Tremor in Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease: No evidence of cerebellar dysfunction

Highlights

• This is the first pathophysiological study of tremor in hereditary neuropathies.

• This study reveals features that distinguish it from other forms of tremor, in particular the finding of a normally functioning cerebellum.

• ‘Neuropathic tremor’ is for the first time distinguished from other types of neuropathic tremor on the basis of mechanism, reframing this movement disorder as aetiologically heterogenous.

Abstract

Objectives

Tremor in Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (CMT) can be disabling. Cerebellar abnormalities are thought to underpin neuropathic tremor. Here, we aim to clarify the potential role of the cerebellum in CMT tremor.

Methods

We assessed prevalence of tremor by questionnaire in 84 patients with CMT. Of those, 23 patients with CMT with and without arm tremor and healthy controls underwent a clinical assessment, classical eyeblink conditioning, electro-oculography, visuomotor adaptation test, tremor recording with surface EMG and accelerometry, and retrospective correlation with nerve conduction studies to investigate the possible mechanisms of tremor generation.

Results

The prevalence study revealed tremor in 21% of patients and in 42% of those it caused impairment of function. Tremor recordings revealed a mild-to-moderate amplitude tremor with a weight load-invariant 7.7 Hz frequency component. Performance on classical eyeblink conditioning, visuomotor adaptation and electro-oculography were no different between tremulous and non-tremulous patients and healthy controls.

Conclusions

These results argue against a prominent role for an abnormal cerebellum in tremor generation in the patients studied with CMT. Rather, our results suggest an enhancement of the central neurogenic component of physiological tremor as a possible mechanism for tremor in the patients studied.

Significance

This study is the first to propose differing pathogenic mechanisms for subtypes of neuropathic tremor.

Introduction

Tremor can occur as part of Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (CMT) due to a variety of mutations. In paediatric CMT, tremor is one of the most disabling symptoms (Burns et al., 2010) and also predicts other disabling symptoms (Blyton et al., 2011). The mechanisms that give rise to this tremor is not known although various hypotheses have been postulated (Barbieri et al., 1984, Cardoso and Jankovic, 1993). Cerebellar dysfunction is one hypothesis, as has been shown for tremor in inflammatory neuropathies (Bain et al., 1996, Brooks et al., 1992, Saifee et al., 2013, Schwingenschuh et al., 2013). Co-existence of essential tremor has also been considered, where cerebellar dysfunction would also be expected. Another possibility is fatigue causing entrainment of motor units resulting in an enhanced physiological tremor (Elble and Randall, 1978, Stiles, 1976, Stiles, 1980, Young and Hagbarth, 1980). Fatigue is commonly recognised in CMT and represents an important outcome measure in clinical trials (Pareyson et al., 2011). Understanding tremor mechanisms is important as little is known about treating tremor in CMT, why only some patients seem predisposed and why it predicts other disabling symptoms.

Here we investigate clinical and pathophysiological aspects of the tremor associated with CMT, with an emphasis on techniques sensitive to cerebellar dysfunction such as eyeblink classical conditioning (EBCC) (Christian and Thompson, 2003, De Zeeuw and Yeo, 2005, Linden, 2003, Yeo and Hesslow, 1998), visuomotor adaptation (Galea et al., 2011) and eye movement recording (Helmchen et al., 2003). We hypothesise that these should be abnormal if the cerebellum is functioning abnormally or entrained in a pathological network in tremor in CMT.