Interventions for enhancing adherence with physiotherapy: A systematic review

Abstract

Poor adherence to treatment is commonplace and may adversely affect outcomes, efficiency and healthcare cost. The aim of this systematic review was to identify strategies to improve adherence with musculoskeletal outpatient treatment. Five suitable studies were identified which provided moderate evidence that a motivational cognitive–behavioural (CB) programme can improve attendance at exercise-based clinic sessions. There was conflicting evidence that adherence interventions increase short-term adherence with exercise. There was strong evidence that adherence strategies are not effective at improving long-term adherence with home exercise. Due to the multi-dimensional nature of non-adherence, the strategies to improve adherence with physiotherapy treatment are likely to be broad in spectrum. Combined interventions may be effective at promoting adherence with clinic appointments and exercise, though further research would be required to confirm this. Further research to increase basic understanding of the factors, which act as a barrier to adherence, could facilitate development of strategies to overcome non-adherence.

Introduction

Conservative interventions such as manual therapy, education, advice and exercise are considered to be effective ways of managing a variety of musculoskeletal conditions including back pain (Airaksinen et al., 2006), neck pain (Hurwitz et al., 2008) and hip and knee pain (Zhang et al., 2008). However, randomised controlled trials (RCTs) often indicate that the effect size of these interventions is small (Dziedzic et al., 2005, Roddy et al., 2005, Ferreira et al., 2007). These small effect sizes may, in part, be related to non-adherence with treatment, rather than poor treatment efficacy (Gohner and Schlicht, 2006) since adherence with treatment may influence the outcome of that treatment (Vermeire et al., 2001, Hayden et al., 2005).

Adherence has been defined as “the extent to which a person’s behaviour…. corresponds with agreed recommendations from a healthcare provider” (WHO, 2003). Poor treatment adherence is a problem across a number of healthcare disciplines including physiotherapy (Vasey, 1990, Friedrich et al., 1998, Campbell et al., 2001). Within physiotherapy, the concept of adherence is multi-dimensional (Kolt et al., 2007) and could relate to attendance at appointments, following advice or undertaking prescribed exercises. Studies suggest that non-adherence with treatment and exercise could be as high as 70% (Sluijs et al., 1993) and may be particularly poor for unsupervised home exercise programmes (Reilly et al., 1989, Nelson et al., 1995). Another study found that around 14% of physiotherapy patients did not return for follow-up outpatient appointments (Vasey, 1990). Given the potential impact of non-adherence on treatment outcome, strategies which aim to optimise treatment adherence are required for clinical practice.

The aim of this systematic review is to identify strategies which improve adherence with musculoskeletal outpatient treatment.