Intended for healthcare professionals

News

Cannabis: Canada sees queues and shortages as it legalises recreational use

BMJ 2018; 363 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.k4421 (Published 18 October 2018) Cite this as: BMJ 2018;363:k4421
  1. Owen Dyer
  1. Montreal

On 17 October Canada became the second country to legalise the possession, consumption, and licensed sale of cannabis, after Uruguay.

Legalisation is a typically Canadian patchwork quilt, as each of 10 provinces and three territories has made its own arrangements for the sale and regulation of cannabis. In Ontario you may smoke it in public wherever tobacco is permitted, but in Manitoba this will incur a C$672 (£394; €449; US$515) fine. In some provinces the minimum age is 18, in others 19, and in Quebec the new government threatens to raise it to 21.

In Alberta 17 private retailers have opened. In Quebec long lines formed outside 12 stores operated by a new public monopoly. In Ontario only online sales are permitted through the official Ontario Cannabis Store, but dozens of private stores will open in April. In Saskatchewan shortages of product left many stores unable to open.

In British Columbia, as legal sales began, dozens of illegal dispensaries—normally unmolested by police—closed for the day, fearful that the provincial government, now a competitor, would become a stricter enforcer.

Driving illegal vendors out of business is the federal government’s declared aim in legalising cannabis. “It’s by displacing the black market that we can control sales and put cannabis out of reach of our children,” said Ginette Petitpas Taylor, federal health minister.

Taylor and the prime minister, Justin Trudeau, both cited Colorado, the first US state to legalise recreational marijuana, saying that its illegal market had declined rapidly with the advent of legal pot. Trudeau said that a key marker of success would be a sharp reduction in the Canadian black market’s current estimated $6bn a year turnover.

The other metric on which legalisation should be judged, said the health minister, is cannabis use by minors. This is measured annually in the Canadian Student Tobacco, Alcohol and Drugs survey,1 which recently found that 17% of students aged 13-18 had consumed cannabis in the past year. This is one of the highest percentages in the world and exceeds the 15.6% of Canadians aged over 15 who admitted recent pot consumption to the National Cannabis Survey.2

The health minister said that she had come around to supporting legalisation because of a growing scientific consensus that cannabis poses special risks to developing brains. To reduce adolescent use the government may have to live with higher adult use, as 5.7% of non-users aged over 15 told the National Cannabis Survey that they intend to try cannabis because of legalisation. Among current users, 27.5% said that they intend to increase their consumption.

Half of current users told the survey that they intend to keep purchasing from unofficial sources, but the Liberal government believes that licensed vendors can undercut these on price. Legal pot was selling for as little as $5.25/g in Quebec, where the street price would be nearer $10.

In Nunavut, Canada’s newest territory, which the survey suggests has Canada’s highest cannabis consumption, prices will be nearer $12/g, but illegal drugs are also far pricier in the high north. Nunavut will allow legal marijuana everywhere, even though 19 of its communities have full or partial alcohol bans.

Legal marijuana comes in plain packages carrying Health Canada warnings that highlight the drug’s known dangers. Labelling specifies the proportion of the active ingredients cannabidiol (CBD) and tetrahydrocannabinol (THC). Edibles are due to become legal on 17 October 2019. The industry is also keen to introduce vaporisation pens and infused drinks.

On the morning of legalisation the federal government reversed its course and offered to facilitate pardons for people previously convicted of minor possession offences. The opposition New Democrats said that this did not go far enough, calling for an amnesty with expungement of all records.

Neither option is likely to placate the US’s border guards, who have said that they will not recognise pardons. At a press conference they reiterated their policy of turning away or banning anyone known to have used cannabis. However, polls suggest that New York state voters will strongly back legalisation in three weeks. If they do, New York will become the 10th state to legalise recreational marijuana.

As two of the biggest Canadian marijuana companies went public on the New York Stock Exchange a US cannabis investor took out a full page advertisement in the Wall Street Journal, urging President Donald Trump not to let Canadian companies seize the lead in a market that many expect to eventually go global.

References