Generalized reduced rank tests using the singular value decomposition

doi:10.1016/j.jeconom.2005.02.011

Journal of Econometrics

Volume 133, Issue 1, July 2006, Pages 97-126

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jeconom.2005.02.011 Get rights and content

Abstract

We propose a novel statistic to test the rank of a matrix. The rank statistic overcomes deficiencies of existing rank statistics, like: a Kronecker covariance matrix for the canonical correlation rank statistic of Anderson [Annals of Mathematical Statistics (1951), 22, 327–351] sensitivity to the ordering of the variables for the LDU rank statistic of Cragg and Donald [Journal of the American Statistical Association (1996), 91, 1301–1309] and Gill and Lewbel [Journal of the American Statistical Association (1992), 87, 766–776] a limiting distribution that is not a standard chi-squared distribution for the rank statistic of Robin and Smith [Econometric Theory (2000), 16, 151–175] usage of numerical optimization for the objective function statistic of Cragg and Donald [Journal of Econometrics (1997), 76, 223–250] and ignoring the non-negativity restriction on the singular values in Ratsimalahelo [2002, Rank test based on matrix perturbation theory. Unpublished working paper, U.F.R. Science Economique, University de Franche-Comté]. In the non-stationary cointegration case, the limiting distribution of the new rank statistic is identical to that of the Johansen trace statistic.

Introduction

Tests of many economic hypotheses boil down to testing the rank of a matrix, see, for example, Lewbel (1991). Also the identification of parameters in econometric models often depends on the rank of a matrix. Therefore, since the early stages of the development of econometric methodology a literature focusing on rank tests has developed. An early contribution to this line of work is Anderson (1951). Anderson (1951) proposes a likelihood ratio rank statistic in a multivariate regression model based on canonical correlations. This canonical correlation rank statistic has a $χ^{2}$ limiting distribution when the covariance matrix of the unrestricted matrix estimator has a Kronecker structure. A Kronecker covariance matrix is however not always valid. For example, it does not apply if one opts for the use of heteroscedasticity autocorrelation consistent covariance (HACC) matrix estimators, see, for example, Andrews (1991), Newey and West (1987), West (1997) and White (1980). Alternative approaches to test the rank of a matrix that overcome this deficit have therefore been proposed.

Gill and Lewbel (1992) and Cragg and Donald (1996) use a LDU decomposition (see, for example, Golub and van Loan, 1989) of the unrestricted matrix to construct a rank statistic. They use a (root-T) consistent estimator of the unrestricted matrix, which does not need to have a Kronecker covariance matrix. A disadvantage of their approach is that it can be sensitive to the ordering of the variables. To overcome this sensitivity, the estimator of the unrestricted matrix is permuted using Gaussian elimination. A high level assumption is however needed to ensure that the Gaussian elimination performs adequately.

Cragg and Donald (1997) propose a rank statistic based on a minimum $χ^{2}$ criterion. They assume that the rank of the covariance matrix of the unrestricted matrix is maximal and minimize the objective function numerically. Numerical optimization is often difficult when the dimension of the optimization space is large. Hence, numerical optimization of the criterion function does not always perform satisfactorily when the number of columns or rows of the matrix of interest is large.

Recently, Robin and Smith (2000) construct a rank statistic on the basis of a (root-T) consistent estimator for the unrestricted matrix. The covariance matrix of this estimator does not need to have the Kronecker structure and its rank does not have to be maximal. The limiting distribution of the rank statistic is, however, a weighted average of $χ^{2}$ distributions. The asymptotic critical values of the rank statistic are therefore not tabulated. The limiting distribution shows that this rank statistic is not always appropriately normalized so the range of values of the weights affects the power of the statistic.

To overcome the deficiencies of the rank statistics, we propose a novel rank statistic. The rank statistic involves a (root-T) consistent estimator of the unrestricted matrix, which does not need to have a Kronecker covariance matrix. We decompose the unrestricted matrix estimator using a singular value decomposition. If the limiting distribution of the unrestricted matrix estimator is normal, an orthogonal transformation of the smallest singular values has a normal limiting distribution. Our rank statistic is equal to the quadratic form of this orthogonal transformation with respect to the inverse of its covariance matrix, and hence it has a standard $χ^{2}$ limiting distribution. The rank statistic simplifies to the canonical correlation rank statistic of Anderson (1951) in case of a Kronecker covariance matrix. The rank statistic can also be applied in case of non-stationary variables, for example, for cointegration testing. The asymptotic distribution is in that case a functional of Brownian motions and equal to the asymptotic distribution of the Johansen (1991) trace statistic.

The novel rank statistic is related to the rank statistic proposed by Ratsimalahelo, 2001, Ratsimalahelo, 2002. The limiting distribution of his rank statistic is however based on asymptotic normality of the smallest singular values. Since singular values are non-negative, they cannot have a mean zero normal limiting distribution. We therefore consider an orthogonal transformation of the smallest singular values which removes the non-negativity restriction on the singular values.

The outline of the paper is as follows. In Section 2 we discuss the singular value decomposition of a matrix. We show how this decomposition can be used to obtain a parameter that reflects rank reduction. In Section 3 we construct a rank statistic based on this parameter. We derive its limiting distribution and show that the statistic is a generalization of the canonical correlation rank statistic. We limit ourselves in this section to stationary variables and compare the rank statistic with existing rank statistics. The non-stationary cointegration case is discussed in Section 4. In this case, the limit distribution of our rank statistic is identical to that of the Johansen trace statistic. In Section 5, we apply the rank statistic to test the rank of a matrix that governs the identification of the parameters in the stochastic discount factor model of Jagannathan and Wang (1996). Furthermore, we use a factor model which stems from this application to illustrate the validity of the limiting distribution and to conduct a power comparison of different rank statistics. We end with some concluding remarks and topics for further research in Section 6.

Throughout the paper we use the notation: $a = vec (A)$ for the column vectorization of the $k \times m$ matrix A such that for $A = (A_{1} \dots A_{m})$ , $vec (A) = (A_{1}^{'} \dots A_{m}^{'})^{'}$ , $I_{m}$ is the $m \times m$ identity matrix and $tr (A)$ stands for the trace of a square matrix A. Furthermore, “ $\underset{p}{\to}$ ” stands for convergence in probability and “ $\underset{d}{\to}$ ” for convergence in distribution.

Section snippets

Singular value decomposition and rank reduction

To construct our rank test, we use the fact that a $k \times m$ real matrix C can be decomposed as $C = A_{q} B_{q} + A_{q, ⊥} Λ_{q} B_{q, ⊥},$ with $A_{q}$ a $k \times q$ matrix, $B_{q}$ a $q \times m$ matrix, $Λ_{q}$ a $(k - q) \times (m - q)$ matrix, $A_{q, ⊥}$ a $k \times (k - q)$ matrix, $B_{q, ⊥}$ a $(m - q) \times m$ matrix and where $A_{q}^{'} A_{q, ⊥} \equiv 0$ , $B_{q, ⊥} B_{q}^{'} \equiv 0$ , $A_{q, ⊥}^{'} A_{q, ⊥} \equiv I_{k - q}$ and $B_{q, ⊥} B_{q, ⊥}^{'} \equiv I_{m - q}$ with $q < \min (k, m)$ , see Kleibergen and van Dijk (1998) and Kleibergen and Paap (2002). If $Λ_{q} = 0$ , the rank of the matrix C is determined by the rank of $A_{q} B_{q}$ . If both $A_{q}$ and $B_{q}$ have full rank, the rank of C is then equal to

Rank test: the standard (stationary) case

We are concerned with testing the rank of the $k \times m$ matrix of parameters $Π$ . We assume that the matrix is non-symmetric in case $k = m$ and hence $Π$ is not allowed to be a covariance matrix. Under our null hypothesis, the rank of the matrix $Π$ is equal to q with $q < \min (k, m)$ , that is, $H_{0} : rank (Π) = q$ . To derive the limiting distributions of our test statistics and estimators, we make an assumption about the limiting behavior of an estimator of the unrestricted value of $Π$ denoted by $\hat{Π}$ , where we use the

Rank test: the non-stationary cointegration case

In vector autoregressive (VAR) models, cointegration implies a reduced rank value of the long-run multiplier, see, for example, Engle and Granger (1987) and Johansen, 1991, Johansen, 1995. A convenient specification of a VAR(1) model to reflect cointegration is the so-called error correction specification $Δ y_{i} = Π y_{i - 1} + ε_{i} for i = 1, \dots, T,$ where $y_{i}$ is a $k \times 1$ vector that contains time-series observations of the variable y at time i, $Δ y_{i} = y_{i} - y_{i - 1},$ $ε_{i}$ is a $k \times 1$ vector of disturbances which we assume to be

Testing rank in stochastic discount factor models

Jagannathan and Wang (1996) base the stochastic discount factor (SDF) in a SDF model on a conditional capital asset pricing model (CAPM). A SDF model for asset returns is represented by, see, for example, Campbell et al. (1997), $E [r_{ji + 1} s_{i + 1} | I_{i}] = 1, j = 1, \dots, k,$ where $r_{ji}$ is the return at time i on asset $j,$ $j = 1, \dots, k,$ $I_{i}$ is the information set at time i and $s_{i}$ is the SDF at time i. Based on the conditional CAPM, Jagannathan and Wang (1996) specify the SDF $s_{i + 1}$ as a linear function of a set of additional

Concluding remarks

To overcome some of the deficiencies of statistics that test the rank of a matrix, we propose a novel one. The rank statistic requires a consistent estimator of the unrestricted matrix, which does not need to have a Kronecker covariance matrix. This allows one, for example, to use HACC estimators for the covariance matrix. The unrestricted matrix is decomposed using a singular value decomposition. The rank statistic is a quadratic form of an orthogonal transformation of the smallest singular

Acknowledgements

We thank three anonymous referees and participants of ESEM 2003 in Stockholm and the ${EC}^{2}$ meeting in Bologna for helpful comments and suggestions. The first authors’ research documented in this article has been partially funded by the NWO Vernieuwingsimpuls research grant “Empirical Comparison of Economic Models”.

References (31)

J.C. Cragg et al.
Inferring the rank of a matrix
Journal of Econometrics
(1997)
F. Kleibergen et al.
Direct cointegration testing in error correction models
Journal of Econometrics
(1994)
F. Kleibergen et al.
Priors, posteriors and Bayes factors for a Bayesian analysis of cointegration
Journal of Econometrics
(2002)
K.D. West
Another heteroscedasticity- and autocorrelation-consistent covariance matrix estimator
Journal of Econometrics
(1997)
T.W. Anderson
Estimating linear restrictions on regression coefficients for multivariate normal distributions
Annals of Mathematical Statistics
(1951)
D.W.K. Andrews
Asymptotic results for generalized Wald tests
Econometric Theory
(1987)
D.W.K. Andrews
Heteroskedasticity and autocorrelation consistent covariance matrix estimation
Econometrica
(1991)
J.Y. Campbell et al.
The Econometrics of Financial Markets
(1997)
J.G. Cragg et al.
Testing identifiability and specification in instrumental variable models
Econometric Theory
(1993)
J.C. Cragg et al.
On the asymptotic properties of LDU-based tests of the rank of a matrix
Journal of the American Statistical Association
(1996)

R.F. Engle et al.

Co-integration and error correction: representation, estimation and testing

Econometrica

(1987)

L. Gill et al.

Testing the rank and definiteness of estimated matrices with applications to factor, state-space and ARMA Models

Journal of the American Statistical Association

(1992)

G.H. Golub et al.

Matrix Computations

(1989)

L.P. Hansen

Large sample properties of generalized method moments estimators

Econometrica

(1982)

R.A. Horn et al.

Topics in Matrix Analysis

(1991)

Cited by (1668)

The relationship between labor market institutions and innovation in 177 European regions over the period 2000–2015
2024, Structural Change and Economic Dynamics
The main goal of this paper is to investigate the relationship between labor market institutions (LMIs) and patents in 177 NUTS-1 and NUTS-2 European regions. Fixed effects models, ordinary least squares (OLS), the generalized method of moments estimation of the fixed effects (FE-GMM), multilevel modeling (MLM), and spatial models are employed. Patents are negatively correlated with EPL and union density and positively associated with wage bargaining coverage and centralization. As a result, a uniform wage that is higher than the competitive wage can enable the Schumpeterian creative destruction process, forcing firms to invest in innovation to remain in the market. Spatial analysis emphasizes that regional proximity promotes the flow of knowledge and increases the chance of innovation. Interactions also matter. Increased bargaining power and coordination, in particular, may outweigh the negative consequences of isolated EPL reforms. Thus, policies that strengthen wage-setting institutions are required in Europe to boost innovation.
Operational risk disclosure quality and national culture: Evidence from the E.U. Banking industry
2024, Journal of International Accounting, Auditing and Taxation
In this study, we analyze the association between national culture and voluntary operational risk disclosure quality in the European Union banking industry. Complementarily, we assess whether the potential impact of culture differs between global banks and banks with low levels of internationalization. Finally, we consider the impact of the formal institutional environment. Our sample covers 15 countries, and we construct a disclosure score based on hand-collected data. Three main results were obtained. First, banks in societies that score higher on individualism or long-term orientation and lower on uncertainty avoidance or power distance have better disclosures. Second, in global banks, where executive board members interact with stakeholders from different cultures, these associations are absent. Finally, contextual factors also affect the association between culture and disclosure, but this substitution effect is weaker than the one we document for globalization. Our results are robust to instrumental variables estimation, the use of the GLOBE project’s cultural dimensions, and a subsample analysis of civil code law countries.
Indirect effects of trading restrictions
2024, Journal of Corporate Finance
Stock market trading restrictions affect prices and liquidity directly through constraints on investors' transactions and indirectly by altering the information environment. We isolate this indirect effect by analyzing how stock market restrictions affect corporate bond yields. Exploiting the staggered reductions of trading restrictions in the Chinese stock market as a quasi-natural experiment, we document that the easing of trading restrictions on a firm's stock decreases its corporate bond spreads. This effect is stronger for firms with less transparency or lower credit ratings. Our evidence suggests that the effect is likely due to improved stock price informativeness.
How does climate vulnerability affect the just allocation of climate aid funds?
2024, International Review of Economics and Finance
In the process of global climate finance, the perspective of climate justice, especially distributive justice, has received widespread attention. However, how this principle is implemented in the practice of climate finance is still a topic that deserves in-depth discussion. Accordingly, this study aims to empirically examine the impact of climate vulnerability on the just allocation of climate aid (including mitigation and adaptation) funds based on balanced panel data of 89 countries from 2010 to 2020. To better understand this relationship, asymmetry, the moderating effects of government quality and low-carbon technologies, and the threshold effect of financial development are also empirically tested. The empirical results confirm that there is justice in the allocation of climate aid funds. Specifically, countries with higher climate vulnerability tend to receive more mitigation and adaptation funds, with adaptation funds being more responsive. However, this relationship is not universal but asymmetric. In addition, we test the mechanisms behind it. The quality of government and low-carbon technology development can enhance the beneficial effects of climate vulnerability, but government quality can only have an effect on the just allocation of mitigation finance. We also find a single threshold effect of financial development in the allocation of mitigation finance. Climate vulnerability contributes more to improving the just allocation of mitigation finance when the level of financial development exceeds the threshold. Finally, we provide policy implications for donors and recipients, respectively.
Urban agglomeration and regional economic performance connectedness: Thin ice in developing regions
2024, Research in Globalization
This paper evaluates the evolution of urban agglomeration from 2000 to 2020 in 66 developing and developed economies from Asia, Europe, and Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) and examines how urban agglomeration changes impinge on economic performance changes. The aim is to overcome the limitations of the empirical literature by constructing a nuanced measure of urban agglomeration using the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index calculation, which captures nations’ urban demographic structure more robustly than the indicators in the literature. The findings demonstrate that urban agglomeration has, on average, declined across world economies, contrary to a long-held assumption in the recent two decades. Empirically, the findings show a significant deleterious effect of urban agglomeration on economic performance in developing economies (i.e., Sub-Saharan Africa and Asia) and a beneficial effect in developed economies (i.e., Europe) in the short-run. However, the effect turns out to be beneficial in the developing economies in long-term. Based on the findings, we conclude that the relationship between urban agglomeration and economic performance is country-specific. Therefore, this paper professes that country-specific industrialization policy frameworks and governance effectiveness can enhance long-term positive economic effects of urban agglomeration in developing economies.
Excessive financialization and “Original Sin Theory”: Redemption from corporate reputation
2024, Research in International Business and Finance
Empirical studies suggest that excessive financialization that firms invest in a high proportion of financial assets will have a negative impact on firm value. This goes against the capital asset pricing theory, which suggests that high risk can produce high expected return. However, there is no explanation for the negative effect. We have empirically found that financial investments can yield higher expected returns compared with physical investments at any level, which aligns with the capital asset pricing theory. However, excessive financialization can harm a company’s reputation, which can be measured through product and service competitiveness, research and development output, and corporate social responsibility. As corporate reputation is an important intangible asset, excessive financialization has a negative impact on the overall firm value. Furthermore, excessive financialization has a greater negative impact on corporate reputation for firms with high financial leverage and sensitivity to economic policy uncertainty.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Generalized reduced rank tests using the singular value decomposition

Abstract

Introduction

Section snippets

Singular value decomposition and rank reduction

Rank test: the standard (stationary) case

Rank test: the non-stationary cointegration case

Testing rank in stochastic discount factor models

Concluding remarks

Acknowledgements

Journal of Econometrics

Journal of Econometrics

Journal of Econometrics

Journal of Econometrics

Estimating linear restrictions on regression coefficients for multivariate normal distributions

Annals of Mathematical Statistics

Asymptotic results for generalized Wald tests

Econometric Theory

Heteroskedasticity and autocorrelation consistent covariance matrix estimation

Econometrica

The Econometrics of Financial Markets

Testing identifiability and specification in instrumental variable models

Econometric Theory

On the asymptotic properties of LDU-based tests of the rank of a matrix

Journal of the American Statistical Association

Co-integration and error correction: representation, estimation and testing

Econometrica

Testing the rank and definiteness of estimated matrices with applications to factor, state-space and ARMA Models

Journal of the American Statistical Association

Matrix Computations

Large sample properties of generalized method moments estimators

Econometrica

Topics in Matrix Analysis