Mechanical properties of nasal fascia and periosteum

doi:10.1016/S0268-0033(03)00136-0

Clinical Biomechanics

Volume 18, Issue 8, October 2003, Pages 760-764

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0268-0033(03)00136-0 Get rights and content

Abstract

Objective. To determine under which layer the silicone implants should be inserted into, the biomechanical properties of fascia and periosteum were investigated.

Design. Biomechanical testing of cadaveric tissues.

Background. In silicone augmentation rhinoplasty, most complications are closely related to the depth of implant and the mechanical character of the tissue surrounding the implant.

Methods. Biomechanical properties of human nasal periosteum and fascia were studied, including tensile strength, stress–strain relationship and stress relaxation under uniaxial elongation.

Result. Although with less failure strain, the periosteum has more tensile strength than fascia. The slope of the linear part of stress–strain curve of the periosteum is bigger than that of fascia, which indicates the periosteum is stiffer than fascia. The stress-relaxation slope of periosteum is smaller than that of fascia.

Conclusion. In the view of biomechanics, the periosteum is thicker, stronger and stiffer than fascia. Under periosteum the silicone implants are easier to be fixed at desired position, thus periosteum is more suitable for covering silicone implants.
Relevance

The periosteum is more suitable than fascia for covering silicone implants in augmentation rhinoplasty.

Introduction

With the rapid development of aesthetic plastic surgery, augmentation rhinoplasty has become one of the most popular plastic surgery procedures in China. Silicone implant augmentation rhinoplasty is used to correct congenital saddle-nose and flat nose (Rozner et al., 1980; Lovice et al., 1999; Deva et al., 1998). The increasing number of patients requesting this operation is linked with improvement of technique and more demand on beauty. It is frequent to see patients asking for correction of minor defects. The operation is simple and makes people look better, more beautiful, and more vibrant (Ercolani and Baldaro, 1999). But the results of our follow-up indicate that many problems in rhinoplasty stem not only from the technique of the surgeon but also from the layer that silicone implants was inserted into.

According to our clinical experience, silicone implants can be inserted into one of three anatomical layers of the nasal dorsum: subcutaneous, subperiosteal or subfascial (Lovice et al., 1999; Deva et al., 1998) (Fig. 1). Many postoperative complications, such as drifting of the plastic frame, step-like deformity at the nasal bridge, maldirected silicone implants, changing in skin color, abnormal sensation and the silicone implants protruding through nasal skin, occur when the silicone implants are inserted into subcutaneous or subfascial shallow layers (classical rhinoplasty). According to our clinic experience, these complications can be greatly reduced if the silicone implants are implanted deeper. But the mechanism is not clear. Therefore the biomechanical properties of human nasal periosteum and fascia, including their tensile strength, stress–strain relationship and stress-relaxation characters under uniaxial elongation were investigated.

Section snippets

Methods

Periosteum and fascia were removed from 15 adult cadavers (aged from 17 to 49) within 48 h postmortem. Periosteum and fascia were separated, placed on microscopic slides (Mutou et al., 1975), covered with saline moistened gauze and stored in refrigerator at 4 °C before experiment. Their width and thickness were measured with optic magnifying scale. Mechanical test was performed with a hydraulically powered uniaxial elongation machine, (Instron Limited, Buckinghamshire, UK) under room

Tensile strength

Table 1 gives the comparison of tensile strength (engineering stress) and failure strain (engineering strain) of the periosteum and fascia, The tensile strength of the periosteum is greater than that of the fascia, but the failure strain is much less. Although having bigger tensile strength, periosteum has less deformation under failure strain so they are less extensible than fascia. This explains why it is so easy to lacerate the periosteum when it is separated to insert silicone implants.

Stress–strain relationship

The

Discussion

According to our clinical investigation, the site of implantation plays an important role in the success of rhinoplasty. Our research on biomechanical properties of human nasal periosteum and fascia provides strong evidence that periosteum is less extensible than fascia and has less stress relaxation, thus more suitable for implant fixation. In clinical practice, the silicone implant are sculptured into the shape of part of the nose before it is implanted. In an additional experiment, we have

Acknowledgements

This work was supported by the Chinese National Nature Science Foundation.

References (10)

M. Ercolani et al.
Short-term outcome of rhinoplasty for medical or cosmetic indication
J. Psychosom. Res.
(1999)
G.Y. Fu et al.
Biorheological features of some soft tissues under a surgical tissue expansion procedure
Biorheology
(1997)
K. Huang et al.
Alteratons in the biorheological features of some soft tissues after limb lengthening
Biorheology
(1998)
D.B. Lovice et al.
Grafts and implants in rhinoplasty and nasal reconstruction
Otolaryngol. Clin. North Am.
(1999)
Y. Mutou
The complications of augmentation rhinoplasty in orientals
Br. J. Plast. Surg.
(1975)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (30)

Mechanically enhanced and osteobioactive synthetic periosteum via development of poly(ε-caprolactone)/microtantalum composite
2023, Colloids and Surfaces B: Biointerfaces
Periosteum, the thin layer covering adjacent to bone containing specific architecture, is important for functional bone regeneration and remodeling. Synthetic periosteum investigated presently lacks the resemblance of natural periosteum, suffering from poor mechanical strength and cell attachment. Here, we report a newly-developed biomimetic film to function as synthetic periosteum. Based on poly(ε-caprolactone) (PCL), where surface wettability of the synthetic periosteum is enhanced by microtantalum (mTa) particle blending and after a cold drawing process, further obtains topographical anisotropy without any involvement of solvent. This new blend shows mechanical enhancement over pure PCL, with yield stress and elastic strain approaching the natural periosteum. A distinct degradation mechanism is proposed for the blend, and by seeding with mouse calvarial preosteoblasts, cell proliferation is promoted on surface of the drawn PCL but delayed on the mTa-blended PCL. However, cell mineralization is accelerated on the mTa-blended surface. This is less on the drawn PCL. The synergistical integration of cellular proliferation, alignment and osteogenic enhancement suggest that the cold drawn PCL/Ta blend has unique potential for developing into a synthetic periosteum and other tissue-engineering products.
Electrospun and 3D printed polymeric materials for one-stage critical-size long bone defect regeneration inspired by the Masquelet technique: Recent Advances
2022, Injury
Citation Excerpt :
Similar to other characterisation methods, membranes’ mechanical properties (mainly, tensile properties) have been mainly performed with PCL. In these studies, tensile strengths of PCL-based electrospun materials ranged from 1 MPa in Owston et al. [6] to 4.6–11.2 MPa in Zhou et al. [24] all within the range of natural periosteum (Zeng et al. [32]). Young's modulus is a measure how a material can withstand changes in length when under lengthwise tension.
Critical-size long bone defects represent one of the major causes of fracture non-union and remain a significant challenge in orthopaedic surgery. Two-stage procedures such as a Masquelet technique demonstrate high level of success however their main disadvantage is the need for a second surgery, which is required to remove the non-resorbable cement spacer and to place the bone graft into the biological chamber formed by the ‘induced membrane’. Recent research efforts have therefore been dedicated towards the design, fabrication and testing of resorbable implants that could mimic the biological functions of the cement spacer and the induced membrane. Amongst the various manufacturing techniques used to fabricate these implants, three-dimensional (3D) printing and electrospinning methods have gained a significant momentum due their high-level controllability, scalable processing and relatively low cost. This review aims to present recent advances in the evaluation of electrospun and 3D printed polymeric materials for critical-size, long bone defect reconstruction, emphasizing both their beneficial properties and current limitations. Furthermore, we present and discuss current state-of-the art techniques required for characterisation of the materials’ physical, mechanical and biological characteristics. These represent the essential first steps towards the development of personalised implants for single-surgery, large defect reconstruction in weight-bearing bones.
Core-sheath micro/nano fiber membrane with antibacterial and osteogenic dual functions as biomimetic artificial periosteum for bone regeneration applications
2019, Nanomedicine: Nanotechnology, Biology, and Medicine
Citation Excerpt :
The stress–strain curves in Figure 2, B show that the membranes were stretchable, a significant property for the artificial periosteum to bear the stress during the surgical operation and physiological process. PGMI and PGM possessed the tensile strength of more than 1 MPa, which is comparable with natural periosteum,44 as demonstrated in Table S2. As shown in Figure 2, C, all the core-sheath fiber membranes indicated excellent hydrophilicity with contact angles of 10°-60°.
The traditional Chinese medicine icariin (ICA) and broad-spectrum antibacterial drug moxifloxacin hydrochloride (MOX) were introduced into a polycaprolactone core and gelatin shell, respectively, to develop osteogenic and antibacterial biomimetic periosteum by coaxial electrospinning. The physical properties, drug release, degradation, antibacterial property, in vitro and in vivo osteogenesis performances were investigated. Results demonstrated that stepwise and controlled drug release profiles were achieved based on the core-shell configuration and disparate degradation rate of PCL and gelatin. Only 20% ICA was released from this dual drug-loaded membrane after 1 month while the release of MOX was almost completed. Moreover, clear in vitro antibacterial effect and enhancement in osteogenic marker expressions including osteocalcin, type-I collagen expression, and calcium deposition were observed. Notably, the dual drug-loaded membrane displayed fascinating properties contributing to in vivo bone formation in terms of quality and quantity in a rabbit radius defect model.
Structural interaction between bone and implants due to arthroplasty of the first metatarsophalangeal joint
2019, Foot and Ankle Surgery
Citation Excerpt :
Maximum principal stresses obtained for cortical bones with Tornier implant showed a value of 18.12 MPa, this value is below the value reported by Shin et al. [24] for this tissue (175 MPa), this means that cortical bone is not damage. However, this value according to Zeng et al. [29] may damage the periosteum. On the other hand, some strains values showed in Table 3 for Swanson and Tornier models are above the values reported by Trabersi et al. [30] for microcracks.
Currently, the metatarsophalangeal joint replacement through a restorative arthroplasty, where implants are used, is a viable invasive surgical medical procedure in the treatment of severe cases of osteoarthritis in this joint, better known as hallux rigidus. However, few things are known about the postoperative complications that implants can cause on the joint, like Swanson and Tornier implants.Research in this field can provide a valuable information that would help the specialist surgeon in the decision-making during the selection of the more suitable joint implant in each patient, as well as the redesign of the devices, to make them more efficient, durable and biocompatible with the human body.
The aim of this work is to perform a structural biomechanical analysis of a restorative arthroplasty of the first metatarsophalangeal joint, and to analyze the interaction between bone and medical grade silicone implants. For that, a simulation of a foot with Swanson and Tornier joint implants were performed to evaluate the stress/strain distribution during a critical stage (toe-off).
Principal stresses obtained for the first metatarsal with both implants suggest that failure is induced in this bone because, values exceed (up to 136.84% for Swanson model) the tensile strength reported for phalange trabecular bone, which may be related to osteolysis. Stress and strain values obtained in this work suggest that arthroplasty surgery with Swanson implant is more likely to cause postoperative complications versus Tornier implant.
Icariin-loaded electrospun PCL/gelatin nanofiber membrane as potential artificial periosteum
2018, Colloids and Surfaces B: Biointerfaces
Citation Excerpt :
The stress-strain curves in Fig. 2d show that the membranes are stretchable, which is crucial for an artificial periosteum. As shown in Table S1, the tensile strength of all the membranes were in the range of 10–14 MPa, which is higher than natural periosteum (3–4 MPa) [37] and we are confident that this meets the clinical requirements. Hydrophilicity of biomaterials is an important characteristic to control, especially when they interact directly with cells.
Due to the significant role of the periosteum in bone regeneration, we hypothesised that using a specially engineered artificial periosteum could lead to an enhancement in osteogenesis in bone grafts. Herein, we describe our work aimed at fabricating an electrospun fibrous membrane as an artificial periosteum that exhibits flexibility, permeability and osteoinduction. This membrane was designed to cover the complex surface of bone grafts to facilitate and accelerate bone regeneration. The traditional Chinese medicine icariin (ICA) was subsequently introduced into poly (ε-caprolactone) (PCL) /gelatin nanofibers to fabricate an artificial periosteum for the first time. The effects of ICA content on morphology, physical properties, drug release profile, in vitro degradability, biocompatibility and osteogenic differentiation properties were investigated. The ICA-loaded electrospun membranes showed significant improvement in hydrophilicity, high mechanical strength, appropriate degradation rates and excellent biocompatibility. Furthermore, clear enhancement in alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity, as well as an increase in osteocalcin (OCN) and type collagen I (COL I) expression in MC3T3-E1 cells were detected. Furthermore, we observed clear calcium deposition content in MC3T3-E1 cells cultured on ICA-loaded fibrous matrix. The membrane loaded with 0.05 wt.% ICA displayed properties contributing to cell attachment, proliferation and differentiation. These results indicate the huge potential of this ICA-loaded PCL/gelatin electrospun membrane as a biomimetic artificial periosteum to accelerate bone regeneration.
Viscoelastic behavior of human fasciae under extension in manual therapy
2007, Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies
Citation Excerpt :
The mechanical properties of ex vivo rat superficial fascia (subcutaneous tissue) under uniaxial tension have recently been investigated due to its potential importance in a variety of therapies involving mechanical stretch (Iatridis et al., 2003). The mechanical properties of in vitro human superficial nasal fascia and nasal periosteum were investigated by Zeng et al. (2003) to determine under which layer silicon implants should be inserted for better results of esthetic plastic surgery to correct congenital saddle-nose and flat nose. Similarly the mechanical properties of in vitro and in vivo properties of plantar fascia and fascia lata have also been investigated by Wright and Rennels (1964).
The basic field equations for viscoelastic soft tissues are employed for exploring the relationship between time varying mechanical stresses and dynamic deformations of human fasciae in manual therapy. The predicted stress range for plastic deformation of plantar fascia, based on the viscoelastic model is close to experimental data. Fascia lata (in vitro) and plantar fascia (in vitro) are found to exhibit similar behavior, irrespective of how the fasciae are deformed.
Manual therapists should avoid increasing deformation with time. It is desirable to produce deformation which should become constant after some time, and be applied for the duration up to 60 s. The therapists may apply almost the same load to produce the same plastic deformation for plantar fascia and fascia lata. Greater loads are needed to produce the same strain with higher rate of deformation. The data presented in this paper may also be useful for surgeons in planning the orientation of fascia in knee and hip replacement surgeries.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text