Choir Singers Without Rehearsals and Concerts? A Questionnaire Study on Perceived Losses From Restricting Choral Singing During the Covid-19 Pandemic

doi:10.1016/j.jvoice.2020.11.006

Journal of Voice

Volume 37, Issue 1, January 2023, Pages 146.e19-146.e27

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvoice.2020.11.006 Get rights and content

Summary

Background

Choir singing is an activity that engages individuals all over the world with a broad demographic representation. Both qualitative and quantitative studies have examined the benefits of the activity but very few have examined the effects when someone loses access to it and stops singing.

Objectives

Examining the governmental and organisational responses precipitated by the COVID-19 pandemic, we asked what happens when a choir singer loses all of their routines associated with regular participation in choir singing.

Materials and Methods

One national choir organization in Sweden (n = 3163) and one in Norway (n = 1881) were approached with a short survey. This comprised questions relating to the issue “what do you as a choir singer misses the most?” Each participant was asked to rate the importance of a number of elements that pertain to the experience of choir singing.

Results

The social aspect of singing emerged as having the strongest weight in terms of perceived loss that is, it was the element that the participants missed the most. Professional singers report that they miss the aesthetic experiences, flow, and all the physical aspects (physical training, voice training, and breathing training) to a greater degree as compared to reports from the amateurs. The importance of aesthetic experiences and physical components appeared to rise with increasing number of years that an individual had engaged with choir singing.

Conclusion

In the Scandinavian setting, the social aspect has a stronger weight than the other components and this seemed to be more significant in Norway compared to Sweden.

Section snippets

INTRODUCTION

Choir singing is a popular activity in many countries. This activity engages individuals with wide representation (age, gender, education, and religion). Several qualitative studies have examined the perceived benefits of choir singing.1, 2, 3, 4 Patients with specific medical conditions such as mental illness⁵ and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease⁶ have been reported to benefit from participating in choir singing, but choir singing also has a more general role in public health.

Presently,

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The two national choir organizations in Sweden and Norway were approached. Church choirs organized by the Swedish (previous) State Church were not included. The participating organizations have mixed member lists, of individual choir singers and of whole choirs whose leaders received the electronic questionnaire. The questionnaire first of all contained questions about demographics (age, gender, number of years as choir singer, amateur/professional status, genre [Classical music, gospel, Jazz,

RESULTS

There were altogether 3163 Swedish and 1881 Norwegian participants (Table 1). A total of 51% of the Swedish and 77% of the Norwegian participants reported a mixture of genres. A total of 31% of the Swedish and 14% of the Norwegian participants reported classical music, while 7% of the Swedish and 2% of the Norwegians reported gospel. Pop was reported by 5% of the Swedish and 3% of the Norwegian participants.

There was female dominance, in Sweden 20% men versus 80% women and in Norway 29% men and

DISCUSSION

The findings in the present study show that in the Scandinavian setting the social aspect has a stronger weight than the other components and this seems to be particularly true in Norway compared to Sweden. Professional singers report that they miss the aesthetic experiences, flow and all the physical aspects (physical training, voice training, and breathing training) more than the amateurs. The importance of aesthetic experiences and physical components rises with increasing number of years

CONCLUSIONS

In this Scandinavian choir setting the social aspect has a stronger weight than the other components on perception of loss during the changes to choral singer routines in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. Professional singers report that they miss the aesthetic experiences, flow, and all the physical aspects of choral singers more than amateurs do. The importance of aesthetic experiences and physical components rises with increasing number of years that an individual has engaged in choir

Acknowledgments

Many thanks to Karin Eklundh (Director of the Swedish Choir Association) and Åsmund Maehle (Director of the Norwegian Choir Association) for their invaluable and crusal support during the study period. Without their support with data collection, the study would not have been possible.

References (25)

S.W. Porges
The polyvagal perspective
Biolog Psychol
(2007)
J. Sundberg et al.
Voice source effects of diaphragmatic activity in singing
J Phonetics
(1986)
S.M. Clift et al.
Choral singing and psychological wellbeing: quantitative and qualitative findings from English choirs in a cross- national survey
J Appl Arts Health
(2010)
S.M. Clift
Singing, wellbeing, and health
A.H. Balsnes
Singing for a better life: choral singing and public health
G. Cohen
New theories and research findings on the positive influence of music and art on health with ageing
Arts & Health
(2009)
E. Williams et al.
A systematic review of mental health and wellbeing outcomes of group singing for adults with a mental health condition
Eur J Public Health
(2018)
A. Skingley et al.
Community singing groups for people with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Participant Perspectives
(2018)
C. Grape et al.
Does singing promote well-being? An empirical study of professional and amateur singers during a singing 527 lesson
Integr Physiol Behav Sci
(2003)
Y. Ooishi et al.
Increase in salivary oxytocin and decrease in salivary cortisol after listening to relaxing slow-tempo and exciting fast-tempo music
PLoS One
(2017)

G. Kreutz

Does singing facilitate social bonding?

Music and Medicine

(2014)

M. Schladt, G. C. Nordmann, R. Emilius, et al. Choir versus solo singing: effects on mood, and salivary oxytocin and...

Cited by (17)

Vocal Health Assessment of Professional Performers Returning to the Stage After the COVID-19 Pandemic Shutdown
2024, Journal of Voice
This study assessed the vocal health of performers returning to full-time performance after the COVID-19 pandemic shutdown and investigated how differences in voice usage, exposure to voice care professionals, and vocal pathology before and during the pandemic contributed to variability in self-perceived and instrumental vocal outcome measures.
This was a prospective, case-control observational study conducted at a single outpatient site.
Twenty-two patients, 11 cases and 11 controls, were enrolled for the study. All participants were full-time singing professionals prior to the COVID-19 pandemic. Cases were recruited from patients presenting to a tertiary care voice center for vocal or pharyngeal complaints. Controls were healthy volunteers recruited from the general population of professional singers in the surrounding metropolitan area. All participants provided responses to the Voice Handicap Index-10, Evaluation of Ability to Sing Easily, and Laryngopharyngeal Measure of Perceived Sensation validated questionnaires as well as a study survey with questions regarding vocal use and history prior to and during the pandemic. All participants underwent instrumental acoustic and videostroboscopic voice evaluations.
Cases had poorer outcome measures overall and were more likely to report their voices were worse at study enrollment when compared to their prepandemic perception (P = 0.027). Cases tended to be older and less likely to have pursued alternative employment during the pandemic that involved increased speaking voice use (27% vs 55%), but these differences were not statistically significant.
There was a variable response among performers to the prolonged hiatus from performing during the COVID-19 pandemic. Those with poorer outcomes tended to be older and may have used their voice less during the pandemic. These findings are consistent with detraining periods in the exercise physiology literature and support the construct of treating vocal performers as vocal athletes.
Challenges and opportunities experienced by performing artists during COVID-19 lockdown: Scoping review
2022, Social Sciences and Humanities Open
This scoping review synthesises published literature on the experiences of professional and amateur performing artists during COVID-19 and their perceptions of the challenges and opportunities faced. Six electronic databases were searched for published English-language articles containing primary data on this topic; twenty-one studies were reviewed. Themes included loss of work, financial impact, concerns about the future, psychological wellbeing, social connections, continuing creative pursuits, and inequalities. Participants reported both detrimental psychological effects of lockdown such as anxiety and sleep problems and positive effects including reduced stress and enjoyment of having more free time. Most continued creative pursuits throughout lockdown, most commonly shifting to online platforms. However, many barriers to creative pursuits were reported, including lack of technological expertise or equipment. Concerns were raised about inequality, in particular racial disparities in the financial impact of the pandemic and additional pressures faced by performers with disabilities; with insufficient funds to afford the equipment needed to shift to remote performing; and with additional caring responsibilities. It is important that performing artists have access to peer support; that education on digital technologies is incorporated into future performing arts education; and that inequities are addressed to ensure the needs of diverse communities are met.
How Safe is Singing Under Pandemic Conditions? - CO<inf>2</inf>-Measurements as Simple Method for Risk Estimation During Choir Rehearsals
2022, Journal of Voice
The SARS-CoV-2 pandemic has forced choirs to pause or at least to restrict rehearsals and concerts. Nevertheless, an uncertainty about the risks of infection while singing remains, especially with regard to distances, duration of singing, number of singers and their positions in the room, size of the room as well as ventilation strategies. Based on the assumption that CO $_{2}$ is a suitable indicator for the exhaled aerosols in a room, it is the aim of this study to deduce recommendations for a choir rehearsal with a minimum risk of infection.
During two choir rehearsals in a typical, nonventilated classroom, we installed 30 CO $_{2}$ sensors, which allow spatial and temporal evaluation of the CO $_{2}$ dispersion during singing. Various singing and ventilation phases were applied and the rates of CO $_{2}$ increase during singing as well as its decrease during ventilation phases were evaluated and compared for different scenarios.
The measurements reveal a linear relation between the duration of singing, size of the room and number of persons. For our size of the room of 200 m $^{3}$ the average CO $_{2}$ increase is 1.83 ppm/min per person. Masks or pure breathing without singing do - in contrast to aerosol dispersion - not influence the rate of CO $_{2}$ increase. CO $_{2}$ disperses fast and homogeneously on horizontal planes. However, a vertical layering with a maximum CO $_{2}$ concentration is observed near the ceiling. Shock ventilation shows the largest CO $_{2}$ decrease within the first 5 min, after 10 min of ventilation the outside base concentration of 400 ppm is reached again.
The evaluated relations allow to calculate safe singing times for a defined number of singers and size of the room until a critical threshold of 800 ppm is reached. Furthermore, in order to monitor the actual CO $_{2}$ concentration during choir rehearsal, just one CO $_{2}$ sensor is representative for the air quality and CO $_{2}$ concentration of the whole room and thus considered sufficient. For an early warning, it should be installed near the ceiling. Direct singing into a sensor should be avoided. A ventilation time of just 5 min is recommended which represents a compromise between strong CO $_{2}$ reduction and still sufficient room temperature during winter time.
Aerosol Dispersion During Different Phonatory Tasks in Amateur Singers
2021, Journal of Voice
Citation Excerpt :
Because of the prohibition of singing, many amateur singers feel very restricted concerning their communicative scope. For many of the amateur singers, singing represents an essential part of their social and psychological living conditions.26,36 Therefore, it appears important to examine if the collected data from professional singers is transferable to amateur singers.
Due to increased aerosol generation during singing, choir rehearsals were widely prohibited in the course of the CoVID-19 pandemic. Most studies on aerosol generation and dispersion focus on professional singers. However, it has not been clarified if these data are also representative for amateur singers.
Nine non-professional singers (four male, five female) were asked to perform five tasks; speaking (T+), singing a text softly (MT-) and loudly (MT+), singing on the vowel [ə] (M+) and singing with a N95 mask (MT+N95). Before performing the tasks, the singers were asked to inhale 0.5 L vapor produced by an e-cigarette consisting of the basic liquid. The spread of the exhaled vapor was recorded in all three dimensions by high-definition cameras and the impulse dispersion was detected as a function of time.
Regarding the median dispersion to the front, all tasks showed comparable distances from 0.69 m to 0.82 m at the end of the tasks. However, the maximum aerosol dispersion showed a larger variety among different subjects or tasks, respectively. Especially in the M+ task a maximum distance of 1.96 m to the front was reached by a single subject. Although singing with a N95 mask resulted in a slightly increased median dispersion to the front, the maximum dispersion was decreased from 1.47 m (MT+) to 1.04 m (MT+N95).
The maximum dispersion distance to the front of 1.96 m at the end of the M+ task and 1.47 m at the end of the MT+ task showed higher values in comparison to professional singers. Differences in phonation, articulation and mouth opening could lead to greater impulse dispersion. Singing in loud phonation with a N95 mask reduced the maximum impulse dispersion to the front to 1.04 m. Taking all results into consideration, a slightly larger safety distance should be necessary for non-professional singers.
How Australian singers experienced disruption to choir participation caused by pandemic lockdowns: A thematic analysis
2024, Psychology of Music
Distance learning and contemporary music education in China
2024, Education and Information Technologies

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Choir Singers Without Rehearsals and Concerts? A Questionnaire Study on Perceived Losses From Restricting Choral Singing During the Covid-19 Pandemic

Summary

Background

Objectives

Materials and Methods

Results

Conclusion

Section snippets

INTRODUCTION

MATERIALS AND METHODS

RESULTS

DISCUSSION

CONCLUSIONS

Acknowledgments

Biolog Psychol

J Phonetics

Choral singing and psychological wellbeing: quantitative and qualitative findings from English choirs in a cross- national survey

J Appl Arts Health

Singing, wellbeing, and health

Singing for a better life: choral singing and public health

New theories and research findings on the positive influence of music and art on health with ageing

Arts & Health

A systematic review of mental health and wellbeing outcomes of group singing for adults with a mental health condition

Eur J Public Health

Community singing groups for people with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease

Participant Perspectives

Does singing promote well-being? An empirical study of professional and amateur singers during a singing 527 lesson

Integr Physiol Behav Sci

Increase in salivary oxytocin and decrease in salivary cortisol after listening to relaxing slow-tempo and exciting fast-tempo music

PLoS One

Does singing facilitate social bonding?

Music and Medicine