In-depth snapshot of the equine subgingival microbiome
Introduction
Horses are non-ruminant herbivores that possess two successive sets of teeth: the deciduous and permanent sets. The permanent dentition continually erupts to replace mineralized tissues lost on masticatory surfaces due to functional wear. Adult horses have 36–42 permanent teeth: 12 incisors (6 upper, 6 lower), 0–4 canine teeth, 12–16 premolars, and 12 molars [1]. The premolars and molars of horses are commonly referred to as ‘cheek teeth’, and are arranged in opposing sets of functional units known as arcades. Analogous to humans, horses can suffer from a variety of oral/dental diseases that have polymicrobial infectious etiologies; such as caries, endodontic or periapical infections, and periodontal disease [1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6]. Periodontal diseases such as periodontitis (in humans and animals) are results of host–parasitic interactions where the bacterial agents presented as dental plaque biofilm communities that inhabited niches below the gum-line, on the hard non-shedding tooth tissues. Upon disease initiation and progression, the bacterial composition of these subgingival plaque communities alters; promoting the proteolytic and inflammation-mediated destruction of the gum and tooth-supporting structures [7].
In humans, a variety of bacterial species (phylotypes) are commonly implicated in periodontal disease pathogenesis (reviewed in [7], [8], [9], [10], [11], [12]). Investigations over the past few decades have demonstrated that Porphyromonas gingivalis, Tannerella forsythia, Treponema denticola and Aggregatibacter actinomycetemcomitans commonly play major etiological roles, even though they may only constitute a fairly minor proportions of the total microbiota present [13], [14], [15], [16]. However, results from more recent 16S rRNA gene sequence-based analyses have revealed that many other bacterial taxa are also associated with human periodontal disease, including various phylotypes belonging to the genus Treponema; and the phyla Bacteroidetes, Firmicutes, Synergistetes and TM7 [12], [17], [18], [19], [20], [21], [22], [23], [24], [25], [26]. The etiology of periodontal disease in domesticated cats and dogs appears less well established. Members of the Treponema, Tannerella and Porphyromonas genera have been identified in oral (especially subgingival) niches, and represent potential ‘periodontal pathogens’ [27], [28], [29], [30], [31], [32], [33].
Dental diseases and disorders are notable health concerns for horses [1], [2]. Periodontal disease prevalence is estimated to be between 29% and 60%, which tends to increase with age [2], [3], [34], [35]. Equine periodontal infections are generally ‘secondary’ forms of periodontal disease, and occur predominantly in diastemata (spaces between adjacent teeth), especially those between cheek teeth. These sites are often subjected to chronic food impaction, which may result in physical trauma and bacterial accumulation, resulting in progressive inflammation-driven destruction of the underlying periodontal tissues [1].
In notable contrast to the situation for domestic cats and dogs [31], [33], [36], [37], [38], the oral microbiota of horse has been relatively poorly explored. The first investigation was reported in 1918, where Boyer used a culture-based method to study the species of bacteria normally present on the mucous membranes of a horse's mouth [39]. He noted that the majority of bacteria present were ‘rod-shaped’, and only one out of 43 observed organisms was gram-negative [39]. Nearly one century later, dos Santos et al. (2014) noted that the majority of bacterial isolates cultured from periodontal plaque samples were Staphylococcus spp., followed by Streptococcus spp. [40]. However, investigations performed over the past few decades or so have largely focused on microbes detectable on oral or upper respiratory tract mucosae, or those associated with bite-wounds [41], [42], [43], [44]. Particular emphasis has been placed on the presence and diversity of Actinobacillus spp., which are gram-negative members of the family Pasteurellaceae. These are considered to be commensal microbes of the oral cavity and gastrointestinal tract of horses [45], [46]. Most notably, many equine Actinobacillus isolates are with haemolytic abilities properties, due to the presence of the Actinobacillus equuli RTX (Aqx) protein, a secreted, pore-forming cytolysin that belongs to the RTX or repeat-in-toxin family [47]. Opportunistic infections can lead to an acute form of septicemia in foals, or can progress to chronic forms of diseases in the joints, kidneys and lungs. There are reports of this genus of bacteria causing infections in humans after horse bites [42], [43], [44]. Several members of the genus Fusobacterium have also been isolated within the oral cavity of horses; with their properties and phylogenies studied in some detail [48], [49]. These taxa have also been associated with equine diseases as well as other soft tissue infections in cats and dogs [41], [48], [49], [50].
Spirochetes (phylum Spirochaetes) constitute a diverse group of gram-negative, motile bacteria, with highly distinctive helical or flat-wave cell morphologies. Some are free-living aerobes (e.g. Leptospira spp.); but most are host-associated strict anaerobes, which are commensal or parasitic in nature [51], [52], [53]. Several individual spirochete species are notable pathogens in humans and animals, such as Treponema pallidum (the causative agent of syphilis), Leptospira interrogans (leptospirosis) and Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato (Lyme Borreliosis). Spirochetes belonging to the genus Treponema are strongly suspected of playing key roles in various diseases caused by chronic polymicrobial biofilm-associated infections. In addition to periodontal disease in humans (noted above) and dogs [29], treponemes have been implicated in the etiology of several tissue-destructive infections in ruminant livestock animals such as sheep [54], [55] and cows [56], [57], [58], [59] as well as non-ruminant pigs [60]. Spirochetes have been frequently reported in the bacterial communities from the gastrointestinal tract or faeces of horses ranging from 0.5% to 5% of the total microbiota [61], [62], [63], [64], [65], [66], among which only Treponema spp. were observed, which included Treponema brennaborense, Treponema parvum, Treponema porcinum, and Treponema saccharophilum [64].
Recently, there have been several investigations into the etiology and histopathology of diseases of the periodontium in horse, which have implicated treponeme bacteria. Cox et al. identified numerous cells with distinctive spirochete morphologies within silver-stained preparations of tissue samples obtained from various sites of periodontal infection (periodontal pockets) [67]. They further noted that these tissue samples exhibited many histopathological features that were typical of analogous periodontal infections in animals and humans; e.g. gingival hyperplasia, eroded gingival epithelia, degradation of periodontal attachment tissues, neutrophil infiltration, and degradation of the cementum. In another study, an Austrian research group investigated the histopathology and etiology of equine odontoclastic tooth resorption and hypercementosis (EOTRH) [68]. They used several targeted molecular approaches to analyse the Treponema, Tannerella and Porphyromonas spp. present in the gingival crevicular fluid sampled from both EOTRH-affected and disease-free horses. The levels of certain Treponema and Tannerella phylotypes were positively associated with EOTRH [68]. Outside the oral cavity, treponeme species have also been detected within canker lesions (a chronic and suppurative form of hypertrophic pododermatitis), which are polymicrobial infections of the frog, bar and sole of the horse's hoof [69], [70], [71], [72]. The respective studies reported treponeme taxa belonging to species/phylotypes previously detected in the oral cavity; e.g. Treponema medium, Treponema vincentii, T. denticola, Treponema putidum, Treponema lecithinolyticum, and Treponema pectinovorum; as well as others more commonly associated with animal soft tissue infections; e.g. Treponema refringens, Treponema phagedenis, and Treponema pedis. Such findings further triggered our interest to investigate whether such hoof/canker lesion-associated treponeme populations may reside within healthy gum niches in horses.
The earlier studies by this research group using primers (TPU1 and C90) that co-amplify Spirochaetes and Synergistetes 16S rRNA from human subgingival plaque DNA samples [25], [26] demonstrated the phylogenetic relationship between the two taxa. Interestingly, certain Synergistetes operational taxonomic units (OTUs)/clones detected in subgingival plaque, and the putative periodontopathogen T. denticola, were found to be significantly associated with human chronic periodontitis [25], [26]. Hence the present group investigated if such treponemes or Synergistetes co-existence can be observed in the subgingival niches of horses?
With respect to human Synergistetes, molecular investigations performed over the past 5–10 years have revealed that a diverse selection of Synergistetes phylotypes commonly reside within the human oral cavity [14], [26], [73], [74], [75]. Synergistetes populations are typically present in very low levels (often undetectable) in healthy human subgingival niches; however, their diversity and levels are greatly increased within diseased periodontal niches [12], [14], [21], [22], [23], [24], [26], [76], [77]. There are two principal clusters of human oral Synergistetes based on their phylogenetic origins, with the vast majority of these correspond to as-yet uncultivated phylotypes [22], [26], [73], [74], [75]. Cluster A is the larger group, comprising mainly uncultivated phylotypes with only one cultivated species Fretibacterium fastidiosum [78]. Cluster B is considerably smaller, but contains two cultivated species: Jonquetella anthropi [79] and Pyramidobacter piscolens [80]. Recently a novel genus and species Rarimicrobium hominis was isolated from various non-oral human clinical infections, which was phylogenetically-related to P. piscolens [81]. However, the corresponding situation in animals remains obscure. To the best of our knowledge, there are no reports of Synergistetes having been detected in the equine oral cavity.
Here we report the first in-depth molecular investigation of the bacteria that populate healthy subgingival niches in the horse oral cavity. Due to the possible etiological roles in equine periodontal diseases, as well as other oral infectious diseases and soft tissue infections, we focus on the populations of spirochetes detectable in the subgingival plaque. We also analyse Synergistetes taxa, to investigate whether this phylum inhabits healthy equine subgingival niches. Our data reveals that the communities of bacteria found below the gum-line in horses share similarities with those found in analogous regions in humans, as well as in domesticated cats and dogs. Furthermore, we note that equine oral spirochete populations are notably different to those commonly detected within non-oral soft tissue infections in horses and other animals.
Section snippets
Equine subgingival plaque sampling
Samples were collected from two recently euthanized adult horses (ca. 1–2 h post mortem) that were both determined to have good oral and periodontal health, after a thorough periodontal examination. The first subject was a pony (EQ1), and the other a former racehorse (EQ2). In brief, the gingivae were visually inspected by the clinical periodontist (WKL) to confirm absence of swelling and calculus deposition around teeth, which indicate possible gingivitis. This was followed by full mouth
Results and discussion
Here, we used a combination of 454 pyrosequencing and phylum-specific clone-based DNA sequencing approaches to survey the equine subgingival microbiome. Our main aim was to identify the bacterial species and phylotypes present within ‘healthy’ subgingival niches, and to compare this with taxa typically present in equivalent oral sites in humans, domesticated cats and dogs, as well as other animals. In particular, we were interested in the populations of Treponema and Synergistetes taxa present,
Conclusions
Here we provide the first detailed snapshot of the equine subgingival microbiome. Our pyrosequencing data reveals that diverse bacterial communities inhabit subgingival niches in horses; with taxa spanning 12 phyla. Putative ‘periodontopathogens’, such as Treponema, Synergistetes, Porphyromonas, Tannerella and TM7 taxa were present in low levels; indicative of good periodontal health. Treponema phylotypes belonging to human oral phylogroups 1–7 were present, as well as spirochetes that belonged
Conflict of interest and sources of funding statement
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interests. The work described in this paper was financially supported by the Infection and Immunology Strategic Research Theme, the University of Hong Kong (to RMW and WKL), substantially supported by a General Research Fund (GRF) grant from the Research Grants Council of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China (780713 to RMW); and was partially supported by Small Project Funding, and Seed Funding Programme for Basic Research grants
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to sincerely thank Dr. Christopher Riggs and Dr. Frank Low of the Hong Kong Jockey Club Equine Hospital, Sha Tin Racecourse, Sha Tin, N.T., Hong Kong SAR, China; for their assistance in the oral sampling of the two euthanized horses. The work described in this paper was financially supported by the Infection and Immunology Strategic Research Theme, the University of Hong Kong (to RMW and WKL), substantially supported by a General Research Fund (GRF) grant from the
References (100)
- et al.
A review of equine dental disorders
Vet. J.
(2005) - et al.
Prevalence of occlusal pulpar exposure in 110 equine cheek teeth with apical infections and idiopathic fractures
Vet. J.
(2008) - et al.
Chapter 10, Equine dental pathology
A new understanding of oral and dental pathology of the equine cheek teeth
Vet. Clin. N. Am. Equine Pract.
(2013)- et al.
The relationship of the oral microbiotia to periodontal health and disease
Cell Host Microbe
(2011) The oral microbiome in health and disease
Pharmacol. Res.
(2013)- et al.
Pigmented-anaerobic bacteria associated with canine periodontitis
Vet. Microbiol.
(2005) - et al.
Association of Treponema spp. with canine periodontitis
Vet. Microbiol.
(2008) - et al.
Comparison of periodontal pathogens between cats and their owners
Vet. Microbiol.
(2010) - et al.
Distribution of periodontopathic bacterial species in dogs and their owners
Arch. Oral Biol.
(2012)
The feline oral microbiome: a provisional 16S rRNA gene based taxonomy with full-length reference sequences
Vet. Microbiol.
Pathophysiology of acquired dental diseases of the horse
Vet. Clin. N. Am. Equine Pract.
Characterization of the oral microbiota of healthy cats using next-generation sequencing
Vet. J.
Oral associated bacterial infection in horses: studies on the normal anaerobic flora from the pharyngeal tonsillar surface and its association with lower respiratory tract and paraoral infections
Vet. Microbiol.
Microbiology and management of human and animal bite wound infections
Prim. Care Clin. Off. Pract.
Host cell specific activity of RTX toxins from haemolytic Actinobacillus equuli and Actinobacillus Suis
Vet. Microbiol.
Fusobacterium canifelinum sp. nov., from the oral cavity of cats and dogs
Syst. Appl. Microbiol.
Taxonomy of spirochetes
Anaerobe
Characterisation of Dichelobacter nodosus and detection of Fusobacterium necrophorum and Treponema spp. in sheep with different clinical manifestations of footrot
Vet. Microbiol.
Three unique groups of spirochetes isolated from digital dermatitis lesions in UK cattle
Vet. Microbiol.
Identification of candidate pathogens of papillomatous digital dermatitis in dairy cattle from quantitative 16S rRNA clonal analysis
Vet. Microbiol.
Host and environmental reservoirs of infection for bovine digital dermatitis treponemes
Vet. Microbiol.
Occurrence of Treponema spp. in porcine skin ulcers and gingiva
Vet. Microbiol.
Histopathological lesions associated with equine periodontal disease
Vet. J.
The division “Synergistes”
Anaerobe
Phylogeny, diversity and host specialization in the phylum Synergistetes with emphasis on strains and clones of human origin
Res. Microbiol.
The obligate and facultatively anaerobic bacterial flora of the normal feline gingival margin
Vet. Microbiol.
Identification of bacteria associated with feline chronic gingivostomatitis using culture-dependent and culture-independent methods
Vet. Microbiol.
Revised definition of Actinobacillus sensu stricto isolated from animals. A review with special emphasis on diagnosis
Vet. Microbiol.
Some aspects of equine dental disease
Equine Vet. J.
Equine dental disease Part 4: a long-term study of 400 cases: apical infections of cheek teeth
Equine Vet. J.
Periodontitis: a polymicrobial disruption of host homeostasis
Nat. Rev. Microbiol.
Evidence of bacterial etiology: a historical perspective
Periodontol. 2000
Lessons learned and unlearned in periodontal microbiology
Periodontol. 2000
Newly identified pathogens associated with periodontitis: a systematic review
J. Dent. Res.
Microbial complexes in subgingival plaque
J. Clin. Periodontol.
Bacterial diversity in human subgingival plaque
J. Bacteriol.
Porphyromonas gingivalis, Treponema denticola, and Tannerella forsythia: the ‘red complex’, a prototype polybacterial pathogenic consortium in periodontitis
Periodontol. 2000
Prevalence and distribution of principal periodontal pathogens worldwide
J. Clin. Periodontol.
Association of Bacteroides forsythus and a novel Bacteroides phylotype with periodontitis
J. Clin. Microbiol.
Prevalence of bacteria of division TM7 in human subgingival plaque and their association with disease
Appl. Environ. Microbiol.
Molecular analysis of bacteria in periodontitis: evaluation of clone libraries, novel phylotypes and putative pathogens
Microbiology
New bacterial species associated with chronic periodontitis
J. Dent. Res.
Comparisons of subgingival microbial profiles of refractory periodontitis, severe periodontitis, and periodontal health using the human oral microbe identification microarray
J. Periodontol.
Diversity and morphology of members of the phylum “Synergistetes” in periodontal health and disease
Appl. Environ. Microbiol.
Distinct and complex bacterial profiles in human periodontitis and health revealed by 16S pyrosequencing
ISME J.
The subgingival microbiome in health and periodontitis and its relationship with community biomass and inflammation
ISME J.
Comparative analysis of oral treponemes associated with periodontal health and disease
BMC Infect. Dis.
Prevalence and diversity of Synergistetes taxa in periodontal health and disease
J. Periodontal Res.
Cultivable oral microbiota of domestic dogs
J. Clin. Microbiol.
Cited by (22)
Metagenomic Analysis Reveals A Possible Association Between Respiratory Infection and Periodontitis
2022, Genomics, Proteomics and BioinformaticsCitation Excerpt :Synergistetes is another significantly enriched phylum playing a role in increasing pocket depth, inflammation, anaerobiosis, and gingival tissue destruction [33]. Species members Fretibacterium fastidiosum, Desulfobulbus sp. oral taxon 041, and Bacteroidetes bacterium oral taxon 272, which were significantly enriched in our periodontitis patients, have been reported to be significantly associated with periodontitis [33–35]. Several eggNOG terms associated with drug-resistance and bacteria virulence were found to be significantly enriched in periodontitis patients.
Dysbiosis and Predicted Functions of the Dental Biofilm of Dairy Goats with Periodontitis
2023, Microbial EcologyDysbiosis and predicted function of dental and ruminal microbiome associated with bovine periodontitis
2022, Frontiers in Microbiology
- 1
These authors contributed equally on this manuscript.
- 2
Present Addresses: Department of Oral Radiology and State Key Laboratory of Oral Diseases, West China College of Stomatology, Sichuan University, Chengdu 610041, China.
- 3
Present Addresses: School of Applied Sciences, Faculty of Health and Environmental Sciences, Auckland University of Technology, Private Bag 92006, Auckland 1142, New Zealand.