Review article
Cognitive rehabilitation in patients with traumatic brain injury: A narrative review on the emerging use of virtual reality

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jocn.2018.12.020Get rights and content

Highlights

  • About 10% of TBI patients have a severe brain damage with severe motor and cognitive dysfunctions.

  • New cognitive interventions, including VR training, can be useful in TBI.

  • VR creates a positive, motivating and enjoyable learning experience for the TBI patients.

Abstract

Traumatic brain injury (TBI) is a clinical condition characterized by brain damage due to an external, rapid and violent force. TBI causes attention, memory, affectivity, behaviour, planning, and executive dysfunctions, with a significant impact on the quality of life of the patient and of his/her family. Cognitive and motor rehabilitation programs are essential for clinical recovery of TBI patients, improving functional outcomes and the quality of life. Various researches have underlined the possible effectiveness of innovative techniques, with regard to virtual reality (VR), during the different phases of rehabilitation after TBI. This review aims to evaluate the role of VR tools in cognitive assessment and rehabilitation in individuals affected by TBI. Studies performed between 2010 and 2017 and fulfilling the selected criteria were found on PubMed, Scopus, Cochrane and Web of Sciences databases. The search combined the terms VR, assessment, rehabilitation and TBI. Our review has shown that VR has the potential to provide an effective assessment and rehabilitation tool for the treatment of cognitive and behavioral impairment on TBI patients.

Introduction

Traumatic brain injury (TBI) is a clinical condition characterized by brain damage due to an external, rapid and violent force. The injury can lead to an increased or altered state of consciousness, with impaired cognitive, neuro-somatic and emotional-behavioural functions. Following a TBI, about 70% of cases present with a mild brain injury (i.e. the patient can be conscious and oriented or slightly confused and disoriented, without any focal neurological lesions). In 10–12% of cases, instead, there are moderate injuries as a result of which the patient becomes unconscious and can be affected by personality change, headache, epileptic attack and mydriasis. Finally, in up to 10% of cases, there is a severe damage with a global dysfunction. The prevalence of TBI in the overall population is 12–16.7% in males and 8.5% in females [1]. TBI rarely causes focal and circumscribed damage, the patients usually undergo widespread lesions, and an “integrated and holistic” treatment and a diagnosis are needed, especially in young people (TBI mostly occur between 15 and 30 years) [2]. The cognitive impairment is due to both the focal/diffuse lesions due to the impact and secondary damage following possible complications, such as hypoxia and intracranial hypertension. The brain areas most involved in TBI are the frontal and temporal lobes, especially in the basal areas and in the subcortical white matter. This causes attention, memory, affectivity, behaviour, planning, and executive dysfunctions, with a significant impact on the quality of life of the patient and of his/her family [3], [4]. To define a rehabilitative program, diagnosis and prognosis are fundamental to get a realistic evaluation of the possible functional recovery, also concerning social and work reintegration. Cognitive and motor rehabilitation programs are essential for clinical recovery of TBI patients, improving functional outcomes and the quality of life. These strategies are based on reparative, compensatory strategies and adapt to the patient's resources and disability. TBI induces both injurious and neuro-regenerative response including angiogenesis, neurogenesis and brain plasticity [5]. These spontaneous regeneration mechanisms are short-lived and too weak to contrast the worsening of the damage, but new therapeutic strategies could stimulate and boost such mechanisms. In fact, physical and cognitive exercise may increase the process of brain repair and plasticity after the lesions [6], [7]. For this reason, it would be useful to implement rehabilitation interventions, stimulating specific sensory or motor neuronal circuits, considering the kind and the level of injury and the level of motor and cognitive disabilities [8], [9]. Various researches have underlined the possible effectiveness of innovative techniques, with regard to virtual reality (VR), during the different phases of rehabilitation after TBI [10], [11], [12]. VR consists of an interactive and virtual environment the patient can interact with, created by computer graphics and with different degrees of immersive sensations [12]. VR can offer real and ecological demands of the real world (i.e. finding objects, carrying out actions and buying things) that can improve brain plasticity and regenerative processes [12], [14], [15], [16]. VR has been used in the motor and cognitive rehabilitation of different pathologies, with good results obtained thanks to the flexibility, the sense of presence (i.e. the feeling of “being there”) and the emotional involvement it gives to the patient [13]. Indeed, VR allows a sense of global well-being, thanks to the stimulation of multiple perceptual channels, implemented by the use of auditory and visual feedback, which stimulate the patient's awareness of his performance. Finally, the playful environment allows increasing the patient's compliance, amplifying the effects of the rehabilitation treatment itself, which can also be customized according to the actual needs of the subject [17], [18]. All together, these are the reasons why this new technology, may have advantages in the treatment patients affected by TBI. In fact, TBI leads to very heterogeneous symptoms and clinical manifestations (especially frontal lobe dysfunction) with a significant negative impact on daily life.

This review aims to evaluate the role of VR tools in Cognitive Rehabilitation of TBI patients.

Section snippets

Search strategy

The studies were identified by searching on Scopus, PubMed, Web of Science, and Cochrane database. The studies fulfilling our selected criteria and published between 2010 and 2017 were evaluated for possible inclusion. The search combined the following terms: (“virtual reality”[MeSH Terms] OR (“virtual”[All Fields] AND “reality”[All Fields]) OR “virtual reality”[All Fields]) AND (“brain injuries, traumatic”[MeSH Terms] OR (“brain”[All Fields] AND “injuries”[All Fields] AND “traumatic”[All

TBI and VR

Following TBI, patients may present motor, cognitive and social changes with a devastating impact on important aspects of their life. Various research has shown that new cognitive interventions, including VR training, can be useful in TBI patients. In fact, in the literature there are many studies, in which VR has been used successfully as both as assessment tool and therapeutic intervention (see Table 1) [10], [11], [12], [13], [14], [15], [16], [17], [18], [19].

VR assessment tool in TBI patients

As an assessment tool, VR was used to identify both cognitive and behavioral disorders in TBI patients. Onakomaiya et al. have carried out a study using the computer-assisted rehabilitation environment (CAREN) to identify co-morbidity post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in service members (214 individuals with a history of TBI). The results showed that VR has an important potential in the evaluation of PTSD, as the performance of the service members with PTSD was significantly slower than TBI

VR and rehabilitation in TBI patients

As a rehabilitation tool, VR has been shown to increase cognitive abilities in TBI patients. In fact, VR could stimulate motivation and enjoyment, which are important factors for successful rehabilitation training [28]. Dahdah et al. carried out a study on 15 TBI patients using a VR version of the Stroop. The authors observed that immersive VR interventions are effective in improving executive functions and the information processing speed in TBI patients, during the sub-acute phase [29]. VR

Discussion

Current literature is demonstrating that VR could be useful both as an assessment and rehabilitation tool in cognitive recovery post-TBI. However, the evaluation protocols with VR have been mainly applied in mild TBI, which is difficult to evaluate with traditional tools [33]. Instead, VR treatment protocols for cognitive rehabilitation are more widely used (i.e. from mild to severe conditions), although the efficacy of these interventions should be further explored [28]. Indeed, although

References (37)

  • T. Zoerle et al.

    Rethinking neuroprotection in severe traumatic brain injury: toward bedside neuroprotection

    Front Neurol

    (2017)
  • J. Aida et al.

    Immersive virtual reality in traumatic brain injury rehabilitation: a literature review

    NeuroRehabil

    (2018)
  • E.R. Zanier et al.

    Virtual Reality for Traumatic Brain Injury

    Front Neurol

    (2018)
  • M.G. Maggio et al.

    What About the Role of Virtual Reality in Parkinson Disease's Cognitive Rehabilitation? Preliminary Findings From a Randomized Clinical Trial

    J Geriatr Psychiatry Neurol

    (2018)
  • C.J. Bohil et al.

    Virtual reality in neuroscience research and therapy

    Nat Rev Neurosci

    (2011)
  • R. De Luca et al.

    Effects of Virtual Reality-Based Training with BTs-Nirvana on Functional Recovery in Stroke Patients: Preliminary Considerations

    Int J Neurosci

    (2017)
  • M. Russo et al.

    Does body shadow improve the efficacy of virtual reality-based training with BTS NIRVANA?: A pilot study

    Medic

    (2017)
  • R. De Luca et al.

    Improving post-stroke cognitive and behavioral abnormalities by using virtual reality: a case report on a novel use of nirvana

    Appl Neuropsychol Adult

    (2017)
  • Cited by (76)

    • Limb apraxia in individuals with multiple sclerosis: Is there a role of semi-immersive virtual reality in treating the Cinderella of neuropsychology?

      2023, Multiple Sclerosis and Related Disorders
      Citation Excerpt :

      Maggio et al., 2018) Recent studies have shown the potential use of virtual reality (VR) in increasing cognitive and motor functions, favoring functional recovery in various neurological disorders, including MS. (MG Maggio et al., 2019; MG Maggio et al., 2019; MG Maggio et al., 2019; MG Maggio et al., 2019; Leonardi et al., 2021; MG Maggio et al., 2020; Park et al., 2021; Jonsdottir et al., 2018; R De Luca et al., 2018; De Luca et al., 2020; Emedoli et al., 2021; Leocani et al., 2007; Peruzzi et al., 2016) The use of VR allows several advantages: it provides increased feedback due to the integration of visual, auditory and tactile inputs that stimulate the patient, favoring greater involvement in training sessions. ( Andaloro et al., 2020; Saeki and Hachisuka, 2004; Kamm et al., 2012; MG Maggio et al., 2020; Daumüller and Goldenberg, 2010; Geusgens et al., 2007; Maggio et al., 2018; MG Maggio et al., 2019; MG Maggio et al., 2019; MG Maggio et al., 2019; MG Maggio et al., 2019; Leonardi et al., 2021) Moreover, VR involves the mirror neuron system through visual-motor information coming from virtual "scenarios": this information recalls the memorized motor plans, helping to improve motor performance, (Andaloro et al., 2020; Daumüller and Goldenberg, 2010; Leonardi et al., 2021) as well as motor programming thus enhancing the praxis skills. Previous studies have confirmed that VR can be an effective tool in the motor and cognitive recovery of MS patients in various cognitive areas.

    • Embodied cognition in neurodegenerative disorders: What do we know so far? A narrative review focusing on the mirror neuron system and clinical applications

      2022, Journal of Clinical Neuroscience
      Citation Excerpt :

      The neurons activate the motor models of the body involved in the observed or simulated action and the neural structures used for the actual execution of the same actions [85]. In our previous studies, we hypothesized that virtual reality (VR) may improve cognitive and motor outcomes in neurological disorders, by activating “mirror neurons” [86–89]. In line with this topic, in patients with PD and other neurological illness, observation of the action associated with physical training could also improve the effects of rehabilitation training, as observed in individuals after stroke [90,91].

    • Rehabilitation Strategies and Innovations in Later Life for Traumatic Brain Injury

      2022, Comprehensive Clinical Psychology, Second Edition
    • Extended reality for patient recovery and wellness

      2022, Extended Reality for Healthcare Systems: Recent Advances in Contemporary Research
    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text