The cerebellum and olfaction in the aging brain: a functional magnetic resonance imaging study

Abstract

The present study investigated activation of distinct cerebellar regions as a result of olfactory stimulation in healthy young and elderly adults using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI). Ten young and 10 elderly adults were imaged using a 1.5-TMR scanner. The odorant amyl acetate was delivered in 12-s on, 40-s off cycles. Throughout the scan participants responded with a button press at first detection of each stimulus interval followed by a second button press upon odorant extinction. Images were processed with AFNI software. Elderly participants showed significantly decreased cerebellar activation in both the superior semilunar lobule (Crus I) and the inferior semilunar lobule (Crus II), two of three previously identified regions of interest for odor processing, compared to young adults. Interestingly, both groups showed similar levels of activation in the third region of interest, the posterior quadrangular lobule (VI), although the elderly showed more variability than the young did. Previous research identifying this area to be involved in attention may reflect the possibility that elderly adults engaged in olfactory tasks may show more variability than young participants in the degree of attentional demands needed for these tasks as a result of decreased olfactory abilities.

Introduction

Changes in olfactory perception are characteristic of the aging process in healthy individuals. Psychophysical studies report impairment in odor threshold over the lifespan Murphy, 1993, Murphy, 1983, Schiffman, 1993 as well as deficits in odor identification Doty et al., 1984, Murphy and Cain, 1986, Murphy et al., 2002, Schiffman, 1977 and odor memory Murphy et al., 1991, Murphy et al., 1997. Aging is also related to structural changes in the brain, with elderly adults showing a significant loss of brain volume in temporal lobe structures and the cerebellum Jack et al., 1998, Jernigan et al., 2001. These findings have led to investigations of functional changes in the brain reflecting the observed decline in olfactory function seen in healthy aging. Using olfactory event-related potentials, researchers have found decreases in response amplitude and increases in response latency in the elderly, reflecting a weaker response to olfactory stimuli in the brains of elderly adults (Murphy et al., 2000). Brain imaging research has indicated reduced olfactory-related brain activation in the elderly within select areas of the olfactory network. Yousem and colleagues (1999) found that young adults show greater volumes of odorant-induced brain activation in various parts of the olfactory pathway including the perisylvian, inferior frontal, and superior frontal regions. Our laboratory has observed decreased activation in the elderly in these olfactory areas as well as in the orbital frontal cortex, frontal operculum, insula, and piriform cortex Cerf-Ducastel and Murphy, 2001, Wiser, et al., 2000. Although the precise mechanism by which this olfactory loss occurs is unknown, these studies imply that some areas of the olfactory network are more affected by the aging process than others.

Researchers employing brain imaging techniques to investigate the olfactory network have observed odorant-induced activation in the cerebellum Savic, and Gulyasz, 2000, Small et al., 1997, Sobel et al., 1998, Yousem et al., 1997, a structure traditionally associated with the motor system and more recently found to play a role in higher cognitive processes such as episodic memory (Andreasen et al., 1999). This olfactory-related activation has occurred in basic sensory tasks such as odor detection Small et al., 1997, Yousem et al., 1997 as well as in cognitively complex tasks such as odor recognition memory, discrimination of odor quality, and discrimination of odor intensity (Savic, 2001). To further understand the nature of this activation Sobel et al. (1998) performed functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) of the cerebellum during both pure olfactory and pure sniffing tasks. With this method the researchers were able to dissociate three cerebellar regions of interest (ROIs) involved in olfaction located primarily in the posterior lateral hemispheres: the posterior quadrangular lobule (VI), superior semilunar lobule (Crus I), and inferior semilunar lobule (Crus II) illustrated in Fig. 1. This paper has adopted the corresponding terminology used by Schmahmann et al., (2000), as shown in parentheses.

Taken together, the above findings indicate that olfactory ROIs in the cerebellum could be affected differentially in the aging process. The present study explores differences between young and elderly adults in odorant-induced brain activation of the cerebellar lobules VI, Crus I, and Crus II using fMRI.