Conceptual analysis of health systems resilience: A scoping review

doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2019.04.020

Social Science & Medicine

Volume 232, July 2019, Pages 168-180

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socscimed.2019.04.020 Get rights and content

Highlights

•
In this paper, we provide a conceptual analysis of health systems resilience.
•
Based on the results of a scoping review, we argue that health systems resilience lacks conceptual maturity.
•
We call for clarification of the concept to guarantee effective communication and valid empirical study.

Abstract

System resilience has long been an area of study, and the term has become increasingly used across different sectors. Studies on resilience in health systems are more recent, multiplying particularly since the 2014 Ebola epidemic in West Africa. The World Health Organization (WHO) is calling for national governments to increase the resilience of their health systems. Concepts help define research objects and guide the analysis. Yet, to be useful, concepts need to be clear and precise.

We aimed to improve the conceptual understanding of health systems resilience by conducting a scoping review to describe the state of knowledge in this area. We searched for literature in 10 databases, and analyzed data using a list of themes. We evaluated the clarity and the precision of the concept of health systems resilience using Daigneault & Jacob's three dimensions of a concept: term, sense, and referent.

Of the 1091 documents initially identified, 45 met the inclusion criteria. Term: multiple terms are used, switching from one to the other to speak about the same subject. Sense: there is no consensus yet on a unique definition. Referent: the magnitude and nature of events that resilient health systems face differ with context, covering a broad range of situations from sudden crisis to everyday challenges.

The lack of clarity in this conceptualization hinders the expansion of knowledge, the creation of reliable analytical tools, and the effectiveness of communication. The current conceptualization of health systems resilience is too scattered to enable the enhancement of this concept with great potential, opening a large avenue for future research.

Section snippets

Background

The World Health Organization's (WHO) reports on the performance of health systems (World Health Organization, 2000) and on universal health coverage (World Health Organization, 2013) highlight that health systems in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) are still facing multiple challenges, owing to their performance, responsiveness, and resilience. The topic of health systems resilience has gained major traction over the past few years.

In 1973, C.S Holling (1973) worked on the resilience

Method

A scoping review is a review methodology that allows for a preliminary assessment to identify nature and extent of available evidence (including ongoing research).

We conducted our review using Arksey & O'Malley's (Arksey and O'Malley, 2005) methodological framework, based on five main stages: (a) identifying the research question; (b) identifying relevant studies; (c) studies selection; (d) charting the data; and (e) summarizing and analyzing the results. We complemented it with subsequent

Search findings

Our search strategy yielded a total of 1092 citations (903 from scientific databases, 150 from grey literature, and 39 from handsearching). That number was reduced to 752 after excluding 264 duplicate records; 77 of these were selected on the basis of their titles and abstract. A final set of 45 articles met all inclusion criteria, and were included in our review. Fig. 2 presents the Prisma chart of our study selection process and Appendix 2 includes the characteristics of selected papers.

Reflecting on main results

The widespread use of the concept of health systems resilience, and its mention in the 2016–2030 SDGs, reflect the attractiveness of the concept. This prominence has led to the publication of a profusion of papers. While drawing on three existing – and significantly different – frameworks (WHO – Kruk et al., Blanchet et al.) (van de Pas et al., 2017), many authors adapt and improve them when they identify gaps by proposing their own vision and interpretation of this concept. The multiplicity of

Conclusion

In light of these reflections, we conclude that the popular concept of health systems resilience remains highly confusing. First, the concept of health systems resilience is still polysemic (Koffi et al., 2018): it depends on one's perception, one's discipline, one's function, and what one wants to achieve. Second, depending on how the health system is perceived and the relative importance of its components, dimensions of the resilience may also be different according to users. The review shows

Acknowledgements

This work was conducted as part of the UNISSahel (Couverture UNIverselle Santé au Sahel) research program, collaborative project between the Institute for Research on Sustainable Development (IRD) and the Agenge Française de Développemnt (AFD); it has been financed by Inserm, public research institute.. We would like to thank Emmanuelle Floch-Galaud, coordinator and librarian of the college of health at the university of Bordeaux, for her careful review of the search strategy; Heather Hickey

References (72)

V. Haldane et al.
Health systems resilience: meaningful construct or catchphrase?
Lancet
(2017)
M.E. Kruk et al.
What is a resilient health system? Lessons from Ebola
Lancet
(2015)
M. Leach et al.
Governing epidemics in an age of complexity: narratives, politics and pathways to sustainability
Glob. Environ. Chang.
(2010)
L.M. Pfadenhauer et al.
Context and implementation: a concept analysis towards conceptual maturity
Zeitschrift für Evidenz, Fortbildung und Qualität im Gesundheitswesen
(2015)
S. Abimbola et al.
Adaptation with robustness: the case for clarity on the use of “resilience” in health systems and global health
BMJ Glob. Health
(2018)
Action Against Hunger
International. Health System Strengthening : from Diagnosis to Planning [Internet]
(2017)
A.K. Ager et al.
Health service resilience in Yobe state, Nigeria in the context of the Boko Haram insurgency: a systems dynamics analysis using group model building
Conflict Health
(2015)
W. Ammar et al.
Health system resilience: Lebanon and the Syrian refugee crisis
J. Glob. Health
(2016)
H. Arksey et al.
Scoping studies: towards a methodological framework
Int. J. Soc. Res. Methodol.
(2005)
D. Autissier et al.
Conduite du changement: concepts clés : 60 ans de pratiques héritées des auteurs fondateurs
(2018)

E.W. Barasa et al.

From bouncing back, to nurturing emergence: reframing the concept of resilience in health systems strengthening

Health Policy Plan.

(2017)

E. Barasa et al.

What is resilience and how can it Be nurtured? A systematic review of empirical literature on organizational resilience

Int. J. Health Policy Manag.

(2018)

C. Bayntun et al.

Developing a health system approach to disaster management: a qualitative analysis of the core literature to complement the WHO Toolkit for assessing health-system capacity for crisis management

PLoS Curr.

(2012)

C. Béné et al.

Making the Most of Resilience

(2013)

K. Blanchet

Governance of health systems

Int. J. Health Policy Manag.

(2013)

K. Blanchet

Thinking shift on health systems: from blueprint health programmes towards resilience of health systems

Int. J. Health Policy Manag.

(2015)

K. Blanchet et al.

Governance and capacity to manage resilience of health systems: towards a new conceptual framework

Int. J. Health Policy Manag.

(2017)

A. Boin et al.

The rise of resilience

G.A. Bonanno

Loss, trauma, and human resilience: have we underestimated the human capacity to thrive after extremely aversive events?

Am. Psychol.

(2004)

Castleden

Resilience thinking in health protection

J. Public Health (Oxford, England)

(September 2011)

Commission on a Global Health Risk Framework for the Future, National Academy of Medicine, Secretariat. The Neglected Dimension of Global Security: A Framework to Counter Infectious Disease Crises [Internet]

(2016)

P.-M. Daigneault

La participation à l’évaluation : du concept à la mesure

(2012)

P.-M. Daigneault et al.

Les concepts souffrent-ils de négligence bénigne en sciences sociales? Eléments d’analyse conceptuelle et examen exploratoire de la littérature francophone à caractère méthodologique

Soc. Sci. Inf.

(2012)

A. Dauphiné et al.

La résilience : un concept pour la gestion des risques, Resilience : a concept for risk management

Ann. Geograph.

(2007)

S. Degroote et al.

Approach to identifying research gaps on vector-borne and other infectious diseases of poverty in urban settings: scoping review protocol from the VERDAS consortium and reflections on the project's implementation

Infect. Dis. Poverty

(2018)

K.L. Ebi et al.

Some lessons learned from public health on the process of adaptation

Mitig. Adapt. Strategies Glob. Change

(2006)

J.M. Farley et al.

Evaluation of flood preparedness in government healthcare facilities in Eastern Province, Sri Lanka

Glob. Health Action

(2017)

A.K. Fridell et al.

Resilient Health Systems in the European Union

(2017)

S. Fukuma et al.

Fukushima after the Great East Japan Earthquake: lessons for developing responsive and resilient health systems

J. Glob. Health

(2017)

L. Gilson et al.

Everyday resilience in district health systems: emerging insights from the front lines in Kenya and South Africa

BMJ Glob. Health

(2017)

J. Hanefeld et al.

Towards an understanding of resilience: responding to health systems shocks

Health Policy Plan.

(2018)

J.J. Hess et al.

Integrating climate change adaptation into public health practice: using adaptive management to increase adaptive capacity and build resilience

Environ. Health Perspect.

(2012)

C.S. Holling

Resilience and stability of ecological systems

Annu. Rev. Ecol. Systemat.

(1973)

M.-P. Kieny et al.

Health-system resilience: reflections on the Ebola crisis in western Africa

Bull WHO

(2014)

H. Kluge et al.

Strengthening global health security by embedding the International Health Regulations requirements into national health systems

BMJ Glob. Health

(2018)

J.M. Koffi et al.

Formes de résilience et stratégies de politique publique

Cited by (89)

Resilience: conceptualisations and challenges for effective heatwave public health planning
2024, Public Health
This article examines diverse perspectives on heatwave resilience in public health planning, interviewing stakeholders from various sectors. It identifies challenges, including operational, political, economic, and cultural aspects, hindering effective strategies. The study advocates for a holistic approach to heatwave resilience, emphasising interdisciplinary research and collaboration for targeted interventions. Enhancing resilience is crucial to mitigating adverse health impacts and safeguarding vulnerable populations during heatwaves.
Conceptualisations of resilience related to heatwave public health planning and heatwave resilience vary significantly. There is a need to unveil the multifaceted nature of resilience in the context of heatwaves and identify key challenges that hinder effective public health planning efforts.
Qualitative study to explore key stakeholders' conceptualisations of resilience and highlight challenges and opportunities needed for greater heatwave resilience and public health planning.
Interviews were conducted with a diverse group of key stakeholders involved in local, regional, and national heatwave planning, academics, civil sector and private sector representatives.
The findings of this study highlight diverse conceptualisations of resilience. Conceptualisations of resilience mainly differ on the following: ‘whom’; ‘what’; ‘how’; ‘when’; and ‘why’. This analysis shows that the concept of resilience is well understood but has different functions. The analysis of challenges revealed several key problems, such as operational and technical; political and governance; organisational and institutional; economic; linguistic; cultural, social, and behavioural; and communication, information, and awareness. These significantly hinder effective heatwave public health planning strategies.
The study emphasises the need for a holistic and integrated approach to heatwave resilience. Addressing these challenges is crucial for enhancing heatwave public health planning. This study provides valuable insights into the complexities of heatwave resilience, offering guidance for different sectors of society to develop targeted interventions and strategies. The development of new resilience interdisciplinary and intersectoral research, practice, and governance will prove crucial to ongoing efforts to strengthen national heatwave resilience public health planning. By fostering resilience, societies can mitigate the adverse impacts of heatwaves and safeguard the health and well-being of vulnerable populations.
Health system resilience: a critical review and reconceptualisation
2023, The Lancet Global Health
This Viewpoint brings together insights from health system experts working in a range of settings. Our focus is on examining the state of the resilience field, including current thinking on definitions, conceptualisation, critiques, measurement, and capabilities. We highlight the analytical value of resilience, but also its risks, which include neglect of equity and of who is bearing the costs of resilience strategies. Resilience depends crucially on relationships between system actors and components, and—as amply shown during the COVID-19 pandemic—relationships with wider systems (eg, economic, political, and global governance structures). Resilience is therefore connected to power imbalances, which need to be addressed to enact the transformative strategies that are important in dealing with more persistent shocks and stressors, such as climate change. We discourage the framing of resilience as an outcome that can be measured; instead, we see it emerge from systemic resources and interactions, which have effects that can be measured. We propose a more complex categorisation of shocks than the common binary one of acute versus chronic, and outline some of the implications of this for resilience strategies. We encourage a shift in thinking from capacities towards capabilities—what actors could do in future with the necessary transformative strategies, which will need to encompass global, national, and local change. Finally, we highlight lessons emerging in relation to preparing for the next crisis, particularly in clarifying roles and avoiding fragmented governance.
Health systems resilience: is it time to revisit resilience after COVID-19?
2023, Social Science and Medicine
The concept of health system resilience has been challenged by the COVID-19 pandemic. Even well-established health systems, considered resilient, collapsed during the pandemic. To revisit the concept of resilience two years and a half after the initial impact of COVID-19, we conducted a qualitative study with 26 international experts in health systems to explore their views on concepts, stages, analytical frameworks, and implementation from a comparative perspective of high- and low-and-middle-income countries (HICs and LMICs). The interview guide was informed by a comprehensive literature review, and all interviewees had practice and academic expertise in some of the largest health systems in the world. Results show that the pandemic did modify experts' views on various aspects of health system resilience, which we summarize and propose as refinements to the current understanding of health systems resilience.
Practical strategies to achieve resilient health systems: results from a scoping review
2024, BMC Health Services Research
Health systems resilience in fragile and conflict-affected settings: a systematic scoping review
2024, Conflict and Health
The Impact of Online Services on the COVID-19 Resilience of Korean Older Adults
2024, Asia-Pacific Journal of Public Health

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Review articleConceptual analysis of health systems resilience: A scoping review

Highlights

Abstract

Section snippets

Background

Method

Search findings

Reflecting on main results

Conclusion

Acknowledgements

Lancet

Lancet

Glob. Environ. Chang.

Zeitschrift für Evidenz, Fortbildung und Qualität im Gesundheitswesen

Adaptation with robustness: the case for clarity on the use of “resilience” in health systems and global health

BMJ Glob. Health

International. Health System Strengthening : from Diagnosis to Planning [Internet]

Health service resilience in Yobe state, Nigeria in the context of the Boko Haram insurgency: a systems dynamics analysis using group model building

Conflict Health

Health system resilience: Lebanon and the Syrian refugee crisis

J. Glob. Health

Scoping studies: towards a methodological framework

Int. J. Soc. Res. Methodol.

Conduite du changement: concepts clés : 60 ans de pratiques héritées des auteurs fondateurs

From bouncing back, to nurturing emergence: reframing the concept of resilience in health systems strengthening

Health Policy Plan.

What is resilience and how can it Be nurtured? A systematic review of empirical literature on organizational resilience

Int. J. Health Policy Manag.

Developing a health system approach to disaster management: a qualitative analysis of the core literature to complement the WHO Toolkit for assessing health-system capacity for crisis management

PLoS Curr.

Making the Most of Resilience

Governance of health systems

Int. J. Health Policy Manag.

Thinking shift on health systems: from blueprint health programmes towards resilience of health systems

Int. J. Health Policy Manag.

Governance and capacity to manage resilience of health systems: towards a new conceptual framework

Int. J. Health Policy Manag.

The rise of resilience

Loss, trauma, and human resilience: have we underestimated the human capacity to thrive after extremely aversive events?

Am. Psychol.

Resilience thinking in health protection

J. Public Health (Oxford, England)

Commission on a Global Health Risk Framework for the Future, National Academy of Medicine, Secretariat. The Neglected Dimension of Global Security: A Framework to Counter Infectious Disease Crises [Internet]

La participation à l’évaluation : du concept à la mesure

Les concepts souffrent-ils de négligence bénigne en sciences sociales? Eléments d’analyse conceptuelle et examen exploratoire de la littérature francophone à caractère méthodologique

Soc. Sci. Inf.

La résilience : un concept pour la gestion des risques, Resilience : a concept for risk management

Ann. Geograph.

Approach to identifying research gaps on vector-borne and other infectious diseases of poverty in urban settings: scoping review protocol from the VERDAS consortium and reflections on the project's implementation

Infect. Dis. Poverty

Some lessons learned from public health on the process of adaptation

Mitig. Adapt. Strategies Glob. Change

Evaluation of flood preparedness in government healthcare facilities in Eastern Province, Sri Lanka

Glob. Health Action

Resilient Health Systems in the European Union

Fukushima after the Great East Japan Earthquake: lessons for developing responsive and resilient health systems

J. Glob. Health

Everyday resilience in district health systems: emerging insights from the front lines in Kenya and South Africa

BMJ Glob. Health

Towards an understanding of resilience: responding to health systems shocks

Health Policy Plan.

Integrating climate change adaptation into public health practice: using adaptive management to increase adaptive capacity and build resilience

Environ. Health Perspect.

Resilience and stability of ecological systems

Annu. Rev. Ecol. Systemat.

Health-system resilience: reflections on the Ebola crisis in western Africa

Bull WHO

Strengthening global health security by embedding the International Health Regulations requirements into national health systems

BMJ Glob. Health

Formes de résilience et stratégies de politique publique

Review article
Conceptual analysis of health systems resilience: A scoping review

International. Health System Strengthening : from Diagnosis to Planning [Internet]

Conduite du changement: concepts clés : 60 ans de pratiques héritées des auteurs fondateurs

La participation à l’évaluation : du concept à la mesure

La résilience : un concept pour la gestion des risques, Resilience : a concept for risk management