Does place explain racial health disparities? Quantifying the contribution of residential context to the Black/white health gap in the United States
Introduction
The traditional focus of research examining the determinants of health status has been on individual-level differences in socio-economic status (SES) and the health behaviors associated with them. Though SES and health behaviors explain a large portion of the health disparities between non-Hispanic blacks and non-Hispanic whites (henceforth referred to as blacks and white, respectively), in the United States, they do not fully account for the gap (Williams & Collins, 1995). Moreover, health care has been found to contribute little to health status (House & Williams, 2000). The persistence of the unexplained health gap between blacks and whites has led many to direct their attention to differences in residential environments as a contributor to observed health disparities (Kaplan, 1996). This increasing recognition that the social and structural environment where one lives may independently contribute to the formation and development of human conditions, including health outcomes, suggests a research area that has yet to be fully exploited. In this paper, we generate quantitative estimates of the contribution of local residential context toward explaining the black/white health gap in the United States, net of individual-level characteristics.
Section snippets
Black/white differences in health and mortality
Despite a marked increase in life expectancy in the United States over the last century, a gap in life expectancy between blacks and whites remains (NCHS, 2007). Although this gap has narrowed from seven to just over five years between 1990 and 2004, mortality differences between blacks and whites have grown or have remained unchanged for a number of causes such as heart disease, HIV, diabetes mellitus, and several types of cancer (NCHS, 2007). These trends in mortality are indicative of most
Social environment
In addition to individual-level influences on health, a substantial body of literature indicates that where one lives also has important implications for health (Morenoff and Lynch, 2002, Robert, 1999a, Robert, 1999b). Most of the existing literature has focused on the social environment including neighborhood racial segregation (Williams & Collins, 2001), neighborhood demographic or socio-economic characteristics (Robert, 1999b), and social cohesion (e.g., social capital, trust, crime) (
Neighborhood context and health disparities
The level of risk and concentration of resources in the social and physical space are clustered in patterns that mimic the larger patterns of stratification in society (Fitzpatrick & LaGory, 2003). That is, individuals of lower SES and racial minorities are segregated spatially (Jargowksy, 1997, Massey and Fong, 1990, Massey and Shibuya, 1995) into areas that contain higher levels of contextual risk factors that promote the creation of urban sub-cultures that lead to higher rates of risky
Data set
Our analysis is based on data from the 1989–1994 National Health Interview Survey (NHIS) cross-sections. Since 1957, the NHIS has annually conducted nationwide household interviews to collect information concerning the health of the U.S. civilian non-institutionalized population. The 1989–1994 NHIS sample design is a multi-stage probability sample of U.S. households with new households interviewed each year (Massey, Moore, Parsons, & Tadros, 1989). The survey collects information on race,
Analytical strategy
Conventional models that investigate racial health disparities may be subject to bias if they omit neighborhood characteristics that contribute to health outcomes and are correlated to race. While one strategy would be to explicitly include neighborhood characteristics as controls, as a number of studies have done (e.g., Yen & Kaplan, 1999a), the reliance on imprecisely measured units of context, the use of administrative data (and hence a scarcity of potential contextual variables), and the
Results
We present results for male respondents in Table 2 and female respondents in Table 3. In each of these tables, we first present the results of the OLS model and FE models with health controls (models 1 and 2). Next, we present results from the OLS and FE models that excluded health controls (models 3 and 4).
Because all models interact race with age, and age has been centered by the sample mean age, the race coefficients directly estimated from the models reflect the racial health disparities at
Discussion
Our analyses lead to two important conclusions. One, the exclusion of neighborhood context leads to upwardly biased estimates of racial health disparities that were believed to be independent of socio-economic conditions. As a consequence—our second conclusion is that accounting for place provides further explanation for a moderately large portion of observed racial health disparities. The contribution of neighborhood context to the observed racial health gap varies considerably by age and
Acknowledgments
This work was completed with support from grant #NIEHS 1 P50 ESO12383-01. Support for D. Phuong Do was provided by the Kellogg Health Scholars Program grant # P0117943.
References (81)
- et al.
Income inequality and weight status in US metropolitan areas
Social Science & Medicine
(2005) What to make of it? The (re)emergence of a biological conceptualization of race in health disparities research
Social Science & Medicine
(2007)- et al.
Socioeconomic disparities in health change in a longitudinal study of U.S. adults: the role of health-risk behaviors
Social Science & Medicine
(2001) - et al.
Unraveling the tangle of pathology: the effect of spatially concentrated joblessness on the well-being of African Americans
Social Science Research
(1995) - et al.
The relationship of community quality to the health of women and men
Social Science & Medicine
(1998) - et al.
A multilevel analysis of race, community disadvantage, and body mass index among adults in the U.S
Social Science & Medicine
(2004) - et al.
Gender differences in the association between health and neighbourhood environment
Social Science & Medicine
(2005) The role of genetics in population health
- et al.
Neighborhood environment and loss of physical function in older adults: evidence from the Alameda County study
American Journal of Epidemiology
(2002) - et al.
Neighborhood poverty and the resurgence of tuberculosis in New York City, 1984–1992
American Journal of Public Health
(2001)
Community studies reporting association between self-rated health and mortality: additional studies, 1995 to 1998
Research on Aging
Gender and health: The effects of constrained choice and social policies
Individual and contextual risks of death among race and ethnic groups in the United States
Journal of Health and Social Behavior
Fast food and obesity in children
Pediatrics
Microeconometrics: Methods and applications
Assessment of the magnitude of geographical variations and socioeconomic contextual effects on ischaemic heart disease mortality: a multilevel survival analysis of a large Swedish cohort
Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health
Segregation and mortality: the deadly effects of racism?
Sociological Forum
A note on the biologic concept of race and its application in epidemiologic research
American Heart Journal
Neighbourhood environment and its association with self rated health: evidence from Scotland and England
Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health
If not genetics, then what? Biological pathways and population health
Urban sprawl as a risk factor in motor vehicle occupant and pedestrian fatalities
American Journal of Public Health
Relationship between urban sprawl and physical activity, obesity, and morbidity
American Journal of Health Promotion
Utility of health data from social surveys: is there a gold standard for measuring morbidity?
American Sociological Review
Health trajectories: long-term dynamics among black and white adults
Journal of Health and Social Behavior
Race/ethnic disparities in infant mortality: the role of behavioral factors
Social Biology
Validity of self-rated health among Latino(a)s
American Journal of Epidemiology
Placing' health in an urban sociology: cities as mosaics of risk and protection
City and Community
Health and community design: The impact of the built environment on physical activity
Air pollution and medical care use by older Americans: a cross-area analysis
Health Affairs
Neighborhoods, aging and functional limitations
Why genes don't count (for racial differences in health)
American Journal of Public Health
Changes in outlet densities affect violence rates
Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research
Poverty and health. Prospective evidence from the Alameda County study
American Journal of Epidemiology
Understanding and reducing socioeconomic and racial/ethnic disparities
Racial wage inequality: job segregation and devaluation across U.S. labor markets
American Journal of Sociology
Neighborhood environment, access to places for activity, and leisure-time physical activity in a diverse North Carolina population
American Journal of Health Promotion
Self-rated health and mortality in the NHANES-I epidemiologic follow-up study
American Journal of Public Health
Self-rated health and mortality: a review of twenty-seven community studies
Journal of Health and Social Behavior
Cited by (101)
The effects of race and class on community-level stigmatization of opioid use and policy preferences
2023, International Journal of Drug PolicyThe Relationship Between Peripheral Arterial Disease Severity and Socioeconomic Status
2023, Annals of Vascular SurgeryThe influence of socioeconomic status on outcomes of lower extremity arterial reconstruction
2022, Journal of Vascular SurgeryThe Role of Place in Disparities Affecting Black Men Receiving Hemodialysis
2021, Kidney International ReportsCitation Excerpt :Our finding of lower rate of cardiovascular disease and lower comorbidity scores among men treated in communities with substantial proportions of Black resdients could represent a difference in disease severity, but could also represent administrative under-coding or a shortfall in diagnostic vigilance for those cared for by healthcare systems serving these communities.42,43 The role of residential segregation, a phenomenon established by historical redlining and housing policies and perpetuated by governmental institutions and corporate practices in driving healthcare inequities as well established and a recognized contributing factor to health disparities like the ones described here.18,44-46 The lingering impact of institutional discrimination is evident in our data and consistent with other studies using census track level community data, indicating that areas with sizable Black populations had higher levels of poverty and family disruption as well as lower overall educational attainment.15,44,47,48
Gentrification and binge drinking in California neighborhoods: It matters how long you've lived there
2018, Drug and Alcohol Dependence