Doctors expressions of uncertainty and patient confidence
Introduction
Uncertainty is central to medicine and is inherent in many medical encounters. Some research indicates that doctors ignore their uncertainty and prefer to present certainty in the presence of their patients. For example Katz [1] argued that doctors habitually suppress their uncertainty as a means to maintain patient confidence, Quill and Suchman [2] referred to an ‘illusion of certainty’ in medicine and Atkinson has suggested that doctors are trained for certainty and that their medical training makes uncertainty difficult to acknowledge [3]. Other research has explored how doctors can be encouraged to express their uncertainty. For example Fox [4] concluded from her study of medical education that medical students are trained to expect and manage uncertainty and Silver [5] argued that ‘uncertainty rather than certainty tends to be the norm’ (pp. 127–128). Further, Quill and Suchman [2] described how uncertainty could be shared with patients and Hewson et al. [6] presented steps for the strategic management of uncertainty and recommended acknowledging and discussing uncertainty with patients. This latter approach is in line with recent work on shared decision making, patient partnerships and patient centred consultations and highlights the sharing of uncertainty as a means to facilitate communication [7], [8], [9].
Therefore, much recent work has encouraged doctors to share their uncertainty with patients as a means to improve doctor patient relationships. However, the potential impact of doctors’ uncertainty on patients remains unclear. For example, Johnson et al. [10] asked patients to rate their satisfaction following a video tape of a simulated clinic visit. The results showed that patients reported most satisfaction when the doctor was the most certain and expressed most dissatisfaction when the doctor consulted a resource. This study indicates that expressing uncertainty is detrimental to the patient’s evaluation of the consultation. In contrast, Gordon et al. [11] analysed transcripts of consultations and showed that doctors expressed more uncertainty to patients with more education, who showed a greater desire for information and who asked more questions and that a greater number of expressions of uncertainty related to higher levels of satisfaction. This inconsistency in the literature may be explained either by the different methodologies used with one study focusing on a simulated consultation and the other analysing real consultation interactions or the use of different populations. An alternative explanation, however, relates to the operationalisation of uncertainty. Medical uncertainty is a complex phenomena and can vary along different dimensions. First, it can relate to different aspects of the consultation such as diagnosis and management with doctors at times feeling uncertain about what the patient’s problem is and at others feeling uncertain about treatment issues. Second, it can vary according the context in which it is expressed. For example uncertainty expressed within a first consultation will be experienced differently to when patients have become familiar with their doctor’s way of functioning. Further, the patient’s previous experiences of seeing this or other doctors and their personal characteristics such as age, sex and class may impact upon their reaction to medical uncertainty. Third, uncertainty can vary according to how it is expressed. For example Gordon et al. [11] focused on statements such as ‘I don’t know’ and ‘It’s not clear’ whereas Johnson et al. [10] used a wider definition which also included referring to source material. It is therefore possible that patient’s reactions to uncertainty are dependent upon which aspect of the consultation that the doctor is feeling uncertain about, the context within which the expression is located and the way in which uncertainty is expressed.
In summary, current writings in medicine therefore encourage the expression of uncertainty yet it remains unclear whether this would have a positive or detrimental impact upon the patient. The present study aimed to explore the impact of doctors’ expressions of uncertainty for a range of diagnostic and management aspects of the consultation. In particular, it first compared behavioural expressions such as using a book or a computer and referring to hospital with verbal expressions such as saying ‘I don’t know’ and ‘I’m not sure about this’ as a means to examine the impact of the ways in which the uncertainty was expressed. Doctors’ and patients’ beliefs about the impact of uncertainty were compared as a means to examine the degree of agreement between these two perspectives. Second, the study also explored the role of the patient’s personal characteristics and their previous experience of their current doctor as a means to address the issue of context. Furthermore, the study examined the impact of both type of expression and context on patient confidence as this is the outcome both implicitly and explicitly deemed to be influenced by doctors’ willingness or unwillingness to reveal their fallibility [3], [4].
Section snippets
Participants
A cross-sectional design was used with comparisons made between GPs and patients and correlations made within the patient group. Questionnaires were distributed to consecutive patients (n=600) from six general practices in the south-east of England (London n=3; Sussex n=1; Essex n=1; Middlesex n=1). Matched questionnaires were also given to GPs (n=75) from the same and surrounding practices. Completed questionnaires were received from 550 patients (response rate=92%) and 66 GPs (response
Results
The results were analysed in the following ways. First the participants’ profile characteristics were analysed using descriptive statistics. Second, the GPs’ and patients’ ratings of the expressions of uncertainty were described separately using percentages according to whether they believed the expression of uncertainty would make the patient feel not confident [1], [2], were unsure [3] or confident [4], [5] and thirdly these two sets of ratings were compared using t-test, confidence intervals
Discussion and conclusion
Medical uncertainty is a complex phenomena and can vary according to the aspects of the consultation that the doctor is uncertain about, the form that the expression of uncertainty takes and the context of any expression of uncertainty. The present study aimed to explore the relationship between expressions of uncertainty relating to both diagnostic and management aspects of the consultation and patient confidence.
The study first addressed the issue of the form of expression and compared GPs’
References (11)
Training for certainty
Soc. Sci. Med.
(1984)- et al.
Patient participation in decision making
Soc. Sci. Med.
(1998) - et al.
Patient centredness: a conceptual framework and review of the empirical literature
Soc. Sci. Med.
(2000) - et al.
Physicians expressions of uncertainty during patient encounters
Patient Educ. Couns.
(2000) Why doctors don’t disclose uncertainty?
Hastings Rep.
(1984)
Cited by (91)
Management of Uncertainty in Everyday Pediatric Care
2024, Pediatric Clinics of North AmericaHow should uncertainty about upcoming painful procedures be communicated? An experimental study into highly uncertain pain predictions
2024, Patient Education and CounselingPatient attitudes toward clinicians’ communication of diagnostic uncertainty and its impact on patient trust
2023, SSM - Qualitative Research in HealthDefinition, purposes, and scope
2023, Clinical Decision Support and beyond: Progress and Opportunities in Knowledge-Enhanced Health and HealthcareNegotiating uncertainty in clinical encounters: A narrative exploration of naturally occurring primary care consultations
2021, Social Science and MedicineCitation Excerpt :A vignette-based study indicates that implicit communication of diagnostic uncertainty might foster patient trust, confidence and adherence more than explicit communication (Bhise et al., 2017). Doctors’ expressions of uncertainty seem to be associated with both increased (Gordon et al., 2000) and decreased (Ogden et al., 2002) patient satisfaction (the first being a study of clinical interaction, the latter a questionnaire study). Uncertainty-utterances by doctors are associated with lower patient satisfaction when the physician is a woman (both real and simulated consultations) and when the patient is a man (real consultations only) (Cousin et al., 2013).