Links between gut microbiome composition and fatty liver disease in a large population sample

Bacterial community structure is correlated with Fatty Liver Index in a population sample

To investigate the link between fatty liver disease (using FLI as a proxy; Figures 1A, 1B) and gut microbial composition, we used linear regression (adjusted R² = 0.29) on the three first principal component (PC) axes of the fecal bacterial beta-diversity (between individuals), sex, age, and alcohol to model FLI. log₁₀(FLI) significantly correlated with all three bacterial PC axes, sex, age, and alcohol use (all P <1×10^-6). Correlations between FLI and archaeal PC axes were not significant (P > 0.05). The effect size estimate on log₁₀(FLI) was a magnitude larger for PC1 (0.11 ± 0.008) than for PC2 (0.04 ± 0.008) and PC3 (−0.06 ± 0.008). The relationships between FLI and the bacterial PC components representing their beta-diversity are visualized for each of the three components in Figure 1C. In our analyses, we classified our reads against the Genome Taxonomy Database (GTDB),²⁸ and thus the taxonomy discussed in this study follows the standardized GTDB taxonomy, unless otherwise noted.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1.

Distribution of FLI (A), its components (B), and FLI in quantiles of the first three PC components of the fecal bacterial composition of the participants (C). The cutoff at FLI = 60 used to divide the participants is indicated with a dashed line in panels A and C.

Bacterial clades with the highest positive loadings on PC1 (and therefore associated with higher FLI values) included members of the Lachnospirales and Oscillospirales taxonomic orders, of the Bacilli class, and of the Ruminococcaceae, Bacteroidaceae and Lachnospiraceae families (Figure S2). These observations led us to further analyses within a machine learning framework to estimate the relative contributions of individual bacterial taxa to the differences in FLI between study participants.

Bacterial lineages within the NCBI Clostridium subclusters IV and XIVa associate with FLI

In our machine learning framework, we used the known covariates in addition to individual archaeal and bacterial “balances” as the predicting features. Briefly, each balance represents a single internal node in a phylogenetic tree, and its value is a log-ratio of the abundances of the two clades descending this node (for details, see methods and ref. 29). Continuous FLI and differences between FLI groups (FLI < 60, N = 4359 and FLI ≥ 60, N = 1910; see Figures 1A, 1B) were modeled with gradient boosting regression or classification using Leave-One-Group-Out Cross-Validation (LOGOCV) between participants from different regions.

After feature selection and Bayesian hyperparameter optimization, the correlation between the predictions of the final regression models (age, sex, self-reported alcohol use, and 18 bacterial balances as features; each trained on the data from 5/6 regions) and true values in unseen data from the omitted region averaged R² = 0.30 (0.26 – 0.33). After feature selection and optimization, the main classification models (age, sex, and 11 bacterial balances as features; each trained on the data from 5/6 regions) averaged AUC = 0.75 (Table S1) and AUPRC = 0.56 (baseline at 0.30; Table S2) on (unseen) test data from the omitted region. Models trained using only the covariates averaged AUC = 0.71 (AUPRC = 0.47) and using only the 11 bacterial balances they averaged AUC = 0.66 (AUPRC = 0.47) on test data. Alternative models were constructed by excluding participants with FLI between 30 and 60 (N = 1583) and discerning between groups of FLI < 30 (N = 2776) and FLI ≥ 60 (N = 1910). These models averaged AUC = 0.80 (AUPRC = 0.75, baseline at 0.41) on their respective test data. They averaged AUC = 0.76 (AUPRC = 0.68) when using only the covariates, and AUC = 0.70 (AUPRC = 0.63) when using only the 20 bacterial balances.

Because training data from all 6 regions was used to prevent overfitting in the selection of core features for all of the models, and similarly in searching for common hyperparameters, participants from the validation region of each model (in the training partition) partly influenced these parameters. Thus, we also constructed classification models discerning between the FLI < 60 and FLI ≥ 60 groups, where data of the validation region was completely excluded in the feature selection and hyperparameter optimization of each LOGOCV model. These models, using their individual feature sets and hyperparameters, averaged AUC = 0.75 and AUPRC = 0.57 (baseline at 0.30) on test data from their respective validation regions (Table S3). Using only covariates, they averaged AUC = 0.71 (AUPRC = 0.47), and AUC = 0.67 (AUPRC = 0.48) with only the bacterial balances.

To facilitate interpretability of the results, we primarily continued examining the main classification models using a common set of core features. In these models, the median effect sizes of the features on the model predictions at their minimum and maximum values were highest for age, followed by sex, and the 11 balances in the phylogenetic tree (Figures S2, S3). All 11 associated balances were in phylum Firmicutes, class Clostridia, and largely in the NCBI Clostridium subclusters IV and XIVa (Figure 2). The specific taxa represented standardized GTDB genera (NCBI in brackets) Negativibacillus (Clostridium), Clostridium M (Lachnoclostridium / Clostridium), CAG-81 (Clostridium), Dorea (Merdimonas / Mordavella / Dorea / Clostridium / Eubacterium), Faecalicatena (Blautia / Ruminococcus / Clostridium), Blautia (Blautia), Sellimonas (Sellimonas / Drancourtella), Clostridium Q (Lachnoclostridium [Clostridium]) and Tyzzerella (Tyzzerella / Coprococcus). Notably, all but one of the features in the main classification models (n226) were identified in the feature selection for the alternative models (constructed otherwise identically, but FLI < 30 was compared against FLI ≥ 60 in different data partitions), together with 10 additional balances (Figure S4). Only one of the balances in the alternative models was outside phylum Firmicutes (n1712 in Bacteroidota), and in addition, 4 balances were outside class Clostridia (n481 in Negativicutes; n826, n1009 and n918 in Bacilli).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 2.

Relative effects of predictive balances and covariates on the FLI < 60 and FLI ≥ 60 classification model (AUC = 0.75) predictions. Nodes of the balances are indicated in the cladogram and the relative effect sizes of their clades (opposite sides of each balance) are shown in the associated heatmap. The relative effect sizes of the covariates (age and sex) are shown below the legend with a heatmap on the same scale as was used for the balances. The two liver-specific balances associated with triglyceride and GGT levels are indicated with bold font. Clades with redundant information have been collapsed but their major genera are indicated. The complete tree is included in Figure S3.

In addition to blood test results, FLI is based on anthropometric markers linked to metabolic syndrome, waist circumference and BMI. This prompted us to attempt to dissect the index and identify which of the covariates and associated microbial balances from the phylogenetic tree can be linked to blood GGT and triglycerides measurements (see Figure 1B), and therefore would be more specific to hepatic steatosis and liver damage. To do so, we performed feature selection (similarly to continuous FLI) for GGT and triglycerides measurements in subsets of participants grouped by age, sex, and BMI. The feature selection identified two balances within the NCBI Clostridia XIVa subcluster (identified as n336 and n330) which were important for both GGT and triglyceride level prediction, and thus likely specific to liver function (Figure 2). Bacterial taxa were positively linked to liver function in these balances, and included (NCBI species) Clostridium clostridioforme, C. bolteae, C. citroniae, C. saccharolyticum and C. symbiosum.

Ethanol and acetate production pathways are identified in representative bacterial genomes from taxa linked to liver function

The values of predictive balances in the phylogenetic tree cannot be summarized for individual taxa, which means that only a qualitative investigation of the associations between their metabolism and fatty liver was possible in this study. We identified genetic pathways predicted to encode for SCFA (acetate, propanoate, butanoate) and ethanol production, BA metabolism, and choline degradation to trimethylamine in representative genomes from the taxa we identified to be linked to liver function (Figure S3). These specific processes were chosen because they have been previously identified to have a mechanistic link to NAFLD (see e.g., ref. 19).

Acetate and ethanol production pathways appeared to be more abundant in the representative genomes of the taxa which had a positive association with FLI. In the liver function specific clades, n336 and n330, MetaCyc pathways for pyruvate fermentation to ethanol III (PWY-6587) and L-glutamate degradation V (via hydroxyglutarate; P162-PWY; produces acetate and butanoate) were present only in genomes positively associated with FLI. In balance n336, also heterolactic fermentation (P122-PWY; produces ethanol and lactate) was more often encoded in the FLI-associated clade (3/5) than the opposing clade (1/2). In representative genomes from the non-liver-specific balance n355, potential ethanol producers (PWY-6587) were seen in the positively associated clade, but for most balances such trends were not clear in the qualitative analysis. Furthermore, we did not detect any of these pathways in the representative genomes of two individual taxa positively associated with FLI, Negativibacillus sp000435195 and Phocea massiliensis (Figure S3).

FLI modeling reveals consistent associations between gram-positive Clostridia and fatty liver disease

We found significant linear correlations between the first three bacterial PC-axes of our samples (a measure of beta diversity) and FLI (see results and Figure 1C). Previous studies have shown differences in beta diversity in relation to NAFLD.³² However, FLI used in our study as a proxy for liver disease also includes features such as BMI and waist circumference, which associate with metabolic syndrome and type 2 diabetes.¹⁶ Links between these diseases and gut microbiome composition are well documented in previous studies.³³ It is thus not surprising that bacterial beta diversity and FLI were correlated, but unfortunately this simple correlation does not enable untangling the relative contributions of fatty liver disease and other metabolic diseases to the differences in bacterial beta diversity.

Several studies have reported highly specific changes in microbial abundances in relation to NAFLD.^12,34-36 In summary, while also conflicting results have been reported, generally increases in Lactobacillus and Escherichia genera, and a decrease in Coprococcus genus have been most often associated with a NAFLD diagnosis.³⁷ Furthermore, increased abundance of several gram-positive bacteria belonging to the Clostridium genus have often been positively linked with NAFLD.^14,38 Differences in unconstrained between-samples (beta) diversity have been also documented for persistent NAFLD,³² and along the NAFLD-cirrhosis spectrum.⁸

In our study, abundances of bacteria from the Coprococcus genus were not specifically associated with FLI, although the genus was nested inside our predictive balances. Strikingly, we did not identify any bacterial associations with FLI outside of the Firmicutes phylum. A possible reason for this might be the higher relative abundance of phylum Firmicutes at high latitudes, where Finland is.³⁹ Among the associations we identified, Faecalicatena gnavus (NCBI: Ruminococcus gnavus) was positively linked with FLI as part of 3 predictive balances, and associated in previous studies with liver cirrhosis.¹⁷ Interestingly, none of the oral Firmicutes, such as Veillonella, suggested to invade the gut, were identified in our own analyses. This might be caused by using FLI as a proxy, which is likely not closely associated with advanced liver disease, such as cirrhosis, and thus would target an earlier phase of liver disease progression.

Two individual taxa, Negativibacillus sp000435195 and Phocea massiliensis, were highly predictive of FLI group (Figures 2, S2), but not of its liver function-specific components. The associations of these taxa with fatty liver disease have not been documented previously. However, a decreasing abundance of both bacteria, Negativibacillus sp000435195 (NCBI: Clostridium sp. CAG:169) and Phocea massiliensis (NCBI: Phocea massiliensis), were seen when the intake of meat and refined cereal was reduced isocalorically in favor of fruit, vegetables, wholegrain cereal, legumes, fish and nuts in overweight and obese subjects in Italy.⁴⁰ While comparisons between these studies are difficult due to annotation, bacteria such as Faecalicatena gnavus (NCBI: Ruminococcus gnavus) and Clostridium Q saccharolyticum (NCBI: Clostridium saccharolyticum) were also found to respond negatively to the Mediterranean diet. Together with their positive association with FLI in our study, these observations would warrant further study on these species as plausible biomarkers for healthy diet choices.

Most taxa in our study with a positive association with FLI belonged to the (broadly defined) Clostridium NCBI genus, which supports several previous observations.^14,38 However, taxonomic standardization according to GTDB has identified the Clostridium genus as the most phylogenetically inconsistent of all bacterial genera in the NCBI taxonomy, and divides it into a total of 121 monophyletic genera in 29 distinct families.²⁸ These reassignments, although more accurate and sensible, complicate comparisons to previous research studies. However, our results strongly suggest that this finer taxonomic resolution might robustly reveal novel discoveries. Thus, while (shallow) shotgun metagenomic sequencing is often more costly than amplicon sequencing, this might be justified by the increased resolution which is required to accurately identify specific taxon-based associations (see e.g., refs. 27,41).

Bacterial taxa associated with a high FLI have a genetic potential to exacerbate the development of fatty liver disease

We identified several plausible new associations between individual taxa and clades of bacteria and fatty liver. All taxa were from class Clostridia, which are obligate anaerobes. We observed that reference genomes from the bacterial taxa positively associated with FLI in the liver-specific balances harbored several genetic pathways necessary for ethanol production. Specifically, genes predicted to enable the fermentation of pyruvate to ethanol (MetaCyc PWY-6587) appeared to be common. Endogenous production of ethanol has been known to both induce hepatic steatosis and increase intestinal permeability,⁴² and several of the taxa identified in our study have also been experimentally shown to produce ethanol, such as C. M asparagiforme, C. M bolteae, C. M clostridioforme / C. M clostridioforme A ⁴³, and C. Q Saccharolyticum.⁴⁴ The relative abundances of these putatively ethanol-producing taxa were predictive of FLI groups in previously unseen data. However, the self-reported alcohol consumption from the participants was not among the best predictors for the FLI groups, as it was excluded in the feature selection step.

All reference genomes from taxa positively associated with FLI in balance n330 harboured genes predicted to encode for the L-glutamate fermentation V (P162-PWY; Figure S3) pathway, which results in the production of acetate and butanoate. Glutamate fermentation could lead to increased microbial protein fermentation in the gut, which has been previously been linked with obesity, diabetes and NAFLD.⁴⁵ Recently, the combined intake of fructose and microbial acetate production in the gut was experimentally observed to contribute to lipogenesis in the liver in a mouse model.⁴⁶ Interestingly, C. Q saccharolyticum (in our study, a FLI-associated species deriving from balance n330), was experimentally shown to ferment various carbohydrates, including fructose, to acetate, hydrogen, carbon dioxide, and ethanol.⁴⁴ Furthermore, while our own pathway analysis did not detect BA modification pathways in the reference genome of C. Q saccharolyticum, a strain of this species has been highlighted as a probable contributor to NAFLD development through the synthesis of secondary BA.¹⁵ The links between dietary intake and gene regulation, combined with microbial fermentation in the gut warrant further mechanistic experiments to elucidate their links with fatty liver, and likely other metabolic diseases.

Intriguingly, NAFLD-associated ethanol producing bacteria in previous cohort studies have all been gram-negatives, such as (NCBI-defined) Klebsiella pneumoniae,¹³ and Escherichia coli.¹² In our population sample, instead of gram-negatives, bacteria from the C. M bolteae, C. M clostridioforme / C. M clostridioforme A and C. M citroniae species (linked in our study with FLI as deriving from balance n336) have been described as opportunistic pathogens,⁴⁷ and are hypothesized to exacerbate fatty liver development similarly through endogenous ethanol production. This result suggests that geographical,³¹ and ethnic variability,⁴⁸ might also strongly affect gut microbiome composition and its associations with disease. In addition to putative endogenous ethanol producers, we identified other FLI-associated taxa deriving from balance n330, for which reference genomes harbored a genetic pathway predicted to encode for the ability to ferment L-lysine to acetate and butyrate. While the production of these SCFAs is often considered beneficial for gut health, other metabolism of proteolytic bacteria might negatively contribute to fatty liver disease.⁴⁹

Through modeling a previously validated risk index for fatty liver, we could associate specific members of the gut microbiome with the disease across geographical regions in this representative sample of the general population in Finland. In addition, sex and age of participants were also strongly predictive of the FLI group in our models (Figures 2, S2, Table S1). Their similar positive associations with fatty liver disease are known from previous studies.^50,51 The associated microbial balances could be used to improve the predictions above the baseline of these covariates on 5/6 regions in Finland. For example, in the model cross-validated with Lapland the balances were more predictive of FLI group than the covariates by themselves, and their combination increased the AUC further. Yet, when testing the model where Turku/Loimaa region was used for cross-validation, the microbial balances were slightly predictive of FLI group but failed to improve the AUC over the covariates (Table S1). This pattern might stem from the cultural and genetic west-east division in Finland,^52,53 with a closer proximity of the Helsinki/Vantaa region to eastern regions than Turku/Loimaa, in both terms. It is thus likely that further incorporation and investigation on the use of spatial information in microbiome modeling would elucidate these geographical patterns in taxa-disease associations.

Conclusions

Modeling an established risk index for fatty liver enabled the detection of associations between the disease and gut microbiome composition, even to the level of individual taxa. These taxa and clades were all from the obligately anaerobic gram-positive class Clostridia, from several redefined GTDB genera previously included in the polyphyletic NCBI genus Clostridium. Many of the representative genomes of taxa positively associated with fatty liver had genomic potential for endogenous ethanol production. This suggests a possible mechanistic link to the pathophysiology of liver disease through increased gut permeability and induction of hepatic steatosis. Further mechanistic links with microbial production of SCFAs, especially acetate, and fatty liver development are also likely. Our models were able to predict the FLI group of participants across geographical regions in Finland, showing that the associations are robust and mostly generalizable in the sampled population.

Survey details and sample collection

Cardiovascular disease risk factors have been monitored in Finland since 1972 by conducting a representative population survey every five years.⁵⁴ In the FINRISK 2002 survey, a stratified random population sample was conducted on six geographical regions in Finland. These are North Karelia and Northern Savo in eastern Finland, Turku and Loimaa regions in southwestern Finland, the cities of Helsinki and Vantaa in the capital region, the provinces of Northern Ostrobothnia and Kainuu in northwestern Finland, and the province of Lapland in northern Finland. The Coordinating Ethics Committee of the Helsinki University Hospital District approved our study protocol (Ref. 558/E3/2001) and all participants have given their written informed consent.

Briefly, at baseline examination the participants filled out a questionnaire form, and trained nurses carried out a physical examination and blood sampling in local health centers or other survey sites. Data was collected for physiological measures, biomarkers, and dietary, demographic and lifestyle factors. Stool samples were collected by giving willing participants a stool sampling kit with detailed instructions. These samples were mailed overnight between Monday and Thursday under Finnish winter conditions to the laboratory of the Finnish Institute for Health and Welfare, where they were stored at −20°C. In 2017, the samples were shipped still unthawed to University of California San Diego for microbiome sequencing.

Further details of the FINRISK cohorts and sampling have been extensively covered in previous publications (for details, see refs. 24,55). The Coordinating Ethics Committee of the Helsinki University Hospital District approved our study protocol. All participants have given their written informed consent.

Stool DNA extraction and shallow shotgun metagenome sequencing

A miniaturized version of the Kapa HyperPlus Illumina-compatible library prep kit (Kapa Biosystems) was used for library generation, following the previously published protocol.⁵⁶ DNA extracts were normalized to 5 ng total input per sample in an Echo 550 acoustic liquid handling robot (Labcyte Inc). A Mosquito HV liquid-handling robot (TTP Labtech Inc was used for 1/10 scale enzymatic fragmentation, end-repair, and adapter-ligation reactions). Sequencing adapters were based on the iTru protocol,⁵⁷ in which short universal adapter stubs are ligated first and then sample-specific barcoded sequences added in a subsequent PCR step. Amplified and barcoded libraries were then quantified by the PicoGreen assay and pooled in approximately equimolar ratios before being sequenced on an Illumina HiSeq 4000 instrument to an average read count of approximately 900,000 reads per sample.

Taxonomic matching and phylogenetic transforms

To improve the taxonomic assignments of our reads, we used a custom index,⁵⁸ based on the Genome Taxonomy Database (GTDB) release 89 taxonomic redefinitions,^28,59 for read classification with default parameters in Centrifuge 1.0.4.⁶⁰ After read classification, all following steps were performed with R version 3.5.2.⁶¹ To reduce the number of spurious read assignments, and to facilitate more accurate phylogenetic transformations, only reads classified at the species level, matching individual GTDB reference genomes, were retained. Samples with less than 50,000 reads, from pregnant participants or recorded antibiotic use in the past 6 months were removed, resulting in a final number of 6,269 samples. We first filtered taxa not seen with more than 3 counts in at least 1% of samples and those with a coefficient of variation ≤ 3 across all samples, following McMurdie and Holmes⁶², with a slight adaption from 20% of samples to 1% of samples, because of our larger sample size. The complete bacterial and archaeal phylogenetic trees of the GTDB release 89 reference genomes, constructed from an alignment of 120 bacterial or 122 archaeal marker genes,²⁸ were then combined with our taxa tables. The resulting trees were thus subset only to species which were observed in at least one sample in our data. The read counts were transformed to phylogenetic node balances in both trees with PhILR.²⁹ The default method for PhILR inputs a pseudocount of 1 for taxa absent in an individual sample before the transform.

In this study, we did not specifically and solely use relative abundances at various taxonomic levels, as is common practice for microbiome studies. Instead, we applied a PhILR transformation to our microbial composition data,²⁹ introducing the concept of microbial “balances”. Indeed, evolutionary relationships of all species harbored in each microbiome sample can be represented on a phylogenetic tree, with species typically shown as external nodes that are related to each other by multiple branches connected by internal nodes. In this context, the value of a given microbial “balance” is defined as the log-ratio of the geometric mean abundance between two groups of microbes descending from the same corresponding internal node on a microbial phylogenetic tree. This phylogenetic transform was used because it i) addresses the compositionality of the metagenomic read data,⁶³ ii) permits simultaneous comparison of all clades without merging the taxa by predefined taxonomic levels, and iii) enables evolutionary insights into the microbial community. The links between microbes and their environment, such as the human gut, is mediated by their functions. Different functions are known to be conserved at different taxonomic resolutions, and most often at multiple different resolutions.⁶⁴ Thus, associations between the microbes and the response variable are likely not best explained by predefined taxonomic levels. In the absence of functional data, concurrently analyzing all clades (partitioned by the nodes in the phylogenetic tree) would likely enable the detection of the associations at the appropriate resolution depending on the function and the local tree topography.

Covariates

Because fatty liver disease is underdiagnosed at the population level,²⁵ and our sampling did not have extensive coverage of liver fat measurements, we chose to use the Fatty Liver index as a proxy for fatty liver.²⁶ Furthermore, the index performs well in cohorts of Caucasian ethnicity, such as ours, to diagnose the presence of NAFLD.²³ We calculated FLI after Bedogni et al.²⁶: (e^0.953*log e^{(triglycerides mg/dL) + 0.139*BMI + 0.718*log} e^{(GGT) + 0.053*waist circumference - 15.745}) / (1+e ^0.953*log e^{(triglycerides mg/dL) + 0.139*BMI + 0.718*log} e^{(GGT) + 0.053*waist circumference - 15.745}) * 100 We chose the cutoff at FLI ≥ 60 to identify participants likely to be diagnosed with hepatic steatosis (positive likelihood ratio = 4.3 and negative likelihood ratio = 0.5, after Bedogni et al.²⁶). Triglycerides, gamma glutamyl transferase (GGT), BMI and waist circumference measurements had near complete coverage for the participants in our data. Self-reported alcohol use was calculated as grams of pure ethanol per week. Cases with missing values were omitted in linear regression models. At least one feature used for FLI calculation was missing for 20 participants (0.3%) and the self-reported alcohol use was missing for 247 participants (3.9%). In the machine learning framework, missing values for FLI and self-reported alcohol use were mean imputed. However, for the feature selection to identify liver function-specific balances, GGT, triglycerides and BMI were not imputed but observations where any of these were missing were simply removed.

Beta-diversity and linear modeling of FLI

Beta-diversity was calculated as Euclidian distance of the PhILR balances through Principal Component Analysis (PCA) on bacterial and archaeal balances separately with “rda” in vegan 2.5.6.⁶⁵ A linear regression model was constructed for FLI with “lm” in base R,⁶¹ with log₁₀-transformed FLI as the dependent variable and with first three bacterial PCs, sex, age, and self-reported alcohol use as the independent variables. Archaeal PCs were dropped from the model because none of them were significantly correlated with FLI (all P > 0.05). Variation of the samples on the top two bacterial PC axes by their effect sizes in the model were plotted together with a unit vector of log₁₀(FLI) to show their correlation.

FLI modeling within a machine learning framework

In the machine learning framework, both regression and categorical models were constructed for FLI. The feature selection, hyperparameter optimization and cross-validation methods were identical for both approaches, unless otherwise stated. The continuous or categorical FLI (groups of FLI < 60 and FLI ≥ 60) were modeled with xgboost 0.90.0.2,⁶⁶ by using both bacterial and archaeal balances, sex, age, and self-reported alcohol use as preliminary predictor features. We used FLI 60 as the cutoff for ruling in fatty liver (steatosis) for the classification, after Bedogni et al., (2006). The data was first split to 70% train and 30% test sets while preserving sex and region balance. To take into account geographical differences (see e.g., ref. 31) and to find robust patterns across all 6 sampled regions in Finland between the features and FLI group, we used Leave-One-Group-Out Cross-Validation (LOGOCV) inside the 70% train set to construct 6 separate models in each optimization step. Because of high dimensionality of the data (3423 predictor features) feature selection by filtering was first performed inside the training data, based on random forest permutation as recommended by Bommert et al.⁶⁷ Briefly, permutation importance is based on accuracy, or specifically the difference in accuracy between real and permuted (random) values of the specific variable, averaged in all trees across the whole random forest. The permutation importance in models based on the 6 LOGOCV subsets of the training data were calculated with mlr 2.16.0,⁶⁸ and the simple intersect between the top 50 features in all LOGOCV subsets were retained as the final set of features. Thus, the feature selection was influenced by the training data from all 6 geographical regions, but this only serves to limit the number of chosen features because of the required simple intersect. This approach was used to obtain a set of core predictive features which would have potential for generalizability across the regions. The number of features included in the models by this approach was deemed appropriate, since the relative effect size of the last included predictor was very small (< 0.1 change in classification probability across its range).

Bayesian hyperparameter optimization of the xgboost models was then performed with only the selected features. An optimal set of parameters for the xgboost models were searched over all LOGOCV subsets with “mbo” in mlrMBO 1.1.3,⁶⁹ using 30 preliminary rounds with randomized parameters, followed by 100 optimization rounds. Parameters in the xgboost models and their considered ranges were learning rate (eta) [0.001, 0.3], gamma [0.1, 5], maximum depth of a tree [2, 8], minimum child weight [1, 10], fraction of data subsampled per each iteration [0.2, 0.8], fraction of columns subsampled per tree [0.2, 0.9], and maximum number of iterations (nrounds) [50, 5000]. The parameters recommended by these searchers were as following for regression: eta=0.00889; gamma=2.08; max_depth=2; min_child_weight=8; subsample=0.783; colsample_bytree=0.672; nrounds=1810, and for classification: eta=0.00107; gamma=0.137; max_depth=5; min_child_weight=9; subsample=0.207; colsample_bytree=0.793; nrounds=4328. We used Root-Mean-Square Error (RMSE) for the regression models and Area Under the ROC Curve (AUC) for the classification models to measure model fit on the left-out data (region) in each LOGOCV subset. The final models were trained on the LOGOCV subset training data, the data from one region thus omitted per model, and using the selected features and optimized hyperparameters. Validation of these models was conducted against participants only from the region omitted from each model, in the 30% test data which was not used in model training or optimization. Sensitivity analysis was conducted by using only the predictive covariates (sex and age) or balances separately, with the same hyperparameters, data partitions and final validation as for the full models.

Partial dependence interpretation of the FLI classification models

Because the classification models have a more clinically relevant modeling target for the difference between FLI < 60 and FLI ≥ 60, the latter used to rule in fatty liver,²⁶ we further interpreted the partial dependence of their predictions. Partial dependence of the classification model predictions on individual features was calculated with “partial” in pdp 0.7.0.⁷⁰ The partial dependence of the features on the model predictions was also plotted, overlaying the results from each of the 6 models. For each feature, its relative effect on the model prediction was estimated as medians of the minimum and maximum yhat (output probability of the model for the FLI ≥ 60 class), calculated at the minimum and maximum values of the feature separately in each of the 6 models. The relative effects of the balances were then overlaid as a heatmap on a genome cladogram which covers all balances in the model with ggtree 2.1.1.⁷¹

Construction of alternative classification models to discern between FLI < 30 and FLI ≥ 60 groups

To assess robustness of the models and how removing the participants with intermediate FLI (between 30 and 60) affects model performance, we removed this group (N = 1910) and constructed alternative classification models to discern between the FLI < 30 and FLI ≥ 60 groups. Other than removing the intermediate FLI participants and resulting new random split to the train (70%) and test (30%) sets, these models were constructed identically to the main models, including LOGOCV design, feature selection, and hyperparameter optimization. The recommended parameters for this classification task were eta=0.00102; gamma=3.7; max_depth=2; min_child_weight=5; subsample=0.49; colsample_bytree=0.631; nrounds=3119. Interpretation of partial dependence was also performed identically, but only the relative effects of the model features were plotted without a cladogram.

Exclusion of validation region data from feature selection and hyperparameter optimization

Because training data from all 6 regions is used to inform the selection of optimal features and hyperparameters, the validation region data cannot be considered completely independent from the training of the LOGOCV models. Thus, we constructed a set of classification models for the FLI ≥ 60 and FLI < 60 groups, where all validation region samples also in the training data were excluded from the simple intercept of top 50 features in each LOGOCV set and from the subsequent hyperparameter optimization. These models with individualized features and hyperparameters were then tested on the validation region samples in the unseen test data to estimate how model performance was affected. The main test (70%) and train (30%) sets were identical to the main models, but additionally 6 randomized 70/30 splits nested inside the test set (excluding the validation region) were used in hyperparameter optimization to reduce overfitting. Average optimal hyperparameters in the 6 models were eta=0.00106; gamma=4.3; max_depth=2; min_child_weight=7; subsample=0.36; colsample_bytree=0.613; nrounds=1772.

Identification of predictive features specific to liver function

Because the FLI also incorporates BMI and waist circumference, and they strongly contribute to the index,²⁶ we deemed it necessary to further investigate which of the identified balances were specific to liver function. The participants were first grouped by age (< 40, 40 – 60, and 60 <), sex (female or male) and BMI (< 25, 25 – 30, and 30 <) into 18 categories (N = 105 ~ 711 per category). We performed feature selection similarly to the FLI models by fitting random forest regressors for GGT and triglycerides with mlr 2.16.0.⁶⁸ This was done separately in each of the 18 categories, and in each category, we again used LOGOCV with the regions to obtain 6 runs per category. Finally, the features predictive of GGT or triglycerides in each category were selected as the intersect of top 50 features in the 6 LOGOCV iterations by permutation importance. The intersect of features predictive of GGT or triglycerides in any of the categories and the features predictive of categorical FLI were identified as specific to liver function.

Pathway inference for taxa associated with FLI

Our taxonomic matching of the reads is based on the genomes of GTDB (release 89),²⁸ which are all complete or nearly complete and available in online databases. This enables us to estimate the likely genetic content, and thus, the metabolic potential of the microbes associated with FLI. We use this approach because the sequencing depth of our samples does not allow assembling contigs and (metagenome-assembled) genomes, required for pathway predictions. Because of the compositional phylogenetic transform, among other features of our data, previously developed approaches such as PICRUSt,⁷² could not be used here.

The genomes of all 336 bacteria under at least one of the predictive balances were downloaded from NCBI. 119 of these genomes were originally not annotated, which is a requirement for pathway prediction. Therefore, Prokka v1.14.6,⁷³ was used to annotate the 119 unannotated genomes as a preliminary step. Pathway predictions were then performed for all 336 genomes with mpwt v0.5.3 multiprocessing tool,⁷⁴ for the PathoLogic pipeline of Pathway Tools 23.0.⁷⁵ Pathways for ethanol and short chain fatty acid (acetate, butyrate, propionate) production, bile acid metabolism, and choline degradation to trimethylamine were identified from MetaCyc pathway classifications (see ref. 76, and Table S4). The prevalence of these processes was then assessed in the analyzed genomes and summarized per process to consider the possible links of the taxa with fatty liver pathophysiology. Finally, the presence of individual pathways for acetate and ethanol production was also outlined for each genome.