Association for Academic Surgery
Laparoscopic Versus Open Appendectomy in Children: Outcomes Comparison Based on a Statewide Analysis

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jss.2009.06.033Get rights and content

Background

To compare the differences in hospital utilization and complications between laparoscopic (LA) and open appendectomy (OA) for pediatric appendicitis.

Methods

A retrospective study from 1999 to 2006 of children aged 1 to 18 y with appendicitis, from the California Patient Discharge Database was performed. Children with significant comorbidities were excluded. Initial hospital course, subsequent readmissions, and the need for additional procedures were analyzed.

Results

The use of LA increased steadily from 19% in 1999 to 52% in 2006. Overall, 95,806 children were studied. Readmissions were tracked over a median period of 3 y. LA was associated with increased need for postoperative intra-abdominal abscess drainage for both perforated appendicitis (4.9% versus 3.8%, P < 0.001) and nonperforated appendicitis (0.6% versus 0.3%, P < 0.001) compared with OA. Multivariate regression showed an increased risk of postoperative abscess drainage for children after LA compared with OA (RR 1.81, 99% CI 1.41–2.27). However, the lengths of readmission hospitalizations were the same between the two groups (5.8 versus 5.7 d, P = NS).

Conclusion

LA has become the preferred operation for pediatric appendicitis. The need for postoperative abscess drainage is small, and laparoscopy appears to increase this risk slightly. However, LA did not affect long-term hospital utilizations.

Introduction

Appendicitis is one of the most common surgical emergencies in childhood. Its incidence peaks between the ages of 11 to 12 y, and has a lifetime risk of 7% to 9% [1]. Open appendectomy (OA), first reported by McBurney in 1894, has become the gold standard treatment for appendicitis [2]. The operation remained virtually unchanged for 100 years owing to its proven efficacy and safety [3]. Nonetheless, since Semm performed the first laparoscopic appendectomy (LA) in 1983, this approach had gained popularity in the treatment of appendicitis over the last 20 y 4, 5.

There remains a wide variation in the utilization of LA among pediatric surgeons 6, 7. While some studies have reported increased risk of postoperative complications with the use of LA in general, recent studies in the pediatric population were unable to confirm these findings 3, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16. Because of the small sample size in a handful of randomized clinical trials, and possible heterogeneity in meta-analyses, a clear consensus of the relative advantages of each procedure has not yet been reached [9].

The aims of this study are to assess the current use of laparoscopy for the treatment of pediatric appendicitis and to compare the long-term outcomes and hospital utilization between children undergoing LA and OA by analyzing longitudinal data from a statewide population perspective.

Section snippets

Methods

This retrospective cohort study was performed after obtaining IRB approvals from both University of California, Los Angeles and the Office of Statewide Health Planning Development (OSHPD) in California. Data were obtained from the California Patient Discharge Database (CaPDD). The CaPDD collects annual data of all inpatients discharged from non-federal hospitals licensed in California. A discharge abstract is reported for each inpatient hospitalization and includes: patient demographics,

Results

There were 105,914 children with appendicitis who were extracted from the CaPDD between 1999 and 2006. After exclusion, 95,806 children remained in the final patient cohort for analysis. These children were treated at 386 different California hospitals with an average annual volume of 32 ± 45 cases per year (range 1–441 cases per year). Approximately one in five children was treated at one of the 16 designated children's hospitals (19%). Overall, the rate of LA was 34%, and it increased

Discussion

From this large population-based cohort of pediatric appendectomy patients, we found that the use of LA increased dramatically from 1999 to 2006 in California. The use of LA had risen 2.8-fold from 18.6% in 1999 to 52.4% in 2006, and has increased at similar rates for both perforated and nonperforated appendicitis. The laparoscopic approach is now the most prevalent technique for pediatric appendectomy.

Early in the laparoscopic experience, Horwitz et al. demonstrated an increased risk of

References (25)

  • K. Semm

    Endoscopic appendectomy

    Endoscopy

    (1983)
  • S. Sauerland et al.

    Laparoscopic versus open surgery for suspected appendicitis

    Cochrane Database Syst Rev

    (2004)
  • Cited by (78)

    • My tummy! Appendicitis

      2021, Pediatric Imaging for the Emergency Provider
    • Pediatric Appendicitis–Factors Associated With Surgical Approach, Complications, and Readmission

      2020, Journal of Surgical Research
      Citation Excerpt :

      Since then, laparoscopic approach has been more frequently used for the management of appendicitis.3,4 Whether it is more likely to result in intraabdominal abscess is controversial,3,5-13 but laparoscopic appendectomy is generally considered a safe and effective approach,11,12,14-16 and is currently the preferred surgical approach for children with appendicitis, as it has advantages of shorter hospitalization, fewer wound complications, earlier return to normal activities, better cosmesis, more effective lavage and better visualization of the peritoneal cavity.15,16 Some of recent studies have suggested that pediatric appendicitis could be safely managed by general surgeons, but general surgeons appear to perform open appendectomy more commonly in this population.17-19

    • Occurrence and treatment of pediatric appendicitis in Finland 2004-2014

      2018, Journal of Surgical Research
      Citation Excerpt :

      It seems that transformation to new technology has not been rapid in Finnish pediatric surgical centers. In comparison, studies from other countries have reported laparoscopic appendectomies becoming more common than open appendectomies with 52-75% of the children with appendicitis being operated laparoscopically.11-13 In our study, laparoscopic appendectomies in children were more often used in non-university hospitals, where adult gastric surgeons are used to performing laparoscopic operations in their daily practice.

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text