Covid-19: Doctors sound alarm over hospital transmissions

No official data

Currently there are no official figures on numbers of patients contracting covid-19 in hospitals. However, the Guardian newspaper reported that the proportion of covid-19 infections acquired in hospital was between 10% and 20%, although NHS sources told the paper that the figures were skewed by poor infection control procedures at one single trust and that the true rate was lower, at around 5% to 7%.2

Although the government loosened lockdown controls last week, the prime minister admitted in parliament that further progress would not be possible “unless we crack these twin epidemics both in care homes and in the NHS.”3

Coebergh said data on hospital acquired covid-19 needed to be made readily available to ensure that patients weren’t put off seeking care in acute settings. “Unless we have the data, we can’t reassure patients and say, ‘We have done this and this and to reduce it,’” he said. “We have a duty to tell people if they’ve been possibly harmed by our care.”

The International Severe Acute Respiratory and Emerging Infection Consortium is looking at data from around a third of hospital trusts in England to try to assess the level of hospital acquired infection connected to covid-19.

Chris Green, senior clinical lecturer and consultant physician in infectious disease at University of Birmingham and an investigator with the consortium, said it was appropriate for each trust to tailor its infection control to local circumstances, noting that larger hospitals may be able to set up separate “hot” and “cold” sites for covid and non-covid patients, while smaller hospitals may have to settle for internal “hot and cold pathways” within one site.

“Getting it right will not be a black and white measure. Some trusts will probably manage better than others, but then some are in a better position than others to get it right in the first place, depending on how they are set up and the local epidemiology,” he said.

But Green emphasised that every hospital should be separating patients into three groups to minimise the spread of infection: patients with confirmed covid-19, patients confirmed not to have it, and those in whom it is suspected but not confirmed.

“The only thing that we can do now—as well as social distancing—is to carry on with these blunt measures, like separating ‘hot’ hospitals from ‘cold’ hospitals (or hot zones from cold zones within hospitals), and aggressively testing staff and patients whenever we can to try to pick out as early as possible who is PCR [polymerase chain reaction] positive and isolate [them]. That’ll be the only way that we can really get the hospital transmission down further.”

But he added, “Of course, you have to be realistic. There will always be some transmission, not least because transmission can occur in asymptomatic people. But there is also a significant false negative rate from nasopharyngeal swabs taken in the early stages of infection.”

More broadly, Green said that the risks of nosocomial transmission needed to be balanced with the risk of a patient not being treated in hospital at all. “Now that we’re coming down the peak . . . there is a risk of hospital acquired infections, but also there is a significant risk of harm coming to you if you don’t have access to hospital care,” he said.

Avoiding overcrowding

The importance of infection control will come into sharper focus as the NHS begins to restart many other services that were stopped during the pandemic and as people who may have been seeking care elsewhere, or not at all, return to hospitals.

Katherine Henderson, president of the Royal College of Emergency Medicine, said it was vital that emergency departments did not return to the chronic overcrowding and “corridor care” of times before the pandemic, as this would make nosocomial infection far more likely.

She said, “We cannot restart emergency departments at the same level that they were at before and end up with crowded departments. But that means quite a lot of reorganisation. We can’t offload ambulances into a corridor any more. How do we do social distancing? How do we make sure we’ve got enough cubicles? All emergency departments in the land are wondering what to do about this. There’s a lot of fast footwork needed, because patients are beginning to come back.”

Henderson said the whole health and care system needed to cooperate to ensure that emergency departments were safe places for patients with genuine emergencies.

“Emergency departments can’t be a safety net for a lot of lower acuity clinical presentations that perhaps other parts of the system should be managing,” she said. “We’ve got to think very carefully about who comes to the emergency department and why, so that we’re seeing the right people and keeping the most vulnerable safe.

“If someone has been shielding at home, and then they happen to get chest pain or fall over and break their hip, it cannot be that it’s a bad thing for them to come into the emergency department.”