Elsevier

The Lancet

Volume 384, Issue 9950, 4–10 October 2014, Pages 1282-1293
The Lancet

Articles
Effect of integrated responsive stimulation and nutrition interventions in the Lady Health Worker programme in Pakistan on child development, growth, and health outcomes: a cluster-randomised factorial effectiveness trial

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(14)60455-4Get rights and content

Summary

Background

Stimulation and nutrition delivered through health programmes at a large scale could potentially benefit more than 200 million young children worldwide who are not meeting their developmental potential. We investigated the feasibility and effectiveness of the integration of interventions to enhance child development and growth outcomes in the Lady Health Worker (LHW) programme in Sindh, Pakistan.

Methods

We implemented a community-based cluster-randomised effectiveness trial through the LHW programme in rural Sindh, Pakistan, with a 2 × 2 factorial design. We randomly allocated 80 clusters (LHW catchments) of children to receive routine health and nutrition services (controls; n=368), nutrition education and multiple micronutrient powders (enhanced nutrition; n=364), responsive stimulation (responsive stimulation; n=383), or a combination of both enriched interventions (n=374). The allocation ratio was 1:20 (ie, 20 clusters per intervention group). The data collection team were masked to the allocated intervention. All children born in the study area between April, 2009, and March, 2010, were eligible for enrolment if they were up to 2·5 months old without signs of severe impairments. Interventions were delivered by LHWs to families with children up to 24 months of age in routine monthly group sessions and home visits. The primary endpoints were child development at 12 and 24 months of age (assessed with the Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler Development, Third Edition) and growth at 24 months of age. Analysis was by intention to treat. This trial is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, number NCT007159636.

Findings

1489 mother–infant dyads were enrolled into the study, of whom 1411 (93%) were followed up until the children were 24 months old. Children who received responsive stimulation had significantly higher development scores on the cognitive, language, and motor scales at 12 and 24 months of age, and on the social–emotional scale at 12 months of age, than did those who did not receive the intervention. Children who received enhanced nutrition had significantly higher development scores on the cognitive, language, and social-emotional scales at 12 months of age than those who did not receive this intervention, but at 24 months of age only the language scores remained significantly higher. We did not record any additive benefits when responsive stimulation was combined with nutrition interventions. Responsive stimulation effect sizes (Cohen's d) were 0·6 for cognition, 0·7 for language, and 0·5 for motor development at 24 months of age; these effect sizes were slightly smaller for the combined intervention group and were low to moderate for the enhanced nutrition intervention alone. Children exposed to enhanced nutrition had significantly better height-for-age Z scores at 6 months (p<0·0001) and 18 months (p=0·02) than did children not exposed to enhanced nutrition. Longitudinal analysis showed a small benefit to linear growth from enrolment to 24 months (p=0·026) in the children who received the enhanced nutrition intervention.

Interpretation

The responsive stimulation intervention can be delivered effectively by LHWs and positively affects development outcomes. The absence of a major effect of the enhanced nutrition intervention on growth shows the need for further analysis of mediating variables (eg, household food security status) that will help to optimise future nutrition implementation design.

Funding

UNICEF.

Introduction

More than 200 million children in developing countries are at risk of not meeting their developmental potential by 5 years of age.1 Risk factors including poverty, malnutrition, and inadequate stimulation are likely to co-occur and accumulate over time, increasing the risk of early childhood mortality, morbidity, poor development, and growth.2, 3, 4 Children who are unable to fulfil their developmental and growth potential are likely to perform poorly in school and earn lower incomes as adults, thus perpetuating social inequalities and contributing to the intergenerational transmission of poverty, poor health, and development.5, 6 The first 2 years of life is an important window of opportunity to implement interventions to promote children's physical growth and development.

Early child stimulation interventions that guide parents to be sensitive (understand their child's signals) and responsive (respond in a contingent and developmentally appropriate way to these signals)7 through developmentally suitable play with their child have shown consistent benefits to children's development.8, 9, 10, 11 The enhancement of these basic caregiving skills, which are learned during play interactions, can also protect children's health by helping families to recognise and respond to the early signs of illness.7 Nutritional intervention is needed to promote healthy growth and development; however, few studies have assessed the additive benefits of combined stimulation and nutrition on child outcomes. Studies from Jamaica showed additive developmental benefits when stimulation was combined with macronutrient supplementation10 and synergistic benefits when it was combined with zinc supplementation.8

Early child development programmes in developing countries are likely to be more effective if they are comprehensive (ie, they include health, nutrition, and stimulation), run for longer, have greater intensity (ie, higher frequency and longer duration of contacts), use a structured curriculum, and enable parents and children to participate together to practise stimulation activities and receive feedback.12, 13 Knowledge gaps remain about how best to combine stimulation and nutrition interventions within existing health services to expand programmes to a large scale.13 To the best of our knowledge, the delivery of integrated early child development interventions with community health workers in public sector effectiveness settings has not been assessed so far.

Pakistan has a high burden of both child undernutrition14 and poor development.1 The National Programme for Family Planning and Primary Healthcare (often referred to as the Lady Health Worker [LHW] programme) provides an opportunity to integrate early child development services at scale (panel 1).15 The LHW programme, started in 1994, is a government-supported community health service providing care to families in rural, remote, and disadvantaged communities across Pakistan. The focus areas for health services are family planning and maternal and child health, which are delivered by LHWs. The programme does not encompass early stimulation at present, and recent assessments have emphasised the need to strengthen nutrition services.16 The aim of this study was to measure the effects of a responsive stimulation intervention delivered by LHWs to families with infants and young children from birth to 24 months of age living in rural Sindh, Pakistan, either alone or in combination with an enhanced care for nutrition intervention. The primary endpoint was child development and growth and the secondary endpoint was child morbidity; all outcomes were assessed at 24 months of age. The hypothesis to test was that, compared with either a responsive stimulation or an enhanced care for nutrition intervention delivered alone, a combined approach would have independent and additive or synergistic effects on child development, growth, and morbidity outcomes at 24 months.

Section snippets

Study design and participants

We did a pragmatic, community-based, cluster-randomised effectiveness trial in the Naushero Feroze district of Sindh, Pakistan, between June 1, 2009, and March 31, 2012. The trial had a 2 × 2 factorial design,17 and we used the cluster-randomised design to reduce the risk of contamination by ensuring that all members of each cluster received the same intervention. Each cluster was defined as an LHW catchment, and we allocated the same number of clusters to each intervention group On average,

Results

1489 mother–infant dyads were enrolled in the study for the in-depth assessment, which represents 42% of all young children receiving LHW services in the study area. 368 infants were enrolled into the control group, 364 into the enhanced nutrition group, 383 into the responsive stimulation group, and 374 into the combined enhanced nutrition and responsive stimulation group. 1391 of 1489 (93%) of the enrolled mother–infant dyads were followed up until the infants reached 24 months of age (figure

Discussion

We designed this study to investigate the effect of the delivery of a model of integrated early child development interventions with community health workers in a public sector effectiveness setting. Our results show that the responsive stimulation intervention had significant benefits on early child cognitive, language, and motor development outcomes, but not on social-emotional development. The treatment effect sizes (moderate to large) of responsive stimulation at 24 months of age were

References (39)

  • ZA Bhutta et al.

    Improvement of perinatal and newborn care in rural Pakistan through community-based strategies: a cluster-randomised effectiveness trial

    Lancet

    (2011)
  • S Gillespie et al.

    The politics of reducing malnutrition: building commitment and accelerating progress

    Lancet

    (2013)
  • NF Krebs et al.

    Randomized controlled trial of meat compared with multimicronutrient-fortified cereal in infants and toddlers with high stunting rates in diverse settings

    Am J Clin Nutr

    (2012)
  • JP Shonkoff et al.

    An integrated scientific framework for child survival and early childhood development

    Pediatrics

    (2012)
  • H Alderman

    The economic cost of a poor start to life

    J Dev Orig Health Dis

    (2010)
  • JJ Heckman

    Skill formation and the economics of investing in disadvantaged children

    Science

    (2006)
  • N Eshel et al.

    Responsive parenting: interventions and outcomes

    Bull World Health Organ

    (2006)
  • C Powell et al.

    Feasibility of integrating early stimulation into primary care for undernourished Jamaican children: cluster randomised controlled trial

    BMJ

    (2004)
  • A Hafeez et al.

    Lady health workers programme in Pakistan: challenges, achievements and the way forward

    J Pak Med Assoc

    (2011)
  • Cited by (297)

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text