‘Understanding Disability’: Evaluating a contact-based approach to enhancing attitudes and disability literacy of medical students

doi:10.1016/j.dhjo.2018.07.007

Disability and Health Journal

Volume 12, Issue 1, January 2019, Pages 65-71

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dhjo.2018.07.007 Get rights and content

Abstract

Background

Health disparities and disparities in the provision of healthcare to people with disabilities remains a topic of concern. Research demonstrates that attitudes of healthcare providers contribute to this disparity. The approach to disability education and training in medical school warrants evaluation.

Objectives

This study sought to investigate the efficacy of an educational intervention in cultivating positive attitudes towards disability in medical students, and determine the specific impact of an interaction-based hospital visit to patients undergoing neurological rehabilitation.

Methods

Web-based questionnaires were distributed to medical students undertaking a 12-week ‘Understanding Disability’ module. Measures of anxiety, attitude, competency and empathy were obtained from 65 students at the beginning (T1), middle (T2) and end (T3) of the module. At T2, approximately half of the students had completed a hospital visit and half had not.

Results

Scores changed significantly across all constructs between the beginning and end of the module suggesting a positive overall module effect. Findings confirmed a significant difference in anxiety and empathy levels between the group of students who had completed the visit to the rehabilitation hospital by the middle survey wave and those who had not, indicating a specific placement effect.

Conclusions

Our findings suggest that interpersonal contact with individuals with disabilities has a distinct impact on the affective variables of anxiety and empathy. Previous research suggests that this contributes towards improved attitudes to disability. Overall, we provide strong evidence for the inclusion of contact-based educational interventions in medical school to enhance students' attitudes to disability.

Section snippets

Theoretical framework

The assumptions of the intergroup contact hypothesis¹⁷ align with the theoretical framework of this research. Originally developed and tested from field research in the context of prejudice between interracial groups, the intergroup contact hypothesis stipulates that contact with individuals from a different social group or ‘outgroup’ may result in improved attitudes and reduced prejudice towards the group in question. The three most commonly tested mediators of this relationship have been

Design

A quasi-experimental longitudinal design was selected for the purpose of this study. Students were asked to complete an online survey at the beginning (T1), middle (T2) and end (T3) of their ‘Understanding Disability’ module. A two-way mixed ANOVA facilitated the investigation of a time effect (impact of overall module across the three time periods), a group effect (impact of hospital visit/associated follow-up at T2 when half the students had completed the hospital placement and half had not)

Results

A two-way mixed ANOVA with independent variables of group (Group A and Group B) and time (T1, T2 and T3) was conducted on the four dependent variables of anxiety, attitude, competency and empathy to determine the efficacy of the overall module and to explore the specific impact of the hospital visit. As per the theoretical background of the study, it is hypothesised that a change in anxiety, competency and empathy scores ultimately contribute to improved attitudes to disability. The data

Discussion

The objective of this study was to evaluate the efficacy of a contact-based educational intervention for medical students that combined taught elements of disability education with direct experience/interaction with patients with disabilities. Ultimately it was hypothesised that this contact-based approach would cultivate positive attitudes towards this patient group - a fundamental step towards reducing the healthcare disparities experienced by people with disabilities today. Our findings

Conclusion

Our findings provide robust evidence for a contact-based approach to disability education in medical school. Over the course of the module, students demonstrated improved attitude, anxiety, competency and empathy. Direct contact with patients with disabilities had a specific impact on medical students' levels of anxiety and empathy. It is widely recommended that this approach to disability education is implemented across medical schools nationwide, and that accreditation standards for

Source of funding

This study was completed without funding.

Conflicts of interest

The authors report no conflicts of interest.

References (37)

P. Heslop et al.
The Confidential Inquiry into premature deaths of people with intellectual disabilities in the UK: a population-based study
Lancet
(2014)
R.C. Tervo et al.
Medical students' attitudes toward persons with disability: a comparative study
Arch PM&R (Phys Med Rehabil)
(2002)
J.A. Seccombe
Attitudes towards disability in an undergraduate nursing curriculum: the effects of a curriculum change
Nurse Educ Today
(2007)
M.J. Paris
Attitudes of medical students and health-care professionals toward people with disabilities
Arch PM&R (Phys Med Rehabil)
(1993)
T. Shakespeare et al.
Disability and the training of health professionals
Lancet
(2009)
A. Officer et al.
Key concepts in disability
Lancet
(2009)
W.G. Stephan et al.
The role of ignorance in intergroup relations
A.B. Symons et al.
A curriculum on care for people with disabilities: effects on medical student self-reported attitudes and comfort level
Disabil Health J
(2014)
R.C. Tervo et al.
Medical students' attitudes toward persons with disability: a comparative study
Arch Phys Med Rehabil
(2002)
L.I. Iezzoni
Eliminating health and health care disparities among the growing population of people with disabilities
Health Aff
(2011)

Organization WH

International classification of functioning, disability and health

(2001)

G.L. Krahn et al.

Persons with disabilities as an unrecognized health disparity population

AJPH (Am J Public Health)

(2015)

L.J. Woodard et al.

An innovative clerkship module focused on patients with disabilities

Acad Med

(2012)

J. Sanchez et al.

Perceived accessibility versus actual physical accessibility of healthcare facilities

Rehabil Nurs: the official journal of the Association of Rehabilitation Nurses

(2000)

M. Byron et al.

Educating health professionals about disability: 'attitudes, attitudes, attitudes'

J R Soc Med

(2000)

W.H. Organisation

World Report on Disability

(2011)

L. Kraus

2016 Disability Statistics Annual Report

(2017)

I. Basnett

Healthcare professionals and their attitudes toward and decisions affecting disabled people

Cited by (21)

Disability training for health workers: A global evidence synthesis
2022, Disability and Health Journal
Health worker training on disability is a recognized component of achieving high standards of health for people with disabilities, given that health worker’s lack of knowledge, stigma, and negative attitudes towards people with disabilities act as barriers to high quality health care.
To understand the published literature on training health workers about disability.
We searched five databases for relevant peer-reviewed articles published between January 2012 and January 2021. Studies that focused on training health care workers to improve knowledge, confidence, self-efficacy, and competence to support people with physical, sensory, or intellectual impairments were included. Data about the details of the intervention (setting, participants, format, impact assessments, etc.) and its effects were extracted.
There is an array of highly local tools to train health workers across stages of their training and careers (preservice, in-service, and continuing professional development). Studies involving people with disabilities in the training, community placements, simulations, or interactive sessions were found to be most effective in improving knowledge, confidence, competency, and self-efficacy.
As part of initiatives to build inclusive health systems and improve health outcomes for people with disabilities, health workers around the world need to receive appropriate and evidence-based training that combines multiple methods and involves people with disabilities. To monitor progress on the impact of training, there should also be a standardized measure of impact on core outcomes.
Explicit and implicit disability attitudes of occupational and physical therapy assistants
2022, Disability and Health Journal
Reduction of explicit and implicit bias in healthcare providers is a critical issue faced by our society in moving toward more equitable and culturally appropriate health and rehabilitation care. Because resources for OT and PT services are limited and shortages in these professions exist, direct care provision by occupational and physical therapist assistants (OTA/PTA) is on the rise and valued in comprehensive rehabilitation practice. It is important to consider attitudes and biases of OTA/PTA, as they are directly involved in provision of rehabilitation services for people with disabilities.
This study examined the explicit and implicit disability attitudes of a large cross-section of OTA/PTA.
Secondary data analysis was completed using data from 6113 OTA/PTA from the Project Implicit Disability Attitudes Implicit Association Test. Implicit attitudes were calculated and OTA/PTA explicit and implicit disability attitudes were compared. Results were further categorized using an adapted version of Son Hing et al.‘s two-dimensional model of prejudice.
Findings revealed the majority of OTA/PTA reported having no explicit preference for people with disabilities or nondisabled people. However, the majority of OTA/PTA were aversive ableists, indicating low explicit and high implicit bias.
Though explicit bias is lower in OTA/PTA, implicit bias is strong, indicating that people with disabilities face bias that may influence clinical interactions, and may be reproduced in professional education, practice, and policy. Concrete action must be taken to recognize and address disability bias to reduce health disparities in people with disabilities.
Disability-competence training influences health care providers’ conceptualizations of disability: An evaluation study
2021, Disability and Health Journal
Citation Excerpt :
Less tangible barriers such as negative provider attitudes, stigma, and inaccessible methods of communication also impede access to care.11,12 These types of obstacles can negatively affect the willingness of patients with disabilities to seek preventive care,13 erode their trust in providers’ ability to understand their health needs,14 and poorly impact their health outcomes.7 Often, health care providers’ approach to people with disabilities is grounded in a medical model perspective, in which disability itself and not the presenting problem is seen as a condition to fix or an outcome to avoid.15
Often, health care providers’ approach to people with disabilities is grounded in a medical model perspective. This view highlights individual deficits and does not foster patient-centeredness. Learning about and adopting a more social model, focused on creating accessible and inclusive approaches and environments, could help providers to reshape their attitudes about disability, dismantling barriers to care.
This study used innovative methods to evaluate a recorded, online disability-competence training for health care providers. It was hypothesized that the training would 1) shift providers’ conceptualizations of disability away from a medical model view toward a social model view of disability and 2) equip providers with actionable strategies to improve access to care for people with disabilities.
Quantitative and qualitative evaluation data were analyzed for n = 192 training participants. Measures included participants’ pre- and post-training conceptualizations of disability, proposed actions steps to facilitate patient-centered care, and measures of satisfaction and self-assessed knowledge gain.
Both hypotheses were supported. After the training, participants’ conceptualizations of disability were more reflective of the social model, and participants were better able to articulate specific action steps they could take to promote accessible, responsive care.
This study demonstrates that health care provider training can positively affect providers’ knowledge, outlook, and approach to caring for people with disabilities. Its findings can inform broader efforts aimed at systematically changing the way health professionals are educated and trained to provide care in disability-competent ways.
Evaluating the longitudinal impact of a disability education intervention on medical students’ attitudes towards persons with a disability
2021, Disability and Health Journal
Citation Excerpt :
Medical students’ attitudes towards persons with a disability are likely to develop during their training, influencing their future practice as qualified medical practitioners. It is imperative that their training is evaluated and designed to cultivate compassionate and empathic practitioners that are capable of providing high quality care to people with disabilities.14 Therefore, effective disability education interventions designed to improve negative attitudes towards persons with a disability and increase empathy levels of future medical professionals may contribute to overcoming these challenges.
The attitudes and empathy levels of healthcare providers towards persons with a disability have been highlighted as important factors contributing to the quality of healthcare provided to this patient population.
This study aimed to investigate whether changes in medical students’ attitudes and empathy towards persons with a disability following an educational intervention were maintained when measured again one year post intervention. This study provided a one year longitudinal follow up to a previous study investigating the efficacy of an educational intervention to cultivate positive change in empathy levels and attitudes towards disability.
An online survey was distributed to medical students who had completed a disability module one year previously during their second year of medical training. The survey comprised measures of attitude, empathy and level of social contact with persons with a disability.
Though there was a statistically significant increase in both attitude and empathy measures immediately post intervention, these gains were not sustained when measured one year later. In the case of empathy, levels measured one year later had decreased significantly from baseline measures at pretest. No significant relationship was observed between level of social contact and measures of attitudes and empathy.
While previous research suggests that the educational intervention has been successful in ameliorating both attitudes and empathy levels in the short term, this study highlights the difficulty in sustaining such improvements. Changes to the design and delivery of educational interventions may be necessary for the benefits to persist into the long term.
Getting comfortable with disability: The short- and long-term effects of a clinical encounter
2021, Disability and Health Journal
Physicians report discomfort when interacting with patients with disabilities, which can negatively impact the quality of healthcare they provide.
An intervention structured around a formative clinical encounter was assessed for its effectiveness in changing comfort towards treating patients with disabilities. It was predicted that this encounter would have a positive short- and long-term impact on medical students.
During the 2017–2018 academic year, 169 third-year medical students conducted a patient encounter with a person who had a disability. Students met individually with the “patient” and completed a brief social and medical history as if they were meeting a new patient to establish care. A measure of perceived comfort caring for patients with disabilities was administered to students before and after the encounter. One year after the patient encounter, 59 students were surveyed about their satisfaction and the impact of the patient encounter.
The impact of encountering people with disabilities in a clinical setting was positive, with statistically significant improvements across all items on the measure of perceived comfort. Students were highly satisfied with the experience and anticipated feeling more confident, more comfortable, less awkward, and more skilled and efficacious when encountering a person with a disability in their future practice. A thematic analysis of the one year follow-up data suggest that students valued the encounter and desired more content on disability throughout their education.
Medical education should include dedicated exposure to persons with disabilities and a simulated patient experience allowing for a safe environment to gain skills and confidence.
Co-development of a training programme on disability for healthcare workers in Uganda
2024, BMC Health Services Research

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Original Article‘Understanding Disability’: Evaluating a contact-based approach to enhancing attitudes and disability literacy of medical students

Abstract

Background

Objectives

Methods

Results

Conclusions

Section snippets

Theoretical framework

Design

Results

Discussion

Conclusion

Source of funding

Conflicts of interest

Lancet

Arch PM&R (Phys Med Rehabil)

Nurse Educ Today

Arch PM&R (Phys Med Rehabil)

Lancet

Lancet

Disabil Health J

Arch Phys Med Rehabil

Eliminating health and health care disparities among the growing population of people with disabilities

Health Aff

International classification of functioning, disability and health

Persons with disabilities as an unrecognized health disparity population

AJPH (Am J Public Health)

An innovative clerkship module focused on patients with disabilities

Acad Med

Perceived accessibility versus actual physical accessibility of healthcare facilities

Rehabil Nurs: the official journal of the Association of Rehabilitation Nurses

Educating health professionals about disability: 'attitudes, attitudes, attitudes'

J R Soc Med

World Report on Disability

2016 Disability Statistics Annual Report

Healthcare professionals and their attitudes toward and decisions affecting disabled people

Original Article
‘Understanding Disability’: Evaluating a contact-based approach to enhancing attitudes and disability literacy of medical students