Elsevier

Gait & Posture

Volume 23, Issue 3, April 2006, Pages 273-281
Gait & Posture

The role of estimating muscle-tendon lengths and velocities of the hamstrings in the evaluation and treatment of crouch gait

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gaitpost.2005.03.003Get rights and content

Abstract

Persons with cerebral palsy frequently walk with excessive knee flexion during terminal swing and stance. This gait abnormality is often attributed to “short” or “spastic” hamstrings that restrict knee extension, and is often treated by hamstrings lengthening surgery. At present, the outcomes of these procedures are inconsistent. This study examined whether analyses of the muscle-tendon lengths and lengthening velocities of patients’ hamstrings during walking may be helpful when deciding whether a candidate is likely to benefit from hamstrings surgery. One hundred and fifty-two subjects were cross-classified in a series of multi-way contingency tables based on their pre- and postoperative gait kinematics, muscle-tendon lengths, muscle-tendon velocities, and hamstrings surgeries. The lengths and velocities of the subjects’ semimembranosus muscles were estimated by combining kinematic data from gait analysis with a three-dimensional computer model of the lower extremity. Log-linear analysis revealed that the subjects who walked with abnormally “short” or “slow” hamstrings preoperatively, and whose hamstrings did not operate at longer lengths or faster velocities postoperatively, were unlikely to walk with improved knee extension after treatment (p < 0.05). Subjects who did not walk with abnormally short or slow hamstrings preoperatively, and whose hamstrings did operate at longer lengths or faster velocities postoperatively, tended to exhibit unimproved or worsened anterior pelvic tilt after treatment (p < 0.05). Examination of the muscle-tendon lengths and velocities allows individuals who walk with abnormally short or slow hamstrings to be distinguished from those who do not, and thus may help to identify patients who are at risk for unsatisfactory postsurgical changes in knee extension or anterior pelvic tilt.

Introduction

Crouch gait, one of the most prevalent and troublesome movement abnormalities among children with cerebral palsy, is characterized by excessive knee flexion during the terminal swing and stance phases. Abnormally “tight” hamstrings, due to spasticity [1], [2], [3] or static contracture [3], [4], are thought to cause the excessive knee flexion in many cases. Thus, crouch gait is commonly treated by surgical lengthening of the hamstrings, typically in combination with other orthopaedic procedures.

Unfortunately, it is difficult to predict which patients will benefit from hamstrings surgery. Many individuals achieve dramatic improvements in knee extension, stride length and walking efficiency following surgery, while others show little improvement or get worse. Previous studies have attempted to explain these inconsistent outcomes by categorizing patients on the basis of preoperative gait kinematics and/or surgical interventions and comparing postoperative changes in knee, hip and pelvis angles during walking across the patient groups (e.g. [5], [6], [7], [8]). These studies have provided valuable documentation of patients’ gait kinematics and kinetics before and after surgery; however, these analyses have identified only a few of the factors that potentially influence outcomes, and the reported findings have been contradictory. One reason is that several factors in addition to tight hamstrings may contribute to crouch gait, and determining whether an individual's gait abnormality is due to short or spastic hamstrings [6], [9], [10], [11], spastic hip flexors [9], [12], [13], weak knee extensors [14], weak ankle plantarflexors [15], torsional deformities of the tibia [16], [17], problems with balance or another source is not straightforward. To improve the outcomes of treatments for crouch gait, more efficacious strategies for making treatment decisions are needed.

The purpose of this study was to assess whether analyses of the muscle-tendon lengths and lengthening velocities of patients’ hamstrings during crouch gait may be helpful when deciding whether a patient is likely to benefit from hamstrings surgery. We reasoned that if hamstrings contracture is the source of a patient's excessive knee flexion (i.e. if crouch gait is caused by excessive passive forces that are generated when abnormally short hamstrings are stretched), then the patient's hamstrings are likely to operate at abnormally short muscle-tendon lengths, particularly in terminal swing, when the hamstrings are stretched to their maximum lengths during walking. In such cases, surgical lengthening of the hamstrings may improve knee extension by decreasing the passive forces generated by the muscles, thereby enabling short hamstrings to operate at longer muscle-tendon lengths. Alternatively, if hamstrings spasticity is the source of a patient's excessive knee flexion (i.e. if crouch gait is caused by an exaggerated, velocity-dependent resistance of the hamstrings to stretch), then the patient's hamstrings are likely to lengthen at abnormally slow muscle-tendon velocities, particularly during the mid-swing phase, when the hamstrings are rapidly stretched. In such cases, surgical lengthening of the hamstrings may improve knee extension by attenuating the muscles’ exaggerated response to stretch, thereby enabling spastic hamstrings to lengthen at greater muscle-tendon velocities. We also reasoned that if a patient's hamstrings are not operating at short lengths or slow velocities during walking, and are not restricting knee extension, then surgical lengthening of the muscles may not alleviate excessive knee flexion, or may unnecessarily compromise hamstrings strength. These arguments suggest that estimates of patients’ hamstrings lengths and velocities, as determined from gait analysis and a computer model that accurately characterizes the musculoskeletal geometry, may help to distinguish those who have short or spastic hamstrings from those who do not, and thus may augment the techniques currently used to identify candidates for surgery.

Several research groups have estimated the muscle-tendon lengths [18], [19], [20], [21], [22], [23] and/or velocities [2], [24] of the hamstrings during normal and crouch gait. A consistent finding from these studies is that not all persons with crouch gait walk with hamstrings that are shorter than normal [18], [19], [20], [21], [22], [23], [24] or slower than normal [2], [24]. Previous analyses have also shown that subjects with abnormally “short” hamstrings tend to walk with longer muscle-tendon lengths, and subjects with abnormally “slow” hamstrings tend to walk with longer muscle-tendon velocities, when knee extension is improved following hamstrings surgery; by contrast, subjects whose hamstrings do not operate at short lengths or slow velocities preoperatively do not tend to walk with longer or faster hamstrings postoperatively [24]. The results of these studies are encouraging, and suggest that analyses of the muscle-tendon lengths and velocities warrant further investigation.

The analyses of muscle-tendon lengths and velocities performed in each of the previous studies [2], [18], [19], [20], [21], [22], [23], [24] had important limitations. Most studies relied on generic models of the lower extremity with normal adult musculoskeletal geometry. However, many individuals who undergo surgery to treat crouch gait are children with bone deformities, and only Schutte et al. [20] and Arnold et al. [24] evaluated whether variations in musculoskeletal geometry due to age or bone deformities may have compromised the accuracy of the muscle-tendon lengths or velocities estimated with their models. Only a small number of subjects were analyzed in previous studies (typically 10–30 subjects), and only Cosgrove et al. [21] examined whether the subjects’ gait deviations were systematically altered after surgery. Hence, important questions remain unanswered, and the role of muscle-tendon lengths and velocities in surgical decision-making remains unclear.

In this study, we retrospectively determined the muscle-tendon lengths and lengthening velocities of the medial hamstrings for 152 subjects, at the body positions corresponding to each subject's measured gait, using a well-tested computer model of the lower extremity [25]. The following questions were addressed:

  • What percentage of patients walk with hamstrings that are operating at abnormally short muscle-tendon lengths?

  • What percentage of patients walk with hamstrings that is lengthening at abnormally slow muscle-tendon velocities?

  • Is knee extension during terminal swing and early stance more likely to be improved after surgery when the hamstrings are operating at abnormally short lengths or slow velocities preoperatively? Is knee extension more likely to be improved when the hamstrings operate at longer lengths or faster velocities postoperatively?

  • Is anterior pelvic tilt more likely to be exaggerated after surgery when the hamstrings are not operating at abnormally short lengths or slow velocities preoperatively? Is anterior pelvic tilt more likely to be exaggerated when the hamstrings operate at longer lengths or faster velocities postoperatively?

  • If the hamstrings are not operating at abnormally short lengths or slow velocities preoperatively, is it possible to improve knee extension without hamstrings lengthening surgery?

This work examines these questions and critically evaluates the utility of analyzing muscle-tendon lengths and velocities of the hamstrings in a large sample of subjects before and after surgery.

Section snippets

Methods

The 152 subjects were selected from the motion analysis laboratory databases at two children's medical centers (hereafter referred to as Center A and Center B). All had spastic cerebral palsy, were able to ambulate without orthoses or other assistance, and were 6 years of age or older (mean 10 years, range 6–22 years) preoperatively. All had undergone at least two gait analyses as part of their routine medical care, and all but one had undergone intervening orthopaedic surgery and physical

Results

Approximately one-third of the subjects walked with abnormally short semimembranosus muscle-tendon lengths (54 of 152 subjects, 35%); in most cases, these subjects also walked with abnormally slow muscle-tendon velocities. Another one-third of the subjects had hamstrings that operated at abnormally slow muscle-tendon velocities, but not short lengths (45 of 152 subjects, 30%). The remaining one-third of the subjects (53 of 152 subjects, 35%) walked with peak semimembranosus lengths and

Discussion

Analyses of muscle-tendon lengths and lengthening velocities alone, like any other variable measured during gait analysis, cannot predict the outcome of multi-level orthopaedic surgery. However, estimates of the peak lengths and velocities of patients’ hamstrings during crouch gait may be helpful when assessing if abnormally tight hamstrings are limiting a patient's knee extension, and thus may help to identify patients who are at risk for unsatisfactory postsurgical changes in knee extension

Acknowledgements

We are grateful to Saryn Goldberg, Katherine Bell, Dennis Tyburski, Melany Westwell and Jean Stout for assistance with data collection, to Silvia Blemker for contributions to the model, and to Jim Gage, Tom Novacheck, George Rab, Luciano Dias, Stephen Vankoski, Julie Witka, Roy Davis and Kevin Granata for the many stimulating discussions we have had regarding muscle-tendon lengths and velocities. This work was supported by NIH RO1 HD33929 and HD046814, the Whitaker Foundation and the United

References (32)

  • R.M. Kay et al.

    Outcome of medial versus combined medial and lateral hamstring lengthening surgery in cerebral palsy

    J Pediatr Orthop

    (2002)
  • T. Novacheck et al.

    Intramuscular psoas lengthening improves dynamic hip function in children with cerebral palsy

    J Pediatr Orthop

    (2002)
  • E.E. Bleck

    Orthopaedic management in cerebral palsy

    (1987)
  • J.R. Gage

    Surgical treatment of knee dysfunction in cerebral palsy

    Clin Orthop Rel Res

    (1990)
  • J. Perry et al.

    Function of the hamstrings in cerebral palsy

  • J. Reimers

    Static and dynamic problems in spastic cerebral palsy

    J Bone Joint Surg [Br]

    (1973)
  • Cited by (135)

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text