Abstract
Traditional theories of motor control view it as a serial process of planning and execution situated at the end of a larger serial process of perceptual representation and cognitive decision-making. Here, I examine the assumption that “planning” and “execution” are distinct processes separated by a neural representation of a “desired trajectory”. I propose that neural data do not support the existence of a desired trajectory or of any pre-generated plan other than a crude representation of the intended motion of a controlled object. That representation appears to be more strongly involved in decision-making processes than in the control of a specific movement, and it does not appear to be converted into a detailed motor command until after the movement begins, even in well-trained tasks. Thus, one is led to question whether the traditional distinction between decision-making, planning, and motor execution is a useful foundation for interpreting neural data and generating computational theories of motor control.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abend W, Bizzi E, Morasso PG (1982) Human arm trajectory formation. Brain 105:331–348
Ajemian R, Bullock D, Grossberg S (2000) Kinematic coordinates in which motor cortical cells encode movement direction. J Neurophysiol 84:2191–2203
Ajemian R, Bullock D, Grossberg S (2001) A model of movement coordinates in the motor cortex: posture-dependent changes in the gain and direction of single cell tuning curves. Cereb Cortex 11:1124–1135
Albus JS (1971) A theory of cerebellar function. Math Biosci 10:25–61
Alexander GE, Crutcher MD (1990) Preparation for movement: neural representations of intended direction in three motor areas of the monkey. J Neurophys 64:133–150
Alexander GE, Delong MR, Crutcher MD (1992) Do cortical and basal ganglionic motor areas use “motor programs” to control movement? Behav Brain Sci 15:656–665
Andersen RA (1995) Encoding of intention and spatial location in the posterior parietal cortex. Cereb Cortex 5:457–469
Ashe J, Georgopoulos AP (1994) Movement parameters and neural activity in motor cortex and area 5. Cereb Cortex 4:590–600
Atkeson CG, Hollerbach JM (1985) Kinematic features of unrestrained vertical arm movements. J Neurosci 5:2318–2330
Basso MA, Wurtz RH (1998) Modulation of neuronal activity in superior colliculus by changes in target probability. J Neurosci 18:7519–7534
Bhushan N, Shadmehr R (1999) Computational nature of human adaptive control during learning of reaching movements in force fields. Biol Cybern 81:39–60
Bizzi E, Accornero N, Chapple W, Hogan N (1984) Posture control and trajectory formation during arm movement. J Neurosci 4:2738–2744
Bizzi E, Hogan N, Mussa-Ivaldi FA, Giszter SF (1992) Does the nervous system use equilibrium-point control to guide single and multiple joint movements? Behav Brain Sci 15:603–613
Bizzi E, Tresch MC, Saltiel P, d’Avella A (2000) New perspectives on spinal motor systems. Nat Rev Neurosci 1:101–108
Bullock D, Grossberg S (1988) Neural dynamics of planned arm movements: emergent invariants and speed-accuracy properties during trajectory formation. Psychol Rev 95:49–90
Bullock D, Cisek P, Grossberg S (1998) Cortical networks for control of voluntary arm movements under variable force conditions. Cereb Cortex 8:48–62
Buneo CA, Jarvis MR, Batista AP, Andersen RA (2002) Direct visuomotor transformations for reaching. Nature 416:632–636
Butler AB, Hodos W (1996) Comparative vertebrate neuroanatomy: evolution and adaptation. Wiley-Liss, New York
Cisek P (1999) Beyond the computer metaphor: behaviour as interaction. J Conscious Stud 6:125–142
Cisek P (2001) Embodiment is all in the head. Behav Brain Sci 24:36–38
Cisek P, Kalaska JF (2001) Activity in dorsal premotor cortex (PMd) reflects anticipation of the likely response choice during a selection task (abstract). Soc Neurosci Abstracts 27
Cisek P, Kalaska JF (2002) Simultaneous encoding of multiple potential reach directions in dorsal premotor cortex. J Neurophysiol 87:1149–1154
Cisek P, Kalaska JF (2004) Neural correlates of mental rehearsal in dorsal premotor cortex. Nature 431:993–996
Cisek P, Kalaska JF (2005) Neural correlates of reaching decisions in dorsal premotor cortex: specification of multiple direction choices and final selection of action. Neuron (in press)
Cisek P, Turgeon M (1999) ’Binding through the fovea’, a tale of perception in the service of action. Psyche 5(34)
Cisek P, Grossberg S, Bullock D (1998) A cortico-spinal model of reaching and proprioception under multiple task constraints. J Cogn Neurosci 10:425–444
Cisek P, Crammond DJ, Kalaska JF (2003) Neural activity in primary motor and dorsal premotor cortex in reaching tasks with the contralateral versus ipsilateral arm. J Neurophysiol 89:922–942
Cisek P, Michaud N, Kalaska JF (2004) Integration of motor planning and sensory feedback in area 5. Soc Neurosci Abstr 30
Crammond DJ, Kalaska JF (2000) Prior information in motor and premotor cortex: activity during the delay period and effect on pre-movement activity. J Neurophysiol 84:986–1005
Deacon TW (1990) Rethinking mammalian brain evolution. Am Zool 30:629–705
Desmurget M, Epstein CM, Turner RS, Prablanc C, Alexander GE, Grafton ST (1999) Role of the posterior parietal cortex in updating reaching movements to a visual target. Nat Neurosci 2:563–567
Domkin D, Laczko J, Jaric S, Johansson H, Latash ML (2002) Structure of joint variability in bimanual pointing tasks. Exp Brain Res 143:11–23
Donchin O, Gribova A, Steinberg O, Bergman H, Vaadia E (1998) Primary motor cortex is involved in bimanual coordination. Nature 395:274–278
Evarts EV (1968) Relation of pyramidal tract activity to force exerted during voluntary movement. J Neurophysiol 31:14–27
Feldman AG (1986) Once more on the equilibrium-point hypothesis (lambda model) for motor control. J Motor Behav 18:17–54
Fetz EE (1992) Are movement parameters recognizably coded in the activity of single neurons? Behav Brain Sci 15:679–690
Flanagan JR, Wing AM (1997) The role of internal models in motion planning and control: evidence from grip force adjustments during movements of hand-held loads. J Neurosci 17:1519–1528
Flash T, Hogan N (1985) The coordination of arm movements: an experimentally confirmed mathematical model. J Neurosci 5:1688–1703
Georgopoulos AP (1995) Current issues in directional motor control. Trends Neurosci 18:506–510
Georgopoulos AP, Kalaska JF, Caminiti R, Massey JT (1982) On the relations between the direction of two-dimensional arm movements and cell discharge in primate motor cortex. J Neurosci 2:1527–1537
Georgopoulos AP, Caminiti R, Kalaska JF, Massey JT (1983) Spatial coding of movement: a hypothesis concerning the coding of movement direction by motor cortical populations. Exp Brain R (Suppl) 7:327–336
Georgopoulos AP, Kettner RE, Schwartz AB (1988) Primate motor cortex and free arm movements to visual targets in three-dimensional space. II. Coding of the direction of arm movement by a neural population. J Neurosci 8:2928–2937
Glimcher PW (2003) The neurobiology of visual-saccadic decision making. Annu Rev Neurosci 26:133–179
Glimcher PW, Sparks DL (1992) Movement selection in advance of action in the superior colliculus. Nature 355:542–545
Gold JI, Shadlen MN (2000) Representation of a perceptual decision in developing oculomotor commands. Nature 404:390–394
Gold JI, Shadlen MN (2003) The influence of behavioral context on the representation of a perceptual decision in developing oculomotor commands. J Neurosci 23:632–651
Gordon J, Ghilardi MF, Cooper SE, Ghez C (1994) Accuracy of planar reaching movements: II. Systematic extent errors resulting from inertial anisotropy. Exp Brain Res 99:112–130
Gribble PL, Scott SH (2002) Overlap of internal models in motor cortex for mechanical loads during reaching. Nature 417:938–941
Grossberg S (1969) On learning of spatiotemporal patterns by networks with ordered sensory and motor components. I. Excitatory components of the cerebellum. Stud Appl Math 48:105–132
Harris CM, Wolpert DM (1998) Signal-dependent noise determines motor planning. Nature 394:780–784
Hernandez A, Zainos A, Romo R (2002) Temporal evolution of a decision-making process in medial premotor cortex. Neuron 33:959–972
Holland LZ, Holland ND (1999) Chordate origins of the vertebrate central nervous system. Curr Opin Neurobiol 9:596–602
Horwitz GD, Batista AP, Newsome WT (2004) Representation of an abstract perceptual decision in macaque superior colliculus. J Neurophysiol 91:2281–2296
Hoshi E, Tanji J (2000) Integration of target and body-part information in the premotor cortex when planning action. Nature 408:466–470
Hoshi E, Tanji J (2002) Contrasting neuronal activity in the dorsal and ventral premotor areas during preparation to reach. J Neurophysiol 87:1123–1128
Imamizu H, Miyauchi S, Tamada T, Sasaki Y, Takino R, Pütz B, Yoshioka T, Kawato M (2000) Human cerebellar activity reflecting an acquired internal model of a new tool. Nature 403:192–195
Ito M (1984) The cerebellum and neural control. Raven, New York
Johnson PB, Ferraina S, Bianchi L, Caminiti R (1996) Cortical networks for visual reaching: physiological and anatomical organization of frontal and parietal arm regions. Cereb Cortex 6:102–119
Jordan MI, Rumelhart DE (1992) Forward models: supervised learning with a distal teacher. Cogn Sci 16:307–354
Kalaska JF, Crammond DJ (1992) Cerebral cortical mechanisms of reaching movements. Science 255:1517–1523
Kalaska JF, Crammond DJ (1995) Deciding not to GO: neuronal correlates of response selection in a GO/NOGO task in primate premotor and parietal cortex. Cereb Cortex 5:410–428
Kalaska JF, Cohen DAD, Hyde ML, Prud’homme MJ (1989) A comparison of movement direction-related versus load direction-related activity in primate motor cortex, using a two-dimensional reaching task. J Neurosci 9:2080–2102
Kalaska JF, Sergio LE, Cisek P (1998) Cortical control of whole-arm motor tasks. In: Glickstein M (ed) Sensory guidance of movement, Novartis foundation symposium #218. Wiley, Chichester, pp 176–201
Karst GM, Hasan Z (1991) Initiation rules for planar, two-joint arm movements: agonist selection for movements throughout the work space. J Neurophys 66:1579–1593
Katz PS, Harris-Warrick RM (1999) The evolution of neuronal circuits underlying species-specific behavior. Curr Opin Neurobiol 9:628–633
Kawato M, Gomi H (1992) The cerebellum and VOR/OKR learning models. Trends Neurosci 15:445–453
Kim JN, Shadlen MN (1999) Neural correlates of a decision in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex of the macaque. Nat Neurosci 2:176–185
Krakauer JW, Ghilardi MF, Ghez C (1999) Independent learning of internal models for kinematic and dynamic control of reaching. Nat Neurosci 2:1026–1031
Kurata K (1993) Premotor cortex of monkeys: set- and movement-related activity reflecting amplitude and direction of wrist movements. J Neurophys 69:187–200
Lackner JR, DiZio P (1994) Rapid adaptation to Coriolis force perturbations of arm trajectory. J Neurophysiol 72:299–313
Latash ML, Gottlieb GL (1991) An equilibrium-point model for fast, single-joint movement: I. Emergence of strategy-dependent EMG patterns. J Motor Behav 23:163–177
MacLean PD (1973) A triune concept of the brain and behaviour. University of Toronto Press, Toronto
Marr DC (1969) A theory of cerebellar cortex. J Physiol 202:437–470
Mazurek ME, Roitman JD, Ditterich J, Shadlen MN (2003) A role for neural integrators in perceptual decision making. Cereb Cortex 13:1257–1269
Medina L, Reiner A (2000) Do birds possess homologues of mammalian primary visual, somatosensory and motor cortices?. Trends Neurosci 23:1–12
Mehta B, Schaal S (2002) Forward models in visuomotor control. J Neurophys 88:942–953
Miall RC, Wolpert DM (1996) Forward models for physiological motor control. Neural Netw 9:1265–1279
Morasso PG (1981) Spatial control of arm movements. Exp Brain Res 42:223–227
Mussa-Ivaldi FA (1988) Do neurons in the motor cortex encode movement direction? an alternate hypothesis. Neurosci Lett 91:106–111
Newell A, Simon HA (1972) Human problem solving. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs
Pellionisz A, Llinás R (1985) Tensor network theory of the metaorganization of functional geometries in the central nervous system. Neuroscience 16:245–273
Platt ML, Glimcher PW (1997) Responses of intraparietal neurons to saccadic targets and visual distractors. J Neurophysiol 78:1574–1589
Platt ML, Glimcher PW (1999) Neural correlates of decision variables in parietal cortex. Nature 400:233–238
Polit A, Bizzi E (1978) Processes controlling arm movements in monkeys. Science 201:1235–1237
Prut Y, Fetz EE (1999) Primate spinal interneurons show pre-movement instructed delay activity. Nature 401:590–594
Ratcliff R, Cherian A, Segraves M (2003) A comparison of macaque behavior and superior colliculus neuronal activity to predictions from models of two-choice decisions. J Neurophysiol 90:1392–1407
Riehle A, Requin J (1989) Monkey primary motor and premotor cortex: single-cell activity related to prior information about direction and extent of an intended movement. J Neurophysiol 61:534–549
Roesch MR, Olson CR (2003) Impact of expected reward on neuronal activity in prefrontal cortex, frontal and supplementary eye fields and premotor cortex. J Neurophysiol 90:1766–1789
Roesch MR, Olson CR (2004) Neuronal activity related to reward value and motivation in primate frontal cortex. Science 304:307–310
Romo R, Hernandez A, Zainos A, Lemus L, Brody CD (2002) Neuronal correlates of decision-making in secondary somatosensory cortex. Nat Neurosci 5:1217–1225
Romo R, Hernandez A, Zainos A (2004) Neuronal correlates of a perceptual decision in ventral premotor cortex. Neuron 41:165–173
Sanger TD (1994) Theoretical considerations for the analysis of population coding in motor cortex. Neural Comput 6:29–37
Schall JD, Bichot NP (1998) Neural correlates of visual and motor decision processes. Curr Opin Neurobiol 8:211–217
Schall JD, Thompson KG (1999) Neural selection and control of visually guided eye movements. Annu Rev Neurosci 22:241–259
Scholz JP, Schöner G (1999) The uncontrolled manifold concept: identifying control variables for a functional task. Exp Brain Res 126:289–306
Scholz JP, Danion F, Latash ML, Schöner G (2002) Understanding finger coordination through analysis of the structure of force variability. Biol Cybern 86:29–39
Schwartz AB (1992) Motor cortical activity during drawing movements: single unit activity during sinusoid tracing. J Neurophysiol 68:528–541
Schwartz AB (1993) Motor cortical activity during drawing movements: population representation during sinusoid tracing. J Neurophysiol 70:28–36
Schweighofer N, Arbib MA, Kawato M (1998) Role of the cerebellum in reaching movements in humans. I. Distributed inverse dynamics control. Eur J Neurolsci 10:86–94
Scott SH (2000) Population vectors and motor cortex: neural coding or epiphenomenon?. Nat Neurosci 3:307–308
Scott SH, Kalaska JF (1996) Temporal changes in the effect of arm orientation on directional tuning of cells in monkey primary motor (M1) and dorsal premotor (PMd) cortex during reaching. Soc Neurosci Abstr 22
Scott SH, Kalaska JF (1997) Reaching movements with similar hand paths but different arm orientations. I. Activity of individual cells in motor cortex. J Neurophysiol 77:826–853
Scott SH, Gribble PL, Graham KM, Cabel DW (2001) Dissociation between hand motion and population vectors from neural activity in motor cortex. Nature 413:161–165
Sergio LE, Kalaska JF (1997) Systematic changes in directional tuning of motor cortex cell activity with hand location in the workspace during generation of static isometric forces in constant spatial directions. J Neurophys 78:1170–1174
Sergio LE, Kalaska JF (1998) Changes in the temporal pattern of primary motor cortex activity in a directional isometric force versus limb movement task. J Neurophysiol 80:1577–1583
Sergio LE, Kalaska JF (2003) Systematic changes in motor cortex cell activity with arm posture during directional isometric force generation. J Neurophysiol 89:212–228
Shadlen MN, Newsome WT (2001) Neural basis of a perceptual decision in the parietal cortex (area lip) of the rhesus monkey. J Neurophysiol 86:1916–1936
Shadmehr R, Mussa-Ivaldi FA (1994) Adaptive representation of dynamics during learning of a motor task. J Neurosci 14:3208–3224
Shen L, Alexander GE (1997a) Neural correlates of a spatial sensory-to-motor transformation in primary motor cortex. J Neurophysiol 77:1171–1194
Shen L, Alexander GE (1997b) Preferential representation of instructed target location versus limb trajectory in dorsal premotor area. J Neurophys 77:1195–1212
Tanji J, Okano K, Sato KC (1987) Relation of neurons in the nonprimary motor cortex to bilateral hand movement. Nature 327:618–620
Tanji J, Okano K, Sato KC (1988) Neuronal activity in cortical motor areas related to ipsilateral, contralateral, and bilateral digit movements of the monkey. J Neurophysiol 60:325–343
Thompson KG, Hanes DP, Bichot NP, Schall JD (1996) Perceptual and motor processing stages identified in the activity of macaque frontal eye field neurons during visual search. J Neurophysiol 76:4040–4055
Thompson KG, Bichot NP, Schall JD (1997) Dissociation of visual discrimination from saccade programming in macaque frontal eye field. J Neurophys 77:1046–1050
Todorov E, Jordan MI (2002) Optimal feedback control as a theory of motor coordination. Nat Neurosci 5:1226–1235
Uno Y, Kawato M, Suzuki R (1989) Formation and control of optimal trajectory in human multijoint arm movement. Minimum torque-change model. Biol Cybern 61:89–101
Wise SP (1985) The primate premotor cortex: past, present, and preparatory. Annu Rev Neurosci 8:1–19
Wolpert DM, Kawato M (1998) Multiple paired forward and inverse models for motor control. Neural Netw 11:1317–1329
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Communicated by Irene Ruspantini and Niels Birbaumer
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cisek, P. Neural representations of motor plans, desired trajectories, and controlled objects. Cogn Process 6, 15–24 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10339-004-0046-7
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10339-004-0046-7