the parameters obtained following this procedure are somewhat shifted, though the paper's central conclusion of lower susceptibility and somewhat lower infectivity in children did not change. 2. We have improved our description of the data collection process. In addition, we have added tables and figures (figures 2,3) summarizing the data. Most importantly, we have now made all the data used in our analysis publicly available in the Supporting Material: we include diagrams presenting the testing timeline in all households in the study. In view of the significant changes made, the structure of the paper has somewhat changed, with the addition of sections describing the new serological data (Section 2.1.2), the imputation procedure (Section 2.2.3) and the results of serological testing (Section 3.2) and of adjusted parameter and estimates with imputation (Section 3.4).
Data Availability
The household data used for fitting the model and the computer code (in the R language) for the data analysis can be downloaded from https://github.com/yairgoldy/sl4hm.
