1 Challenges of stakeholders’ engagement for developing pragmatic, primary 2 health care interventions for chronic respiratory diseases in low resource set- 3 tings in India 4

Chronic respiratory diseases (CRDs) in low resource settings in India are often poorly diagnosed, 23 leading to missed opportunities for early initiation of treatment and poor patient pathways. There 24 is also a poor understanding in rural communities of the causes of CRDs; many symptoms are 25 incorrectly attributed to ‘asthma’ and treatment is inconsistent and often based on inaccurate di- 26 agnoses. There is a high prevalence of CRDs in rural regions of India. It is vital that interven- 27 tions are developed to improve an understanding about CRD in low resource settings in India in 28 order to reduce exposure to common risk factors and improve access to evidence based care. We 29 piloted a frontline health care worker delivered ‘educate, screen and treat’ intervention pro- 30 gramme. We explored the role of stakeholders’ engagement towards the development of feasible 31 community based interventions. The hypothesis was that without meaningful engagement with 32 the key stakeholders, long term sustainability of the programme would be limited and potentially 33 viewed as primarily for the organisation’s self-interest. A mixed method study combined a quan- 34 titative online survey of the sensitised health care providers and a qualitative assessment of the 35 other stakeholders’ engagement activities. The methods of qualitative data collection included 36 focus group discussions, feedback and individual interviews and data analysis used a thematic 37 framework. We identified key stakeholders and investigated their knowledge, perceptions, be- 38 liefs, practices, educational needs and suggestions for improved care for CRD. Three main 39 themes were 1) Community trust building 2) Mismatch between community awareness about 40 CRD and access to evidence based care resources 3) Finding effective communication methods 41 for low health literate and older age group population with CRD. First theme was built on two 42 sub-themes: sensitised influential people in the community (community advisory committee); 43 empowered, trained health workers in the community for patient screening and navigation. Sec- 44

Chronic respiratory diseases (CRDs) in low resource settings in India are often poorly diagnosed, 23 leading to missed opportunities for early initiation of treatment and poor patient pathways. There 24 is also a poor understanding in rural communities of the causes of CRDs; many symptoms are 25 incorrectly attributed to 'asthma' and treatment is inconsistent and often based on inaccurate di -26 agnoses. There is a high prevalence of CRDs in rural regions of India. It is vital that interven-27 tions are developed to improve an understanding about CRD in low resource settings in India in 28 order to reduce exposure to common risk factors and improve access to evidence based care. We 29 piloted a frontline health care worker delivered 'educate, screen and treat' intervention pro -30 gramme. We explored the role of stakeholders' engagement towards the development of feasible 31 community based interventions. The hypothesis was that without meaningful engagement with 32 the key stakeholders, long term sustainability of the programme would be limited and potentially 33 viewed as primarily for the organisation's self-interest. A mixed method study combined a quan-34 titative online survey of the sensitised health care providers and a qualitative assessment of the 35 other stakeholders' engagement activities. The methods of qualitative data collection included 36 focus group discussions, feedback and individual interviews and data analysis used a thematic 37 framework. We identified key stakeholders and investigated their knowledge, perceptions, be-38 liefs, practices, educational needs and suggestions for improved care for CRD. Three main 39 themes were 1) Community trust building 2) Mismatch between community awareness about 40 CRD and access to evidence based care resources 3) Finding effective communication methods 41 for low health literate and older age group population with CRD. First theme was built on two 42 sub-themes: sensitised influential people in the community (community advisory committee); 43 empowered, trained health workers in the community for patient screening and navigation. Sec-44 ond theme informed by three sub-themes: availability of sensitized health care providers and 45 empowered health system; recognizing access to evidence based care for CRD in the re-46 gion/district; recognizing the community's change in behavior related to management of CRD 47 with education. Third theme was informed by 2 sub-themes: community's ability to understand 48 the messages through different educational media and tools; challenges in engaging the low 49 health literacy population. The findings of this study add to the literature on the numerous chal-50 lenges faced by patients with CRD in low resource settings, indicating the need for identifying 51 and educating key stakeholders, continuous support of patients, personalised education, and ca-52 pacity building of health care providers. Given the significant challenges that the patients face, a 53 feasible primary health care model needs to be developed incorporating strategies to deal with 54 these challenges. 55 56 Background 57 Chronic Respiratory Diseases (CRDs), including asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease 58 (COPD) and bronchiectasis, are common public health problems with high prevalence and mor-59 tality rates globally and more so in developing countries. 1,2 COPD is the 3rd leading cause of 60 death in the world; around 90% of all COPD deaths and 88% of all disability-adjusted life years 61 (DALYs) due to COPD occur in developing countries. 3 Asthma is the 16 th most important dis-62 order in the world in terms of the extent and duration of disability. 4 It is estimated that asthma 63 alone accounts for the loss of approximately 15 million DALYs and 180,000 deaths annually 64 representing approximately 1% of the total global disease burden, and its prevalence has been 65 . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 19, 2022 Towards the development of culturally appropriate, feasible, community based interventions to 80 address issues related to management of CRD in the rural areas, we explored the role of stake-81 holder engagement. We undertook significant stakeholder engagement activities to identify the 82 best tools for effective communication within the available resources, foster trust and confidence 83 of communities, and support for our new intervention on CRD care. We hypothesized that with-84 out meaningful engagement with the key stakeholders, long term sustainability of the program 85 would be limited and potentially viewed as primarily for the organization's self-interest. 86 The World Health Organization (WHO) defines stakeholder engagement as the process of devel-87 oping relationships that enable stakeholders to work together to address health-related issues and 88 . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 19, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.04.15.22272333 doi: medRxiv preprint promote well-being to achieve positive health outcomes. 11 In this paper, we present the process 89 of identifying stakeholders, methods of engagement, stakeholders' perceptions and experiences 90 of the factors influencing implementation and patient participation in the program. 91

92
Study setting 93 The study was undertaken in a rural population in the State of Tamil Nadu, India. The residents 94 of the study villages were mostly engaged in agriculture related jobs; other occupations include 95 small businesses, weaving, poultry farming and salaried service jobs. About 97% of the popula-96 tion identified as Hindus; literacy level among men was approximately 74% and among women 97 was 57%; sex ratio was 984; ~30% of the households use biomass fuel as an alternative source of 98 energy for cooking. A recent study conducted by the investigators showed a CRD prevalence 99 rate of 14 percent in this population. 12  The first step of stakeholders' engagement was to identify those stakeholders who can promote 108 the proposed primary health care based interventions and make suggestions for improvement. 109 We had identified primary care physicians in the district for whom a workshop was organized 110 . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 19, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.04.15.22272333 doi: medRxiv preprint prior to project inception, followed by a continuing medical education (CME) workshop; the 111 primary care nurses who attended a nursing conference were engaged through a talk and exhibi-112 tion; and the health care workers who were expected to do the patient screening and navigate 113 them for care were given training. The next step was to engage those who are impacted by CRD 114 (patients, family members and community) to raise awareness, support behavior change, maxi-115 mize screening uptake and improve compliance to treatment and follow-up. The community en-116 gagement used theory of planned behavior informed approach and the methods comprised of 117 face-to-face, individual and group-based behaviour change interventions using leaflets, video-118 shows, live puppet shows, 'health mela'(health festival) and school health programme. In addi-119 tion, we formed a community advisory committee comprising of CRD patients, village leaders 120 and key influencers in the community to ensure community participation in the development of 121 the programme. 122

123
The focus of the overall research was to develop feasible, effective interventions to enhance the 124 ability of patients, providers and policymakers to make evidence-based decisions on CRD man-125 agement in low resource settings. A mixed method study was conducted using quantitative 126 online survey for a sample of sensitised healthcare providers, 3 months after the CME and quali-127 tative assessment of the other stakeholders' engagement activities. The qualitative study was 128 based on grounded theory that involved the collection and analysis of actual data and the meth-129 ods included focus group discussions, feedback, and individual interviews. 13 We stopped the 130 qualitative research after a theoretical saturation was reached at a point where we had sampled 131 and analyzed the data and uncovered all data. 14 The study explored the knowledge, change in 132 attitude and practices regarding CRD management among the health care providers. 133 . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 19, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.04.15.22272333 doi: medRxiv preprint The community education was based on pragmatic, theory-of planned behavior informed ap-134 proach. Community members who participated in the puppet shows, video shows, and received 135 leaflets were assessed to gather the depth of understanding of the health messages. Individual, 136 semi-structured interviews were conducted with the purposively sampled participants of the edu-137 cational activities. Structured topic guides were developed for interviews. Interviews conducted 138 in vernacular language (Tamil) were recorded, transcribed verbatim and translated into English 139 by the transcribers and translators (PJ, BBV). Analysis employed the thematic framework 140 method. 141

142
The quantitative data from survey of health care providers was analysed using frequencies and 143 percentages. Analysis of the qualitative data was conducted by a team of experts comprised of 144 implementation research expert, community health physicians and a public health specialist who 145 have had training in qualitative data analysis. Transcripts were manually analyzed using qualita-146 tive thematic framework analysis. Data analysis proceeded in two steps. (a) In the initial step, 147 coding of the transcripts was carried out that described the CRD related knowledge acquired, 148 perceived preventive measures, change of attitude, change in practices and behavior made, ac-149 cess to care and suggestions to ways of reaching community. This first step was conducted sepa-150 rately by H and PJ guided by RI. In the second step, preliminary codes were compared across the 151 types of participants by RI, H and similar codes were grouped and put under the same categories 152 and sub-categories which were later discussed and revised together with RI, H, and PJ during a 153 series of meetings. By sorting the codes into categories, we were able to detect consistent and 154 overarching themes emerging from the data and the sub-categories were the supporting/sub-155 themes. 156 . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 19, 2022. ; In order to enhance credibility and trustworthiness, H, BBV and PJ examined the transcripts 157 from the interviews with the community members and the other stakeholders and together the 158 data collection team reached a consensus on the final analysis. The process of thematic analysis 159 is displayed in 166 In order to develop community trust, key people in the community were invited to form a com-167 munity advisory group. They were expected to promote the proposed community interventions 168 and obtain feedback from the wider community on the new CRD care initiative. Those who vol-169 unteered to participate were former 'panchayat'(village council) presidents, coordinator and 170 . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 19, 2022   . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 19, 2022 Though about 70% of the providers were comfortable using mMRC and GINA guidelines, about 216 38% of them did not have access to spirometer or peak flow meters to measure the lung function; 217 42.9% of them have changed the practice of using oral medications to recommended inhaler 218 . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 19, 2022. The people's ability to understand the educational messages was as follows: 232 . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 19, 2022 . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 19, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.04.15.22272333 doi: medRxiv preprint ..After seeing the videos, my family is advising me to take inhaler before going to bed. They ha-256 ven't said these things before but after seeing the video only this change has happened. All these 257 give happiness to me; …. Before they (family) never used to ask me, they have only seen me ei-258 ther crying or struggling to breathe and get air. Since they too watched the video shows along is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 19, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.04.15.22272333 doi: medRxiv preprint Studies report several barriers to primary health care based interventions at various levels of 279 healthcare delivery: at the patient level, provider team level, organizational level, or policy 280 level. 16 A study undertaken in Sweden on stakeholders' engagement in the prevention and man-281 agement of Type 2 diabetes found community members were comfortable in living in close prox-282 imity with shared beliefs, values and resources. Authors identified several mismatches between 283 awareness of patient needs and motivation to access available resources for type 2 diabetes 284 (T2D) prevention. People were content to follow common, routine practices, however they were 285 willing to make changes if their issues were addressed in a culturally appropriate manner 17 In 286 addition, investigators observed the interaction between the communities and stakeholders was 287 limited and concluded there are barriers in the collaboration between community, healthcare in-288 stitutions and other stakeholders which will consequently affect the implementation of preven-289 tive interventions. Henceforth, the authors recommended exploring innovative ways to link the 290 community to the healthcare sector and build the capacity of health systems for T2D prevention 291 in socioeconomically disadvantaged communities. The identification of the influential stake-292 holders before starting the intervention is crucial and integral to its success. We recruited a panel 293 of stakeholders that included patients and their family members, key community members and 294 health care providers. Yoshita et al (2016) emphasized the significance of involving patients 295 themselves, the most crucial stakeholders who are being impacted. 18 However, the highlight of 296 the literature has been the challenges associated with stakeholders' participation in any new in-297 tervention. 19,20,21 These challenges have not been empirically explored, especially within the con-298 text of low income countries. 299 This study is one of the few that discusses the definition of stakeholder engagement, processes 300 involved in engaging them, their contribution to launching primary health care model of CRD 301 . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. Building Community trust 320 The initiative to involve the gate keepers (community advisory committee) in the community 321 certainly helped to build a community trust. It was proved by the enthusiasm shown by them 322 about the new CRD care initiative and their many suggestions including ways to inform the 323 community, provision of community pharmacy managed by health workers and how to motivate 324 . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 19, 2022. ; people to comply with preventive measures. Studies have shown that community partnerships 325 are most effective in building trust and thereby contributes significantly to health promotion and 326 disease prevention programmes. 25,26, 27 327 Stakeholders' engagement for sustainable delivery of evidence based 328 care for CRD 329 For sustainable care, about 80 primary care physicians in the district were trained through CME, 330 followed by a sample survey after 3 months to understand the outcome. The majority (70%) of 331 the health care providers in the district, the backbone of health services, felt comfortable using 332 mMRC and GINA guidelines for managing asthma and COPD respectively after attending the 333 CME. About 42.9% of them changed the practice of using oral medications to recommended in-334 haler therapy. However, around 38% did not have access to spirometer or peak flow meters and a 335 similar proportion of providers found it difficult to follow up the patients with clinical reviews at 336 regular intervals. In low resource settings in India, most centers have no diagnostic facilities like 337 spirometers and imaging facilities to make the correct diagnosis and recommend appropriate 338 treatment. Culturally, most patients choose to access care from a randomly picked provider, mak-339 ing out-of pocket payment and often not returning to the same provider for follow-up that results 340 in logistical difficulties in tracking disease progression and compliance to treatment in patients. 341 In addition, on assessment of access to care, the patients opined that due to the chronic nature of 342 the disease, medications should be delivered at the peripheral health centers (a community phar-343 macy) to avoid people losing a day's wage by traveling 10-15 km to secondary care level hospi-344 tals and waiting hours for medication refills in the overcrowded busy outpatient department. Pre-345 vious studies undertaken in other low resource settings around the world have identified similar 346 barriers to accessing appropriate evidence based care for chronic diseases. 28,29,30 347 . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 19, 2022

Impact of community engagement/ Community educational efforts
Knowledge deficits and beliefs concerning certain aspects of CRD and its treatment were re-349 vealed from both the patients' and the community members' accounts. These accounts also ex-350 posed disempowerment and uncertainty regarding access to inhalers, a mismatch between the 351 awareness and access to evidence based care. It was enlightening for the investigators to see 352 how the same education materials and methods were viewed differently by people of similar 353 educational background and age. Some were able to understand the health messages from live 354 puppet shows whereas some others did not engage. However the multiple educational methods 355 and tools used for this research did raise the general awareness about CRD care as shown in the 356

362
The findings of this study add to the literature on the numerous challenges faced by patients with 363 CRD in low resource settings, indicating the need for identifying relevant stakeholders, continu-364 ous support of patients, personalised education, and capacity building of health care providers to 365 navigate through the many hurdles faced by the patients. Overall, the community welcomed the 366 idea of the new initiative to treat their diseases, however, the patients felt that they have limited 367 capacity to procure inhalers and manage the cultural and economic factors that challenge CRD 368 care. Given the significant challenges that the patients face, a feasible primary health care model 369 needs to be developed incorporating strategies to deal with these challenges. 370 . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted April 19, 2022 We are indebted to our research team at the study site who worked passionately to complete the 372 study, frontline health care workers who volunteered to assist with the care, the RESPIRE team 373 at the university of Edinburgh (lead partner) and other partner organisations for their support and 374 suggestions and to all the participants who responded to stakeholders' engagement activities. 375