Application of nanofibers to improve the filtration efficiency of the most penetrating aerosol particles in fibrous filters

Abstract

Conventional, mechanical fibrous filters made of microfibers exhibit a local minimum of fractional collection efficiency in the aerosol particle size-range between 100 and 500 nm, which is called the most penetrating particle size (MPPS). Simple theoretical calculations predict that this efficiency may be significantly increased using nanofibrous media. The main objective of this paper is an experimental verification of these expectations and simultaneously checking whether this anticipated gain in the filtration efficiency is not overpaid with an excessive pressure drop. For this purpose we developed a modified melt-blown technology, which allowed us to produce filters composed of micrometer as well as nanometer sized fibers. One conventional microfibrous filter and five nanofibrous filters were examined. The complete structural characteristics, pressure drop and efficiency of removal of aerosol particles with diameters 10–500 nm were determined for all media. The results of the experiments confirmed that using nanofibrous filters a significant growth of filtration efficiency for the MPPS range can be achieved and the pressure drop rises moderately. Simultaneously, we noticed a shift of the MPPS towards smaller particles. Consequently, the quality factor for bilayer systems composed of a microfibrous support and a nanofibrous facial layer was considerably higher than this one for a conventional microfibrous filter alone. Additionally, it was found that utilization of many-layer nanofibrous filters combined with a single microfibrous backing layer is even more profitable from the quality factor standpoint. Comparing experimental results with theoretical calculations based on the single-fiber theory we concluded that for microfibrous filters a fairly good agreement can be obtained if the resistance-equivalent fiber diameter is used in calculations instead of the mean count diameter determined from the SEM images analysis; in the latter case, filtration efficiency computed theoretically is slightly overestimated. This is even more evident for nanofibrous media, suggesting that in such case a structural filter inhomogeneity has a strong influence on the filter efficiency and its resistance and one should strive for minimization of this effect manufacturing nanofibrous filters as homogeneous as possible. We can finally conclude that fibrous filters containing nanofibers, which are produced using the melt-blown technique, are very promising and economic tools to enhance filtration of the most penetrating aerosol particles.

Introduction

Fibrous filters are typically manufactured with the fibers of diameters about a few dozen micrometers, and the filter porosity is usually 80–90%. Such structure allows removing submicrometer and micrometer particles with a high efficiency, maintaining a relatively low resistance to the air flow. However, there is the size-range of the particles that are not filtered out as efficiently as other particles. The fibrous filter efficiency achieves a minimum at so-called the most penetrating particle size (MPPS), which is usually between 0.1 and $0.5\mathrm{\mu }\mathrm{m}$ for mechanical filters. Theoretical predictions and preliminary investigations indicate that significant increase of the filter efficiency for the MPPS, accompanied by only a slight rise of the pressure drop, may be achieved by using the nanometer fibers to produce the fibrous filters (Hinds, 1999, Grafe et al., 2001). Nomenclature concerning objects with the size of nanometers is still not clearly defined and may be somewhat confusing. In the case of particles, these that have diameter smaller than $0.1\mathrm{\mu }\mathrm{m}$ (100 nm) are considered as nanoparticles (Aitken et al., 2004). However, some authors define the term “nanoparticles” in a different manner, limiting the upper size of nanoparticles to 50 nm (Hinds, 1999) or even 40 nm (ISO, 2004). Contrary to these definitions, as “nanofibers” generally fibers with diameter less than $1\mathrm{\mu }\mathrm{m}$ are considered (Grafe et al., 2001, Graham et al., 2002). In this paper, the filters that have at least some fraction of fibers with diameter below $1\mathrm{\mu }\mathrm{m}$ will be called “nanofibrous medium”.

Nanofibers are characterized by a very large surface area to volume ratio, which significantly increases the probability of the aerosol particles deposition on the fiber surface and thereby improves the filter efficiency (Huang et al., 2003, Park and Park, 2005). Filters composed of nanofibers provide high filtration efficiency of the particles with the MPPS at relatively low pressure drops.

In addition to a large surface area to volume ratio, the nanofibrous media have low basis weight, high permeability, and tight pore size that make them appropriate for a wide range of filtration applications. There are three major processes for producing nanofibers for filtration media: electrostatic spinning, melt-blown technique, and multicomponent fiber spinning or the ‘islands-in-the sea’ method (Ward, 2005). Currently, the nanofibers are mostly produced using electrospinning technology. The fibers made by electrospinning have in general diameter in the range $0.04–2\mathrm{\mu }\mathrm{m}$ (Grafe and Graham, 2002, Kosmider and Scott, 2002, Park and Park, 2005); however, it may be found in the literature that using electrospinning method fibers less than 3 nm can be produced (Huang et al., 2003). The diameter of the fibers depends, among other things, on the polymer solution concentration. The thinner fibers may be achieved using less concentrate solution. However, decrease of the solution concentration increases the amount of hazardous vapors emitted from electrospinning solution while forming the fibers that need to be recovered or disposed of, and this involves additional equipment and cost (Jaroszczyk et al., 2005). The drawbacks of this process, besides the hazardous vapors emission, are that the production rate is very slow, thus the product is expensive (Jaroszczyk et al., 2005, Kalayci et al., 2005), some polymers are difficult to dissolve (Ward, 2005), the fiber diameters obtained are seldom uniform (Demir et al., 2002), and nanofibers may have defects like beads and pores (Huang et al., 2003).

Electrospun fibers have diameters smaller than that of melt-blown fibers; however, currently there are investigations aimed at improving of the latter technique to produce nanofibers. The melt-blown technique may allow making large quantities of such fibers at low cost, which will considerably increase their commercial applications.

In our study the filters containing fibers of diameter as small as $0.2\mathrm{\mu }\mathrm{m}$ were manufactured by the melt-blown method. Since nanofibrous media have weak mechanical properties, they were used with additional microfibrous support. We investigated the performance of self-manufactured filters composed of the fibers, which some fraction had diameter below $1\mathrm{\mu }\mathrm{m}$ (nanofibrous filters). The filtration efficiencies of the sets of microfibrous filter covered by layer of nanofibrous media were tested against liquid particles with diameter from 10 to 500 nm.