Psychological treatment for recurrent symptoms of colds and flu in children

Abstract

The effect of stress management and relaxation with guided imagery on upper respiratory tract infections (URTIs) was investigated in 45 children with a history of 10 or more infections in the past year. To investigate the influence of psychological treatment on mucosal immunity, secretory immunoglobulin A (sIgA) was measured before and during treatment. The number of symptomatic episodes during 13 weeks of monitoring was similar in treatment and waitlist conditions; however, episodes were shorter in stress management and guided imagery conditions than in the waitlist condition. Levels of sIgA increased toward the end of treatment. These findings were confirmed in a replication study. In addition, symptom reduction and improvements in psychological state persisted at 1-year follow-up. The findings suggest that psychological treatment interrupts a chronic illness cycle in children with symptoms of recurrent URTI.

Introduction

In the United States of America, respiratory illnesses account for nearly two-thirds of the total illness in a community; account for as much as 40% of the problems seen in a pediatric practice and are responsible for over one-third of school absences [1]. In Australia, upper respiratory tract infection (URTI) is the second most frequently managed problem in general practice [2]. Three studies across the world have shown a high frequency of URTI is linked to development of asthma in children (in Sweden [3], in Hong Kong [4] and in Australia [5]). Treatment options are limited in children because vaccination against viral respiratory infections is often short-lived or unsuccessful, and long-term use of antibiotics may lower mucosal immune resistance by depleting sIgA [6], [7], [8].

Psychological stress influences susceptibility to colds and flu [9], [10], [11], [12], [13], [14], possibly by decreasing the concentration of secretory immunoglobulin A (sIgA) in the upper respiratory tract [15], [16], [17]. Secretory IgA prevents penetration of antigens into the lining of the upper respiratory tract [18], [19], [20], [21], and is deficient in children with recurrent colds and flu [22], [23], [24]. Secretory IgA decreases during periods of chronic stress [25]. Conversely, sIgA increases acutely during relaxation [26], [27], [28], [29], [30], [31], [32], but the clinical utility of this response has not been explored.

We previously investigated the association between psychosocial stress and susceptibility to URTI in 45 children with a history of recurrent colds and flu and in 45 healthy children of similar age and sex [24]. The number of stressful life events in the past 12 months was greater in the children with recurrent URTI than in the healthy children. In addition, children with recurrent URTI had higher scores on anxiety, neuroticism and depression and lower scores on assertiveness and extraversion than the healthy children. These findings are comparable to those in adults, where a high degree of life event stress predicted URTI [33], [34], [35], [36], [37] as did dissatisfaction with life [38], emotional distress associated with a tendency to hypochondriasis and low ego strength [39] and introversion associated with a sense of loss [34], [40]. Importantly, the level of sIgA, expressed as a ratio to albumin, was lower in children with recurrent URTI compared with healthy children [24].

In the first experiment of the present study, we investigated the effect of psychological treatment on symptoms of recurrent infections in the 45 children studied previously with recurrent URTI. Psychological treatment consisted of stress management, which aimed to reduce self-reported stress levels through the use of relaxation procedures and methods that improve coping skills. We also evaluated the clinical efficacy of training in imagery techniques that are known to increase levels of sIgA [29], [30]. Symptoms of illness were compared between the treatment and waitlist groups of children with recurrent infection problems. In addition, sIgA was measured over the course of treatment to determine whether an increase in mucosal immunity contributed to the therapeutic response. We hypothesized that symptoms of colds and flu would decrease and sIgA would increase during psychological treatment. The effect of treatment on extraversion/introversion, depression, anxiety, negative and positive mood, family satisfaction and assertiveness was also assessed.