Dynamics of change in the practice of female genital cutting in Senegambia: Testing predictions of social convention theory
Highlights
► Mixed-method study of dynamics of behavior change with respect to female genital cutting (FGC) in Senegal and The Gambia. ► Generates predictions from a leading theory of behavior change for FGC, social convention theory, and empirically tests these predictions. ► We find that the practice is best described as a peer convention, rather than a marriage convention. ► Identifies access to social networks and accumulation of social capital as key factors for continuation of the practice. ► Suggests interventions be coordinated among members of intergenerational social networks.
Introduction
Female genital cutting (FGC), also known as female genital mutilation or female “circumcision,” refers to a set of practices involving the partial or complete removal of the external female genitalia. These practices can be found in a wide variety of contexts throughout the northern half of sub-Saharan Africa, Sudan, Egypt, parts of the Middle East and Asia, as well as across the African diaspora. Beginning in the 1970’s, the international community, national and local institutions, and the governments of numerous countries have openly taken a stance against FGC, and backed numerous campaigns aimed at eliminating the practice using a variety of approaches.
By the end of the 1990’s many participants in the international campaign to end FGC reached the conclusion that programming efforts had, in many instances, yielded limited results. Subsequently, a series of reviews (Denison et al., 2009, Feldman-Jacobs and Ryniak, 2006, Frontiers in Reproductive Health/Population Council, 2002, Toubia and Sharief, 2003) echoed a question posed by the World Health Organization (WHO, 1999): What works and what doesn’t? In addressing this question, one review (Frontiers in Reproductive Health/Population Council, 2002) emphasized that in order to improve our understanding of why and how interventions cause change, intervention research needs to be informed by theory on behavior change.
A significant body of academic research has, indeed, focused on the development of theoretical models of behavior change. These models fall broadly under two main paradigms: 1) decision-theoretic models, and 2) game-theoretic models. Decision-theoretic models employ a rational choice approach for weighing costs and benefits of behavioral options for independent actors. For example, community-based health education programs, which were widely employed in the first two decades of the global campaign to end FGC (and still are used, though now often alongside other approaches), were framed by a health belief model that employs a rational choice approach. These programs centered on delivering messages about the adverse health risks of FGC, assuming that improved knowledge of medical risks would alter the cost-benefit calculus of proceeding with FGC, and promote behavior change. While these programs have succeeded in raising awareness and generating public discussion, they have failed to motivate large-scale abandonment of FGC. A number of critiques of rational choice models have pointed to the flaw of assuming a direct link between an individual’s intention and behavior, and stress the importance of understanding the interactions of decision makers and the context in which decisions are made (Davies, 1992, Parker, 2004, Shell-Duncan and Hernlund, 2006, Yoder, 1997, Yoder, 2001).
As an alternative to the rational choice models, Mackie, 1996, Mackie, 2000 has proposed a game-theoretic model, social convention theory, which delineates the means by which actions of individuals are interdependent, necessitating coordinated change among interconnected actors. Mackie (2000) argues that FGC can be best understood as a convention maintained by interdependent expectations in the marriage market. Once it becomes widely expected of potential brides, the practice is locked in place: those who fail to comply also fail to marry and reproduce. A convention shift, whereby a critical mass of people abandons the practice and allows their children to marry uncircumcised women, is necessary to sustain abandonment of FGC. The success of community-based programs that seek to coordinate change within a community, such as the Senegalese Tostan project, which organizes public declarations of abandonment of FGC, provided strong initial support for social convention theory (Mackie, 2000, Tostan, 1999). This correspondence has drawn considerable attention from individuals designing, implementing and evaluating programs, as well as donors, policy makers and academics. UNICEF, in particular, has been instrumental in organizing a series of academic consultations and program reviews aimed at exploring the theoretical dimensions of behavior change, and gaining insights from correspondences with empirical program experiences (UNICEF, 2005, UNICEF, 2010). Few studies, however, have specifically tested predictions generated by social convention theory. One notable exception is a 2005 study by Hayford, which, using 1998 Kenya Demographic and Health Survey (DHS) data, tested whether the decision to circumcise a daughter was influenced by group norms in a marriage market, using community characteristics as a proxy for marriage market. After controlling for individual level variability, the results showed that women’s decisions regarding their daughters’ circumcision were correlated within communities, as predicted by social convention theory. More direct and detailed information on the role of marriageability is, however, not available in DHS data.
The purpose of this research was to develop an improved understanding of the dynamics of behavior change regarding FGC by explicitly testing predictions from social convention theory with empirical data from a three year mixed-method study conducted in Senegal and The Gambia. These countries share a tremendous amount in common in terms of languages, religion and cultural practices, including FGC. In Senegal, however, intervention efforts have led to wide-scale abandonment of FGC. Together, these settings provide a unique window into the behavior change process for FGC across a wide spectrum. We compared findings from both qualitative and quantitative data against predictions derived from Mackie’s social convention theory.
Section snippets
Theoretical background
Social convention theory as a game theoretic model delineates that actions of individuals are interdependent, necessitating coordinated change among interconnected actors. Mackie, 1996, Mackie, 2000 proposed that FGC arose under conditions of imperial polygyny and extreme resource inequality, with powerful elite controlling crucial resources. He suggests that within this context, FGC may have originated as a means of signaling fidelity to highly polygynous male elites who control great economic
Study population
This research project was conducted at sites located in Senegal and The Gambia. Often, these nations are referred to collectively as Senegambia, owing to the fact that they share much in common in terms of language, dominant religion (over 90% Muslim in both), subsistence activities, cultural practices, landscape, and climate. As the practice of FGC is most closely tied to ethnic affiliation, the overall prevalence rates for The Gambia and Senegal vary. In Senegal, where the largely
Methods
Research was conducted in three distinct regions: 1) peri-urban communities surrounding the Gambian capital, Banjul; 2) the Gambian North Bank Division rural border area known as Baddibu, and 3) the Senegalese region directly across the border from Baddibu, falling mostly in rural Kaolack Division, including several villages covered in the Tostan program. These research sites do not provide nationally representative samples, but were selected instead to capture variation in abandonment of FGC
Results
Characteristics of survey respondents are described in Table 1. All three study areas included women from multiple ethnic groups, and women who reported that their family did or did not come from a “circumcising tradition.” Overall, 58% of women reported that they came from families that traditionally practiced FGC.
Some ethnic groups were close to uniform in their circumcising tradition (97% of Mandinka women participating in the survey reported that FGC is/was a tradition in their family; 96%
Discussion
Social convention theory posits that the practice of FGC is perpetuated first and foremost by concerns over marriageability (Mackie, 1996, Mackie, 2000). In our study sites, however, we find only weak evidence in support of the marriage convention hypothesis. Instead, it appears that an intergenerational peer convention better explains the perpetuation of circumcision in our study sites in Senegambia than does a marriage convention model. We propose that limited, variable resources render
Acknowledgements
This research was supported by National Science Foundation (grant number 0313503) and by the UNDP/UNFPA/WHO/World Bank Special Programme on Research, Development, and Research Training in Human Reproduction. Research affiliation was provided by Dr. C. Niang through Université Cheikh Anta Diop, and by Dr. A. B. Senghore through Gambia College, Brikama Campus. Ethics approval for this study was obtained from The Gambia College in Brikama, Université Cheikh Anta Diop, University of Washington, and
References (30)
- et al.
Female genital mutilation: Have we made progress yet?
International Journal of Gynaecology and Obstetrics
(2003) - Ahmadu, F. (2005). Cutting the Anthill: The Symbolic Foundations of female and male circumcision rituals among the...
Social capital in the creation of human capital
American Journal of Sociology
(1988)- et al.
Listening to the voice of the people: A situation analysis of female genital mutilation in The Gambia
(1999) On relapse: recidivism or rational response?
- et al.
Effectiveness of interventions designed to reduce the prevalence of female genital mutilation/cutting
(2009) Excision
- et al.
Abandoning female genital mutilation/cutting: An in-depth look at promising practices
(2006) Shame in two cultures: implications for evolutionary approaches
Journal of Cognition and Culture
(2004)Using operations research to strengthen programmes for encouraging abandonment of female genital cutting
(2002)
Conformity and change: community effects on female genital cutting in Kenya
Journal of Health and Social Behavior
Cutting without ritual and ritual without cutting: female "circumcision" and the re-ritualization of initiation in the Gambia
Becoming a Muslim, becoming a person: female "circumcision," religious identity, and personhood in Guinea-Bissau
The design and analysis of focus group studies: a practical approach
Social resources and strength of ties: structural factors in occupational status attainment
American Sociological Review
Cited by (98)
Abandoning female genital mutilation/cutting (FGMC) is an emerging but costly parental investment strategy in rural Ethiopia
2023, Social Science and MedicineEvolutionary ecological insights into the suppression of female sexuality
2023, Current Research in Ecological and Social PsychologyPre-existing fairness concerns restrict the cultural evolution and generalization of inequitable norms in children
2022, Evolution and Human BehaviorCitation Excerpt :As a very different example of coordination and inequality, a prominent hypothesis posits that female genital cutting, especially infibulation, is a coordination norm that helps men manage paternity uncertainty (Efferson, Vogt, & Fehr, 2020; Howard & Gibson, 2019; Mackie, 1996; Vogt, Zaid, Ahmed, Fehr, & Efferson, 2016). Once a cutting norm is in place, parents face strong incentives to cut their daughters to improve the future marriage prospects of these daughters (Camilotti, 2016; Efferson et al., 2020; Efferson, Vogt, Elhadi, Ahmed, & Fehr, 2015; Howard & Gibson, 2019; Platteau & Auriol, 2018; Shell-Duncan, Wander, Hernlund, & Moreau, 2011; Vogt et al., 2016). To the extent that such a coordination norm evolves, it shifts the distribution of reproductive benefits away from women and toward men, once again with the potential to entrench status differentials that spill over to other types of social exchange (Henrich & Boyd, 2008).
Attitude towards female circumcision among women in Ethiopia
2021, Sexual and Reproductive HealthcareBargaining With patriarchy, resisting sisterarchy: Contextualising women's participation in female genital mutilation/ cutting (FGM/C)
2023, The Emerald International Handbook of Feminist Perspectives on Women's Acts of ViolenceSpatially Varying Intergenerational Changes in the Prevalence of Female Genital Mutilation/Cutting in Nigeria: Lessons Learnt from a Recent Household Survey
2023, Applied Spatial Analysis and Policy