Planar covariation of elevation angles in prosthetic gait

Abstract

In order to achieve efficacious walking, transfemoral amputees must adapt coordination within both the artificial and the sound lower limb. We analyzed kinematic strategies in amputees using the planar covariation of lower limb segments approach. When the elevation angles of the thigh, shank and foot are plotted one versus the others, they describe a regular loop which lies close to a plane in normal adults’ gait. Orientation of this plane changes with increased speed, in relation to mechanical energetic saving. We used an opto-electronic device to record the elevation angles of both limbs’ segments of novice and expert transfemoral amputees and compared them to those of control subjects. The statistical structure underlying the distribution of these angles was described by principal component analysis and Fourier transform. The typical elliptic loop was preserved in prosthetic walking, in both limbs in both novice and expert transfemoral amputees. This reflects a specific control over the thigh elevation angle taking into account knowledge of the other elevation angles throughout the gait cycle. The best-fitting plane of faster trials rotates around the long axis of the gait loop with respect to the plane of slower trials for control subjects, and even more for the sound limb of expert amputees. In contrast, plane rotation is very weak or absent for the prosthetic limb. We suggest that these results reveal a centrally commanded compensation strategy.

Introduction

Numerous experimental studies of locomotion have demonstrated that the elevation angles of the lower limb segments provide a kinematic template revealing a motor organizational rule [1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6]. Intersegmental coordination of the lower limbs could be used by the nervous system for limiting energy expenditure to walk in a smooth and effortless manner [7]. When the elevation angles of the thigh, shank and foot are plotted one versus the others, they describe a regular loop which lies close to a plane. Lacquaniti et al. [3] calls this the “first law of intersegmental coordination”. The orientation of this plane and the shape of the loop are similar for normal subjects [6]. Moreover, the orientation of the plane slightly changes with increased walking velocity, and this plane rotation limits the increment in mechanical energy expenditure; this is considered as the “second law of planar covariation” [3], [7], [8]. This physiological approach to gait control has proved useful to better understand a number of gait disorders associated with various conditions of the brain, whether acquired such as Parkinson's disease [9] or developmental, such as cerebral palsy or Angelman syndrome [10], or the spinal cord [11], [12]. It has also been tested in situations where the peripheral system is artificially altered, such as walking on a slippery surface [13] or reducing joint mobility [14]. Here we studied the reorganization of lower limb coordination in patients who developed prosthetic gait in the context of transfemoral amputation to see whether a transfemoral amputee will simulate the specific coordination observed in normal subjects. We analyze the prosthetic lower limb kinematics of transfemoral amputees at different stages of rehabilitation, walking at different speeds in order to verify the existence of both laws of elevation angle covariation. Amputees adjust to a device over time, essentially optimizing their physiological system with that of the prosthesis [15]. Thus, we have to consider the amputee's physiological system not as a fixed component but as a compliant biological one like that observed in typical gait maturation [16]. As such, we also see how the compensatory strategies of unilateral amputees affect their sound limb's coordination pattern. We included the very first walking trials of fresh amputees, even bilaterally amputated, to check whether the first law of planar covariation could be found within a very heterogeneous group of amputees.

Only expert amputees, able to walk at different speed levels on a treadmill, allowed testing the existence of the second “law of planar covariation”. The main purpose of this study is to highlight specific differences between a sound and a prosthetic limb in the walking strategies of expert amputees.

Additionally, the results of this study might give insights into the physiological relevance of the first and second law of planar covariation. A key issue concerns the role of the thigh elevation angle, which could either be marginal with respect to the correlation between shank and foot elevation angles [17] or contribute independently to the pattern of intersegmental coordination and planar covariance. Analyzing the prosthetic limb of an amputee, where knee and ankle joint functioning are based on a completely passive mechanism and on the voluntary forward and backward oscillation of the thigh, might allow gaining further insight to these questions.