Planar covariation of elevation angles in prosthetic gait
Highlights
► Kinematic strategies in transfemoral amputees were analyzed by planar covariation. ► The typical elliptic loop was preserved in prosthetic walking in both limbs. ► The orientation of the loop for the prosthetic limb did not change with speed. ► The relation to speed was even stronger for the sound limb than for control subjects. ► These results reveal a centrally commanded compensation strategy.
Introduction
Numerous experimental studies of locomotion have demonstrated that the elevation angles of the lower limb segments provide a kinematic template revealing a motor organizational rule [1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6]. Intersegmental coordination of the lower limbs could be used by the nervous system for limiting energy expenditure to walk in a smooth and effortless manner [7]. When the elevation angles of the thigh, shank and foot are plotted one versus the others, they describe a regular loop which lies close to a plane. Lacquaniti et al. [3] calls this the “first law of intersegmental coordination”. The orientation of this plane and the shape of the loop are similar for normal subjects [6]. Moreover, the orientation of the plane slightly changes with increased walking velocity, and this plane rotation limits the increment in mechanical energy expenditure; this is considered as the “second law of planar covariation” [3], [7], [8]. This physiological approach to gait control has proved useful to better understand a number of gait disorders associated with various conditions of the brain, whether acquired such as Parkinson's disease [9] or developmental, such as cerebral palsy or Angelman syndrome [10], or the spinal cord [11], [12]. It has also been tested in situations where the peripheral system is artificially altered, such as walking on a slippery surface [13] or reducing joint mobility [14]. Here we studied the reorganization of lower limb coordination in patients who developed prosthetic gait in the context of transfemoral amputation to see whether a transfemoral amputee will simulate the specific coordination observed in normal subjects. We analyze the prosthetic lower limb kinematics of transfemoral amputees at different stages of rehabilitation, walking at different speeds in order to verify the existence of both laws of elevation angle covariation. Amputees adjust to a device over time, essentially optimizing their physiological system with that of the prosthesis [15]. Thus, we have to consider the amputee's physiological system not as a fixed component but as a compliant biological one like that observed in typical gait maturation [16]. As such, we also see how the compensatory strategies of unilateral amputees affect their sound limb's coordination pattern. We included the very first walking trials of fresh amputees, even bilaterally amputated, to check whether the first law of planar covariation could be found within a very heterogeneous group of amputees.
Only expert amputees, able to walk at different speed levels on a treadmill, allowed testing the existence of the second “law of planar covariation”. The main purpose of this study is to highlight specific differences between a sound and a prosthetic limb in the walking strategies of expert amputees.
Additionally, the results of this study might give insights into the physiological relevance of the first and second law of planar covariation. A key issue concerns the role of the thigh elevation angle, which could either be marginal with respect to the correlation between shank and foot elevation angles [17] or contribute independently to the pattern of intersegmental coordination and planar covariance. Analyzing the prosthetic limb of an amputee, where knee and ankle joint functioning are based on a completely passive mechanism and on the voluntary forward and backward oscillation of the thigh, might allow gaining further insight to these questions.
Section snippets
Methods
A total of 20 subjects participated in this study (males, age: 35 ± 6 years): seven expert transfemoral amputees walked as naturally as possible on a treadmill at various self-selected speed levels, reaching their self selected maximal speed; two bilateral transfemoral amputees walked on the ground with two crouches after only two months of rehabilitation and one unilateral amputee, with his recently matched prosthesis performed his first steps without crouches in the laboratory setting.
The
Results
Evolution of elevation angles of the three segments of the lower limb was studied throughout gait cycles. Fig. 2 shows this evolution in one representative amputee (left and middle column for prosthetic and sound leg, respectively) and in one representative control subject (right column) all walking at 3 km/h. When plotting the time-varying series of elevation angles shown in Fig. 2A one versus the others in 3D-position space, we found a planar covariation for both the prosthetic and the sound
Discussion
We found that the first law of intersegmental coordination of elevation angles was verified in both limbs of transfemoral amputees, whether novice or expert in the use of their prosthesis. This contrasts with findings in the gait pattern of young toddlers, which differs significantly from the typical planar covariation that emerges over the first few months and years of walking experience in normal development [16], [19], [20], [21]. In fact, in amputees, planarity of the covariation was
Conflict of interest statement
Concerning our manuscript entitled ‘Planar covariation of elevation angles in prosthetic gait’, all authors disclose any financial and personal relationships with other people or organizations that could inappropriately influence (bias) this work Leurs F, Bengoetxea A, Cebolla AM, De Saedeleer C, Dan B, Cheron G.
Acknowledgements
This work was funded by the Belgian Federal Science Policy Office the European Space Agency (AO-2004, 118), the FEDER support (BIOFACT project), the FP7 support (ICT-247959-MINDWALKER), the National Research Fund of the Grand-duchy of Luxembourg, the Belgian National Fund for Scientific Research (FNRS), the Research Fund of the Université Libre de Bruxelles and of the University of Mons (Belgium). The authors thank J. McIntyre for insightful comments about the manuscript. We wish to thank E.
References (30)
- et al.
Effect of intrathecal baclofen on gait control in human hereditary spastic paraparesis
Neurosci Lett
(2000) - et al.
Gait control in spinal palsy
Brain Dev
(2004) - et al.
Energy storage and return prostheses: does patient perception correlate with biomechanical analysis?
Clin Biomech
(2002) - et al.
Early emergence of temporal co-ordination of lower limb segments elevation angles in human locomotion
Neurosci Lett
(2001) - et al.
A methodology for studying the effects of various types of prosthetic feet on the biomechanics of trans-femoral amputee gait
J Biomech
(1999) - et al.
Evidence for bilaterally delayed and decreased obstacle avoidance responses while walking with a lower limb prosthesis
Clin Neurophysiol
(2009) - et al.
The control of limb geometry in cat posture
J Physiol
(1990) - et al.
Coordinate transformations in the control of cat posture
J Neurophysiol
(1994) - et al.
Motor patterns in walking
News Physiol Sci
(1999) - et al.
Kinematic control of walking
Arch Ital Biol
(2002)
Kinematic analysis of cat hindlimb stepping
J Neurophysiol
Kinematic determinants of human locomotion
J Physiol
Kinematic coordination in human gait: relation to mechanical energy cost
J Neurophysiol
Individual characteristics of human walking mechanics
Pflugers Arch
Basal ganglia and gait control: apomorphine administration and internal pallidum stimulation in Parkinson's disease
Exp Brain Res
Cited by (25)
Asymptomatic Genu Recurvatum reshapes lower limb sagittal joint and elevation angles during gait at different speeds
2021, KneeCitation Excerpt :The proof is that the instructions given to subjects with GR of orthopaedic origin to reduce knee hyperextension during the stance phase of gait are based as much on voluntary adaptations of the kinematics of the hip (avoid excessive hip flexion) and ankle (avoid excessive plantar flexion and maintain dorsiflexion) joints [21] as on the knee (maintaining a knee-flexion position [21] or within a target at 5 degrees of knee flexion [2,27]). Furthermore, since the proposal to measure elevation angles of the thigh, leg and foot during walking and their coordination [28], many studies have successfully used this methodology to better understand motor control of walking in healthy subjects [29–31] and patients with various pathologies [32–34]. To the best of our knowledge, neither lower limb joint nor elevation angles have yet been assessed in subjects with asymptomatic GR.
Use of Segmental Coordination Analysis of Nonparetic and Paretic Limbs During Obstacle Clearance in Community-Dwelling Persons After Stroke
2013, PM and RCitation Excerpt :Strong evidence that supports this argument was presented by Cheron et al [32], who showed the refinement of a planar pattern during development in children and related this refinement to the updating of a neural command adapting to morphologic changes that occur during growth. As well, Leurs et al [33] showed planar covariance of elevation angles in participants with a transfemoral prosthetic device, and concluded that this pattern is conserved by a neural tuning of the thigh elevation angle trajectory and accounts for movement by the prosthetic shank and foot segments. The current study adds support to the argument that planar patterns that arise from elevation angle trajectories are related to neural control due to the suggestion of the preservation of a basic locomotor control pattern in the population of stroke participants studied.
Characterization of prosthetic knees through a low-dimensional description of gait kinematics
2023, Journal of NeuroEngineering and RehabilitationBiomechanical strategies to maximize gait attractiveness among women
2023, Frontiers in Sports and Active LivingAsymmetric Changes in Intersegmental Covariation Across Ambulation Levels and Prosthetic Devices for Transfemoral Amputee Gait
2023, International IEEE/EMBS Conference on Neural Engineering, NER