Ineligible parents, eligible children: Food Stamps receipt, allotments, and food insecurity among children of immigrants

doi:10.1016/j.ssresearch.2004.09.001

Social Science Research

Volume 35, Issue 1, March 2006, Pages 228-251

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssresearch.2004.09.001 Get rights and content

Abstract

The Personal Responsibility, Work, and Reconciliation Act (PRWORA) made non-citizens ineligible for federally funded food assistance and reduced Food Stamp allotments (the amount of Food Stamps benefits provided) for households containing a mixture of citizens and non-citizens. Using the Survey of Program Dynamics, we assess the effects of PRWORA on household-level Food Stamps recipiency, Food Stamps allotments, and food security among the children of non-citizens. We find that the children of non-citizens experienced more persistent and higher levels of food insecurity following PRWORA’s enactment than the children of citizens. While declines in Food Stamps allotments substantially explain the disproportionately high levels of food insecurity among the children of non-citizens in the year following welfare reform, high levels of food insecurity continued as late as 2001 among the children of non-citizens on account of both low allotments and Food Stamps receipt among those in need of food assistance.

Introduction

Changes in welfare policy during the 1990s restricted non-citizen’s access to food assistance and may have increased food insecurity among non-citizens and their children. Food insecurity involves the limited or uncertain availability of food in a household—a condition resulting from household resource constraints (Bickel et al., 2000). Food insecurity among the children of immigrants is of policy significance because children of immigrants comprise the fastest growing segment of the US population under age 15 (Hernandez and Charney, 1998). Currently, the children of immigrants comprise one-fifth of all children in the United States (Van Hook and Fix, 2000) and 1 in 10 children live in a household with at least one non-citizen parent (Fix and Zimmermann, 2001). If children of immigrants are experiencing increasingly high levels food insecurity on account of reductions in Food Stamps eligibility, this could have long-term deleterious consequences for the physical and cognitive development of this already-disadvantaged population (Johnston and Markowitz, 1993, Morley and Lucas, 1997).

Enacted in 1996, the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act (PRWORA) made most non-citizens with less than ten years of US residency ineligible for federally funded food assistance (for more details see Espenshade et al., 1997, Zimmermann and Tumlin, 1999). In addition, the rules under PRWORA specified that Food Stamp allotments (the amount of Food Stamps benefits provided) be reduced in proportion to the number of non-citizens living in the household. In the years following the enactment of PRWORA, Food Stamp caseloads and recipiency levels dropped particularly sharply among non-citizens and their children (Borjas, 2002, Fix, 2001, Fix and Passel, 1999, Fix and Passel, 2002), and it is likely that allotment levels dropped as well. We evaluate here the relationships among declines in Food Stamps recipiency, declines in Food Stamps allotments, and food insecurity levels among children of immigrants for the five years following PRWORA’s enactment, paying particular attention to the children of non-citizens. Although the majority of children of immigrants remained eligible for Food Stamps following welfare reform for reasons explained below, the children of non-citizens experienced the greatest drops in Food Stamps recipiency and thus may have become particularly vulnerable to food insecurity.

Section snippets

Background

Food Stamps recipiency declined more for children of non-citizen parents than other children even though most of these children were not the intended targets of welfare reform. As of 1998, 83% of children living with two non-citizen parents and 88% of children living with a non-citizen single parent were US citizens (Fix and Zimmermann, 2001), and US citizen children, regardless of their parents’ citizenship status, have been and continue to be allowed to receive Food Stamps (USDA, 2004).

Survey of program dynamics

We use the longitudinal files of the Survey of Program Dynamics (SPD) (US Census Bureau, 2001). The SPD allows us to examine Food Stamp recipiency for a cohort of children in nearly all years between 1993 and 2000 (excluding 1995 and 1996), and it includes measures of food insecurity in 1998 and 2001. The SPD was developed by the Census Bureau to evaluate the short- and medium-term effects of Welfare Reform. The SPD sample includes roughly half of the original respondents from the 1992 and 1993

Basic patterns and trends

During the 1990s, the proportion of children covered by Food Stamps declined for all nativity and citizenship groups, but children of non-citizens who never naturalized and children of parents who naturalized in the post-reform period saw the greatest declines (Table 1). Between 1993 and 2000, Food Stamps recipiency declined by 11 percentage points among children of natives and by 5 percentage points among children of citizens who naturalized before 1993. Among children of parents who

Conclusion

Children of non-citizens experienced the highest levels of food insecurity shortly following PRWORA’s enactment. Moreover, children of non-citizens did not recover as much as did other groups between 1998 and 2001, particularly if their parents had not subsequently naturalized. In this paper, we assessed whether the changes in welfare policy inaugurated by PRWORA, in particular changes that may have led to reductions in Food Stamps receipt and Food Stamps allotments, were responsible for the

References (29)

G.J. Borjas
Food insecurity and public assistance
Journal of Public Economics
(2004)
J.D. Angrist et al.
Instrumental variables and the search for identification: from supply and demand to natural experiments
Journal of Economic Perspectives
(2001)
F.D. Bean et al.
Country of origin, type of public assistance and patterns of welfare recipiency among US immigrants and natives
Social Science Quarterly
(1997)
S.H. Bell
Why Are Welfare Caseloads Falling
(2001)
G. Bickel et al.
Guide to Measuring Household Food Security, Revised 2000
(2000)
G.J. Borjas
Welfare reform and immigrant participation in welfare programs
International Migration Review Winter
(2002)
Capps, R., 2001. Hardships among children of immigrants: findings from the 1999 National Survey of America’s Families....
Dion, M.R., Pavetti, L., 2000. Access to and participation in medicaid and the Food Stamp Program: a review of the...
R. Dunifon et al.
The influences of participation in the national school lunch program and food insecurity on child well-being
Social Service Review
(2003)
T. Espenshade et al.
Implications of the 1996 welfare and immigration reform acts for US immigration
Population and Development Review
(1997)

M. Fix

Comment to welfare reform and immigration

M. Fix et al.

Trends in Non-citizens and Citizens Use of Public Benefits Following Welfare Reform: 1994–1997

(1999)

M. Fix et al.

The Scope and Impact of Welfare Reform’s Immigrant Provisions

(2002)

M. Fix et al.

All under one roof, mixed status families in an era of reform

International Migration Review

(2001)

Cited by (94)

Policy solutions to eliminate racial and ethnic child health disparities in the USA
2024, The Lancet Child and Adolescent Health
Societal systems act individually and in combination to create and perpetuate structural racism through both policies and practices at the local, state, and federal levels, which, in turn, generate racial and ethnic health disparities. Both current and historical policy approaches across multiple sectors—including housing, employment, health insurance, immigration, and criminal legal—have the potential to affect child health equity. Such policies must be considered with a focus on structural racism to understand which have the potential to eliminate or at least attenuate disparities. Policy efforts that do not directly address structural racism will not achieve equity and instead worsen gaps and existing disparities in access and quality—thereby continuing to perpetuate a two-tier system dictated by racism. In Paper 2 of this Series, we build on Paper 1's summary of existing disparities in health-care delivery and highlight policies within multiple sectors that can be modified and supported to improve health equity, and, in so doing, improve the health of racially and ethnically minoritised children.
Measuring Food Security in the United States for More Than 25 years: History, Methods, Findings, and Opportunities
2023, Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics
This article sets the stage for the “25 Years of Food Security Measurement: Answered Questions and Further Research” conference, with support from the Economic Research Service of the US Department of Agriculture, by providing some history of federal food security measurement, summarizing notable findings, and reviewing selected special topics in analysis methods. The federal government uses food security surveys to monitor national progress toward reducing food insecurity and to evaluate federal nutrition assistance programs. For the monitoring purpose, there is a tension between focus (on a single authoritative measurement approach) and breadth (encompassing multiple tools or instruments suitable for diverse populations, contexts, and applications). For the program evaluation purpose, challenges include coordination with study designs capable of real causal estimation in the face of strong self-selection effects and tailored reference periods in survey questions that match the timing of program participation. Some analysis methods treat the food security survey items as distinct experiences of hardship, whereas others treat the food security survey items as windows on an underlying latent variable, a food insecurity score. The severity of food-related hardship may be assessed quantitatively by the number of distinct hardships reported, by the estimated value of a latent food insecurity score, or by the frequency of occurrence for sentinel hardships. Ongoing work investigates statistical approaches that are sufficiently simple for policy application and yet sufficiently flexible to accurately match the empirical survey evidence.
Supplemental nutrition assistance program and school readiness skills
2020, Children and Youth Services Review
This analysis examines the relationship between participating in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and school readiness skills, specifically in early reading, early math, and approaches to learning skills, among low-income children in their preschool to kindergarten-entry years. We also investigate whether this relationship differs depending on depth of household poverty. By using wave 3 and kindergarten-entry wave from the Early Childhood Longitudinal Study Birth Cohort (ECLS-B) data and the child fixed-effects approach as its main empirical strategy, we find strong evidence that SNAP is positively related to children's early math skills (0.22 standard deviation increase) and that this relationship is stronger for children who were in deep poverty and/or poverty prior to their receipt of SNAP. For early reading skills, although we find no significant main effect, the relationship between SNAP and early reading is stronger for children who lived in deep poverty before their SNAP receipt, compared to children who were not as poor. We also find suggestive evidence that SNAP is related to approaches to learning skills (0.3 standard deviation increase), though marginally significant, and that the relationship is much stronger among children who were in deep poverty than those who were not. Through these results, we provide strong support for the role of SNAP, especially for the most economically disadvantaged families, in advancing key school readiness skills that are important to children’s developmental outcomes.
Maternal Place of Birth, Socioeconomic Characteristics, and Child Health in US-Born Latinx Children in Boston
2020, Academic Pediatrics
Among US-born children of Latina US (USB) and Latina foreign-born mothers (FBM), to determine whether 1) household and child characteristics differ; 2) child health outcomes differ; 3) these differences diminish for children of FBM with longer duration of residence in the United States; and 4) these differences can be explained by food insecurity (FI) or by Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) participation.
Cross-sectional survey of 2145 Latina mothers of publicly insured US-born children 0 to 48 months old in a Boston emergency department (ED) 2004 to 2013. Predictors were FBM versus USBM and duration of residence in the United States. Outcomes were mothers’ report of child health, history of hospitalization, developmental risk, and hospital admission on the day of ED visit. Multivariable logistic regression adjusted for potential confounders and effect modification.
FBM versus USBM households had more household (31% vs 26%) and child (19% vs 11%) FI and lower SNAP participation (44% vs 67%). Children of FBM versus USBM were more likely to be reported in fair/poor versus good/excellent health (adjusted odds ratios 1.9, 95% confidence interval [1.4, 2.6]), with highest odds for children of FBM with shortest duration of residence, and to be admitted to the hospital on the day of the ED visit (adjusted odds ratios 1.7, 95% confidence interval [1.3, 2.2]). SNAP and FI did not fully explain these outcomes.
When providing care and creating public policies, clinicians and policymakers should consider higher rates of food insecurity, lower SNAP participation, and risk for poor health outcomes in Latinx children of FBM.
Food Insecurity Among Hispanic/Latino Youth: Who Is at Risk and What Are the Health Correlates?
2019, Journal of Adolescent Health
We examined the correlates and health implications of household food insecurity among Hispanic/Latino youth (aged 8–16 years), a high food insecurity–risk population.
Using the Hispanic Community Children's Health/Study of Latino Youth (n = 1,362) and bivariate and multivariate analyses, we examined the correlates of household and child food insecurity and very low food security. We assessed the influence of four sets of risk/protective factors—child demographic, acculturation, socioeconomic, and family/social support. We then examined associations between food insecurity and four health indicators—body mass index, diet quality, depression, and anxiety—and used modification effects to assess whether these associations differed by sex, age, household income, parent nativity, and acculturative stress levels.
We found high rates of food insecurity: 42% of Hispanic/Latino youth experienced household food insecurity and 33% child food insecurity. Moreover, 10% lived in a very low food secure household. Compared with their food secure peers, Hispanic/Latino youth in food insecure households experienced greater parent/child acculturative and economic stress and weakened family support systems. Associations of food insecurity with health outcomes varied by sex, age, household income, parent nativity, and child acculturative stress levels.
Food insecurity is highly prevalent among Hispanic/Latino youth and has detrimental health implications, especially for girls, older youth, and youth experiencing acculturative stress. Reducing food insecurity and improving health among Hispanic/Latino youth will likely require comprehensive policies that address their multiple migration, familial, and economic stressors.
Adolescent food insecurity: The special case of Marshallese youth in north-west Arkansas, USA
2020, Public Health Nutrition

View all citing articles on Scopus

^☆: This research was supported in part by a grant from the Joint Center for Poverty Research and the USDA Food Assistance Program. Infrastructure support was provided by a center grant to the Center for Family and Demographic Research from the National Institutes of Health [R21-HD-42831-01]. Further support was provided by the National Institutes of Health [R01-HD-39075-1]. The authors would like to acknowledge Rebecca Clark, Randy Capps, and Darren Lubotsky for their helpful comments and suggestions.

View full text

Ineligible parents, eligible children: Food Stamps receipt, allotments, and food insecurity among children of immigrants☆

Abstract

Introduction

Section snippets

Background

Survey of program dynamics

Basic patterns and trends

Conclusion

Journal of Public Economics

Instrumental variables and the search for identification: from supply and demand to natural experiments

Journal of Economic Perspectives

Country of origin, type of public assistance and patterns of welfare recipiency among US immigrants and natives

Social Science Quarterly

Why Are Welfare Caseloads Falling

Guide to Measuring Household Food Security, Revised 2000

Welfare reform and immigrant participation in welfare programs

International Migration Review Winter

The influences of participation in the national school lunch program and food insecurity on child well-being

Social Service Review

Implications of the 1996 welfare and immigration reform acts for US immigration

Population and Development Review

Comment to welfare reform and immigration

Trends in Non-citizens and Citizens Use of Public Benefits Following Welfare Reform: 1994–1997

The Scope and Impact of Welfare Reform’s Immigrant Provisions

All under one roof, mixed status families in an era of reform

International Migration Review