The role of the thalamus in schizophrenia from a neuroimaging perspective

Highlights

• We reviewed evidence on alterations of the thalamus associated with schizophrenia.

• The thalamus is involved in Schizophrenia, but the picture is complex.

• Anatomical parceling studies found consistent evidence on the mediodorsal nucleus.

• Studies on non-affected relatives preliminarily suggest thalamic endophenotypes.

• Imaging genetics relates thalamic alterations with a variety of molecular pathways.

Abstract

The thalamus is a crucial node for brain physiology and part of functional and structural pathways relevant for schizophrenia. Relatively few imaging studies on schizophrenia have focused on this brain region, yet extant evidence supports the association between this brain disorder and thalamic anomalies. Nevertheless, the mechanisms underlying this association remain largely conjectural. Here, we review imaging literature on the relationship between the thalamus and schizophrenia, focusing on critical challenges for future studies, in particular: (i) the anatomical and functional organization of the thalamus in separate nuclei, which are also differently connected with the cortex; (ii) state-dependent variables, which do not allow firm conclusions on the relevance of thalamic correlates as core phenotypes of schizophrenia and (iii) genetic variation, which affects thalamic physiology and may lead to variability of structural and functional patterns. Current evidence from the studies reviewed does not appear conclusive, although the relevance of thalamo-prefrontal interactions clearly emerges. Results from imaging genetics are beginning to cast insight on possible mechanisms of the involvement of the thalamus in schizophrenia.

Introduction

The thalamus is involved in the bidirectional flow of neuronal signals between cortical and subcortical regions, as well as between different cortical areas (Sherman and Guillery, 2006). Its role as a node of multiple brain pathways implicated in processing of sensorial inputs makes this brain region a critical hub for high-order cognition as well as for emotion processing. Cognitive and emotional abnormalities, together with anomalies in specific thalamo-cortical networks, characterize schizophrenia (Lindenmayer et al., 2007), a neurodevelopmental (Bertolino and Blasi, 2009, Harrison and Weinberger, 2005) and complex brain disorder associated with a strong genetic component (McGuffin et al., 2001). Indeed, current evidence suggests a role of the thalamus in schizophrenia. In this regard, the “cognitive dysmetria” model (Andreasen et al., 1998) proposed that abnormal function and structure of a critical network of brain regions including the prefrontal cortex (PFC), the thalamus, and the cerebellum contributes to the pathophysiology of this brain disorder. According to this model, compromised electrophysiological coordination of the thalamo-cortical connections would in turn be reflected in poor cognitive focus, e.g., impaired attention, and “cognitive dysmetria”, i.e. difficulty in coordinating information processing (Andreasen et al., 1998). Such a dysfunction is thought to underlie abnormalities in sensory experience and attribution, motor coordination, and neuropsychological function in patients with schizophrenia (SCZ). Another model of dysfunctional thalamo-cortical information processing in schizophrenia is known as the “filtering hypothesis” and is based on the evidence that some thalamic nuclei function as signal enhancers (“gating function” of the thalamus; Sherman and Guillery, 2006, Van der Werf et al., 2003a). Both the “cognitive dysmetria” and the “filtering” models assume a homogeneous functional architecture of the thalamus, which is challenged by current evidence on inhomogeneity of structure and function between thalamic nuclei. In spite of these theoretical efforts, it is still debated how exactly the thalamus contributes to schizophrenia. This topic becomes increasingly relevant while evidence accumulates that this brain region appears to carry a great amount of information in pattern classification analyses aimed to predict diagnostic variables in SCZ (Koutsouleris et al., 2012, Mourao-Miranda et al., 2012).

This article aims at evaluating how extant evidence and currently available models can detail the mechanisms of contribution of thalamic abnormalities to schizophrenia. In our view, three key points among others entangle attempts to investigate this issue. First, this brain region is parceled into separate nuclei with distinct functions and anatomical connections which contribute to integrating information across cognitive domains (Ahissar and Oram, 2013, Sherman, 2007). Therefore, investigations aimed at disentangling the contribution of specific thalamic nuclei and thalamo-cortical systems to schizophrenia are warranted. Second, it is unclear to what extent structural and functional alterations are associated with disease state or whether they are at the core of the pathophysiology of schizophrenia (Keedy et al., 2009, Sim et al., 2006). Given the confound introduced by state-dependent variables, investigation of healthy subjects at genetic risk for schizophrenia could be informative to identify thalamic trait phenotypes at the core of the illness. Third, genetic variability modulates modes of phenotypic expression of thalamic structure and function in different individuals. In this regard, it should be considered that risk for schizophrenia is likely explained by multiple genetic variants, each with small effect (McGuffin et al., 2001). Thus, it is crucial to understand how variability in genes putatively involved in the pathophysiology of schizophrenia concurs in determining thalamic function and structure. This approach also helps to conceive better founded hypotheses on the relationship between gene function and anomalous phenotypic expression in the thalamus.

In this review, we will first provide a reappraisal on the relationship between the thalamus and schizophrenia, which has been also well reviewed elsewhere (Alelu-Paz and Gimenez-Amaya, 2008, Pakkenberg et al., 2009). Then, we will use a neuroimaging perspective to highlight lines of investigation that have addressed the three points above mentioned. In particular, we will focus on approaches based on (i) parceling of structure and function of thalamic nuclei; (ii) investigation of thalamic structure and function in healthy subjects at high genetic risk for schizophrenia; (iii) investigation of the relationship between genetic variability and thalamic structure and function.