Changes in cortical thickness and volume after cranial radiation treatment: A systematic review

doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2019.02.013

Radiotherapy and Oncology

Volume 135, June 2019, Pages 33-42

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.radonc.2019.02.013 Get rights and content

Highlights

•
New RT innovations enable sparing of brain areas susceptible to radiation damage.
•
Interest in the effect of radiation therapy on the cerebral cortex has increased.
•
We found papers with great heterogeneity and lacking in methodological strength.
•
More robust research is needed to make recommendations for clinical practice.

Abstract

Cognitive decline has a clear impact on quality of life in patients who have received cranial radiation treatment. The pathophysiological process is most likely multifactorial, with a possible role for decreased cortical thickness and volume. As radiotherapy treatment systems are becoming more sophisticated, precise sparing of vulnerable regions and tissue is possible. This allows radiation oncologists to make treatment more patient-tailored. A systematic search was performed to collect and review all available evidence regarding the effect of cranial radiation treatment on cortical thickness and volume. We searched the Pubmed, Embase and Cochrane databases, with an additional reference check in the Scopus database. Studies that examined cortical changes on MRI within patients as well as between treated and non-treated patients were included. The quality of the studies was assessed with a checklist specially designed for this review. No meta-analysis was performed due to the lack of randomised trials. Out of 1915 publications twenty-one papers were selected, of which fifteen observed cortical changes after radiation therapy. Two papers reported radiation-dependent decrease in cortical thickness within patients one year after radiation treatment, suggesting a clear relation between the two. However, study quality was considered mostly suboptimal, and there was great inhomogeneity between the included studies. This means that, although there has been increasing interest in the effects of radiation treatment on cortex morphology, no reliable conclusion can be drawn based on the currently available evidence. This calls for more research, preferably with a sufficiently large patient population, and adequate methodology.

Section snippets

Search strategy

The systematic review was conducted according to the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) Statement [36]. A search was performed in the Pubmed, Embase and Cochrane databases on the 21st of March 2018, and was constructed with help of a research librarian at Utrecht University, specialised in medical systematic reviews. The full search strings for each database are found in Appendix A. In short, we searched with terms relating to radiation therapy and

Results

After duplicate removal, the search yielded a total of 1915 unique studies. After screening of title and abstract, 63 studies were selected for full text evaluation. After reading the full text, 21 studies were included for this review. A reference check in Scopus revealed no additional studies. The flow-chart of study selection is shown in Fig. 1.

Of the selected studies, 7 reported on cortical thickness after radiation therapy. Thirteen measured either cortical or grey matter volume after RT,

Discussion

In this systematic review we set out to find all available evidence regarding the effects of radiation therapy on cortical thickness and volume. From 1915 manuscripts we included 21 studies, of which 7 studied cortical thickness, 13 studied cortical or grey matter volume after RT, and 1 studied both.

Fifteen papers seemed to show at least some degree of cortical change, with Karunamuni et al. and Seibert et al. providing the most reliable evidence as scored by our checklist (Table 1, Table 4).

Conclusion

Thinning of the cerebral cortex is associated with cognitive decline. Thickness and volume of the cerebral cortex can be easily measured from T1 MRIs that are acquired as part of the normal clinical routine. There seems to be a relation between radiation therapy and changes in cortical thickness and volume. Furthermore, higher doses may lead to more thinning and sharper cognitive decline. However, despite the amount of studies found, the present studies are too inhomogeneous and lacking in

Conflict of interest

None.

Acknowledgements

Special thanks to Felix Weijdema MSc (Subject Librarian Medicine, Utrecht University, Utrecht, the Netherlands) for helping set up and conducting the search.

References (82)

V. Gondi et al.
Why avoid the hippocampus? A comprehensive review
Radiother Oncol
(2010)
R. Dahnke et al.
Cortical thickness and central surface estimation
Neuroimage
(2013)
N. Kriegeskorte et al.
An efficient algorithm for topologically correct segmentation of the cortical sheet in anatomical MR volumes
Neuroimage
(2001)
J. Ashburner et al.
Voxel-based morphometry—the methods
Neuroimage
(2000)
J. Ashburner et al.
Unified segmentation
Neuroimage
(2005)
D. MacDonald et al.
Automated 3-D extraction of inner and outer surfaces of cerebral cortex from MRI
Neuroimage
(2000)
S.W. Seo et al.
Cortical thickness in single- versus multiple-domain amnestic mild cognitive impairment
Neuroimage
(2007)
A.I. Garcia-Diaz et al.
Cortical thinning correlates of changes in visuospatial and visuoperceptual performance in Parkinson’s disease: a 4-year follow-up
Parkinsonism Relat Disord
(2018)
L.M. Gazdzinski et al.
Radiation-induced alterations in mouse brain development characterized by magnetic resonance imaging
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys
(2012)
A.M. Winkler et al.
Cortical thickness or grey matter volume? The importance of selecting the phenotype for imaging genetics studies
Neuroimage
(2010)

T. Knoll et al.

Key steps in conducting systematic reviews for underpinning clinical practice guidelines: methodology of the european association of urology

Eur Urol

(2018)

R. Karunamuni et al.

Dose-dependent cortical thinning after partial brain irradiation in high-grade glioma

Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys

(2016)

T.M. Seibert et al.

Cerebral cortex regions selectively vulnerable to radiation dose-dependent atrophy

Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys

(2017)

J. Lin et al.

Radiation-induced abnormal cortical thickness in patients with nasopharyngeal carcinoma after radiotherapy

NeuroImage Clin

(2017)

A.K. Liu et al.

Changes in cerebral cortex of children treated for medulloblastoma

Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys

(2007)

B.J. Nieman et al.

White and gray matter abnormalities after cranial radiation in children and mice

Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys

(2015)

M. Simo et al.

Longitudinal brain changes associated with prophylactic cranial irradiation in lung cancer

J Thorac Oncol

(2016)

M. Simó et al.

Cognitive and brain structural changes in a lung cancer population

J Thorac Oncol

(2015)

J. Petr et al.

Photon vs. proton radiochemotherapy: effects on brain tissue volume and perfusion

Radiother Oncol

(2018)

A. Gommlich et al.

Retrospective assessment of MRI-based volumetric changes of normal tissues in glioma patients following radio(chemo)therapy

Clin Transl Radiat Oncol

(2018)

C. Follin et al.

Impaired brain metabolism and neurocognitive function in childhood leukemia survivors despite complete hormone supplementation in adulthood

Psychoneuroendocrinology

(2016)

W.E. Reddick et al.

A hybrid neural network analysis of subtle brain volume differences in children surviving brain tumors

Magn Reson Imaging

(1998)

J.R. Fike et al.

Radiation dose response of normal brain

Int J Radiat Oncol

(1988)

C.D. Good et al.

Cerebral asymmetry and the effects of sex and handedness on brain structure: a voxel-based morphometric analysis of 465 normal adult human brains

Neuroimage

(2001)

R. Rosenthal

The file drawer problem and tolerance for null results

Psychol Bull

(1979)

V. Gondi et al.

Hippocampal-sparing whole-brain radiotherapy: a “how-to” technique using helical tomotherapy and linear accelerator-based intensity-modulated radiotherapy

Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys

(2010)

J.J.W. Lagendijk et al.

MRI/linac integration

Radiother Oncol

(2008)

R.A. Karunamuni et al.

Radiation sparing of cerebral cortex in brain tumor patients using quantitative neuroimaging

Radiother Oncol

(2016)

V.L. Murzin et al.

4pi plan optimization for cortical-sparing brain radiotherapy

Radiother Oncol

(2018)

R.S. Desikan et al.

An automated labeling system for subdividing the human cerebral cortex on MRI scans into gyral based regions of interest

Neuroimage

(2006)

M.T. Makale et al.

Mechanisms of radiotherapy-associated cognitive disability in patients with brain tumours

Nat Rev Neurol

(2017)

D. Greene-Schloesser et al.

Radiation-induced cognitive impairment-from bench to bedside

Neuro Oncol

(2012)

Y.W. Lee et al.

Whole brain radiation-induced cognitive impairment: pathophysiological mechanisms and therapeutic targets

Biomol Ther (Seoul)

(2012)

C. Yin et al.

Brain imaging of mild cognitive impairment and Alzheimer’s disease

Neural Regen Res

(2013)

E. Pääkkö et al.

White matter changes on MRI during treatment in children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia: correlation with neuropsychological findings

Med Pediatr Oncol

(2000)

O. Fujii et al.

White matter changes on magnetic resonance imaging following whole-brain radiotherapy for brain metastases

Radiat Med

(2006)

V. Gondi et al.

Hippocampal dosimetry predicts neurocognitive function impairment after fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy for benign or low-grade adult brain tumors

Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys

(2013)

B. Fischl et al.

Measuring the thickness of the human cerebral cortex from magnetic resonance images

Proc Natl Acad Sci USA

(2000)

I. Bosma et al.

Synchronized brain activity and neurocognitive function in patients with low-grade glioma: a magnetoencephalography study

Neuro Oncol

(2008)

Cited by (25)

Transcriptional expression of radiation-induced early cortical morphological alterations and its association with radiation necrosis in patients with nasopharyngeal carcinoma
2023, Radiotherapy and Oncology
To explore the effects of standard radiotherapy on cortical morphology and its potential transcriptional expression, and to determine the predictive power of cortical morphological measurement at the early stage for radiation necrosis (RN) occurrence within 3 years post-radiotherapy in patients with nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC).
185 NPC patients participated. Pre-treatment and post-radiotherapy (1–3 months) structural MRI were collected longitudinally and prospectively. Multiple cortical morphological indices were compared between pre-treatment and post-radiotherapy. Brain-wide gene expression was used to assess the transcriptional profiles associated with radiation-induced cortical morphological changes. Machine learning was used to construct predictive models for RN with cortical morphological alterations at the early stage.
Relative to pre-treatment, NPC patients exhibited a widespread reduction in cortical volume (CV) and cortical thickness (CT) post-radiotherapy (p < 0.001). Partial least squares regression analysis revealed that radiotherapy-related cortical atrophy was closely related to transcriptional profiles (p < 0.001), with the most correlated genes enriched in ATPase Na⁺/K⁺ transporting alpha-1 and alpha-3 polypeptide and respiratory electron transport chain. Furthermore, models constructed with cortical morphological features at 1–3 months post-radiotherapy had favorable predictive power for RN occurrence in NPC patients within 3-year follow-up, the area under the curve was 0.854 and 0.843 for CV and CT, respectively.
NPC patients exhibited widespread cortical atrophy at 1–3 months post-radiotherapy, which was closely correlated with dysfunction of the ATPase Na⁺/K⁺ transporting alpha-1 and alpha-3 polypeptide and respiratory electron transport chain. Cortical morphology at 1–3 months post-radiotherapy may serve as an early biomarker for identifying RN.
Volumetric changes in gray matter after radiotherapy detected with longitudinal magnetic resonance imaging in glioma patients
2022, Radiotherapy and Oncology
We evaluated volumetric changes in the gray matter (GM) after radiotherapy (RT) and identified factors that were strongly associated with GM volume reduction.
A total of 461 magnetic resonance imagings (MRI) from 105 glioma patients treated with postoperative RT was retrospectively analyzed. Study patients’ MRIs were collected at five time points: before RT and 1 month, 6 months, 1 year, and 2 years after RT. Using the ‘FastSurfer’ platform, a deep learning-based neuroimaging pipeline, 73 regions were automatically segmented from longitudinal MRIs and their volumetric changes were calculated. Regions were grouped into 10 functional fields. A multivariable linear mixed-effects model was established to identify the potential predictors of significant volume reduction.
The median age was 50 years (range, 16–86 years). Forty-seven (44.8 %) patients were female and 68 (64.8 %) had glioblastoma. Postoperative RT was delivered at 54–60 Gy with or without concurrent chemotherapy. At 2 years after RT, the median volumetric changes in the overall, ipsilateral, and contralateral GM were −3.5%, −4.5%, and −2.4%, respectively. The functional fields of cognition and execution of movement showed the greatest volume reductions. In the multivariable linear mixed model, female sex (normalized coefficient = −0.14, P < 0.001) and the interaction between age at RT and days after RT (normalized coefficient = −6.48e-6, P < 0.001) were significantly associated with GM reduction. The older patients received RT, the greater volume reduction was seen over time. However, in patients with relatively younger age (e.g., 45, 50, and 60 years for hippocampus, Broca area, and Wernicke area, respectively), the volume was not significantly reduced.
GM volume reduction was identified after RT that could lead to long-term treatment sequelae. Particularly for susceptible patients, individualized treatment and prevention strategies are needed.
Quantifying the post-radiation accelerated brain aging rate in glioma patients with deep learning
2022, Radiotherapy and Oncology
Citation Excerpt :
textcolorredConsequently, normal appearing brain tissue should be spared as much as possible to avoid this post-radiation accelerated aging when irradiating the tumor-affected area. The changes are quantified with an interpretable score using the entire brain without the potential bias or limitation of commonly used, pre-defined features found in neuroimaging studies, such as cortical thickness [6] and volumetric measures [7], e.g.: hippocampus volume [35]. The population average saliency maps provide insights into the workings of the SFCN model.
Changes of healthy appearing brain tissue after radiotherapy (RT) have been previously observed. Patients undergoing RT may have a higher risk of cognitive decline, leading to a reduced quality of life. The experienced tissue atrophy is similar to the effects of normal aging in healthy individuals. We propose a new way to quantify tissue changes after cranial RT as accelerated brain aging using the BrainAGE framework.
BrainAGE was applied to longitudinal MRI scans of 32 glioma patients. Utilizing a pre-trained deep learning model, brain age is estimated for all patients’ pre-radiotherapy planning and follow-up MRI scans to acquire a quantification of the changes occurring in the brain over time. Saliency maps were extracted from the model to spatially identify which areas of the brain the deep learning model weighs highest for predicting age. The predicted ages from the deep learning model were used in a linear mixed effects model to quantify aging of patients after RT.
The linear mixed effects model resulted in an accelerated aging rate of 2.78 years/year, a significant increase over a normal aging rate of 1 (p < 0.05, confidence interval = 2.54–3.02). Furthermore, the saliency maps showed numerous anatomically well-defined areas, e.g.: Heschl’s gyrus among others, determined by the model as important for brain age prediction.
We found that patients undergoing RT are affected by significant post-radiation accelerated aging, with several anatomically well-defined areas contributing to this aging. The estimated brain age could provide a method for quantifying quality of life post-radiotherapy.
Morphological changes after cranial fractionated photon radiotherapy: Localized loss of white matter and grey matter volume with increasing dose
2021, Clinical and Translational Radiation Oncology
Citation Excerpt :
We used pre-RT and post-RT MRI scans from glioma patients to assess intracranial morphological changes in the brain after fractionated photon radiotherapy. In addition to reports on specific susceptible areas [3–10], we found that the entire brain is susceptible to radiation induced morphological changes after RT for brain tumors. Total grey matter volume and total white matter volume were reduced by respectively 2.1% and 5.8%, with a compensatory increase in CSF volume.
Numerous brain MR imaging studies have been performed to understand radiation-induced cognitive decline. However, many of them focus on a single region of interest, e.g. cerebral cortex or hippocampus. In this study, we use deformation-based morphometry (DBM) and voxel-based morphometry (VBM) to measure the morphological changes in patients receiving fractionated photon RT, and relate these to the dose. Additionally, we study tissue specific volume changes in white matter (WM), grey matter (GM), cerebrospinal fluid and total intracranial volume (TIV).
From our database, we selected 28 patients with MRI of high quality available at baseline and 1 year after RT. Scans were rigidly registered to each other, and to the planning CT and dose file. We used DBM to study non-tissue-specific volumetric changes, and VBM to study volume loss in grey matter. Observed changes were then related to the applied radiation dose (in EQD2). Additionally, brain tissue was segmented into WM, GM and cerebrospinal fluid, and changes in these volumes and TIV were tested.
Performing DBM resulted in clusters of dose-dependent volume loss 1 year after RT seen throughout the brain. Both WM and GM were affected; within the latter both cerebral cortex and subcortical nuclei show volume loss. Volume loss rates ranging from 5.3 to 15.3%/30 Gy were seen in the cerebral cortical regions in which more than 40% of voxels were affected. In VBM, similar loss rates were seen in the cortex and nuclei. The total volume of WM and GM significantly decreased with rates of 5.8% and 2.1%, while TIV remained unchanged as expected.
Radiotherapy is associated with dose-dependent intracranial morphological changes throughout the entire brain. Therefore, we will consider to revise sparing of organs at risk based on future cognitive and neurofunctional data.
Dose-dependent volume loss in subcortical deep grey matter structures after cranial radiotherapy
2021, Clinical and Translational Radiation Oncology
Citation Excerpt :
All imaging data was processed with Statistical Parametric Mapping (SPM12, v7487) [20], Computational Anatomy Toolbox (CAT12.6 r1450) [21], and in-house algorithms developed in MATLAB (Mathworks, Natick, Massachusetts, USA). Image processing was done in concordance to our own previously published criteria [3], amended for the current research question. More detailed image processing methods can be found in our previous work [4].
The relation between radiotherapy (RT) dose to the brain and morphological changes in healthy tissue has seen recent increased interest. There already is evidence for changes in the cerebral cortex and white matter, as well as selected subcortical grey matter (GM) structures. We studied this relation in all deep GM structures, to help understand the aetiology of post-RT neurocognitive symptoms.
We selected 31 patients treated with RT for grade II-IV glioma. Pre-RT and 1 year post-RT 3D T1-weighted MRIs were automatically segmented, and the changes in volume of the following structures were assessed: amygdala, nucleus accumbens, caudate nucleus, hippocampus, globus pallidus, putamen, and thalamus. The volumetric changes were related to the mean RT dose received by each structure. Hippocampal volumes were entered into a population-based nomogram to estimate hippocampal age.
A significant relation between RT dose and volume loss was seen in all examined structures, except the caudate nucleus. The volume loss rates ranged from 0.16 to 1.37%/Gy, corresponding to 4.9–41.2% per 30 Gy. Hippocampal age, as derived from the nomogram, was seen to increase by a median of 11 years.
Almost all subcortical GM structures are susceptible to radiation-induced volume loss, with higher volume loss being observed with increasing dose. Volume loss of these structures is associated with neurological deterioration, including cognitive decline, in neurodegenerative diseases. To support a causal relationship between radiation-induced deep GM loss and neurocognitive functioning in glioma patients, future studies are needed that directly correlate volumetrics to clinical outcomes.
Dose distribution of the brain tissue associated with cognitive functions in high-grade glioma patients
2020, Cancer/Radiotherapie
Citation Excerpt :
Hence, the protection of these nuclei located close to the hippocampi could be clinically relevant. Identification of the cortical brain areas highly sensitive to radiotherapy could help to develop new techniques in order to improve patients’ quality of life [30]. This prospective dosimetric study performed in 37 patients with glioblastoma demonstrated significantly improved healthy tissue sparing with VMAT compared with HT without jeopardizing PTV coverage.
The purpose of this prospective dosimetric study was to assess the dose distribution regarding the brain areas implied in cognitive functions using two approaches: volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) and helical tomotherapy (HT).
Thirty-seven patients were treated using a dual-arc VMAT approach for supratentorial glioblastoma between 2016 and 2018. The total dose of 60 Gy in 30 daily fractions was administered to the planning target volume (PTV). The brain structures that play an important role in cognitive physiology, such as the hippocampi, corpus callosum, cerebellum, subventricular zones (SVZ), were delineated. For each patient, a new treatment plan in HT was determined by a second medical physicist in a blindly fashion according to the same dose constraints and priorities. Statistical analyses were performed using the Wilcoxon-signed rank test.
Conformity indexes remained similar with both techniques. The mean values were 0.96 (0.19–1.00) for VMAT and 0.98 (range, 0.84–1.00) for HT, respectively (P = 0.73). Significant D_50% reductions were observed with VMAT compared to HT: 14.6 Gy (3.8–28.0) versus 17.4 Gy (12.1–25.0) for the normal brain (P = 0.014); 32.5 Gy (10.3–60.0) versus 35.6 Gy (17.1–58.0) for the corpus callosum (P = 0.038); 8.1 Gy (0.4–34.0) versus 12.8 Gy (0.8–27.0) for the cerebellum (P < 0.001), respectively.
The VMAT approach seemed to improve the sparing of the key brain areas implied in cognitive functions without jeopardizing PTV coverage.
L’objectif de cette étude prospective dosimétrique était d’évaluer la distribution de dose en regard des aires cérébrales impliquées dans les fonctions cognitives selon deux techniques : arcthérapie volumétrique modulée (VMAT) et tomothérapie hélicoïdale (HT).
Trente-sept patients ont été pris en charge pour un glioblastome sus-tentoriel par une VMAT à base de deux arcs entre 2016 et 2018. Une dose totale de 60 Gy en 30 fractions quotidiennes a été administrée au volume cible prévisionnel (PTV). Les structures cérébrales occupant une place importante dans la physiologie cognitive, comme les hippocampes, le corps calleux, le cervelet, les zones péri-ventriculaires (ZPV), ont été délinées. Pour chaque patient, un nouveau plan de HT a été déterminé en aveugle par une seconde physicienne médicale selon les mêmes contraintes de dose et priorités. Les analyses statistiques ont été menées à l’aide du test des rangs signés de Wilcoxon.
Les indices de conformité étaient similaires entre les deux techniques. Les valeurs moyennes étaient de 0,96 (0,19–1,00) respectivement en VMAT et de 0,98 (0,84–1,00) en tomothérapie hélicoïdale (p = 0,73). Des réductions significatives de la D_50 % (dose reçue dans 50 % du volume) ont été observées en VMAT, comparativement à la HT : respectivement 14,6 Gy (3,8–28,0) contre 17,4 Gy (12,1–25,0) pour l’encéphale sain (p = 0,014), 32,5 Gy (10,3–60,0) contre 35,6 Gy (17,1–58,0) pour le corps calleux (p = 0,038), 8,1 Gy (0,4–34,0) contre 12,8 Gy (0,8–27,0) pour le cervelet (p < 0,001).
La VMAT semblait améliorer la protection des principales régions cérébrales impliquées dans les fonctions cognitives sans compromettre la couverture du PTV.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Systematic ReviewChanges in cortical thickness and volume after cranial radiation treatment: A systematic review

Highlights

Abstract

Section snippets

Search strategy

Results

Discussion

Conclusion

Conflict of interest

Acknowledgements

Radiother Oncol

Neuroimage

Neuroimage

Neuroimage

Neuroimage

Neuroimage

Neuroimage

Parkinsonism Relat Disord

Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys

Neuroimage

Eur Urol

Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys

Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys

NeuroImage Clin

Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys

Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys

J Thorac Oncol

J Thorac Oncol

Radiother Oncol

Clin Transl Radiat Oncol

Psychoneuroendocrinology

Magn Reson Imaging

Int J Radiat Oncol

Neuroimage

Psychol Bull

Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys

Radiother Oncol

Radiother Oncol

Radiother Oncol

Neuroimage

Mechanisms of radiotherapy-associated cognitive disability in patients with brain tumours

Nat Rev Neurol

Radiation-induced cognitive impairment-from bench to bedside

Neuro Oncol

Whole brain radiation-induced cognitive impairment: pathophysiological mechanisms and therapeutic targets

Biomol Ther (Seoul)

Brain imaging of mild cognitive impairment and Alzheimer’s disease

Neural Regen Res

White matter changes on MRI during treatment in children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia: correlation with neuropsychological findings

Med Pediatr Oncol

White matter changes on magnetic resonance imaging following whole-brain radiotherapy for brain metastases

Radiat Med

Hippocampal dosimetry predicts neurocognitive function impairment after fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy for benign or low-grade adult brain tumors

Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys

Measuring the thickness of the human cerebral cortex from magnetic resonance images

Proc Natl Acad Sci USA

Synchronized brain activity and neurocognitive function in patients with low-grade glioma: a magnetoencephalography study

Neuro Oncol

Systematic Review
Changes in cortical thickness and volume after cranial radiation treatment: A systematic review