Depression after stroke and lesion location: a systematic review

doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(00)02448-X

The Lancet

Volume 356, Issue 9224, 8 July 2000, Pages 122-126

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(00)02448-X Get rights and content

Summary

Background

There is conflicting evidence on the hypothesis that the risk of depression after stroke is influenced by the location of the brain lesion. We undertook a systematic review to examine the hypotheses that depression is more commonly associated with left-hemisphere strokes than with right-hemisphere strokes and with lesions of the left anterior brain than with other regions.

Methods

We did a computer-aided search of MEDLINE, BIDS ISI, and PsychLit databases supplemented by hand searches of key journals. We included all reports on the association of depression after stroke with the location of the brain lesion. Studies were systematically and independently examined by two investigators. Fixed-effects and random-effects meta-analyses were done.

Findings

143 reports were identified by the search strategy. 48 were eligible for inclusion. Not all reports included original data. Only two reports of original data supported the hypotheses and seven clearly did not. The pooled (random-effects) relative risk of depression after a left-hemisphere stroke, compared with a right-hemisphere stroke, was 0·95 (95% Cl 0·83–1·10). For depression after a left anterior lesion compared with all other brain areas the pooled (random-effects) relative risk was 1·17 (0·87–1·62). Restriction of the analyses to reports from high-quality studies or major depressive disorder did not substantially affect the findings. Nor were they affected by stratification of the time between stroke and the assessment of depression. Multiple publications from the same samples of patients were apparent.

Interpretation

This systematic review offered no support for the hypothesis that the risk of depression after stroke is affected by the location of the brain lesion.

Introduction

There has been wide dissemination of the idea that the risk of becoming depressed after a stroke is influenced by the location of the brain lesion, but is it true? The hypothesis originated more than 20 years ago when researchers at Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, USA, reported associations between laterality of experimentally induced brain damage, brain catecholamine concentrations, and activity in rats¹ and later between left-hemisphere strokes, in particular lesions of the left frontal region, and depression in human beings.2, 3, 4

This hypothesis was widely publicised and attractive because it linked neurobiology with clinical practice. There have been many attempts to replicate these findings. Some studies have confirmed an association between left-hemisphere lesions and depression, but others have not. Some have even suggested the opposite effect—that depression is associated with right-hemisphere lesions.

In view of the apparently conflicting evidence, we undertook a systematic review of all reported studies relevant to two hypotheses. The first is that the risk of depression after stroke is higher with left-sided lesions than with right-sided lesions; the second is that the risk of depression is higher with left anterior lesions than with lesions in other sites in the brain.

Section snippets

Search strategy

All studies that included an assessment of depression in patients who had had strokes and made an attempt to relate the presence of depression to the site of the stroke lesion were eligible for inclusion.

We first searched three computerised databases up to August, 1999: MEDLINE (from January, 1966), BIDS ISI (from January, 1981), and PsychLit (from January, 1960). Our strategy used the keywords “depression or mood or affective” and “stroke or cerebrovascular”. The on-line abstracts were

Results

The inclusion and exclusion of reports is shown in figure 1. The search strategy identified 143 reports (the full list of references is available on The Lancet website [www.thelancet.com] or from the authors). 48 reports were judged eligible for inclusion. 38 reported no significant differences in risk of depression in relation to the site of the lesion; two reported an increased risk with left-sided lesions; seven reported increased risk with right-sided lesions; and one showed an association

Discussion

Our findings do not support the hypothesis that lesions of the left hemisphere, and particularly the left anterior brain, are associated with an increased risk of depression after stroke. We found no association whether we analysed reports on all cases of depression, those that included only cases of major depression, or those that examined only depression developing within a month of stroke.

Why did individual studies obtain different results? The examination of potential biases suggests that

References (39)

JA Schwartz et al.
Depression in stroke rehabilitation
Biol Psychiatry
(1993)
RG Robinson et al.
Effect of experimental cerebral infarction in rat brain on catecholamines and behaviour.
Nature
(1975)
RM Parikh et al.
The impact of poststroke depression on recovery in activities of daily living over a 2‐year follow‐up.
Arch Neurol
(1990)
RG Robinson et al.
Mood changes in stroke patients: relationship to lesion location.
Compr Psychiatry
(1983)
HS Mayberg et al.
PET imaging of cortical S2 serotonin receptors after stroke: lateralized changes and relationship to depression
Am J Psychiatry
(1988)
SM MacHale et al.
Depression and its relation to lesion location after stroke
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry
(1998)
AO House et al.
Mood disorders after stroke and their relation to lesion location: a CT scan study
Brain
(1990)
G Andersen et al.
Risk factors for post‐stroke depression
Acta Psychiatr Scand
(1995)
G Gainotti et al.
Frequency, phenomenology and anatomical‐clinical correlates of major post‐stroke depression
Br J sychiatry
(1999)
KC Ng et al.
A study of post‐stroke depression in a rehabilitative center
Acta Psychiatr Scand
(1995)

SJ Collin et al.