Parents’ hesitancy towards vaccination in Indonesia: A cross-sectional study in Indonesia

Abstract

Background

Hesitancy towards vaccination has been studied as a barrier to vaccination among children, as well as participation in vaccine trials. This study aimed to investigate hesitancy towards vaccination among parents in Indonesia, as a part of the Indonesia Zika Vaccine Study.

Methods

A cross-sectional study was conducted in eleven regencies and municipalities in Aceh and West Sumatra province, Indonesia. Parents were recruited from families at outpatient clinics of community health centers or hospitals. The survey included various questions about sociodemographic factors and the Parent Attitudes about Childhood Vaccination (PACV) scale. Linear regression was employed to assess the association between explanatory variables and vaccine hesitancy.

Results

A total of 956 parents were interviewed and 26.4% of participants had heard about Zika. Overall, 152 parents (15.9%) were vaccine hesitant, and this proportion was the highest in the safety and efficacy subdomain (61.6%). In the unadjusted analysis, having a diploma certificate, working in the health sector, and having heard about Zika were significantly associated with non-hesitancy towards children vaccination. Having heard about Zika was the only factor that was significantly associated with hesitancy towards vaccination in multivariate model (aOR: 0.43, 95% CI: 0.26–0.71). Mothers, younger parents (aged 20–29 years old), and those with only a primary school education were more concerned about vaccine safety and efficacy compared to fathers, older groups, and individuals with more education, respectively.

Conclusions

Hesitancy towards pediatric vaccination is observed in 15% of respondents and most of the hesitancy was expressed in terms of vaccine safety and efficacy. Therefore, continuous dissemination of vaccine information needs to be carried out to earn parents’ trust and increase vaccination coverage in Indonesia.

Introduction

The World Health Organization (WHO) reported that in 2017, an estimated 19.9 million infants worldwide did not receive routine vaccination services and approximately 60% of them live in 10 countries: Afghanistan, Angola, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Ethiopia, India, Indonesia, Iraq, Nigeria, Pakistan and South Africa [1]. In Southeast Asia alone, 4.2 million children under 1 year old have not received the third dose of diphtheria-tetanus-pertussis vaccine (DTP3) [2]. Despite improved vaccine coverage experienced by most countries in the region since year 2000, where seven countries in Southeast Asia have achieved ≥ 90% national coverage for DTP3 in 2016, DTP3 coverage has declined below 80% in Indonesia since 2014 [2]. Coverage of full vaccination for children aged 12–23 months in Indonesia was reported at 57.9% in 2018 [3], far below the global vaccination coverage of 85% [1]. Aceh was the province with the lowest vaccination coverage with only 20% of its children fully vaccinated [3]. West Sumatra was not far better, ranked the 5th province with lowest vaccine coverage with only 40% children aged 12–23 months fully vaccinated [3].

A number of studies have been conducted to investigate barriers to pediatric vaccination, and divided them into health system barriers, provider barriers, and parental barriers [4]. Health system barriers include cost for vaccination, difficulties in vaccine storage, problems in vaccine supply and distribution, and lack of information systems to collect and consolidate individuals’ vaccination status [4], [5]. For providers, barriers comprise poor knowledge of vaccination indications and contraindications, lack of access to children’s vaccination records, and poor communication with parents [4], [5], [6]. The barriers from the parents’ side include poor understanding of the real value of vaccines, fear of adverse effects, limited access to clinics, and economic problems [4], [5], [6]. Problems with health systems and providers can be addressed by improving services that reach the community, maintaining the vaccine supply, and training health workers. However, parental attitudes and knowledge issues are more difficult to address.

One growing concern related to vaccination is vaccine hesitancy [7], [8], which refers to the delay in acceptance or refusal of vaccination despite the availability of vaccination services [9]. Hesitant attitudes to vaccination are prevalent and increasing worldwide, with safety concerns as the most commonly cited reason [7], [8], [9], [10], [11]. Lack of knowledge and awareness, low perceived severity of illness, media influence, beliefs, and perceived crowding of the immunization schedule are other concerns and challenges raised by vaccine hesitant parents [10], [11], [12]. In contrast, advice from healthcare workers, knowledge and awareness of vaccine are some of the factors supporting positive attitudes towards vaccination [6], [10]. The WHO has listed vaccine hesitancy as one of the ten threats to global health in 2019 [13], but information from low- and middle-income countries is more limited [14], [15]. In addition, there is concern that vaccination programs in middle-income countries, like Indonesia, face particular challenges in that they receive less guidance and funding support from various international organizations [16]. As populations rapidly urbanize and become more educated in these middle income countries, determining if and how vaccine hesitancy has taken root is an important component of disease control programs. It is also possible that there is a complex interplay between acceptance of vaccines and the presence of severe disease in the community or an ongoing pandemic [17], [18]. Severity and susceptibility are often taken into consideration by parents in making decision regarding vaccination [19] and are also associated with willingness to pay for vaccination [20]. Parents are more likely to get their children vaccinated against a more severe, very contagious and easily transmitted diseases [19]. In this current study, we focus on Zika given its epidemic potential for Indonesia [18], [21].

The immunization program in Indonesia was first initiated in 1956, and through this program the country was declared free of smallpox in 1974 [22]. Since 1977, Indonesia has expended the program to cover vaccines for tuberculosis, diphtheria, pertussis, measles, polio, tetanus, hepatitis B, and pneumonia. Vaccines are provided for free at the community health centers (Puskesmas) and made compulsory for children under five, for elementary students in 1st-3rd grade, and women of reproductive age [22]. However, the coverage of vaccination in Indonesia has been decreasing for the past few years, even below global targets [1], [3]. On top of that, the country also experienced the re-emergence of diphtheria, a disease that has not been found for decades, due to low coverage of the compulsory diphtheria vaccine [3]. One possible reason why many children do not get vaccinated is that parents express various degrees of hesitancy towards vaccines. This study was conducted to investigate parents’ hesitancy towards vaccination in Indonesia.