ApoER2-Dab1 disruption as the origin of pTau-related neurodegeneration in sporadic Alzheimer’s disease

BACKGROUND Sporadic Alzheimer’s disease (sAD) is not a global brain disease. Specific regions, layers and neurons degenerate early while others remain untouched even in advanced disease. The prevailing model used to explain this selective neurodegeneration—prion-like Tau spread—has key limitations and is not easily integrated with other defining sAD features. Instead, we propose that in humans Tau hyperphosphorylation occurs locally via disruption in ApoER2-Dab1 signaling and thus the presence of ApoER2 in neuronal membranes confers vulnerability to degeneration. Further, we propose that disruption of the Reelin/ApoE/ApoJ-ApoER2-Dab1-P85α-LIMK1-Tau-PSD95 (RAAAD-P-LTP) pathway induces deficits in memory and cognition by impeding neuronal lipoprotein internalization and destabilizing actin, microtubules, and synapses. This new model is based in part on our recent finding that ApoER2-Dab1 disruption is evident in entorhinal-hippocampal terminal zones in sAD. Here, we hypothesized that neurons that degenerate in the earliest stages of sAD (1) strongly express ApoER2 and (2) show evidence of ApoER2-Dab1 disruption through co-accumulation of multiple RAAAD-P-LTP components. METHODS We applied in situ hybridization and immunohistochemistry to characterize ApoER2 expression and accumulation of RAAAD-P-LTP components in five regions that are prone to early pTau pathology in 64 rapidly autopsied cases spanning the clinicopathological spectrum of sAD. RESULTS We found that: (1) selectively vulnerable neuron populations strongly express ApoER2; (2) numerous RAAAD-P-LTP pathway components accumulate in neuritic plaques and abnormal neurons; and (3) RAAAD-P-LTP components were higher in MCI and sAD cases and correlated with histological progression and cognitive deficits. Multiplex-IHC revealed that Dab1, pP85αTyr607, pLIMK1Thr508, pTau and pPSD95Thr19 accumulated together within dystrophic dendrites and soma of ApoER2-expressing neurons in the vicinity of ApoE/ApoJ-enriched extracellular plaques. These observations provide evidence for molecular derangements that can be traced back to ApoER2-Dab1 disruption, in each of the sampled regions, layers, and neuron populations that are prone to early pTau pathology. CONCLUSION Findings support the RAAAD-P-LTP hypothesis, a unifying model that implicates dendritic ApoER2-Dab1 disruption as the major driver of both pTau accumulation and neurodegeneration in sAD. This model provides a new conceptual framework to explain why specific neurons degenerate and identifies RAAAD-P-LTP pathway components as potential mechanism-based biomarkers and therapeutic targets for sAD.


I. Supplementary
. Competing explanatory hypotheses: Tau prion-like connectome-based spread vs dendritic RAAAD-P-LTP pathway disruption Table S2. Sixty-four cases spanning the clinicopathological spectrum of sAD  Tau has unique prion-like features-including the ability to serve as bio-template to convert native Tau into pathogenic species-that enable neuron-to-neuron spread • Progression reflects connectome-based spread throughout the brain from a single point of origin • Tau accumulation is the primary histopathological feature • Dendritic ApoER2-Dab1 disruption is the underlying cause of neurodegeneration • ApoER2-Dab1 disruption traps ApoER2 ligands in the extracellular space and disrupts signaling pathways that mediate cytoskeletal and synaptic stability • pTau is locally generated by ApoER2 expressing neurons in response to ApoER2-Dab1 disruption • High ApoER2 expression and demand for ApoER2-Dab1 activation predispose specific neurons to pTau accumulation • pTau is only one of multiple RAAAD-P-LTP pathway components that accumulate together in response to ApoER2-Dab1 disruption Global considerations • Mechanistic links to cytoskeletal and synaptic dysfunction and memory deficits Formation of new memories requires fine-tuned control of molecular pathways that shape and strengthen the actin cytoskeleton, microtubule cytoskeleton, and receptor complexes located within the dendrites of excitatory neurons (Fig 2B) No clear mechanism to explain destabilization of the actin cytoskeleton or postsynaptic receptor complexes Provides a straightforward mechanism-dendritic ApoER2-Dab1 disruption-that can explain destabilization of the actin and microtubule cytoskeletons, synaptic dysfunction, and cognitive deficits that characterize sAD in humans (Fig 2C) Intrinsic molecular features to explain local production of pTau Experimental evidence indicates that disruption of the ApoER2-Dab1 pathway induces Tau hyperphosphorylation [1][2][3][4][5] Does not propose a mechanism for local production Finding that ApoER2 expression parallels laminar and cellular distribution of pTau aligns with RAAAD-P-LTP disruption hypothesis ApoER2 is strongly expressed by each of five sampled neuron populations that are vulnerable to NFT pathology (Fig 3) Connectome-based pTau spread vs. local production at multiple anatomical locations Rodent and cellular models indicate that trans-synaptic Tau transmission is possible 6 Discrepancies between neuronal connectivity and NFT progression are extensive and detailed in each section below Accommodation requires hypothetical projections and a revised model of brain connectivity [7][8][9] Posits that pTau is locally produced by ApoER2-expressing neurons, thus no assumptions about neuronal connectivity are needed Does not require hypothetical projections or a revised model of brain connectivity Co-accumulation of RAAAD-P-LTP components in affected regions pTau is one of multiple RAAAD-P-LTP components that accumulate together in affected regions (Figs 4-9 No clear mechanism to explain why multiple RAAAD-P-LTP components-both upstream and parallel to pTau production-accumulate together with pTau -Since prion-like properties that enable propagation are thought to be unique to Tau, connectome-based spread of multiple RAAAD-P-LTP components is not likely Finding that pTau is one of numerous RAAAD-P-LTP components that accumulate together with pTau aligns with RAAAD-P-LTP disruption hypothesis • Demonstrates expression of molecular machinery required for local pTau production • Accumulation of RAAAD-P-LTP components that are both upstream and parallel to pTau production aligns with concept of ApoER2-Dab1 disruption Dendritic origin of pTau lesions pTau pathology originates in distal dendritic tips with sequential progression to proximal dendrites, soma, and finally axons 7 9 10 ApoER2, Dab1 and downstream RAAAD-P-LTP signaling partners are localized to PI-enriched lipid rafts within dendritic spines [11][12][13][14][15] Origin of pTau lesions in distal dendrites is attributed to axonto-dendrite spread No mechanism to explain why multiple RAAAD-P-LTP components accumulate together with pTau in dystrophic dendrites

Finding that RAAAD-P-LTP components including pTau accumulate in dendrites aligns with dendritic RAAAD-P-LTP disruption hypothesis
ApoER2 is strongly expressed within dendritic projections emanating from vulnerable neuron populations (Fig 3) Multiple RAAAD-P-LTP components co-accumulate in MAP2-labeled dystrophic dendrites in each region (Figs 4-9) Mechanistic & spatial links between four pTau-containing lesions Molecular mechanisms linking four pTau-containing sAD lesions (NTs, NFTs, NPs, GVDs) are not yet clearly defined No clear mechanism to spatially link NT/NFTs to NPs and GVDs Provides a straightforward mechanism-dendritic ApoER2-Dab1 disruption-that could mechanistically and spatially link these four pTau-containing lesions (Fig 2C) Tau prion-like connectome-based spread hypothesis pTau pathology originates in distal dendrites, followed by cell bodies and finally axons 7 9 16 No clear explanation for this laminar and cellular distribution of pTau Finding that ApoER2 expression parallels laminar and cellular distribution of pTau aligns with RAAAD-P-LTP disruption hypothesis • ApoER2 is strongly expressed by ErC L2 stellate neurons and subsets of L2 and L4 pyramids (Fig 3) •

•
ErC pTau pathology precedes LC in some cases 26 Discrepancies with neuronal connectivity: -No known connections or mechanisms to explain selective spread of pTau from LC to ErC L2 while sparing other LCconnected layers and neurons

No assumptions about neuronal connectivity are needed
ProS-CA1 border region Laminar, cellular, and subcellular pTau distribution -ProS-CA1 border region is the first hippocampal area to accumulate pTau (NFT stage II) -Involvement of the basal 'stripe' of the ProS is particularly prominent and early -pTau later accumulates the apical stripe

No clear explanation for this laminar and cellular distribution of pTau
Finding that ApoER2 expression parallels laminar and cellular distribution of pTau aligns with RAAAD-P-LTP disruption hypothesis -ApoER2 is strongly expressed by two basal ProS-CA1 neuron populations (basal pyramids and CR-like cells that reside in the basal stripe) (Fig 3) -Moderate-to-strong expression in basal & apical dendritic tufts emanating from ProS-CA1 pyramids (Fig 3) pTau spread: neuronal connectivity -In NFT stage I, pTau pathology is confined to ErC L2 projection neurons. In NFT stage II, pTau pathology progresses to include the basal lamina of the ProS-CA1 border region. In successive NFT stages, pTau pathology progresses throughout the cornu ammonis. DG neurons are spared from NFT pathology until late-stage sAD (NFT stages V-VI) (Fig 1A).
-The first connection of the unidirectional tri-synaptic memory circuit is made between axons projecting from ErC L2 neurons to dendritic arbors emanating from DG neurons (Fig 1A). 27 These axons are known as the 'perforant path' because they perforate (bypass) the subiculum before synapsing with DG neurons. 27 The second and third synapses underlying memory connect DG neurons to CA3 pyramids (via mossy fiber axons) and CA3 neurons to CA1 pyramids (via Schaffer collateral axons), respectively. -Thus, NFT progression proceeds in a direction opposite to unidirectional connectivity in the medial temporal lobe memory system 27 28 and spares the major synaptic recipient of ErC L2 neurons (DG neurons) until latestage sAD (Fig 1A). 7 Discrepancies with neuronal connectivity: -Since cortical NFT pathology begins in ErC L2, a connectome-based spread model predicts sequential pTau spread in accordance with unidirectional connectivity in the medial temporal lobe memory system (from ErC L2 to DG, followed by DG to CA3, CA3 to CA1, and finally to the subiculum).
There are no known connections or mechanisms to explain: -Why NFT progression proceeds in a direction opposite to unidirectional connectivity in the medial temporal lobe memory system -Selective spread of pTau from ErC L2 (NFT stage I) to ProS (NFT stage II) 27 28 while sparing the major synaptic recipient of ErC L2 neurons (DG neurons) until end-stage sAD ( Fig  1A). 7

No assumptions about neuronal connectivity are needed
Tau prion-like connectome-based spread hypothesis

Dendritic RAAAD-P-LTP disruption hypothesis
Solitary L5 & L2/3 temporal pyramids Cellular and laminar pTau distribution -pTau accumulates in distal dendrites of rare, isolated L5 and L2/3 neocortical pyramids in the earliest stage of sAD (NFT stage 1) -all dendrites of each affected neuron are generally involved while neighboring neurons are spared -Spiny stellate cells in L4 are spared even in advanced sAD 9 29 No clear explanation for this laminar and cellular distribution of pTau Finding that ApoER2 expression parallels cellular and laminar distribution of pTau in neocortex aligns with RAAAD-P-LTP disruption hypothesis -ApoER2 strongly expressed by subset of L5 and L2/3 pyramidal neurons, their basal and apical dendrites, and dendritic tufts in the L2/3 border region (Fig 3) -L4 spiny stellate cells have weak or absent ApoER2 expression (Fig 3) -The strong expression in L2 and low expression in L3 creates a visible laminar threshold at the L2-L3 border (Fig 3) pTau spread: neuronal connectivity -pTau lesions are classically thought to originate in the LC before spreading to the cortex. 17 18 -LC axons arborize over large areas and functionally diverse targets, [19][20][21][22][23][24] including pyramidal neurons in all layers of the human temporal cortex (Fig 1). 25 -Individual projection neurons classically innervate hundreds (or even thousands) of neighboring target neurons 30 31 rather than making one-toone connections with a single target neuron. Yet pTau accumulates within solitary L5 and L2/3 neocortical pyramids in very early sAD stages ( Fig  1A) 9  The observation that all dendrites of affected solitary pyramids accumulate pTau while neighboring neurons are spared is not easily reconciled with prion-like propagation Braak et al 8 9 suggested we may need to rethink traditional brain connectivity in order to reconcile these isolated pTau lesions with the Tau prion-like spread hypothesis. In this connectome-inspired revision, all pre-synaptic terminals emanating from a single donor axon synapse on dendrites emanating from a single target neuron and refrain from contacting neighboring neurons. 8 9 No assumptions about neuronal connectivity are needed Finding that pTau accumulates within multiple distal dendrites of rare, isolated L5 and L2/3 neocortical pyramids is attributed to ApoER2-Dab1 disruption-with ensuring Tau hyperphosphorylation-in ApoER2-enriched dendritic spines of L5 and L2/3 pyramids Pontine LC-PC and Raphe nucleus pTau distribution -Pre-tangles are evident in the LC and peri-coeruleus in the earliest stages of sAD (pre-tangle stages a/b) -LC fusiform-shaped neurons prominently affected -pTau later accumulates in raphe nucleus (pre-tangle stage c) -Classically precedes cortical pTau; however, ErC precedes LC and raphe nucleus in some cases 26

No clear explanation for this laminar and cellular distribution of pTau
Finding that ApoER2 expression matches the cellular distribution of pTau aligns with RAAAD-P-LTP disruption hypothesis -ApoER2 is strongly expressed by LC and raphe nucleus neurons including fusiform shaped projection neurons, and neurons located between these two nuclei (Fig 3) -ApoER2 is strongly expressed in highly branched neuritic projections emanating from LC and raphe neurons and in the peri-coeruleus region harboring MAP2-labeled dendritic tufts emanating from LC neurons (Fig 3) -ApoER2 is also strongly expressed within proximal dendrites, and dense dendritic projections emanating into in the peri-coeruleus (Fig 3) pTau spread: neuronal connectivity -LC axons arborize over large areas and functionally diverse targets, [19][20][21][22][23][24] including pyramidal neurons in all layers of the human temporal cortex (Fig 1) 25 -Raphe nucleus serotonergic axons arborize over large areas and functionally diverse targets 33 Discrepancies with neuronal connectivity: -No known connections or mechanisms to explain selective spread from LC and/or the raphe nucleus to either ErC L2 neurons or rare, isolated L5 and L2/3 neocortical pyramids