Changing conceptualizations of regression: What prospective studies reveal about the onset of autism spectrum disorder
Introduction
The onset of behavioral signs of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is usually conceptualized as occurring in one of two ways: an early onset pattern, in which children demonstrate delays and deviances in social and communication development early in life, and a regressive pattern, in which children develop largely as expected for some period and then experience a substantial decline in or loss of previously developed skills. While it was long believed that the majority of children with ASD demonstrated an early onset pattern, more recent studies suggest that regressive onset occurs more frequently than previously recognized (Brignell et al., 2017; Hansen et al., 2008; Kern et al., 2015; Pickles et al., 2009; Shumway et al., 2011; Thurm et al., 2014; for a review, see meta-analysis by Barger et al., 2013). Studies occasionally also identify a third onset pattern, that of developmental stagnation or plateau (Shumway et al., 2011), that is characterized by intact early skills that fail to progress or transform into more advanced developmental achievements. This onset pattern is distinct from regression, in that the child does not lose acquired skills, but instead fails to make expected gains.
The most common procedure for collecting information about the timing of early symptoms is retrospective parent report. A number of factors can influence report validity, including awareness of the child’s eventual diagnosis and knowledge of developmental milestones. It has long been understood that retrospective reports are subject to problems of memory and interpretation (Finney, 1981; Henry et al., 1994; Pickles et al., 1996), including in studies of ASD (Andrews et al., 2002). Multiple studies have documented the ways in which recall problems and other biases can influence parent report. Changes in recall occur over time, with past events often reported to occur more recently, closer to the time of recollection, than they actually took place, an error called forward telescoping (Loftus and Marburger, 1983). Studies of children with ASD have demonstrated significant forward telescoping in parent report of milestones, resulting in parents being less likely to report regression and more likely to report early delays as their children grow older (Hus et al., 2011; Lord et al., 2004). A recent study from our research team (Ozonoff et al., 2018a) conducted longitudinal interviews with parents about onset of ASD symptoms when their child was 2–3 years old (Time 1) and approximately 6 years old (Time 2). Significant forward telescoping was found in both age of regression and age when milestones were achieved. The correspondence between Time 1 and Time 2 parent report of onset was low (kappa = .38). One-quarter of the sample changed onset categories, most often due to parents not recalling a regression at Time 2 that they had reported at Time 1.
Analysis of home movies of children later diagnosed with ASD is another retrospective method used in research studies to study symptom emergence (Goldberg et al., 2008; Palomo et al., 2006). Video analysis may be a more objective procedure for documenting early symptoms than parent recall (Werner and Dawson, 2005) but it is labor-intensive and subject to other limitations, such as selective recording (e.g., tendency of parents to film positive behaviors). In a study from our team that compared classification of onset based on coding of family movies to onset type as recalled by parents (Ozonoff et al., 2011a), less than half of children whose home video displayed clear evidence of a major decline in social and communication behavior were reported to have had a regression by parents. Similarly, only 40% of participants with clear evidence of early delays and little evidence of skill decline on video were reported by parents to show an early onset pattern.
Questions about when and how behavioral signs of autism emerge may be better answered through prospective investigations, in which infants are recruited and enrolled near birth, prior to the advent of parent concerns, and then followed longitudinally through the window of developmental risk, until the age at which ASD can be confidently diagnosed or ruled out, usually 36 months. A few large general population cohorts have been studied prospectively to examine onset patterns (Brignell et al., 2017; Havdahl et al., 2018) but this study design is inefficient, since fewer than 2 in 100 participants will develop ASD (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2018), making it difficult to achieve an appropriate sample size. Additionally, large prospective cohort studies must, of necessity, rely upon parent questionnaires and rarely provide the opportunity for in-person clinical assessments to verify diagnosis or onset pattern.
For this reason, most prospective investigations utilize high-risk samples in order to increase the number of ASD outcomes that are informative for study. The most widely used high-risk group has been later-born siblings of children with ASD, who are known to be at higher ASD risk than the general population (Constantino et al., 2010). Most investigations compare high-risk infants to lower-risk participants with no known family history of ASD in first-, second-, and sometimes third-degree relatives. This study design improves on retrospective methods in a number of important ways. Serial comprehensive assessments, in standardized testing contexts, are used to document the timing of symptom emergence, thus avoiding reliance on potentially fallible parent recall or non-representative home video. Assessments can utilize a wide range of tools, including eye tracking, EEG, and imaging, allowing broader investigations of symptom onset and testing of specific hypotheses. And while most retrospective studies recruit samples through clinics, which may influence the results by including more severely affected children, infant sibling studies avoid such potential biases by ascertaining participants via family history alone.
Several recent papers provide comprehensive reviews of the infant sibling literature (Bölte et al., 2013; Jones et al., 2014; Pearson et al., 2018; Szatmari et al., 2016). Here we focus on research reports of greatest relevance to symptom emergence, specifically those that study infants beginning in the first year of life on measures that are appropriate for examining potential skill decline over time. Using a variety of different prospective methods, these studies have reported largely intact early development, followed by developmental declines and onset of symptoms around the first birthday and in the second year of life. For example, Zwaigenbaum et al. (2005), using the Autism Observation Scale for Infants (AOSI), reported no differences at 6 months between infants subsequently diagnosed with ASD and both high- and low-risk infants without ASD outcomes; significant group differences emerged at 12 months and increased over time. This pattern on the AOSI was later replicated by an independent research team (Gammer et al., 2015). Wan et al. (2013) found that infant-parent interaction quality at 6–10 months did not predict which children would be diagnosed with ASD at age 3, but by 12–15 months, such variables were significantly associated with diagnostic outcome. Similar findings of lack of early group differences (or lack of early predictive ability), followed by later divergence from typically developing infants, have been reported by Landa and Garrett-Mayer (2006) using the Mullen Scales of Early Learning, Rozga et al. (2011) in joint attention, Bedford et al. (2012) on a gaze-following eye-tracking task, Elsabbagh et al. (2013) on a gap-overlap attention task, and Wolff et al. (2014) studying repetitive behavior. In an incisive recent review that attempts to reconcile retrospective and prospective studies of regression and explore how study design affects the likelihood of capturing regression, Pearson et al. (2018) conclude that, among infants who later develop ASD, “the majority show declining fixation of eyes, gaze to faces, and social engagement, from typical levels in early infancy (2–6 months) to significantly reduced levels by 24–36 months (p. 14).”
Section snippets
Findings from the University of California Davis infant sibling study
In our laboratory, we have taken the analytic approach of growth curve modeling to examine directly the evidence of longitudinal developmental change in the first three years of life. Between 2003 and 2015, the UC Davis Infant Sibling Study recruited three cohorts of later-born siblings, each composed of 50 low-risk and 100 high-risk infants. Participants were tested as early as 6 months of age and then seen every 3 to 6 months until their 3rd birthday (up to 7 in-person evaluations). They have
Conclusions and theoretical implications
A number of conclusions can be drawn from the collective body of work reviewed in this paper.
Clinical implications
Finally, the studies reviewed here provide hope and promise for improvements in screening, early diagnosis, and treatment. Many prospective studies (e.g., Bosl et al., 2018; Jones and Klin, 2013; Ozonoff et al., 2010) used measures, such as behavioral coding, eye tracking, and EEG, that are expensive, labor intensive, and not practical for routine use. Studies reviewed in this paper, however, have demonstrated that prospective parent report can identify declining trajectories of development (
Conflict of interest
The authors have no competing interests to declare.
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by NIH grants R01 MH068398 (Ozonoff) and R01 MH099046 (Ozonoff). Thank you to Sofie Boterberg for her reading of an earlier version of this manuscript. We are deeply grateful to all the children and parents who participated in and showed sustained commitment to our longitudinal program of research.
References (81)
- et al.
Diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder: reconciling the syndrome, its diverse origins, and variation in expression
Lancet Neurol.
(2016) Editorial: coming closer to describing the variable onset patterns in autism
J. Am. Acad. Child Adolesc. Psychiatry
(2011)- et al.
Model-based hypothesis of gut microbe populations and gut-brain barrier permeability in the development of regressive autism
Med. Hypotheses
(2014) - et al.
Disengagement of visual attention in infancy is associated with emerging autism in toddlerhood
Biol. Psychiatry
(2013) - et al.
Behavioral markers for autism in infancy: Scores on the Autism Observational Scale for Infants in a prospective study of at-risk siblings
Infant Behav. Dev.
(2015) Genetics of autism spectrum disorders
Trends Cogn. Sci. (Regul. Ed.)
(2011)- et al.
Parental report of vaccine receipt in children with autism spectrum disorder: do rates differ by pattern of ASD onset?
Vaccine
(2016) - et al.
Head grown in Rett syndrome
Brain Dev.
(2001) - et al.
Regression in autism: prevalence and associated factors in the CHARGE study
Ambul. Pediatr.
(2008) - et al.
Developmental chronology of preverbal social behaviors in infancy using the M-CHAT: baseline for early detection of atypical social development
Res. Autism Spectr. Disord.
(2010)
Developmental pathways to autism: a review of prospective studies of infants at risk
Neurosci. Biobehav. Rev.
Prospective longitudinal studies of infant siblings of children with autism: lessons learned and future directions
J. Am. Acad. Child Adolesc. Psychiatry
Behavioral manifestations of autism in the first year of life
Int. J. Dev. Neurosci.
Recall bias, MMR, and autism
Arch. Diseases Childhood
Memory recall errors in retrospective surveys: a reverse record check study
Qual. Quant.
Commentary: the meaning of “regression” in children with autism spectrum disorder: why does it matter?
J. Dev. Behav. Pediatr.
Prevalence and onset of regression within autism spectrum disorders: a meta-analytic review
J. Autism Dev. Disord.
The relationship between regression in autism spectrum disorder, epilepsy, and atypical epileptiform EEGs: a meta-analytic review
J. Intellect. Dev. Disabil.
Precursors to social and communication difficulties in infants at-risk for autism: gaze following and attentional engagement
J. Autism Dev. Disord.
Infants at risk for autism: a European perspective on current status, challenges, and opportunities
Eur. Child Adolesc. Psychiatry
EEG analytics for early detection of autism spectrum disorder: a data-driven approach
Sci. Rep.
Regression in Autism Spectrum Disorder: Characteristics, Etiology, Early Development, and Outcomes – a Review of Retrospective Studies
The Clinical Contribution of Parent Reported Regression in Autism Spectrum Disorder: Characteristics, Early Development, and Later Outcomes
Parent-reported patterns of loss and gain in communication in 1- to 2-year-old children are not unique to autism spectrum disorder
Autism
Prevalence of autism spectrum disorder among children aged 8 years – autism and developmental disabilities monitoring network, 11 sites, United States, 2014
MMWR Surv. Summary
Sibling recurrence and the genetic epidemiology of autism
Am. J. Psychiatry
The Activity Kit for Babies and Toddlers at Risk: How to Use Everyday Routines to Build Social and Communication Skills
Improving the reliability of retrospective survey measures: results of a longitudinal field survey
Eval. Rev.
Gene disrupting mutations associated with regression in autism spectrum disorder
J. Autism Dev. Disord.
Use of home videotapes to confirm parental reports of regression in autism
J. Autism Dev. Disord.
Neurogenetic analysis of childhood disintegrative disorder
Mol. Autism
Genetic heritability and shared environmental factors among twin pairs with autism
Arch. Gen. Psychiatry
Loss of Social-communication Skills and Outcomes During Childhood in a Large General Population Cohort
On the “remembrance of things past.” A longitudinal evaluation of the retrospective method
Psychol. Assess.
Telescoping of caregiver report on the autism diagnostic interview-revised
J. Child Psychol. Psychiatry
Attention to eyes is present but in decline in 2 to 6 month old infants later diagnosed with autism
Nature
Autistic disturbances of affective contact
Nerv. Child
Evaluation of regression in autism spectrum disorder based on parental reports
N. Am. J. Med. Sci.
Modeling the functional genomics of autism using human neurons
Mol. Psychiatry
Development in infants with autism spectrum disorders: a prospective study
J. Child Psychol. Psychiatry
Cited by (86)
Gastrointestinal symptoms have a non-temporal association with regression in a cohort with autism spectrum disorder using the simons simplex collection
2024, Research in Autism Spectrum DisordersImpaired white matter integrity in infants and young children with autism spectrum disorder: What evidence does diffusion tensor imaging provide?
2023, Psychiatry Research - NeuroimagingPrototypical autism: New diagnostic criteria and asymmetrical bifurcation model
2023, Acta Psychologica