Elsevier

Developmental Review

Volume 48, June 2018, Pages 40-54
Developmental Review

Review
Great expectations? Do mothers’ and fathers’ prenatal thoughts and feelings about the infant predict parent-infant interaction quality? A meta-analytic review

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dr.2018.03.007Get rights and content

Highlights

  • Expectant parents’ thoughts and feelings about their unborn infant are measurable.

  • Prenatal measures predict modest variation in observed postnatal parenting.

  • These predictive effects are stronger for mothers than fathers.

Abstract

Drawing on data gathered from 14 studies involving a total of 1862 mothers and fathers, this meta-analysis reviews the measures that are used to tap into thoughts and feelings about the unborn infant during pregnancy and examines links between these prenatal measures and parent-child interaction quality. Questionnaire scores for parental-fetal attachment and interview ratings of expectant parents’ representations of their infant showed modest but robust associations with observed parent-child interaction quality. Moderator analyses showed that these associations were significantly stronger for mothers than for fathers. Key lessons for future research include the need for greater consistency in study measures, sample diversity and the examination of associations with child outcomes.

Introduction

Attachment, defined as infants’ adaptive propensity to seek comfort and protection from a familiar caregiver when they are alarmed or unwell, has long been recognized as an important predictor of children’s development and adjustment (Bowlby, 1969, Sroufe, 2005). Using standardized observational paradigms such as Ainsworth’s strange situation (1970), researchers have identified three main profiles of infant attachment: secure (e.g., seeks and accepts comfort), insecure-resistant (e.g., seeks yet resists comfort) or insecure-avoidant (e.g., absence of help-seeking behaviour). Variation in parental sensitivity, defined as the ability to notice, interpret and respond in a timely and appropriate manner to children’s signals (Ainsworth, Bell, & Stayton, 1974), is thought to underpin these contrasts in infant attachment. In contrast, parental displays of frightening or atypical behaviour are thought to lead to a pattern of disorganised attachment in a fourth group of children (e.g., Duschinsky, 2018, van Ijzendoorn et al., 1999). In a further expansion of the field, researchers have also examined parents’ representations of their infants, with a particular focus on two related constructs: (i) mind-mindedness, which refers to parents’ propensity to see their children as individuals with their own minds (Meins, 1997); and (ii) and reflective function, which refers to parents’ ability to reflect upon the internal states that govern their own and their children’s behaviour (Fonagy, Steele, Steele, Moran, & Higgitt, 1991).

Importantly, this shift in focus from parent behaviour to parental representations enables predictors of parent-child relationship quality to be examined from as early as the prenatal period. This is an exciting prospect for fostering infant development and adjustment because pregnancy provides a valuable window of opportunity for delivering programmes to support new parents (Sadler et al., 2013). With this goal in mind, researchers have used diverse interviews and questionnaires to examine whether expectant parents’ thoughts and feelings about their unborn infant might contribute to early variation in parental sensitivity. However, the findings from this field have yet to be synthesised. To address this gap in the current study, we first summarise the different interview and questionnaire measures available to tap into expectant parents’ thoughts and feelings about the unborn infant. Next, we outline some of the observational parenting measures used in studies tracking participants across the transition to parenthood. Following this, we aim to provide a quantitative summary of effects from studies adopting similar methodologies and possible moderation effects (Rosenthal, 1984) by conducting a meta-analysis of the strength of associations between prenatal thoughts and feelings about the unborn infant and observed parenting quality in the first years of life.

Section snippets

Assessing expectant parents’ thoughts and feelings about their unborn infants

Fonagy, Steele, Moran, Steele, and Higgit (1993) found that expectant mothers’ representations of their own caregivers predicted their infants’ attachment security at age 12 and 18 months. Building on this seminal study, other investigators (e.g., Korja et al., 2010) have examined whether parents’ representations of their children (rather than their own caregivers) might provide a more direct predictor of the quality of parent-child interactions and child outcomes. To this end, researchers have

Measuring parenting in the postnatal period

Infancy is a time of rapid development in multiple domains and so parents’ ability to tune into and respond appropriately to infant cues is a particularly salient construct to consider in early childhood. Illustrating the centrality of parental sensitivity for infants’ development (beyond simply considering infant attachment security), recent evidence demonstrates associations with variation in children’s memory, problem solving, language and social skills (Mills-Koonce et al., 2015). It is

Are expectant parents’ thoughts and feelings about their unborn infant associated with the quality of postnatal parenting?

A substantial body of research has identified parental characteristics as a key determinant of parenting quality (Belsky, 1984). Evidence to support this view comes from findings that parenting shows robust associations with variation in mental-health (Murray, Fearon, & Cooper, 2015), personality (Desjardins, Zelenski, & Coplan, 2008) and efficacy (Barnett, Deng, Mills-Koonce, Willoughby, & Cox, 2008). To date however, researchers have rarely considered prenatal thoughts and feelings about the

Moderating effects of sample characteristics and methodological contrasts

Beyond improving the reliability of study findings, meta-analyses also offer a valuable opportunity to establish whether methodological and sample characteristics influence the strength of associations. As outlined above, investigations of associations between prenatal thoughts and feelings about the unborn infant and postnatal parenting have adopted different designs, used distinct methods and drawn on different samples. As a guide to future research in this field, our meta-analysis therefore

Summary of main aims

In order to encourage evidence-based decision-making and practice for both parents and clinicians, the current review aimed to integrate the findings from empirical studies of the association between expectant parents’ thoughts and feelings about the unborn infant and their observed postnatal parenting. To this end, the first main study goal was to conduct a meta-analytic investigation of whether expectant parents’ thoughts and feelings about the unborn infant show meaningful associations with

Search strategy

A literature search was conducted for studies examining the predictive quality of expectant parents’ thoughts and feelings about the unborn infant and postnatal observed parenting using electronic databases, including Scopus, EBSCOhost (PsychINFO, Child and Adolescent Studies and PsychArticles) and WorldCat (theses), between January 2016 and August 2016. The references of the final papers were also checked and authors of the papers subject to the full-paper screen were contacted to ask if they

Results

Table 1 summarise the characteristics of the 14 samples, that together included 1862 parents (n = 1109 mothers, Mage = 28.69, SD = 3.61 years; n = 753 fathers, Mage = 34.50, SD = 0.71 years) and their children (Mage = 9.46, SD = 12.52 months). The majority of studies used samples of mothers (k = 10) and studies typically took place in Europe (k = 8) although North America (k = 4), Australia (k = 1) and South America (k = 1) were also represented. The samples were typically recruited from

Overall effect: Do measures of expectant parents’ thoughts and feelings about the unborn infant relate to postnatal observed parenting?

To calculate the overall strength and significance of the association between prenatal thoughts and feelings about the unborn infant and postnatal parenting, a random-effects model weighted by the inverse variance was used. The weighted mean effect size (r) across the 14 independent correlations was 0.24, 95%CI [0.10, 0.38] (see the Forest Plot in Fig. 2). Although modest, this effect size is significantly greater than zero, Z = 3.40, p < .001 (see Table 3).

Discussion

A focus on pregnancy and maternal antenatal care is a key strategy for achieving the third United Nations (2015) Sustainable Development Goal to ensure healthy lives and promote lifelong wellbeing. For policy-makers interested in the determinants of positive parenting, pregnancy provides a valuable window of opportunity for interventions. The main goal of the current study was to test whether variation in expectant parents’ thoughts and feelings about the unborn infant predicted individual

Acknowledgments

We would like to thank Amanda Aldercotte for statistical advice along with her assistance with reliability coding and Rory T. Devine for statistical advice.

References (104)

  • M. Ainsworth et al.

    Attachment, exploration, and separation: Illustrated by the behavior of one-year-olds in a strange situation

    Child Development

    (1970)
  • M. Ainsworth et al.

    Infant-mother attachment and social development

  • M. Ammaniti et al.

    Maternité et grossesse [Maternity and pregnancy]

    (1999)
  • K. Barnard

    Nursing child assessment training: Learning resource manual

    (1978)
  • M. Barnett et al.

    Interdependence of parenting of mothers and fathers of infants

    Journal of Family Psychology

    (2008)
  • J. Belsky

    The determinants of parenting: A process model

    Child Development

    (1984)
  • D. Benoit et al.

    Mothers' representations of their infants assessed prenatally: Stability and association with infants' attachment classifications

    Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines

    (1997)
  • M. Borenstein et al.

    Introduction to meta-analysis

    (2009)
  • M.H. Bornstein et al.

    Maternal responsiveness to young children at three ages: Longitudinal analysis of a multidimensional, modular, and specific parenting construct

    Developmental Psychology

    (2008)
  • Bowlby, J. (1969). Attachment and Loss: Vol. 1. Attachment. New York: Basic...
  • E.T. Bronfman et al.

    Atypical Maternal Behavior Instrument for Assessment and Classification (AMBIANCE)

    (1999, 2001)
  • Bullock, B., & Dishion, T. (2004). Family Affective Attitude Rating Scale...
  • S. Cairo et al.

    Family interactions in IVF families: Change over the transition to parenthood

    Journal of Reproductive and Infant Psychology

    (2012)
  • A. Caspi et al.

    Maternal expressed emotion predicts children's antisocial behaviour problems: Using monozygotic-twin differences to identify environmental effects on behavioural development

    Developmental Psychology

    (2004)
  • I. Chatoor et al.

    A feeding scale for research and clinical practice to assess mother-infant interactions in the first three years of life

    Infant Mental Health Journal

    (1997)
  • M. Chrzan-Dętkoś et al.

    Maternal romantic attachment, and antenatal and postnatal mother–infant attachment in a sample of Polish women

    European Journal of Developmental Psychology

    (2015)
  • J. Condon

    The assessment of antenatal emotional attachment: Development of a questionnaire instrument

    British Journal of Medical Psychology

    (1993)
  • M. Cranley

    Development of a tool for the measurement of maternal attachment during pregnancy

    MS Nursing Research

    (1981)
  • A. Crawford et al.

    Caregivers' disrupted representations of the unborn child predict later infant-caregiver disorganized attachment and disrupted interactions

    Infant Mental Health Journal

    (2009)
  • P.M. Crittenden

    Abusing, neglecting, problematic and adequate dyads: Differentiating by patterns of interaction

    Merrill-Palmer Quarterly

    (1981)
  • P. Crittenden

    CARE-index manual

    (2001)
  • D. Daley et al.

    Assessing expressed emotion in mothers of preschool AD/HD children: Psychometric properties of a modified speech sample

    British Journal of Clinical Psychology

    (2003)
  • E. de Cock et al.

    Continuous feelings of love? The parental bond from pregnancy to toddlerhood

    Journal of Family Psychology

    (2016)
  • S. Downs et al.

    The feasibility of creating a checklist for the assessment of the methodological quality both of randomized and non-randomized studies of health care interventions

    Journal of Epidemiology Community Health

    (1998)
  • R. Duschinsky

    Disorganization, fear and attachment: Working towards clarification

    Infant Mental Health Journal

    (2018)
  • B.R. Egeland et al.

    24 months coding manual: Project STEEP - revised 1990 from mother-child project scales

    (1990)
  • P. Ellis

    The essential guide to effect sizes: Statistical power, meta-analysis, and the interpretation of research results

    (2010)
  • J. Endendijk et al.

    Gender-differentiated parenting revisited: Meta-analysis reveals very few differences in parental control of boys and girls

    PLoS ONE

    (2016)
  • N. Favez et al.

    The family alliance assessment scales: Steps toward validity and reliability of an observational assessment tool for early family interactions

    Journal of Child and Family Studies

    (2011)
  • A. Field et al.

    How to do a meta-analysis

    British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology

    (2010)
  • S. Foley

    Emerging parental sensitivity: The transition to parenthood through the lens of family systems theory

    (2018)
  • P. Fonagy et al.

    Measuring the ghost in the nursery: An empirical study of the relation between parents' mental representations of childhood experiences and their infants' security of attachment

    Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association

    (1993)
  • P. Fonagy et al.

    The capacity for understanding mental states: The reflective self in parent and child and its significance for security of attachment

    Infant Mental Health Journal

    (1991)
  • J. Fuller

    Early patterns of maternal attachment

    Health Care for Women International

    (1990)
  • J. Gipson et al.

    The effects of unintended pregnancy on infant, child, and parental health: A review of the literature

    Studies in Family Planning

    (2008)
  • J. Grusec et al.

    Integrating different perspectives on socialization theory and research: A domain-specific approach

    Child Development

    (2010)
  • L. Hedges

    Meta-analysis

    Journal of Educational Statistics

    (1992)
  • J. Henrich et al.

    The weirdest people in the world?

    Behavioral and Brain Sciences

    (2010)
  • C. Hughes et al.

    For better or for worse? Positive and negative parentful influences on young children's executive function

    Child Development

    (2017)
  • J. Ives

    Men, maternity and moral residue: negotiating the moral demands of the transition to first time fatherhood

    Sociology of Health & Illness

    (2014)
  • Cited by (58)

    • Narrative coherence across the transition to parenthood: Primiparous parents' representations of their child in relation to parental sensitivity

      2022, Acta Psychologica
      Citation Excerpt :

      Importantly, parents already form mental representations about their child during pregnancy (Glover & Capron, 2017), that may shape their views of their child once they are born and possibly change over time as they gain experience with their child. A recent meta-analysis demonstrated that parents' prenatal representations of their child are related to their postnatal sensitivity (Foley & Hughes, 2018). However, parents' narrative coherence as a specific form of parental representations relevant to attachment theory has only been examined once prenatally (Foley et al., 2019) – and even though this study demonstrated that it is possible to capture individual differences in both mothers' and fathers' narrative coherence during pregnancy, it remains unclear how it develops across the transition to parenthood and to what extent prenatal narrative coherence is related to postnatal narrative coherence as well as parental sensitivity.

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text