Short communicationThe spiral axis as a clinical tool to distinguish essential tremor from dystonia cases
Introduction
Tremor is a common feature of a variety of neurological disorders, including essential tremor (ET), Parkinson's disease (PD), and dystonia [1]. In genetic studies of ET, investigators must screen potential enrollees (i.e., reportedly affected relatives) by mail or telephone to ensure that they do not have other neurological conditions. Many individuals who self-report a diagnosis of “ET” actually have another neurological disorder rather than ET [2]. One previous study on misdiagnosis of tremor disorders reported that of the 26 patients with false ET, 6 (23.1%) were diagnosed with dystonia [2]. Another study of the over-diagnosis of ET demonstrated that 4 (40%) of 10 ET patients had dystonia [3].
To save time and resources, and avoid costly field trips to individuals who do not have ET, it is important to develop methods, aside from self-report, to effectively screen/exclude individuals with dystonic tremor prior to an in-person study visit. We previously reported [4] that on spiral drawing, the wave forms of ET cases generally aligned along a single predominant axis rather than several axes (Fig. 1). To our knowledge, no study has investigated the spiral axis as a screening tool to distinguish ET from dystonia cases. Here, we analyzed the pre-enrollment hand-drawn spiral drawings of 135 individuals enrolled in a genetic study, all of whom self-reported ET. Each of the four spirals was assessed for the presence of a single identifiable tremor orientation axis, and a spiral axis score (range = 0–4) [a single axis on all 4 spirals] was assigned to each enrollee (Fig. 1). After enrollment, each enrollee underwent a neurological examination, and 120 were diagnosed with ET and 15 with dystonic tremor. We hypothesized that the spiral axis would be a useful screening tool to distinguish ET cases from dystonia cases.
Section snippets
Participants
This study was conducted as part of the Family Study of Essential Tremor (FASET), Columbia University Medical Center (CUMC), New York [5]. Prior to enrollment, individuals with familial ET who were reported to have tremor were required to submit a set of four Archimedes spirals (two right, two left), drawn on a standard sheet of paper, without resting their wrist on the paper. These were analyzed and rated by a senior movement disorders neurologist (E.D.L) to determine the features and severity
Results
There were 120 ET cases and 15 dystonia cases (6 with torticollis, 2 with arm dystonia, 1 with blepharospasm, and 6 with dystonia in more than one region). The dystonia cases had not reported a diagnosis of dystonia during the screening phase of the study – dystonia was diagnosed after enrollment based on the videotaped neurological examination. ET cases were on average 7.1 years younger than dystonia cases (p = 0.03, Table 1). The proportion of women was 50.8% in ET cases and 93.3% in dystonia
Discussion
Despite attempts to use questionnaires to screen out enrollees with dystonia, in the current study, we still enrolled 15 dystonia cases, so there is a clear need for better screening methods. This need prompted these analyses. In an earlier study, we examined hand drawn spirals in a small sample of 29 ET cases and identified an axis in one or both spirals in 23/29 cases [4]. We now explore whether a tremor axis is identifiable in dystonia patients. Our current results show that an analysis of
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by NIH grant R01 NS073872.
References (6)
- et al.
Prevalence and features of unreported dystonia in a family study of “pure” essential tremor
Parkinsonism Relat Disord
(2013) - et al.
How to tackle tremor – systematic review of the literature and diagnostic work-up
Front Neurol
(2012) - et al.
Common misdiagnosis of a common neurological disorder: how are we misdiagnosing essential tremor?
Arch Neurol
(2006)
Cited by (33)
Looking for inconsistency: Combining distraction with spirography for diagnosis of functional tremor
2023, Journal of the Neurological SciencesELectronic Archimedes spiral Neural Network (ELANN)
2023, Parkinsonism and Related DisordersClinical features, pathophysiology, treatment, and controversies of tremor in dystonia
2022, Journal of the Neurological SciencesThe clinical and electrophysiological investigation of tremor
2022, Clinical NeurophysiologyThe spiral axis: A comparison of unaffected first-degree relatives of essential tremor cases vs. controls
2021, Journal of the Neurological SciencesCitation Excerpt :Additional examples are provided in Fig. 1 in Michalec et al. [2]). Based on the ratings of 4 spirals per enrollee, a spiral axis score (range = 0–4) [no single axis on all 4 spirals - a single axis on all 4 spirals] was assigned to each enrollee [2]. As detailed [14], 432 FD-ET were enrolled and after screening, we determined that there were 269 unaffected FD-ET; 237 of these had a complete set of spirals.
Focal limb dystonia and tremor: Clinical update
2020, ToxiconCitation Excerpt :Spiral drawing is another feature that can be used in clinic to differentiate ET from dystonia. ET spirals have a single identifiable tremor orientation axis whereas no single predominant axis stands out in dystonic tremor (Michalec et al., 2014). Pen pressure in dystonic tremor is higher and more variable compared to ET patients.