Mining event-related brain dynamics

doi:10.1016/j.tics.2004.03.008

Trends in Cognitive Sciences

Volume 8, Issue 5, May 2004, Pages 204-210

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tics.2004.03.008 Get rights and content

Abstract

This article provides a new, more comprehensive view of event-related brain dynamics founded on an information-based approach to modeling electroencephalographic (EEG) dynamics. Most EEG research focuses either on peaks ’evoked’ in average event-related potentials (ERPs) or on changes ’induced’ in the EEG power spectrum by experimental events. Although these measures are nearly complementary, they do not fully model the event-related dynamics in the data, and cannot isolate the signals of the contributing cortical areas. We propose that many ERPs and other EEG features are better viewed as time/frequency perturbations of underlying field potential processes. The new approach combines independent component analysis (ICA), time/frequency analysis, and trial-by-trial visualization that measures EEG source dynamics without requiring an explicit head model.

Section snippets

EEG sources

Basic facts about cortical physiology allow some predictions about the cortical sources of EEG signals. Cortex has a very high density of local connections [6] and is electrically far from the scalp, so sources of EEG signals are most probably compact regions of cortex whose local field activities at the neuronal scale are similarly oriented by cortical geometry and partially synchronized at the cm²-scale, thereby producing far-field EEG signals that reach the scalp by volume conduction [7].

New models, new measures

A novel approach to EEG (and/or, equally, to magnetoencephalographic or MEG) data analysis applies trial-by-trial visualization and time/frequency analysis to the extracted activities of cortical EEG sources that are first identified and spatially separated not on the basis of ERP or ERSP scalp distributions, but by the unique temporal information they contribute to the whole recorded signals. Brain dynamic responses to events are then modeled as transient perturbations of the ongoing EEG

Benefits of the new approach

Clearly, ‘evoked’ and ‘induced’ event-related EEG dynamics are not mutually exclusive. Rather, event-related spectral dynamics might occupy all portions of the time/frequency state space (Figure 3), including regions without a current acronym in the EEG literature. Combining ICA preprocessing with time/frequency modeling has several benefits for cognitive neuroimaging and neuroscience. ICA minimizes the influence of volume conduction and identifies the activities of the individual cortical

Possible pitfalls

For some researchers accustomed to standard EEG analysis methods, the ICA time/frequency approach might amount to a perplexing paradigm shift. As with most new methods, some user cautions are in order. First, as a ‘blind’ separation technique, ICA cannot be guaranteed to yield physiologically meaningful results in each and every case. Not every independent component is equally robust statistically or equally plausible physiologically. The quality of an ICA decomposition can vary considerably

Future directions

Certainly, further research will be required to fully evaluate the strengths, weaknesses and full implications of the new approach (see Box 2). However, the analysis model outlined here is still largely descriptive. Direct generative models of cortical dynamics involving realistic, multiscale finite-element modeling of field activity in neuropile (the most common usage) are a worthwhile goal. Current generative models 13, 44, 45, 46 include many free parameters. It would be desirable to find

Acknowledgements

Supported by The Swartz Foundation and the invaluable collaboration of Terrence J. Sejnowski and Anthony J. Bell at The Salk Institute and Tzyy-Ping Jung at the Institute for Neural Computation, UCSD.

References (50)

S. Makeig
Auditory event-related dynamics of the EEG spectrum and effects of exposure to tones
Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol.
(1993)
D. Stettler
Lateral connectivity and contextual interactions in macaque primary visual cortex
Neuron
(2002)
A. Bagshaw
Electrical impedance tomography of human brain function using reconstruction algorithms based on the finite element method
Neuroimage
(2003)
J.J. Wright
Toward an integrated continuum model of cerebral dynamics: the cerebral rhythms, synchronous oscillation and cortical stability
Biosystems
(2001)
P. Suffczynski
Computational model of thalamo-cortical networks: dynamical control of alpha rhythms in relation to focal attention
Int. J. Psychophysiol.
(2001)
A. Badea
Surface visualization of electromagnetic brain activity
J. Neurosci. Methods
(2003)
J. Gross
Properties of MEG tomographic maps obtained with spatial filtering
Neuroreport
(2003)
T.W. Lee
A unifying information-theoretic framework for independent component analysis
Comput. Math. Appl.
(2000)
A. Delorme et al.
EEGLAB: an open source toolbox for analysis of single-trial EEG dynamics including independent component analysis
J. Neurosci. Methods
(2004)
G. Pfurtscheller et al.
Event-related EEG/MEG synchronization and desynchronization: basic principles
Clin. Neurophysiol.
(1999)

Cited by (1149)

Mu-ERD reflects action understanding, but the effect is small
2024, Brain Research
Since the mid-2000’s, many researchers have provided evidence that mu-ERD measured at the motor cortex may reflect the collective activation of upstream brain regions associated with the human mirror system during action observation paradigms; however, several recent papers have called these findings into question. Our study represents an effort to address these criticisms. In our study, participants watched videos in which the type of grip an actor used to grasp a coffee mug either conveyed the goal with 100 % certainty (unambiguous-goal trials), or offered no predictive information (ambiguous-goal trials). If mu-ERD indexes action understanding, then we predicted that mu-ERD should increase while participants watched the actor grasp the mug for unambiguous-goal trials, but not for ambiguous-goal trials. During the intervals where participants watched the actor execute the goal, mu-ERD for unambiguous-goal trials should remain steady, whereas mu-ERD for ambiguous-goal trials should now increase. Conversely, if mu-ERD does not index action understanding, and instead reflects general motor processes associated with action (such as the activation of population vectors in M1 or planning processes), then mu-ERD should show no difference across conditions. Across most comparisons, we found that mu-ERD mostly reflected general motor processes; however, there was a small effect when participants overserved unambiguous-goal trials while watching the actor execute the goal suggesting that mu-ERD does reflect mirroring, but the effect is small.
Virtual reality and electroencephalography in architectural design: A systematic review of empirical studies
2024, Journal of Building Engineering
Integrating human needs and desires into the design process has long been a crucial aim of design research. Despite advancements, architectural design still often overlooks the diverse dimensions of human experiences. In this context, the recent development of affordable and mobile brain-imaging devices using electroencephalography (EEG) presents an opportunity for a new approach to human-centered architectural design, especially in combination with virtual reality (VR). Despite existing EEG/VR studies in architecture, a comprehensive review of the methods used to translate EEG data into architectural design is lacking. To address this gap, this article presents a systematic review of empirical studies that use EEG in VR and investigate the impact of designed environments on users. Searches in the databases of Scopus, Web of Science and Science Direct resulted in nineteen articles utilizing both EEG and VR and focusing on an architectural perspective. The data analysis was performed qualitatively and is presented in summary-of-findings tables. The results indicate that in all reviewed studies, the framing environments affect specific brain regions and support different physiological, psychological, and cognitive functions. However, reliable conclusions about the impact spectrum of specific environmental features and associated event-related dynamics require further studies. Several gaps and challenges were identified. These include the need to develop comprehensive strategies for synthesizing data from a variety of sources, considering the distinct effects of familiar and new environments, and addressing limitations posed by sample sizes and demographic diversity. Additionally, long-term studies and investigations of the environmental impact on groups remain areas for future research.
EEG correlates of trait test anxiety in the flanker task for adolescents
2024, Neuroscience Letters
Adolescents face constant exams and often experience severe test anxiety. Previous studies suggested that test anxiety impairs individuals’ inhibitory control. Neurophysiological evidence suggests that anxiety interferes with the recruitment of the prefrontal region of the brain, which modulates top-down attentional control during the completion of inhibitory control tasks. However, there is little neurophysiological evidence regarding how test anxiety impairs inhibitory control in adolescents. This study used the flanker task to measure individuals’ inhibitory control ability, and both event-related potential and electroencephalography indicators were used to measure neurophysiological processes. The results showed that increased trait test anxiety was significantly negatively correlated with theta power oscillation, while adolescents performed both incongruent and congruent trials. This finding suggests that trait test anxiety adolescents are less able to exert greater effort to complete the inhibitory control task and show impoverished top-down attentional control resources.
Exploration of the influence of the quantification method and reference scheme on feedback-related negativity and standardized measurement error of feedback-related negativity amplitudes in a trust game
2024, Cortex
Various approaches have been taken over the years to quantify event-related potential (ERP) responses and these approaches may vary in their utility connecting empirical research and scientific claims. In this work we compared different quantification methods as well as the influence of three reference methods (linked mastoids, average reference, and current source density) on the resulting ERP amplitude. We use the experimental effects and effect sizes (Cohen's d) to evaluate the different methodological variants and we calculate intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC). In addition, the bootstrapped standard error of the means (SME, Luck et al., 2021), which was recently suggested as a quality criterion for ERP research, is used for this purpose. Our example for an ERP is the feedback-related negativity (FRN) to feedback about trustee behavior in a trust game with participants in the trustor position. We found that the quantification methods concerning the FRN influenced the absolute value of condition effects in the experimental paradigm. Yet, the patterns of effects were detected by all chosen methods, except for the ‘individual difference wave’-based peak window approach. In addition, our findings stress the importance of checking the reference electrodes concerning effects of the experimental conditions. Furthermore, interactions of topographical distribution and reference choice should be considered. Finally, we were able to show that the SME is lower for more datapoints that are given in the quantification period of the FRN, and higher for more negative FRN amplitudes. These biases may lead to divergence of SME and effect size detection. Therefore, if the SME was used to compare different processing choices one should consider controlling for these important aspects of the data and possibly include other quality criteria like effect sizes.
Two common issues in synchronized multimodal recordings with EEG: Jitter and latency
2024, Neuroscience Research
Multimodal recording using electroencephalogram (EEG) and other biological signals (e.g., muscle activities, eye movement, pupil diameters, or body kinematics data) is ubiquitous in human neuroscience research. However, the precise time alignment of multiple data from heterogeneous sources (i.e., devices) is often arduous due to variable recording parameters of commercially available research devices and complex experimental setups. In this review, we introduced the versatility of a Lab Streaming Layer (LSL)-based application that can overcome two common issues in measuring multimodal data: jitter and latency. We discussed the issues of jitter and latency in multimodal recordings and the benefits of time-synchronization when recording with multiple devices. In addition, a computer simulation was performed to highlight how the millisecond-order jitter readily affects the signal-to-noise ratio of the electrophysiological outcome. Together, we argue that the LSL-based system can be used for research requiring precise time-alignment of datasets. Studies that detect stimulus-induced transient neural responses or test hypotheses regarding temporal relationships of different functional aspects with multimodal data would benefit most from LSL-based systems.
Measuring the accuracy of ICA-based artifact removal from TMS-evoked potentials
2024, Brain Stimulation
The analysis and interpretation of transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS)-evoked potentials (TEPs) relies on successful cleaning of the artifacts, which typically mask the early (0–30 ms) TEPs. Independent component analysis (ICA) is possibly the single most utilized methodology to clean these signals.
ICA-based cleaning is reliable provided that the input data are composed of independent components. Differently, in case the underlying components are to some extent dependent, ICA algorithms may yield erroneous estimates of the components, resulting in incorrectly cleaned data. We aim to ascertain whether TEP signals are suited for ICA.
We present a systematic analysis of how the properties of simulated artifacts imposed on measured artifact-free TEPs affect the ICA results. The variability of the artifact waveform over the recorded trials is varied from deterministic to stochastic. We measure the accuracy of ICA-based cleaning for each level of variability.
Our findings indicate that, when the trial-to-trial variability of an artifact component is small, which can result in dependencies between underlying components, ICA-based cleaning biases towards eliminating also non-artifactual TEP data. We also show that the variability can be measured using the ICA-derived components, which in turn allows us to estimate the cleaning accuracy.
As TEP artifacts tend to have small trial-to-trial variability, one should be aware of the possibility of eliminating brain-derived EEG when applying ICA-based cleaning strategies. In practice, after ICA, the artifact component variability can be measured, and it predicts to some extent the cleaning reliability, even when not knowing the clean ground-truth data.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Trends in Cognitive Sciences

Mining event-related brain dynamics

Abstract

Section snippets

EEG sources

New models, new measures

Benefits of the new approach

Possible pitfalls

Future directions

Acknowledgements

Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol.

Neuron

Neuroimage

Biosystems

Int. J. Psychophysiol.

J. Neurosci. Methods

Neuroreport

Comput. Math. Appl.

J. Neurosci. Methods

Clin. Neurophysiol.

Trends Neurosci.

Signal Process.

Top-down processing mediated by interareal synchronization

Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A.

Modulation of oscillatory neuronal synchronization by selective visual attention

Science

Correlated neuronal activity and the flow of neural information

Nat. Rev. Neurosci.

Dynamic brain sources of visual evoked responses

Science

Analysis of spatial patterns of phase in neocortical gamma EEGs in rabbit

J. Neurophysiol.

Aperiodic phase re-setting in scalp EEG of beta-gamma oscillations by state transitions at alpha-theta rates

Hum. Brain Mapp.

Alpha-frequency rhythms desynchronize over long cortical distances: a modeling study

J. Comput. Neurosci.

Computational model of thalamo-cortical networks: dynamical control of alpha rhythms in relation to focal attention

Int. J. Psychophysiol.

Dynamic predictions: oscillations and synchrony in top-down processing

Nat. Rev. Neurosci.

Feedback connections act onthe early part of the responses in monkey visual cortex

J. Neurophysiol.

Objective evaluation of auditory evoked EEG responses

Nature

Simultaneous activation of gamma and theta network oscillations in rat hippocampal slice cultures

J. Physiol.

Norepinephrine but not serotonin reuptake inhibitors enhance theta and gamma activity of the septo-hippocampal system

Neuropsychopharmacology