Adolescents' fMRI activation to a response inhibition task predicts future substance use

Abstract

Background

Deficient behavioral regulation may be a risk factor for substance use disorders in adolescents. Abnormalities in brain regions critical to cognitive control have been linked to more intense and problematic future substance use (e.g., Durazzo, Gazdzinski, Mon, & Meyerhoff, 2010; Falk, Berkman, Whalen, & Lieberman, 2011; Paulus, Tapert, & Schuckit, 2005). The goal of this study was to examine the degree to which brain response to an inhibition task measured in mid-adolescence can predict substance use 18 months later.

Method

Adolescents aged 16–19 (N = 80) performed a go/no-go response inhibition task during fMRI at project baseline, and were followed 18 months later with a detailed interview on substance use and dependence symptoms. Participants were 39 high frequency users and 41 demographically similar low frequency users (458 versus 2 average lifetime drug use occasions at baseline, respectively).

Results

Across all subjects, no-go trials produced significant increases in neural response in the ventromedial prefrontal cortex and a region including the left angular and supramarginal gyri (p(FWE) < .01, cluster threshold ≥ 30 voxels). Less ventromedial prefrontal activation but more left angular gyrus activation predicted higher levels of substance use and dependence symptoms in the following 18 months, particularly for those who were high frequency users in mid-adolescence (p < .05).

Conclusions

These findings are consistent with studies showing that impairments in cognitive control have strong associations with substance use. We found a predictive relationship between atypical activation patterns at baseline and substance use behavior 18 months later, particularly among adolescents with histories of previous heavy use.

Introduction

Experimentation with drugs and alcohol is quite common during adolescence. Spanning the years from 8th grade to 12th grade, the proportion of youth reporting recent use of an illicit drug increases from 10% to 24% (Johnston, O'Malley, Bachman, & Schulenberg, 2010). Prevalence of recent drinking to intoxication similarly rises from 5% to 27% across the same time frame (Johnston et al., 2010). Among young adults ages 18–25, over 15% meet criteria for alcohol or drug abuse or dependence (Substance Abuse & Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) (SAMHSA), 2010). Given the detrimental functional and social consequences of substance use disorders, identifying which youth are particularly susceptible to dependence is of great clinical significance. Research that isolates predictors of future substance use problems can refine the etiology of addictive behaviors and point to potential targets and strategies for early intervention.

A number of studies have used longitudinal and cross-sectional methods to identify risk factors for developing substance use disorders in mid to late adolescence. Psychiatric disorders (e.g., conduct disorder, attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder) (Boyle et al., 1992, Elkins et al., 2007), personality factors (e.g., novelty seeking, harm avoidance) (Mâsse & Tremblay, 1997), genetic characteristics (e.g., hypodopaminergic genotypes) (Conner, Hellemann, Ritchie, & Noble, 2010), and cognitive ability (e.g., executive functioning) (Nigg et al., 2006, Tarter et al., 2003) have all been implicated as predictors for alcohol and illicit drug use in adolescence. However, research focusing on brain-behavior relationships to elucidate the neurocognitive correlates of substance use risk is limited.

Recently, some researchers have used neuroimaging (Durazzo, Gazdzinski, Mon, & Meyerhoff, 2010), and functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) in particular, to help clarify the neural precursors of future substance-related behavior in adults. For example, Falk, Berkman, Whalen, and Lieberman (2011) found that medial prefrontal blood oxygen level dependent (BOLD) response during exposure to videos on smoking abstinence predicted subsequent reduction in cigarette use. Among cocaine users, greater fMRI response to a Stroop task in the ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC) predicted longer durations of abstinence (Brewer, Worhunsky, Carroll, Rounsaville, & Potenza, 2008) and, during a drug cue reactivity task, correlated with post-treatment cocaine urine toxicology (Kosten et al., 2006). Dampened neural response in right middle frontal regions during a decision-making task administered to methamphetamine users who were undergoing drug treatment predicted a higher probability of post-treatment relapse (Paulus, Tapert, & Schuckit, 2005).

Response inhibition, which is an executive functioning faculty of cognitive control, has shown strong associations with substance use disorders (Hester and Garavan, 2004, Lawrence et al., 2009, Verdejo-García et al., 2006). In addition, increasing evidence suggests that poor performance on measures of response inhibition and impulsivity indicate a vulnerability to substance use initiation and escalation (for a review, see (Verdejo-García, Lawrence, & Clark, 2008)). We recently examined differential BOLD responses to a go/no-go task in substance-naïve adolescents (ages 12-14); comparing 21 youth who initiated substance use in the subsequent three years to 17 youth who remained non to minimal users throughout adolescence (Norman et al., 2011). Those who went on to use substances had shown significantly less activation at baseline in 12 brain regions including and extending beyond typically observed inhibitory circuitry (Aron, 2007), particularly prefrontal regions.

The purpose of this study was to investigate whether certain characteristics of brain activation during response inhibition could predict future substance use in adolescents with a range of baseline use patterns. We employed a go/no-go task administered during fMRI to high and low frequency users, then longitudinally assessed the adolescents' alcohol and drug use for the subsequent 18 months. Given the importance of executive cognitive control in identifying vulnerability to substance use, we hypothesized that less prefrontal cortex activation during an inhibition task would predict more substance use and problems above and beyond substance use history up until the time of the imaging session.