The sex ratio at birth in South Africa may be a sentinel health indicator
Introduction
The sex ratio at birth is commonly expressed as M/T, denoting male births divided by total births. Males are almost invariably born slightly in excess of females [1]. Numerous factors have been shown to influence this ratio, including stress, which lowers it [1]. This accords with Trivers-Willard hypothesis which proposes that stressed mothers are likelier to produce daughters since these are less costly from the nutritional point of view and are therefore less likely to be frail and likelier to survive and reproduce in a harsh environment [2].
Acute stress, such as that experienced during unexpected violent events, has been shown to reduce this ratio three to five months later [3], [4]. Stressful socioeconomic factors have also been implicated as affecting M/T, presumably through the same mechanisms. For example, the acute economic collapse of East Germany in 1990 after Germany's reunification led to an sudden and transient drop in M/T in this region [5], [6]. Chronic socioeconomic stress has also been shown to lower M/T. Social scale, for example, has been shown to affect M/T, with a lower M/T engendered by individuals who are lower down in the hierarchy of social class [7], [8].
Ethnic background also appears to influence M/T. In the United States, Asians have the highest M/T, followed by Whites, with the lowest M/T ratios encountered in Blacks and American Indians [9]. Asians have artificially high M/T ratios since these cultures prefer males and may thus opt to terminate antenatally diagnosed female fetuses [10]. It has been estimated that for this reason, up to two hundred million women are missing from the world [11].
Historically, Blacks have been shown to have a lower M/T than those from a Whites ethnic background [12], [13], [14], [15], [16], [17], [18]. These differences persevere even when different ethnic background co-exist such as in South Africa and the West Indies [13] and in England and Wales [19].
Innate physiological differences have been proposed as a cause for these discrepancies [12], [13], [14], [15]. It has further been theorised that these difference may be causally related to periconceptual parental hormone levels [19], [20].
The South African population (2011 census) is constituted of a predominantly Black majority (79.2% Black African, 8.9% Colored (mixed ethnic backgrounds), 8.9% White and 2.5% Indian/Asian) [21]. Socioeconomic conditions in South African have been shown to be improving steadily over the past years, so much so that rates of obesity have unfortunately increased [22]. This study was carried out in order to ascertain whether improving conditions in South Africa as measured by available health indicators, were associated with a rise in M/T in this country [23], [24].
Section snippets
Methods
Annual male and female births were obtained from Statistics South Africa [24].
Excel was used for data entry, overall analysis and charting. The quadratic equations of Fleiss were used for exact calculation of 95% confidence intervals for ratios [25]. Chi tests and chi tests for trends for annual male and female births were used throughout using the Bio-Med-Stat Excel add-in for contingency tables [26]. SPSS was used for Kendall correlations of M/T with various available health indicators for
Results
For the period 2003–2014, there were a total of 12,409,437 births as 6,247,702 males and 6,161,735 females (M/T 0.5035, 95% CI 0.5032-0.5037). Annual data is shown in Table 1 and Fig. 1.
There was a rise in M/T over the initial period studied (2003–2010) with a plateau thereafter. The rise over the entire period studied was significant (Chi for linear trend = 30.3, p < 0.0001).
M/T was significantly positively correlated with life expectancy and significantly negatively correlated with infant
Discussion
It has been mooted that the lower M/T observed in Blacks may be stress-related [9], and these findings support this contention. Long-term stress that is related to maternal socio-economic conditions influences M/T. For example, well-nourished mothers are likelier to have higher M/T ratios [28], [29]. It has also been shown in Venezuela that a higher maternal educational status increased M/T while extreme poverty decreased it [30].
In addition, studies have shown a decreasing M/T in association
References (39)
Proximate causes of the variation of the human sex ratio at birth
Early Hum. Dev.
(2015)Terrorist attacks and the male-to-female ratio at birth: the troubles in Northern Ireland, the Rodney King riots, and the Breivik and Sandy Hook shootings
Early Hum. Dev.
(2015)- et al.
Changing sex ratio in the United States, 1969–1995
Fertil. Steril.
(1998) - et al.
The sex ratio at birth in South Africa increased 9 months after the 2010 FIFA World Cup
Early Hum. Dev.
(2015 Dec) - et al.
Natural selection of parental ability to vary the sex ratio of offspring
Science
(1973) - et al.
Exogenous shocks to the human sex ratio: the case of September 11, 2001 in New York City
Hum. Reprod.
(2006) Sex ratios in the two Germanies: a test of the economic stress hypothesis
Hum. Reprod.
(2003)The Great Recession of 2007 in the United States and the male: female ratio at birth
J. Turk. Ger. Gynecol. Assoc.
(2015)The influence of social factors upon the sex-ratio at birth
Am. J. Sociol.
(1931)Statistical study of the sex ratio at birth
J. Hyg. (Lond)
(1936)
State and regional differences in the male-to-female ratio at birth in the United States, 1995–2012
West Indian Med J
Missing women
BMJ
Violence against Women: Zero Tolerance
Variation in the sex ratio at birth in the U.S.
Hum. Biol.
Sex ratio at birth in territories with a relatively complete registration
Eugen. Q.
Socioeconomic factors and the sex ratio at birth
J. Biosoc. Sci.
The secondary sex ratio in the United States 1969–71: association with race, parental ages, birth order, paternal education and legitimacy
Ann. Hum. Genet.
Trend analysis of the sex ratio at birth in the United States
Natl. Health Stat. Report.
Trends in US sex ratio by plurality, gestational age and race/ethnicity
Hum. Reprod.
Cited by (14)
Multivariate analysis of the correlation of sex ratio at birth with health and socioeconomic indicators
2020, Early Human DevelopmentWhat is the sex ratio at birth?
2020, Early Human DevelopmentCorrelation of sex ratio at birth with health and socioeconomic indicators
2018, Early Human DevelopmentCitation Excerpt :There is some evidence that M/T may act as a sentinel public health indicator [2]. For example, a South African study showed that over the years 2003–2010, M/T was significantly positively correlated with life expectancy and significantly negatively correlated with infant mortality, under 5 year mortality and total fertility rate [6]. Thus, not only a fall but also a rise in M/T that has shown to have occurred in association with health improvements also supports the contention that M/T may serve as a public health indicator.
Can sex ratios at birth be used in the assessment of public health, and in the identification of causes of selected pathologies?
2018, Early Human DevelopmentCitation Excerpt :This reasoning will then be supplemented with evidence on the health-related evolutionary context of a second cause of M/T variation. It is first worth noting that the use of M/T as a possible health indicator has been illustrated, with rising M/T correlated with a decline in important health metrics such as infant mortality, and vice versa [24,25]. Large samples of national M/T have shown that this correlates positively with life expectancy [25], and cognitive ability [26], and negatively with parasite stress [27], and, in particular, with prevalence of infection by the parasite Toxoplasma gondii [28].
A socio-economic hypothesis for lower birth sex ratios at racial, national and global levels
2018, Early Human DevelopmentCitation Excerpt :The chronic stress argument for low Black M/T is reinforced by the fact that as socioeconomic conditions in South Africa improved (majority of population Black), there was a rise in M/T over 2003–2010 with a plateau thereafter. This was statistically significant, positively correlated with life expectancy and negatively correlated with infant mortality, and under 5 year mortality [31]. Conversely, in Japan, gross domestic product (GDP) exhibited a statistically significant correlation with M/T following Japan’s economic decline.
No baby booms or birth sex ratio changes following Fifty Shades of Grey in the United States
2017, Early Human DevelopmentCitation Excerpt :More recently, a similar rise in M/T was noted in Japan just prior to 1965 and immediately following 1967, i.e. on both sides of the Chinese Zodiac Fire Horse Year which was deemed inauspicious for a female birth [10]. This may also have been responsible for a rise in M/T following the FIFA World Cup in South Africa in 2010 [11]. In this study, no spikes in births or in M/T are evident post FSOG exposure.