Infant and mother related outcomes from exposure to metals with endocrine disrupting properties during pregnancy

doi:10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.06.134

Science of The Total Environment

Volumes 569–570, 1 November 2016, Pages 1022-1031

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.06.134 Get rights and content

Highlights

•
Low and high dose exposure to lead was associated with low birth weight, preterm birth, stillbirths, spontaneous abortions and hypertension.
•
Exposure to arsenic was associated with fetal loss, stillbirths and spontaneous abortions.
•
Exposure to cadmium was associated with low birth weight.
•
Exposure to mercury was associated with spontaneous abortions and neurotoxic effects.
•
Exposure to copper was associated with low birth weight and spontaneous abortions and exposure to zinc was associated with low birth weight.

Abstract

Background

Endocrine-related adverse health effects from exposure to heavy metals such as lead, arsenic, cadmium, and mercury are yet to be adequately described. The purpose of this review was to gain insight into maternal exposure to heavy metals, and to identify potential endocrine-related adverse health effects in the mother and the infant.

Methods

Relevant databases were searched for original research reports and a total of 46 articles were retained for scrutiny. Required data was extracted from these studies and their methodology was assessed.

Results

Impaired fetal growth was observed from exposure to all endocrine disrupting metals, while exposure to lead and arsenic were associated with spontaneous abortion, stillbirth and neonatal deaths. Maternal exposure to arsenic was associated with impaired glucose tolerance in these mothers.

Conclusion

Impaired fetal growth, fetal loss, and neonatal deaths were significantly associated with heavy metals exposure during pregnancy; however, hypertension and gestational diabetes require further investigation.

Graphical abstract

Section snippets

Background

Endocrine disrupting chemicals (EDCs) mimic endogenous hormones and have the ability to exert agonistic or antagonistic endocrine effects by interacting with the hormone receptors. Exposure to EDCs is ubiquitous since these chemicals are commonly used in trade and commerce and in household products. Because of their inherent characteristics, EDCs can act as ligands and bind to respective hormone receptors which bind to response elements in the target genes to produce undesired downstream

Search strategy and selection criteria

The search strategy for this review identified terms that were infant related that described adverse health effects on the fetus, mother-related outcome terms that described adverse obstetric outcomes observed in the mother and exposure related terms which included endocrine disrupting heavy metals. The search strategy was developed using the PubMed database and when a sufficiently robust search strategy was developed it was used to search other databases (Medline (Ovid), EMBASE, HealthStar,

Lead

. Lead is ubiquitous in the environment because of the past use of lead in commerce and trade, paints, water pipes, cosmetics and industrial use. A number of experimental studies have investigated the physiological properties of heavy metals including lead and their role as EDCs. Vaiserman, 2014 has suggested that exposure to heavy metals with endocrine disrupting properties in-utero and during neonatal development can adversely affect long-term health outcomes through epigenetic programming.

Discussion

The main objective of the present review was to investigate the potential association between environmental exposure to toxic heavy metals and adverse mother- and infant-related outcomes during pregnancy. These metals exhibited endocrine disrupting capability and were toxic beyond a certain threshold. These metals have been documented to have a range of adverse health effects on the mother and the infant. In many parts of the world guidelines have been recommended to prevent adverse effects

Conclusions

This review confirmed some of the findings previously reported by other review studies that examined exposure to heavy metals (lead, arsenic, cadmium and mercury) during pregnancy. The evidence appears to be sufficient for low birth weight and stillbirth from exposure to lead. Exposed mothers were also reported to have a higher risk of preterm births, spontaneous abortions and hypertension during pregnancy. Higher exposures to lead were also associated with impaired fetal growth. The evidence

Authors' contributions

JG conceived of the study, supervised in its design and coordination, and helped to draft and critically revised the manuscript.

AR developed the search strategy and conducted the literature search, extracted data, critically appraised literature, analyzed the data, and drafted the manuscript.

PK read and revised the manuscript for correctness of the information and relevance of the findings to the research objectives.

Acknowledgements

The authors would like to acknowledge the funding for this study provided by the McLaughlin Research Chair awarded to J Gomes. We also like to thank A Rahman for meticulously collecting, collating and assessing the data.

References (65)

J. Annamalai et al.
Endocrine disrupting chemicals in the atmosphere: their effects on humans and wildlife
Environ. Int.
(2015 Mar)
L.L. Aylward et al.
Evaluation of urinary speciated arsenic in NHANES: issues in interpretation in the context of potential inorganic arsenic exposure
Regul. Toxicol. Pharmacol.
(2014 Jun)
D. Bellinger et al.
Weight gain and maturity in fetuses exposed to low levels of lead
Environ. Res.
(1991 Apr)
E. Benefice et al.
Fishing activity, health characteristics and mercury exposure of Amerindian women living alongside the Beni River (Amazonian Bolivia)
Int. J. Hyg. Environ. Health
(2010 Nov)
M.S. Bloom et al.
Spontaneous pregnancy loss in humans and exposure to arsenic in drinking water
Int. J. Hyg. Environ. Health
(2010)
P. Borella et al.
Maternal plasma concentrations of magnesium, calcium, zinc and copper in normal and pathological pregnancies
Sci. Total Environ.
(1990 Dec 1)
D. Churchill et al.
Ambulatory blood pressure in pregnancy and fetal growth
Lancet
(1997 Jan 4)
E. Diaz et al.
Newborn birth weight correlates with placental zinc, umbilical insulin-like growth factor I, and leptin levels in preeclampsia
Arch. Med. Res.
(2002 Jan-Feb)
J.L. Domingo
Vanadium: a review of the reproductive and developmental toxicity
Reprod. Toxicol.
(1996 May-Jun)
K. Grant et al.
Health consequences of exposure to e-waste: a systematic review
The Lancet Global Health
(2013)

M.A. McDiarmid et al.

The clinical content of preconception care: environmental exposures

Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol.

(2008)

C. Pirard et al.

Hair mercury and urinary cadmium levels in Belgian children and their mothers within the framework of the COPHES/DEMOCOPHES projects

Sci. Total Environ.

(2014 Feb 15)

G.D. Shapiro et al.

Exposure to endocrine disrupting chemicals and gestational diabetes

Canadian J Diabetes

(2013)

G.D. Shapiro et al.

Exposure to phthalates, bisphenol A and metals in pregnancy and association with impaired glucose tolerance and gestational diabetes mellitus: the MIREC study

Environ. Int.

(2015)

S. Thomas et al.

Metals exposure and risk of small-for-gestational age at birth in a Canadian birth cohort. The MIREC study

Environ. Res.

(2015)

E.W. Triche et al.

Environmental factors implicated in the causation of adverse pregnancy outcome

Semin. Perinatol.

(2007)

S.A. Ahmad et al.

Arsenic in drinking water and pregnancy outcomes

Environ. Health Perspect.

(2001 Jun)

F. Akhlaghi et al.

A comparative study of relationship between micronutrients and gestational diabetes

ISRN Obstetrics and Gynecology

(2012)

E. Al-Saleh et al.

Maternal-foetal status of copper, iron, molybdenum, selenium and zinc in obese gestational diabetic pregnancies

Acta Diabetol.

(2007 Sep)

E. Al-Saleh et al.

Maternal-fetal status of copper, iron, molybdenum, selenium and zinc in patients with gestational diabetes

J. Matern. Fetal Neonatal Med.

(2004)

G. Bacis

Lead poisoning in pregnancy: Prevention and treatment

Clin. Toxicol.

(2009 June)

A. Basu et al.

Plasma trace elements and preeclampsia in type 1 diabetes: a prospective study

Diabetes

(2014)

D.C. Bellinger

Teratogen update: lead and pregnancy

Birth Defects Res A Clin Mol Teratol

(2005 Jun)

L.K. Boyce et al.

Academic outcomes of very low birth weight infants: the influence of mother-child relationships

Infant Mental Health J

(2015)

M.A. Brown et al.

The detection, investigation, and management of hypertension during pregnancy: full consensus statement

Aust NZ Obstet Gynaecol

(2000)

D. Caserta et al.

Heavy metals and placental fetal-maternal barrier: a mini-review on the major concerns

Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci

(2013 Aug)

N.A. Charania et al.

An examination of traditional foods and cigarette smoking as cadmium sources among the nine First Nations of Eeyou Istchee, Northern Quebec, Canada

Environ Sci Process Impacts

(2014 May)

J. Chlopicka et al.

Lead and cadmium in hair and blood of children from a highly independent area in Poland

Biol. Trace Elem. Res.

(1988)

L.M. Cleveland et al.

Lead hazards for pregnant women and children part I

AJN

(2008 October)

L.M. Cleveland et al.

Lead hazards for pregnant women and children: part 2: more can still be done to reduce the chance of exposure to lead in at-risk populations

Am. J. Nurs.

(2008 November)

T.C. Corvelo et al.

Monitoring mercury exposure in reproductive aged women inhabiting the Tapajos river basin, Amazon

Bull. Environ. Contam. Toxicol.

(2014 May 14)

S.H. Downs et al.

The feasibility of creating a checklist for the assessment of the methodological quality both of randomised and non-randomised studies of health care interventions

J. Epidemiol. Community Health

(1998)

Cited by (82)

Effect of perinatal exposure to glyphosate and its mixture with 2,4-D and dicamba on rat dam kidney and thyroid function and offspring's health
2023, Environmental Research
The increasing use of the herbicide mixture of glyphosate, dicamba and 2-4-D to deal with glyphosate-resistant weeds raises concerns regarding human health and environmental risks. This study aimed to evaluate the effects of developmental exposure to glyphosate and a herbicide mixture containing glyphosate, dicamba and 2-4-D on rat dams' kidney and thyroid function and offspring's health. Pregnant Wistar rats were exposed from day-6 of gestation till weaning to regulatory relevant doses of glyphosate corresponding to the European Union (EU) acceptable daily intake (ADI; 0.5 mg/kg bw/day), and the no-observed-adverse-effect level (NOAEL; 50 mg/kg bw/day), and to a mixture of glyphosate, dicamba and 2,4-D all at the EU ADI (0.5, 0.002 and 0.3 mg/kg bw/day) respectively. After weaning the dams were sacrificed and blood and organs were collected. The pups' health was assessed by measuring viability, gestational and anogenital indices. Perinatal exposure to GLY alone and the herbicide mixture resulted in anti-androgenic effects in male offspring. In dams, exposure to glyphosate resulted in kidney glomerular and tubular dysfunction as well as increased thyroid hormone levels in a dose-dependent manner. Furthermore, exposure to the herbicide mixture resulted in effects similar to those observed with glyphosate at the NOAEL, suggesting at least an additive effect of the herbicide mixture at doses individually considered safe for humans.
Effects of the real-life metal(oid)s mixture on female reproductive function: Less is different
2023, Science of the Total Environment
The current study aimed to examine the effect of toxic metal(oid) mixtures (lead (Pb), cadmium (Cd), arsenic (As), mercury (Hg), cadmium (Cd), chromium (Cr), and nickel (Ni)) on female reproductive function in Wistar rats after the 28- and 90-day exposure to dose levels calculated on the basis of the previously conducted human study. Experimental groups included: 2 controls (28- and 90-day), treated groups - doses based on: median– F2 (28) and F2(90) and 95th percentile concentrations in the general human population – F3(28) and F3(90); calculated lower Benchmark dose confidence limit (BMDL) for effects on hormone levels – F1(28) and F1(90) and a group given the doses calculated on the basis of the reference values from the literature (F4(28)). Blood and ovarian samples were collected for sex hormones and ovary redox status analysis. After 28-day exposure, changes were present both in prooxidants and antioxidants. However, after the 90-day exposure redox status imbalance was majorly caused by the disturbance of antioxidants. Changes in some parameters were observed even after exposure to the lowest doses. After 28-day exposure, the strongest dose-response relationship was found between hormones: LH and FSH and toxic metal(oid)s and, after 90-day exposure, between investigated redox status parameters: sulfhydryl groups, ischemia-modified albumin and nuclear factor erythroid 2–related factor 2 (Nrf2) and toxic metal(oid)s. Low obtained BMDLs and narrow Benchmark intervals for toxic metal(oid)s and some of the parameters might confirm the “no-threshold” paradigm. This study indicates possible detrimental effects of prolonged exposure to real-life mixtures of toxic metal(oid) on female reproductive function.
Environmental pollutants and their effects on human health
2023, Heliyon
Numerous environmental contaminants significantly contribute to human disease, affecting climate change and public and individual health, resulting in increased mortality and morbidity. Because of the scarcity of information regarding pollution exposure from less developed nations with inadequate waste management, higher levels of poverty, and limited adoption of new technology, the relationship between pollutants and health effects needs to be investigated more. A similar situation is present in many developed countries, where solutions are only discovered after the harm has already been done and the necessity for safeguards has subsided. The connection between environmental toxins and health needs to be better understood due to difficulties in quantifying exposure levels and a lack of systematic monitoring. Different pollutants are to blame for both chronic and acute disorders.
Additionally, research becomes challenging when disease problems are seen after prolonged exposure. This review aims to discuss the present understanding of the association between environmental toxins and human health in bridging this knowledge gap. The genesis of cancer and the impact of various environmental pollutants on the human body's cardiovascular, respiratory, reproductive, prenatal, and neural health are discussed in this overview.
Risk assessment of naturally occurring radioactivity in soil adjacent to a coal-fired brick kiln
2023, Radiation Physics and Chemistry
Being aware of the potential health effects brought on by exposure to radionuclides, besides chemical and air pollution, produced by coal-fired brick kilns, first-ever measurements of terrestrial radionuclides were performed in the topsoil sampled from the surrounding of a randomly chosen coal-fired brick kiln operating at the outskirts of megacity Dhaka, Bangladesh. By employing the HPGe gamma-ray spectroscopy, the activity concentrations of ²²⁶Ra, ²³²Th, and ⁴ K was found to be in the range of (19.2 ± 2.7–54 ± 7.0) Bq/kg, (33 ± 5.3–68 ± 9.5) Bq/kg, and (360 ± 43–540 ± 65) Bq/kg respectively, where almost all the values of ⁴⁰ K, ²³²Th; and some of the values of ²²⁶Ra exceeded the corresponding world average values. Possible causes of the elevated level of radionuclides include the deposition of bottom ash in lowlands, the accumulation of fly ash in soils, and the fallout of fine particles that absorb the minerals released from the coal burning process. ¹³⁷Cs was also found in two samples that might indicate contamination of the feed coal. Most of the outdoor absorbed dose rates, some internal absorbed dose rates, annual effective dose, gamma level index and excess lifetime cancer risk surpass the worldwide average. According to these hazard parameters, there are health risks to the brick kiln workers and the populace who consumes food crops produced in the studied agricultural soils. The present quantitative measurements urge the municipal authorities to manage and monitor the discharge of fly ash from the brick kilns and take precautionary actions to reduce unwanted health hazards. It also demands to monitor of the human health of workers and residents near the brick kilns.
Prenatal arsenic exposure, arsenic metabolism and neurocognitive development of 2-year-old children in low-arsenic areas
2023, Environment International
There is limited evidence on the effects of arsenic species and metabolic capacity on child neurodevelopment, particularly at low levels. Further, little is known about the critical window of exposure.
To estimate the associations of arsenic exposure and arsenic metabolism in different pregnancy periods with neurodevelopment of two-year-old children.
Concentrations of arsenobetaine (AsB), arsenite, arsenate, monomethyl arsenic acid (MMA), and dimethyl arsenic acid (DMA) in urine samples collected in three trimesters from 1006 mothers were measured using HPLC − ICPMS. Inorganic arsenic (iAs) was calculated as the sum of arsenite and arsenate. Total arsenic (tAs) was calculated as the sum of iAs, MMA and DMA. Child neurodevelopment was assessed with the Bayley Scales of Infant Development.
The geometric mean (GM) of SG-adjusted tAs in the first, second, third trimester was 16.37, 12.94, 13.04 μg/L, respectively. The mental development index (MDI) score was inversely associated with iAs and tAs. Compared to the 1st quartile, the MDI score decreased 0.43 (95%CI: −4.22, 3.36) for the 2nd, 6.50 (95%CI: −11.73, −1.27) for the 3rd, 5.42 (95%CI: −10.74, −0.10) for the 4th quartiles of iAs, and decreased 4.03 (95%CI: −7.90, −0.15) in the 4th quartile of tAs. In trimester-specific models, negative associations of DMA [−1.94 (95%CI: −3.18, −0.71)] and tAs [−1.61 (95%CI: −3.02, −0.20)] with the psychomotor development index (PDI) were only observed in 1st trimester.
Our study found inverse associations between prenatal arsenic exposure, especially in early pregnancy, and neurodevelopment of children at two years old, even at low exposure levels.
Consequences of the exposome to gestational diabetes mellitus
2023, Biochimica et Biophysica Acta - General Subjects
Citation Excerpt :
Thus, Arsenic induced hyperglycaemia due to deficient signalling to express and maintain the activity of GLUT4 [8,138]. A higher blood level of Arsenic is also reported in women with GDM leading to endocrine disruption and abnormal metabolism of D-glucose increasing the risks of hypertension in pregnancy [13,38,44,120]. The latter occurs when there is chronic exposure to Arsenic increasing the risk of cardiovascular and peripheral diseases such as hypertension [8,138].
The exposome is the cumulative measure of environmental influences and associated biological responses throughout the lifespan, including those from the environment, diet, behaviour, and endogenous processes. The exposome concept and the 2030 Agenda for the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) from the United Nations are the basis for understanding the aetiology and consequences of non-communicable diseases, including gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM). Pregnancy may be developed in an environment with adverse factors part of the immediate internal medium for fetus development and the external medium to which the pregnant woman is exposed. The placenta is the interface between maternal and fetal compartments and acts as a protective barrier or easing agent to transfer exposome from mother to fetus. Under and over-nutrition in utero, exposure to adverse environmental pollutants such as heavy metals, endocrine-disrupting chemicals, pesticides, drugs, pharmaceuticals, lifestyle, air pollutants, and tobacco smoke plays a determinant role in the development of GDM. This phenomenon is worsened by metabolic stress postnatally, such as obesity which increases the risk of GDM and other diseases. Clinical risk factors for GDM development include its aetiology. It is proposed that knowledge-based interventions to change the potential interdependent ecto-exposome and endo-exposome could avoid the occurrence and consequences of GDM.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

ReviewInfant and mother related outcomes from exposure to metals with endocrine disrupting properties during pregnancy

Highlights

Abstract

Background

Methods

Results

Conclusion

Graphical abstract

Section snippets

Background

Search strategy and selection criteria

Lead

Discussion

Conclusions

Authors' contributions

Acknowledgements

Environ. Int.

Regul. Toxicol. Pharmacol.

Environ. Res.

Int. J. Hyg. Environ. Health

Int. J. Hyg. Environ. Health

Sci. Total Environ.

Lancet

Arch. Med. Res.

Reprod. Toxicol.

The Lancet Global Health

Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol.

Sci. Total Environ.

Canadian J Diabetes

Environ. Int.

Environ. Res.

Semin. Perinatol.

Arsenic in drinking water and pregnancy outcomes

Environ. Health Perspect.

A comparative study of relationship between micronutrients and gestational diabetes

ISRN Obstetrics and Gynecology

Maternal-foetal status of copper, iron, molybdenum, selenium and zinc in obese gestational diabetic pregnancies

Acta Diabetol.

Maternal-fetal status of copper, iron, molybdenum, selenium and zinc in patients with gestational diabetes

J. Matern. Fetal Neonatal Med.

Lead poisoning in pregnancy: Prevention and treatment

Clin. Toxicol.

Plasma trace elements and preeclampsia in type 1 diabetes: a prospective study

Diabetes

Teratogen update: lead and pregnancy

Birth Defects Res A Clin Mol Teratol

Academic outcomes of very low birth weight infants: the influence of mother-child relationships

Infant Mental Health J

The detection, investigation, and management of hypertension during pregnancy: full consensus statement

Aust NZ Obstet Gynaecol

Heavy metals and placental fetal-maternal barrier: a mini-review on the major concerns

Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci

An examination of traditional foods and cigarette smoking as cadmium sources among the nine First Nations of Eeyou Istchee, Northern Quebec, Canada

Environ Sci Process Impacts

Lead and cadmium in hair and blood of children from a highly independent area in Poland

Biol. Trace Elem. Res.

Lead hazards for pregnant women and children part I

AJN

Lead hazards for pregnant women and children: part 2: more can still be done to reduce the chance of exposure to lead in at-risk populations

Am. J. Nurs.

Monitoring mercury exposure in reproductive aged women inhabiting the Tapajos river basin, Amazon

Bull. Environ. Contam. Toxicol.

The feasibility of creating a checklist for the assessment of the methodological quality both of randomised and non-randomised studies of health care interventions

J. Epidemiol. Community Health

Review
Infant and mother related outcomes from exposure to metals with endocrine disrupting properties during pregnancy