Abstract
Background
Surgeons have increasingly performed breast-conserving surgery (BCS) utilizing oncoplastic techniques in place of standard lumpectomy for early-stage breast cancer. We assess oncologic outcomes after oncoplastic BCS for T1–T2 breast cancer.
Methods
A systematic literature review identified peer-reviewed articles in PubMed evaluating BCS with oncoplastic reconstruction. Selected studies reported on positive margin rate (PMR), re-excision rate (RR), conversion to mastectomy rate (CMR), overall survival (OS), disease-free survival (DFS), local recurrence (LR), distant recurrence (DR), complication rate, and/or cosmetic outcomes.
Results
The search yielded 474 articles; 55 met the inclusion criteria and collectively evaluated 6011 patients with a mean age 54.6 years over a mean follow-up 50.5 months. T1 (43.8 %) and T2 (39.3 %) invasive ductal carcinoma were the most common tumor histopathologies. PMR, RR, and CMR were 10.8, 6.0, and 6.2 %, respectively, while OS, DFS, LR and DR were 95.0, 90.0, 3.2, and 8.7 %, respectively. Margin widths were heterogeneously defined in studies that included margin assessment. The PMR was not significantly different when positive margins were defined as tumor <10, <5, < 2, and <1 mm from ink margin, or tumor on ink (p = 0.162). Eleven studies reported specific margins for 1455 patients, of whom 143 (9.8 %) had positive margins, including 113 (7.8 %) with tumor on ink.
Conclusions
This study is the largest comprehensive literature review to date on oncoplastic BCS. Our systematic review reveals high rates of OS and DFS with low LR, DR, PMR, RR, CMR and complication rates, thereby confirming the oncologic safety of this procedure in patients with T1–T2 invasive breast cancer.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Breast cancer: estimated incidence, mortality and prevalence worldwide in 2012. World Health Organization International Agency for Research on Cancer. Available at: http://globocan.iarc.fr/old/FactSheets/cancers/breast-new.asp. Accessed 30 Dec 2015.
Franceschini G, Martin Sanchez A, Di Leone A, Magno S, Moschella F, Accetta C, et al. New trends in breast cancer surgery: a therapeutic approach increasingly efficacy and respectful of the patient. G Chir. 2015;36(4):145–52.
Piper M, Peled AW, Sbitany H. Oncoplastic breast surgery: current strategies. Gland Surgery. 2015;4(2):154–163.
Audretsch WP (ed). Reconstruction of the partial mastectomy defect: classification and method. Surgery of the breast: principles and art. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott Raven; 1998.
Asgeirsson KS, Rasheed T, McCulley SJ, Macmillan RD. Oncological and cosmetic outcomes of oncoplastic breast conserving surgery. Eur J Surg Oncol. 2005;31:817–23.
Clough KB, Kroll SS, Audretsch W. An approach to the repair of partial mastectomy defects. Plast Reconstr Surg. 1999;104(2): 409–20.
Masetti R, Pirulli PG, Magno S, Franceschini G, Chiesa F, Antinori A. Oncoplastic techniques in the conservative surgical treatment of breast cancer. Breast Cancer. 2000;7(4): 276–80.
Clough KB, Nos C, Salmon RJ, Soussaline M, Durand JC. Conservative treatment of breast cancers by mammaplasty and irradiation: a new approach to lower quadrant tumours. Plast Reconstr Surg. 1994;96(2):363–70.
Petit JY, Rietjens M, Garusi C. Breast reconstructive techniques in cancer patients: which one, when to apply, which immediate and long term risks? Crit Rev Oncol Hematol. 2001;38(3):231–9.
Papp C, Wechselberger G, Schoeller T. Autologous breast reconstruction after breast-conserving cancer surgery. Plast Reconstr Surg. 1998;102(6):1932–6.
Losken A, Elwood ET, Styblo TM, Bostwick J III. The role of reduction mammaplasty in reconstructing partial mastectomy defects. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2002;109(3):968–75.
Spear SL, Pelletiere CV, Wolfe AJ, Tsangaris TN, Pennanen MF. Experience with reduction mammoplasty combined with breast conservation therapy in the treatment of breast cancer. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2003;111(3):1102–9.
Chang E, Johnson N, Webber B, et al. Bilateral reduction mammoplasty in combination with lumpectomy for treatment of breast cancer in patients with macromastia. Am J Surg. 2004;187(5):647–50, discussion 650–1.
Newman LA, Kuerer HM, McNeese MD, et al. Reduction mammoplasty improves breast conservation therapy in patients with macromastia. Am J Surg. 2001:181(3): 215–20.
Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG. Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses: the PRISMA Statement. BMJ. 2009;339:b2535.
Gulcelik MA, Dogan L, Yuksel M, Camlibel M, Ozaslan C, Reis E. Comparison of outcomes of standard and oncoplastic breast-conserving surgery. J Breast Cancer. 2013;16(2): 193–7.
Lovrics PJ, Cornacchi SD, Farrokhyar F, Garnett A, Chen V, Fanic S, et al. The relationship between surgical factors and margin status after breast-conservation surgery for early stage breast cancer. Am J Surg. 2009;197(6):740–76.
Acosta JA, Greenlee JA, Gubler KD, Goepfert CJ, Ragland JJ. Surgical margins after needle-localization breast biopsy. Am J Surg. 1995;170(6):643–6.
Gajdos C, Ian Tartter PI, Bleiweiss IJ, Hermann G, de Csepel J, Estabrook A, et al. Mammographic appearance of nonpalpable breast cancer reflects pathologic characteristics. Ann Surg. 2002;235(2):246–51.
Papa MZ, Klein E, Davidson B, et al. The effect of anesthesia type on needle localization breast biopsy: another point of view. Am J Surg. 1996;171(2):242–3.
Ananthakrishna P, Balci FL, Crowe JP. Optimizing surgical margins in breast conservation. Intl J Surg Oncol. 2012;2012:585670. doi:10.1155/2012/585670.
Mansfield L, Agrawal A, Cutress RI. Oncoplastic breast conserving surgery. Gland Surg. 2013;2(3):158–62.
Clough KB, Lewis JS, Couturaud B, Fitoussi A, Nos C, Falcou MC. Oncoplastic techniques allow extensive resections for breast-conserving therapy of breast carcinomas. Am J Surg. 2003;237(1):26–34.
Moran MS, Schnitt SJ, Giuliano AE, et al. Society of Surgical Oncology-American Society for Radiation Oncology consensus guideline on margins for breast-conserving surgery with whole-breast irradiation in stages I and II invasive breast cancer. J Clin Oncol. 2014;32(14):1507–15.
Tenofsky PL, Dowell P, Topalovski T. Helmer SD. Surgical, oncologic, and cosmetic differences between oncoplastic and nononcoplastic breast conserving surgery in breast cancer patients. Am J Surg. 2014;207(3):398–402.
Agarwal S, Pappas L, Neumayer L, Kokeny K, Agarwal J. Effect of breast conservation therapy vs mastectomy on disease-specific survival for early-stage breast cancer. JAMA Surg. 2014;149(3):267–74.
Hwang ES, Lichtenstajn MS, Gomze SL, Fowble B, Clarke CA. Survival after lumpectomy and mastectomy for early stage invasive breast cancer. Cancer. 2013;119(7):1402–11.
Morrow M, Harris JR, Schnitt SJ. Surgical margins in lumpectomy for breast cancer: bigger is not better. N Engl J Med. 2012;367:79–82.
Acosta-Marin V, Acosta-Freites V, Contreras A, et al. Oncoplastic breast surgery: initial experience at the Centro Clinico de Estereotaxia—CECLINES, Caracas, Venezuela. Ecancermedicalscience. 2014;8:470.
Aljarrah A, Nos C, Nasr R, Clough KB, Bats AS, Lecuru F. Updated follow-up of patients treated with the oncoplastic “Crescent” technique for breast cancer. Breast. 2012;21:475–9.
Caruso F, Catanuto G, De Meo L, et al. Outcomes of bilateral mammoplasty for early stage breast cancer. Eur J Surg Oncol. 2008;34(10):1143–7.
Caruso F, Ferrara M, Castiglione G, et al. Therapeutic mammaplasties: Full local control of breast cancer in one surgical stage with frozen section. Eur J Surg Oncol. 2011;27(10):871–5.
Chakravorty A, Shrestha AK, Sanmugalingam N, et al. How safe is oncoplastic breast conservation? Comparative analysis with standard breast conserving surgery. Eur J Surg Oncol. 2012;38(5):395–8.
Chang E, Johnson N, Webber B, et al. Bilateral reduction mammoplasty in combination with lumpectomy for treatment of breast cancer in patients with macromastia. Am J Surg. 2004;187(5):647–50.
Clough KB, Gouveia PF, Benyahi D, Massey EJ, Russ E, Sarfati I, et al. Positive margins after oncoplastic surgery for breast cancer. Ann Surg Oncol. 2015;22(13):4247–53.
Colombo PE, Lefevre M, Delmond L, et al. Oncoplastic resection of breast cancers located in the lower-inner or lower-outer quadrant with the modified McKissock mammaplasty technique. Ann Surg Oncol. 2015;22 Suppl 3:486–94.
Crown A, Wechter DG, Grumley JW. Oncoplastic breast-conserving surgery reduces mastectomy and postoperative re-excision. Ann Surg Oncol. 2015;22(10):3363–8.
Cuttress RI, Simoes T, Gill J, Hurren JS. Modification of the Wise pattern breast reduction for oncological mammaplasty of upper outer and upper inner quadrant breast tumours: a technical note and case series. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2013;66(2):e31–6.
Egro FM, Pinell-White X, Hart AM, Losken A. The use of reduction mammaplasty with breast conservation therapy: an analysis of timing and outcomes. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2015;135(6):963e–71e.
El-Marakby HH, Kotb MH. Oncoplastic volume replacement with latissimus dorsi myocutaneous flap in patients with large ptotic breasts. Is it feasible? J Egypt Natl Cancer Inst. 2011;23(4):163–9.
Emiroglu M, Sert I, Karaali C, Aksoy SO, Ugurlu L Aydin C. The effectiveness of simultaneous oncoplastic breast surgery in patients with locally advanced breast cancer. Breast Cancer. 2016;23(3):463–70.
Emiroglu M, Salimoglu S, Karaali C, Sert I, Gungor O, Sert F, et al. Oncoplastic reduction mammoplasty for breast cancer in women with macromastia: oncological long-term outcomes. Asian J Surg. 2015. doi: 10.1016/j.asjsur.2015.07.007.
Fitoussi AD, Berry MG, Fama F, et al. Oncoplastic breast surgery for cancer: analysis of 540 consecutive cases. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2010;125(2):454–62.
Giacalone PL, Roger P, Dubon O, El Gareh N, Rihaoui S, Taourel P, et al. Comparative study of the accuracy of breast resection in oncoplastic surgery and quadrantectomy in breast cancer. Ann Surg Oncol. 2007;14(2):605–14.
Grubnik A, Benn C, Edwards G. Therapeutic mammaplasty for breast cancer: oncological and aesthetic outcomes. World J Surg. 2013;37(1):72–83.
Hamdi M. Oncoplastic and reconstructive surgery of the breast. Breast. 2013;22 Suppl 2:S100–5.
Hernanz F, Regaño S, Redondo-Figuero C, Orallo V, Erasun F, Gómez-Fleitas M. Oncoplastic breast-conserving surgery: analysis of quadrantectomy and immediate reconstruction with latissimus dorsi flap. World J Surg. 2007;31(10):1934–40.
Huemer GM, Schrenk P, Moser F, Wagner E, Wayand W. Oncoplastic techniques allow breast-conserving treatment in centrally located breast cancers. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2007;120(2):390–8.
Kaur N, Petit JY, Rietjens M, et al. Comparative study of surgical margins in oncoplastic surgery and quadrantectomy in breast cancer. Ann Surg Oncol. 2005;12(7):539–45.
Kaviani A, Safavi A, Mohammadzadeh N, Jamei K, Ansari-Damavandi M, Salmon RJ. Oncoplastic surgery in breast conservation: a prospective evaluation of the patients, techniques, and oncologic outcomes. Am J Surg. 2014;208(5):727–34.
Kim J, Yoo J, Lee J, Chang E, Suh K. Oncoplastic reconstruction with superior based lateral breast rotation flap after lower quadrant tumor resection. J Breast Cancer. 2012;15(3):350–5.
Kronowitz SJ, Hunt KK, Kuerer HM, et al. Practical guidelines for repair of partial mastectomy defects using the breast reduction technique in patients undergoing breast conservation therapy. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2007;120(7):1755–68.
De Lorenzi F, Hubner G, Rotmensz N, et al. Oncological results of oncoplastic breast-conserving surgery: Long term follow-up of a large series at a single institution: a matched-cohort analysis. Eur J Surg Oncol. 2016;42(1):71–7.
Losken A, Styblo TM, Carlston GW, Jones GE, Amerson BJ. Management algorithm and outcome evaluation of partial mastectomy defects treated using reduction or mastopexy techniques. Ann Plast Surg. 2007;59(3):235–42.
Losken A, Pinell-White X, Hart AM, Freitas AM, Carlson GW, Styblo TM. The oncoplastic reducation approach to breast conservation therapy: benefits for margin control. Aesthet Surg J. 2014;34(8):1185–91.
Malhaire C, Hequet D, Falcou MC, et al. Outcome of oncoplastic breast-conserving surgery following bracketing wire localization for large breast cancer. Breast. 2015;24(4):370–5.
Mansell J, Weiler-Mithoff E, Martin J, Khan A, Stallard S, Doughty JC, et al. How to compare the oncological safety of oncoplastic breast conservation surgery—To wide local excision or mastectomy? Breast. 2015;24(4):497–501.
Mazouni C, Naveau A, Kane A, et al. The role of oncoplastic breast surgery in the management of breast cancer treated with primary chemotherapy. Breast. 2013;22(6):1189–93.
McCulley SJ, Macmillan RD. Therapeutic mammoplasty: analysis of 50 consecutive cases. Br J Plast Surg. 2005;58(7):902–7.
McCulley SJ, Durani P, Macmillan RD. Therapeutic mammoplasty for centrally located breast tumors. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2006;117(2):366–73.
Meretoja TJ, Svarvar C, Jahkola TA. Outcome of oncoplastic breast surgery in 90 prospective patients. Am J Surg. 2010;200(2):224–8.
Moustafa A, Fakhr I. Outcome of different oncoplastic surgical (OPs) techniques for centrally located breast cancer (CLBC). J Egypt Natl Canc Inst. 2014;26(4):203–9.
Munhoz AM, Montag E, Arruda EG, Aldrighi C, Gemperli R, Aldrighi JM, et al. Critical analysis of reduction mammaplasty techniques in combination with conservative breast surgery for early breast cancer treatment. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2006;117(4):1091–103.
Nos C, Fitoussi A, Bourgeois D, Fourquet A, Salmon RJ, Clough KB. Conservative treatment of lower pole breast cancers by bilateral mammoplasty and radiotherapy. Eur J Surg Oncol. 1998;24(6):508–14.
Ogawa T. Usefulness of breast-conserving surgery using the round block technique or modified round block technique in Japanese females. Asian J Surg. 2014;37(1):8–14.
Patel KM, Hannan CM, Gatti ME, Nahabedian MY. A head-to-head comparison of quality of life and aesthetic outcomes following immediate, staged-immediate, and delayed oncoplastic reduction mammaplasty. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2011;127(6):2167–75.
Piper M, Peled AW, Sbitany H, Foster RD, Esserman LJ, Price ER. Comparison of mammographic findings following oncoplastic mammoplasty and lumpectomy without reconstruction. Ann Surg Oncol. 2016;23(1):65–71.
Regaño S, Hernanz F, Ortega E, Redondo-Figuero C, Gómez-Fleitas M. Oncoplastic techniques extend breast-conserving surgery to patients with neoadjuvant chemotherapy response unfit for conventional techniques. World J Surg. 2009;33(10):2082–6.
Rezai M, Knispel S, Kellersmann S, Lax H, Kimmig R, Kern P. Systematization of oncoplastic surgery: selection of surgical techniques and patient-reported outcome in a cohort of 1,035 patients. Ann Surg Oncol. 2015;22(11):3730–7.
Rietjens M, Urban CA, Rey PC, et al. Long-term oncological results of breast conservative treatment with oncoplastic surgery. Breast. 2007;16(4):387–95.
Rose M, Svensson H. Tunnelled lateral fasciocutaneous thoracodorsal flap with a skin island in breast reconstruction in oncoplastic breast surgery. J Plast Surg Hand Surg. 2012;46(6):404–9.
Roughton MC, Shenaq D, Jaskowiak N, Park JE, Song DH. Optimizing delivery of breast conservation therapy: a multidisciplinary approach to oncoplastic surgery. Ann Plast Surg. 2012;69(3):250–5.
Santos G, Urban C, Edelweiss MI, et al. Long-term comparison of aesthetical outcomes after oncoplastic surgery and lumpectomy in breast cancer patients. Ann Surg Oncol. 2015;22(8):2500–8.
Semprini G, Cattin F, Vaienti L, Brizzolari M, Cedolini C, Parodi PC. Oncoplastic surgery and cancer relapses: cosmetic and oncological results in 489 patients. Breast. 2013;22(5):946–51.
Sherwell-Cabello S, Maffuz-Aziz A, Villegas-Carlos F, Domínguez-Reyes C, Labastida-Almendaro S, Rodríguez-Cuevas S. Feasibility and cosmetic outcome of oncoplastic surgery in breast cancer treatment [in Spanish]. Cir Cir. 2015;83(3):199–205.
Smith ML, Evans GR, Gürlek A, et al. Reduction mammaplasty: its role in breast conservation surgery for early-stage breast cancer. Ann Plast Surg. 1998;41:234–9.
Vallejo da Silva A, Destro C, Torres W. Oncoplastic surgery of the breast: rationale and experience of 30 cases. Breast. 2007;16(4):411–9.
Zaha H, Onomura M, Unesoko M. A new scarless oncoplastic breast-conserving surgery: modified round block technique. Breast. 2013;22(6):1184–8.
Zaha H. Oncoplastic volume replacement technique for the upper inner quadrant using the omental flap. Gland Surg. 2015;4(3):263–9.
Author contributions
Lucy De La Cruz conceptualized and designed the project, and performed data acquisition. Stephanie Blankenship performed data acquisition, data analysis and interpretation, and drafted the initial manuscript. Lucy De La Cruz, Abhishek Chatterjee, Rula Geha, Nadia Nocera, Brian Czerniecki, Julia Tchou, and Carla Fisher assisted in critical revision of the manuscript. All authors reviewed, revised and approved the final manuscript as submitted and agree to be accountable for all aspects of the work.
Disclosures
No external funding was secured for this study. The authors have no financial relationships or conflicts of interest to disclose that are relevant to this article.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
De La Cruz, L., Blankenship, S.A., Chatterjee, A. et al. Outcomes After Oncoplastic Breast-Conserving Surgery in Breast Cancer Patients: A Systematic Literature Review. Ann Surg Oncol 23, 3247–3258 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1245/s10434-016-5313-1
Received:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1245/s10434-016-5313-1