Nigral volume loss in prodromal, early, and moderate Parkinson’s disease

The loss of melanized neurons in the substantia nigra pars compacta (SNc) is a hallmark pathology in Parkinson’s disease (PD). Melanized neurons in SNc can be visualized in vivo using magnetization transfer (MT) effects. Nigral volume was extracted in data acquired with a MT-prepared gradient echo sequence in 33 controls, 83 non-manifest carriers (42 LRRK2 and 41 GBA nonmanifest carriers), 65 prodromal hyposmic participants, 105 de novo PD patients and 26 48-month PD patients from the Parkinson’s Progressive Markers Initiative. No difference in nigral volume was seen between controls and LRRK2 and GBA non-manifest carriers (F=0.076; P=0.927). A significant main effect in group was observed between controls, prodromal hyposmic participants, and overt PD patients (F=5.192; P=0.002). Longer disease duration significantly correlated with lower nigral volume (r=−0.252; P=0.010). This study shows that nigral depigmentation can be robustly detected in prodromal hyposmic participants and overt PD patients.


Introduction
Parkinson's disease (PD) is a heterogeneous neurodegenerative disorder with a variety of motor and nonmotor symptoms that can be clinically challenging to diagnose and manage, and there are currently no effective interventions to stop PD neurodegeneration.Empirical evidence suggests that PD-related neurodegeneration starts prior to symptom onset [1][2][3][4][5] and understanding the magnitude and timing of PD-related neurodegeneration is essential to the development of early-stage diagnostic markers and outcome measures for clinical trials.At risk populations, such as patients with idiopathic rapid eye movement sleep behavior disorder (iRBD) 6 or hyposmia with dopamine transporter deficits 7 , are ideal populations to examine neurodegeneration in the prodromal phase of PD since these patients are likely to phenoconvert to PD or other synucleinopathies [8][9][10] .
Neuromelanin loss in the substantia nigra pars compacta (SNc) is a hallmark pathology of PD 5,11,12 .The role of SNc in PD pathogenesis has been challenging to study in vivo due to a lack of tools to investigate PD-related nigral neurodegeneration in living patients.Recent work has found incidental magnetization transfer (MT) effects 13 or explicit MT effects generated by MT preparation pulses [14][15][16] can be used to generate contrast sensitive to neurons in SNc in vivo.Application of MT effects to image depigmentation has revealed PD-related reductions in MT contrast ratios in SNc 13,[17][18][19] , nigral volume 14,[20][21][22][23][24][25] , or the area of SNc in a single slice 26,27 .Nigral regions of interest, derived from images with MT effects, have also been used to examine PD-related microstructural changes 28,29 or iron deposition 30,31 in SNc.
In prodromal populations, much of the work using MRI has focused on developing diagnostic markers in populations with iRBD.Striatal segmentation in T1-weighted images revealed reductions in striatal volume in iRBD relative to controls 32 .Application of MT effects have found reduced locus coeruleus contrast 33 , SNc area 34 , and SNc volume 35 in iRBD relative to controls.Hyposmic subjects with striatal dopamine transporter (123-I Ioflupane (DaTScan)) deficits  have a high risk of phenoconverting 36 and these results suggest that SNc may also be undergoing neurodegeneration in this population since DaTScan binding ratio is correlated with nigral volume 30 .However, the extent of SNc neuronal loss in hyposmic participants is unknown.

Participants
Criteria for inclusion of subjects from the PPMI database used in this analysis were as follows: 1) participants must be scanned with a MT-prepared gradient recalled echo (GRE) sequence on a Siemens scanner.A total of 312 participants (33 controls, 42 LRRK2 NMC, 41 GBA NMC, 65 prodromal hyposmic participants, 105 de novo PD patients, and 26 PD patients at the 48-month time point) met these criteria.NMC of LRRK2 and GBA mutations were confirmed to have pathogenic variants of LRRK2 (G2019s) or GBA (N409S, R535H, L29Afs*18, L483P) genes.These participants were included in the analysis if they had UPDRS-III scores ≤ 5 at the 48-month time point and were not diagnosed with PD.Non-manifest LRRK2 and GBA participants were taken at the 48-month time point since that was the first time point containing MT-prepared GRE images.All prodromal participants used in the analysis had hyposmia based on the University of Pennsylvania Smell Identification Test (UPSIT), dopamine transporter deficits, and were not diagnosed with PD.The PD patients at the 48month time point are not the same individuals from the de novo PD group.Imaging data were downloaded between July 2022 and January 2023.

Image Processing
MRI data was processed using the FMRIB Software Library (FSL).A transformation was derived between each individual's T1-weighted image and 2 mm Montreal Neurological Institute (MNI) T1-space using FMRIB's Linear Image Registration Tool (FLIRT) and FMRIB's Nonlinear Image Registration Tool (FNIRT) in the FSL software package using the following steps 37,38 .The T1weighted image was brain extracted using the brain extraction tool (BET).Next, an affine transform was used to align the brain extracted T1-weighted images with the MNI brain extracted image.Finally, a nonlinear transformation was used to generate a transformation from individual T1weighted images to T1-weighted MNI T1-space.
For each participant, individual MT-prepared GRE measurements were denoised 39 , corrected for motion by registering all the measurements to the first measurement using a rigid-body transform in FLIRT, and then averaged.Finally, a transform was derived between each individual's T1-weighted image and the averaged MT-prepared GRE image with a boundary-based registration cost function.This transform was then inverted.This procedure is illustrated in Figure 1.
SNc volume was segmented in native space using an automated thresholding method.To ensure consistent placement of reference regions of interest (ROIs), a reference ROI in the cerebral peduncle was created using the MNI template and, for each subject, the cerebral peduncle ROI was transformed to individual MT-prepared GRE images using the MNI-T1 and T1-GRE transforms described in previous paragraphs.The transform was done in a single step to reduce interpolation.The use of standard space ROIs ensured that the reference ROI was placed in similar locations for each subject.The mean (denoted ref), and standard deviation (ref) of the signal intensities were measured in the reference ROI.
Next, a standard space SNc atlas was used to localize regions surrounding SNc for thresholding. 40This atlas was thresholded at a level of 5%, binarized, dilated, and transformed from standard space to individual MT-prepared gradient echo images.The ROIs for thresholding were dilated to ensure that the entire SNc was included for thresholding.Voxels in the resulting ROIs with intensity >ref+2.8refwere considered to be part of SNc.This procedure is illustrated in Figure 1.

Statistical Analysis
All statistical analyses were performed using IBM SPSS Statistics software version 28 (IBM Corporation, Somers, NY, USA) and results are reported as mean  standard deviation.A P value of 0.05 was considered significant for all statistical tests performed in this work.Normality of SNc volume was assessed using the Shapiro-Wilk test for each group and all data was found to be normal.
For demographic data, analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to assess differences in age, years of education, UPDRS-III OFF score, and Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) of the prodromal PD, overt PD (de novo, moderate), and control groups.Chi square was used to examine differences in sex between groups.
The effect of genetic mutations (GBA, LRRK2) in NMC and controls on SNc volume was assessed with an analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) analysis controlling for age, total brain volume, MT-prepared GRE protocol used in the acquisition, and sex.The effect of group (control, prodromals, de novo PD, moderate PD) was tested with an ANCOVA for SNc volume controlling for sex, age, total brain volume, and the MT-prepared GRE protocol used in data acquisition.For all ANCOVAs, if the interaction was significant, post hoc comparisons between each pair of groups were performed using respective two-tailed t-tests.
The effect of nigral volume on clinical measures (MDS UPDRS-III OFF score, disease duration) was assessed by correlating nigral volume with clinical measures in the combined PD group (de novo+48-month).Correlations between clinical measures and nigral volume were performed using Pearson correlations in PD groups, controlling for age and total brain volume.A significant difference in sex was observed between de novo PD and prodromal groups (P=0.018)but no difference was seen between the other groups (Ps>0.202).A significant difference in age (F=5.259;P=0.002) was seen between the groups with the control group being younger, on average, as compared to the de novo PD (P<10 -3 ) and 48-month PD (P=0.003)groups.The prodromal (P=0.017) and 48-month PD (P=0.049)groups were older, on average as compared to the de novo PD group.No difference in education (F=0.541;P=0.655) or MoCA (F=2.006;P=0.114) was seen between the groups.MDS UPDRS-III OFF score exhibited a significant group difference (F=108.619;P<10 -3 ) with higher MDS UPDRS-III scores seen in the 48-month PD group relative to the prodromal, de novo PD, and control groups (Ps<10 -3 ).Higher MDS UPDRS-III scores were seen in the de novo PD group as compared to the prodromal and control groups (Ps<10 -3 ).The prodromal group exhibited higher MDS UPRDS-III scores relative to the control group (P<10 - 3 ).A significant difference was seen in UPSIT score between the groups (F=22.340;P<10 -3 ) with the prodromal (P<10 -3 ) and de novo PD (P<10 -3 ) groups showing reduced olfactory function relative to controls.Demographic information for the control, prodromal, de novo PD, and 48-month PD groups is summarized in Table 2.

Non-manifest Comparisons
The effect of LRRK2, GBA, and no genetic mutation on nigral volume in nonmanifest carriers and controls was tested with an ANCOVA analysis with the number of measurements in the acquisition protocol, total brain volume, sex, and age as covariates.ANCOVA analysis revealed no difference in nigral volume between NMCs of LRRK2 and GBA mutations and controls (F=0.076;P=0.927).The number of measurements in the acquisition protocol (F=0.209;P=0.648), total brain volume (F=3.304;P=0.072), and age (F=3.233;P=0.075) were not significant covariates in the model.These comparisons are shown in Figure 2. Sex was a significant covariate in the model (F=8.974;P=0.003).A spatial comparison of mean population SNc volume in the LRRK2 NMCs, GBA NMCs, and controls is shown in Figure 3.  5 and marginal means for each group are summarized in Table 3.

Nigral Volume Group Comparisons
The effect of genetic mutation (GBA, LRRK2) on SNc volume in the PD-group at the 48-month time point was tested using an ANCOVA with the number of measures in the NM protocol and sex as covariates.No main effect of group (F=0.822;P=0.496) was seen in SNc volume in the 48-month PD group (GBA: 259 mm 3  113 mm 3 ; LRRK2: 262 mm 3  106 mm 3 ).Sex (F=0.910;P=0.351) and NM protocol (F=1.624;P=0.641) were not significant covariates in the model.Reduced SNc volume was seen in PD patients at the 48-month time point with the LRRK2 mutation as compared to nonmanifest LRRK2 carriers (F=3.828;P=0.032).Similarly, reduced SNc volume was observed in PD patients at the 48-month time point with GBA mutation as compared to nonmanifest GBA carriers (F=6.113;P=0.005).

Discussion
This study examined PD-related SNc degeneration in prodromal hyposmic participants, de novo PD participants, and moderate PD participants.Standard space ROIs were used to calculate CNR and define SNc regions used in the thresholding-based segmentation procedure.This method has been shown to exhibit high scan-rescan reproducibility [41][42][43] .Application of the method found no difference in nigral volume between NMC of LRRK2 and GBA mutations and controls.Significant volume loss was seen in SNc of the prodromal PD group as well as in both PD groups as compared to controls.In addition, nigral volume in the moderate PD group (48-month PD) was reduced as compared to the de novo PD and prodromal groups.Further, SNc volume was similar for individuals with LRRK2 and GBA genetic mutations at the 48-month time point.3. Structure volumes from the marginal means in the control-pathology analysis.Data is presented as mean  standard deviation.ANCOVAS were used for group comparisons of SNc volume from which the P-values and F-values are shown.

A prior study examining striatal binding ratio from
. dopamine transporter imaging (123-I Ioflupane DaTScan) in LRRK2 NMCs in the PPMI dataset found no difference in striatal binding ratio between LRRK2 NMCs and non-carrier controls at baseline and observed no progression in striatal binding ratio in follow-ups over two years 44 .As DaTScan striatal binding ratio is correlated with nigral volume 30 , these results suggest that LRRK2 NMCs will have similar nigral volume as controls.Our analysis revealed no difference in nigral between controls and LRRK2 NMCs at the 4-year time point.These results may be due to incomplete penetrance of the LRRK2 mutations as only 5 of 175 of the NMC LRRK2 participants in PPMI have converted to PD or maybe due to slower progression of LRRK2 NMCs as compared to other prodromal groups.
Olfactory dysfunction is a common symptom of PD 45 and may precede clinical diagnosis by at least 4 years [46][47][48] .The prodromal hyposmic participants used here have dopamine transporter deficits and these participants are highly likely to phenoconvert to PD 36,49 .Dopamine transporter deficits suggest this population is experiencing nigral volume loss 30 .Consistent with this posit, reduced nigral volume was observed in the prodromal hyposmic group as compared to controls.Similar reductions in volume in the nigrostriatal system have been found in other PD prodromes likely to phenoconvert, such as iRBD 32,34,35 .Taken together, these results suggest the nigrostriatal system is undergoing neurodegeneration in the prodromal period of PD.
Reductions in contrast in MT-prepared GRE images were seen in the lateral and ventral portions of SNc in both PD groups as compared to controls (see Figure 2).Contrast in these regions is further reduced in the 48-month PD group as compared to the de novo PD group, suggesting that the depletion of melanized neurons continues as PD progresses.However, further longitudinal studies are needed to verify this observation.The loss of nigral volume result agrees with prior studies which found reductions in nigral width 27,50 , loss of contrast in the posterior portion of SNc 25 , or a loss of contrast in the lateral-ventral portions of SNc 19 .Further, these regions have been shown to overlap with nigrosome-1, the subregion of SNc with the greatest loss of melanized neurons 51,52 , and loss of contrast in these regions may be due to depletion of melanized neurons in nigrosome-1.
As compared to controls, reductions in contrast and volume were observed in the caudal and ventral portions of SNc in both PD groups with the 48-month PD group (see Figures 4 and 5).In particular, greater reductions in nigral contrast in these regions were seen in the Z=-18 mm and Z=-16 mm slices as compared the de novo PD group.Interestingly, when the PD groups were combined, a negative association was found between disease duration and nigral volume.These results suggests that loss of nigral neurons continues as PD progresses from the de novo stage into moderate stage of PD and agree with earlier studies that found nigral volume to be related to disease duration 23 .However, because this analysis employed a cross-sectional design with newly diagnosed and moderate PD individuals, a longitudinal study examining nigral volume and contrast in prodromal and de novo patients and following them over the course of PD is necessary to verify these findings.
There are several caveats to this study.First, the study employed a cross-sectional design to examine changes in Reduced contrast can be seen in the prodromal and PD groups as compared to the controls in slices Z=-18 mm and Z=-16 mm.For each group, the mean MTC image was created by transforming MTC images from individual participants to MNI space and then averaging.Arrows point to the regions exhibiting a loss of contrast in the de novo PD and 48-month PD groups as compared to controls.
. nigral volume in prodromal, de novo, and moderate PD.A true longitudinal study is needed to fully assess longitudinal changes in nigral volume over the course of prodromal and overt PD.Second, in contrast to earlier studies 25 , no correlation was seen between nigral volume and MDS-UPDRS-III score.This lack of correlation may be due to a lack of PD patients with more severe motor symptoms.Third, results examining nigral volume at the 48-month time point in LRRK2 and GBA carriers should be interpreted with caution and larger multi-contrast imaging studies examining the effect of genotype on nigral characteristics in PD are needed.Finally, significant heterogeneity was seen in the scan parameters of the MT-prepared GRE sequence.Scan parameter was used as a control in the ANCOVA analysis to combat this heterogeneity and scan parameter was not found to be a significant contributor to the model.
The current findings provide additional evidence that MT-effects robustly detect nigral depigmentation in prodromal hyposmic, de novo PD, and moderate PD groups.The moderate (48-month time point) PD group experienced greater PD-related nigral volume loss as compared to the prodromal and de novo PD groups.Genetic mutation was not found to influence nigral volume in NMCs.Finally, protocol was not found to have a significant effect on nigral volume.Reduced volume can be seen in all pathologic groups as compared to the controls in slices Z=-18 mm and Z=-16 mm.For each group, the SNc population mean was created by transforming SNc masks from individual participants to MNI space and then averaging.

Figure 1 .
Figure 1.Schematics illustrating the processing steps for the MT-prepared GRE data and SNc segmentation procedure.

.
SNpc volume differentiated SWEDD from PD better than SNpc The effect of disease severity (MDS UPDRS-III OFF score) and disease duration on nigral volume in the combined (de novo+48-month) PD group was assessed with Pearson correlations, controlling for age and brain volume.A significant correlation was seen between nigral volume and disease duration (r=-0.252;P=0.010) with longer disease duration correlated with lower nigral volume.No association was observed between nigral volume and MDS UPDRS-III OFF score (r=-0.048;P=0.640).

Figure
Figure 3.A comparison of SNc population mean volume in the control group (top row), nonmanifest LRRK2 carriers (middle row), and non-manifest GBA carriers (bottom row).For each group, the SNc population mean volume was created by transforming SNc masks from individual participants to MNI space and then averaging.

Figure 4 .
Figure 4.A comparison of mean SNc contrast in control (top row), prodromal (second row), de novo PD (third row), and 48-month PD (bottom row) groups.Reduced contrast can be seen in the prodromal and PD groups as compared to the controls in slices Z=-18 mm and Z=-16 mm.For each group, the mean MTC image was created by transforming MTC images from individual participants to MNI space and then averaging.Arrows point to the regions exhibiting a loss of contrast in the de novo PD and 48-month PD groups as compared to controls.

Figure 5 .
Figure 5.A comparison of SNc population means in control (top row), prodromal PD (second row), de novo PD (third row), and 48-month PD (bottom row) groups.Reduced volume can be seen in all pathologic groups as compared to the controls in slices Z=-18 mm and Z=-16 mm.For each group, the SNc population mean was created by transforming SNc masks from individual participants to MNI space and then averaging.

Table 1 .
Demographic information for the analysis examining effect of genetic mutation on nigral volume in nonmanifest subjects.Data is presented as mean  standard deviation unless noted otherwise.ANOVAs were used for group comparisons of age, education, UPDRS-III, and MoCA from which P values are shown.MDS UPDRS-III -Movement Disorders Society Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale Part III; MoCA -Montreal Cognitive Assessment.
. and the control group without mutations.Demographic information for this analysis is summarized in Table1.

Table 2 .
Demographic information for the groups used in the Control-PD pathology analysis.Data is presented as mean  standard deviation unless noted otherwise.ANOVAs were used for group comparisons of age, education, UPDRS-III, and MoCA from which P values are shown.MDS UPDRS-III was measured in the OFF state.UPSIT scores were not released for the 48-month PD participants.MDS UPDRS-III -Movement Disorders Society Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale Part III; UPSIT -University of Pennsylvania Smell Identification Test; MoCA -Montreal Cognitive Assessment.
*, **, and *** denote significant levels of P<0.05, P<0.01, and P<0.001, respectively.group (control, prodromal, de novo PD, 48-month PD) on SNc volume was assessed using an ANCOVA with number of measurements in the NM protocol, age, total brain volume, and sex as covariates.A significant main effect of group (F=5.192;P=0.002) revealed reduced SNc volume in the prodromal (P=0.028), de novo PD (P=0.002), and 48month PD (P<10 -3 ) groups relative to the control group.48month PD group showed reduced nigral volume as compared to the prodromal (P=0.031), and de novo PD (P=0.049)groups.No significant difference was observed between de novo PD and prodromal groups (P=0.537).Sex was a significant covariate in the model (F=13.823;P<10 -3 ) but NM protocol (F=0.830;P=0.363), age (F=0.003;P=0.957), and total brain volume (F=0.756;P=0.385) were not significant covariates.A comparison of SNc population mean volumes is shown in Figure