The responsiveness of health service provider and quality of services when provided at 2 three selected urban primary health care sites in Dhaka city, Bangladesh: A cross– sectional study

Introduction Responsiveness of Health Service Provider (HSP) and quality of services when provided resembles basic professional and social duties of HSP towards their clients.Because of poor responsiveness and quality of services when provided, clients lose their trust towards HSP. These factorsare very important to improve relationship between HSP and clients, clients satisfaction, quality of care and finally increase utilization of Urban Primary Health Care Centre services (UPHC). Objectives This study was done to determine the responsiveness of health service provider and quality of services when provided at selected UPHCs in Dhaka city. Methodology A cross sectional quantitative study was conductedin three UPHCs in Dhaka cityfrom November to December 2017. 257 exit interviewswere conducted bysystematic random sampling for responsiveness and quality of services when provided.49 observations of client-provider interactions were conducted using Responsiveness of Physician (ROP) scale.For exit interview, dichotomous variable was used. Descriptive analysis was done using Stata v 12.1. Findings Majority (90%) of HSP listen carefully, explained about the diseases, facilitated about follow-up, and client understood information clearly. More than 70% of the clients found the providers approach were friendly though only 37% had social talk with the clients. 41% of the clients reported that the providers shared emergency contact number. Around 67% of clients were not asked allergic history and in 47% case consent was not taken before procedure. Being urban area, for more than 39% clients services were not given similar in terms of social status like gender, ethnicity, economic and social status. Fortangible items like gloves (80%) and thermometer (55%) were mostly missingin all UPHCs.88% of theHSP were reliable, 93% assured the client and 91% showed empathy in all facilities. Clients were mostly satisfied withdoctors behaviour and dissatisfied about the long waiting time (average 37 minutes)in all UPHCs. Conclusion: This study has highlighted some important gaps in responsiveness of HSP which translate into the quality of care being provided to clients seeking care from UPHC. Friendliness of HSP should be increased and services should be provided with respect.


26
Responsiveness of Health Service Provider (HSP) and quality of services when provided 27 resembles basic professional and social duties of HSP towards their clients. Because of poor 28 responsiveness and quality of services when provided, clients lose their trust towards HSP. 29 These factors are very important to improve relationship between HSP and clients, clients' 30 satisfaction, quality of care and finally increase utilization of Urban Primary Health Care 31 Centre services (UPHC).

32
Objectives 33 This study was done to determine the responsiveness of health service provider and quality of 34 services when provided at selected UPHCs in Dhaka city.  follow-up, and client understood information clearly. More than 70% of the clients found the 45 providers approach were friendly though only 37% had social talk with the clients. 41% of 46 the clients reported that the providers shared emergency contact number. Around 67% of 47 clients were not asked allergic history and in 47% case consent was not taken before 48 procedure. Being urban area, for more than 39% clients services were not given similar in 49 terms of social status like gender, ethnicity, economic and social status. 50 For tangible items like gloves (80%) and thermometer (55%) were mostly missing in all 51 UPHCs. 88% of the HSP were reliable, 93% assured the client and 91% showed empathy in 52 all facilities. Clients were mostly satisfied with doctor's behaviour and dissatisfied about the  is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint The copyright holder for this this version posted March 31, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.28.22273063 doi: medRxiv preprint 4 85 service delivery. Lack of regular refresher training and supervision from higher authority has 86 raised questions on quality of services. Since there is no regular coordination between 87 MoHFW and MoLGRDC, there is gap in technical advice to improve quality of services 88 when provided [13,14,15]. 89 In Bangladesh, conflicts between doctors and clients is increasing because patient claims that 90 doctors neglect patient while doctors claim back that they are assaulted by clients [8]. Factors 91 like behaviour, friendliness, respecting, informing and guiding, gaining trust and optimizing 92 benefit etc. which influence responsiveness and this directly affect the quality of services 93 when provided at health facilities [7, 16,17,18,19,20,21]. studies on stated aspects. Since responsiveness and quality of services both influence the 103 service access and utilization, hence exploring responsiveness and quality is crucial to ensure 104 service use and promote country achieve sustainable development goals. Therefore, this study 105 will help to give evidence to improve policy and fill the knowledge gaps.  Responsiveness is determined by information, friendliness, trustworthiness, non-maleficence 111 and respect for dignity of person. Similarly, quality of services when provided is determined 112 by tangible items, reliability, assurance, empathy, and client satisfaction. These factors jointly 113 influence on utilization of the services (Fig 1).
. CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a perpetuity.
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint PHCCs one in each ward. There are around 80 satellite clinic pockets in each UPHC. It 138 provides services from 15 sites in each day (Fig 2).

139
Study participants 140 We selected service users for exit interview and service providers for observation as study 141 participants in CRHCC and PHCC of the selected UPHCs. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint  is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint Pre-testing and finalizing tool 178 Preliminary questionnaire was pre-tested to ensure intelligibility, length, organization and  Data collection 186 We collected data by interviewing service users and observing when service was provided by 187 using the tools from 19 November to 3 December 2017.

188
Structured questionnaire was used during exit interview to collect clients' experiences on 189 responsiveness and quality of services provided by HSP because it will give immediate 190 feedback after utilizing the services. The tool was interviewer assisted. Side by side,  is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint We explained to our research assistants and researchers about our questionnaire in detail. We scores. In exit interview, we asked service users regarding their perception regarding HSP. It 213 was dichotomous variable with yes or no answer. (Table 2 & 3) Positive and negative 214 answers were calculated separately. We used descriptive analysis method [12,26].  is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint

234
Sociodemographic of respondents 235 Our research was aimed to find the quality of services when provided and responsiveness of 236 HSP by using exit interview. Out of 257 exit interviews, 114 were from BAPSA, 92 from 237 KMSS and 51 were from Nari Maitree. In our study, 98.8% respondents were female and 238 1.2% were Male. Around 5% participants were below 18 years, more than 50% were from 18 239 to 24 age group, 33% were from 25 to 34, rest of them were above 35 years. About 98% were 240 married. In total, 95% follow Islam religion. Only, 10% were employed. Around 82% clients 241 came from catchment area of respective UPHCs. Only 7.3% were uneducated. We did 242 descriptive analysis. Our findings are divided into two main parts according to the objectives.  is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint Only 70% clients said HSP asked their name and only 37% engaged in social talks to build 271 rapport. In BAPSA, 37% of clients were not asked their name and for 68% social talks was 272 not done as a part of rapport building. According to observation, the average score for asking 273 patient's name was 1.9, social talks was 2 out of 4. It means that, HSP asked the name but did 274 not care about it or used it. There was a minimum social talk.

275
In few cases, HSP asked about the family during the talks. Its score was 1.5 out of 4. That 276 means, HSP was not interested to know about family during their conversation.

277
Around 94% clients said that conversation was socio-cultural friendly and two-way 278 conversation with eye contact in all facilities. Observation showed that average score of 279 friendly was 2, use of patient friendly language was 2.7 and sense of humor was 1.7 out of 4. 280 Friendliness scores showed that, HSP were friendly in minimum level. HSP used some 281 medical terminologies and explained some of it. It also showed that, HSP had some humor or 282 smiling during the conversation. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint that HSP were not service oriented. Observation showed, average score of service orientation 289 service was 3.2 out of 4. Observation showed that HSP services were not business oriented 290 but was not even service oriented also.

291
In 18% cases HSP misbehaved with patient during communication. Height misbehave from 292 HSP was perceived in BAPSA (26%). Observation score was 2.6 out of 4. It suggested that, 293 HSP showed minimum respect to the patient.

294
Observation average score in HSP involving in ethical and legal activities was 3.9 out of 4. It 295 showed HSP was not involve in any illegal activities, which increase trust among the clients.  suggested that, HSP slightly discouraged clients to ask question.

313
After the treatment in 82% cases, closing salute was given. ROP scale score was 1.8 out of 4 314 on closing salute. It means HSP did not greeted but replied back by gesture.

315
Services were not similar in terms of gender, ethnicity, religion, caste, social status and 316 economic status. In terms of gender, ethnicity and religion, 39% felt services was not similar. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint Similarly, for social status and economic status, more than 50% felt services were not similar.

318
Around 42% patient felt dissimilar services in terms of caste.

319
Quality of services when provided 320 In exit interviews, we asked quality of services to service users (clients) regarding their 321 perception when service was provided. They were dichotomous variables with yes or no 322 answer. Findings on five domains are described below. (Table 4) 323 Tangibility 324 Among the seven basic items of examination room, 95% clients find the doctors room 325 visually attractive. Sphygmomanometer (82%) and stethoscope (77%) was mostly available 326 during examination in all UPHCs. Observation finding showed that stethoscope was available 327 (100%) in all places but sphygmomanometer was not available in counselor and pediatrician 328 room. Availability of thermometer and measuring tape was only around 40% in all UPHC 329 while observation showed that, they were available but used occasionally. Finding showed 330 that, availability of gloves was only 20%, being lowest at KMSS (13%). Our observation 331 finds that, gloves was available in 80% of our observation but HSP did not use gloves during 332 examination in all three UPHCs. Among the clients who had already used the services before, 333 said all the UPHCs' standard of services was improved (more than 62%), but around 25% of 334 clients said it was not improved and more than 12% clients said it was degrading. Services 335 were degrading more in KMSS and Nari Maitree (15% each).

337
Majority of the clients said HSP were reliable when they provide services. UPHCs responded 338 timely (96%) and HSP was dependable (98%). However, in 12% cases, they did not write in 339 OPD records, more in KMSS (22%). Our observation showed that, HSP wrote drug 340 prescriptions in OPD records. However, for ANC checkups HSP wrote examination findings.

341
Full history was not written for the future records. In all three UPHCs, HSP gave courage and assurance to clients (96%), there was someone to 345 give assistance (93%) and hence clients felt safe to share their problems (97%). Observation is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint showed, for older physician, courage and assurance was the part of their suggestion whereas 347 for middle aged physician, assurance was not common.

349
Out of total responses, 98% said HSP provided dedicated attention during consultation. 91% 350 clients have said that they got enough time to share problems, 96% said HSP were 351 compassionate and 93% clients' health needs were identified. Consultation time ranges from 352 less than one minutes to 30 minutes with 9 minutes as an average time. It was highest in Nari According to the service users, rate of services was graded into five categories; poor, 357 unsatisfactory, average, satisfactory and good. Since unsatisfactory and satisfactory had less 358 responses, we merged into poor and average respectively. Quality of services was best in Nari 359 Maitree (75%) followed by BAPSA and KMSS (each 66%). 84% users will go again for 360 treatment and 83% will suggested their friends to go seek services in UPHCs. (Graph 2) 361 We asked regarding satisfaction in open ended question. In all the UPHCs, clients said that 362 the behavior of HSP, services and management was satisfactory. In multiple answer question, 363 at least 67% clients said behavior of HSP was good in all facilities where more were satisfied 364 in Nari Maitree (88%). Services was satisfactory for 34% clients in both BAPSA and KMSS. 2). Out of 257 responses, 61% did not find all services they wanted in UPHCs. In KMSS, 372 67% did not find services they wanted where, 59% and 57% were in BAPSA and Nari 373 Maitree. 19% did not get medicines from UPHCs, where KMSS had highest (27%). Around 374 25% said that, there was no doctor and 63% could not choose service provider. Overall, 61% 375 clients said they did not find the services they wanted. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint In all UPHCs, clients described their experiences with services was high waiting time. It was 377 mostly said in BAPSA (77%) and less time said at Nari Maitree (58%). In Nari Maitree, 40% 378 had to explain several times to HSP regarding their problems. But 12% of clients in KMSS 379 and 16% of clients in BAPSA had to ask other HSP about their problems. In KMSS 12% of 380 clients said, HSP did not explain clearly to their clients, where BAPSA and Nari Maitree had 381 only 4% and 0% respectively. 382 We asked about dissatisfaction of UPHC services. More than 59% clients were dissatisfied 383 with high waiting time in all facilities, highest being in BAPSA (65%). Management was 384 more dissatisfactory for 36% of clients of Nari Maitree. Similarly, behavior of HSP was most 385 dissatisfactory for KMSS (13%). Here, we included "buying medicine from outside", "HSP 386 are not enough", "less consultation time", "services" etc. in "management" category (Graph  is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint  is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint Although our research did not compare between private and public, however UPHCs of north 433 city corporations were better than south city corporation due to low patient flow which gives 434 enough time to talk to the clients. In gaining trust, clients did not feel HSP was good in providing emergency contact number 438 and service orientation. Comparatively, HSP of KMSS got less score for providing 439 emergency contact number but in terms of service orientation Nari maitree was poor. We did 440 not find any research on providing emergency contact numbers to clients by HSP in 441 Bangladesh.

442
In exit interview clients of all UPHCs reported HSP misbehave, highest being in BAPSA 443 (26%). According to our observation, though the HSP in all three UPHCs were service 444 oriented but showed minimum respect to patient. Similar study in rural setting showed that, 445 HSP gain more trust in public doctors. In public sector HSP were more sensitive towards 446 financial status of clients [7, 20, 28]. However, in our study, clients were not satisfied with 447 these issues in UPHCs. In other researches done in similar settings showed that, service 448 orientation was the strongest factors to influence clients' satisfaction. But it was not at 449 satisfactory level in Bangladesh as physician were more oriented towards private hospitals to 450 earn money [30]. Although HSP were service oriented, around 30% client had to pay out of 451 pocket money for the medicine. In non-maleficence domain, our finding revealed that people got benefit from treatment with 454 some level of side effect from the treatment. Compare to other centers clients of Nari Maitree 455 mostly reported that they suffer from side effects of prescribed drugs. It might be because 456 HSPs did not ask history in detail or they were not using sterile or new equipment during 457 their procedures. For example, 67% clients were not asked allergic history before prescribing 458 drugs in all facilities which was more common in Nari Maitree and KMSS. Our quality of 459 care findings (Table 4) also suggested that although clients got long consultation time, is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint procedures. Lack of time, lack of motivation and ignorance might be the reasons behind this 463 fact which needs further research to explore. 465 In this domain, it was good in "interaction with respect" subdomain while it was poor 466 responses in "similar type of services in terms of social status". BAPSA was not consistent in 467 keeping female attendant for female patient. Finding also showed that, HSPs miss to take 468 consent before examination in all facilities. Comparatively, it was poor in Nari Maitree. Other studies also showed that private health facilities had more 490 tangible items than public facilities [30,34]. If we assumed UPHCs were a public facility, it 491 cannot be ignored that tangible items were ignored in public institutions. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint beginning and ending interviews etc [28,29]. But our study did not explore on the experience 499 of the doctors. Other factors determining reliability were providing service timely and 500 dependability of HSP, which were more than 98% in all facilities.

502
All three UPHCs quality of services were good in terms of assurance as HSP give courage 503 and reassurance to clients and clients also felt safe to share their problems. It was contrast to 504 the other studies done in Dhaka with same study tool which showed that HSP of Bangladesh 505 were not good in terms of assurance [30,34].

507
Clients were satisfied with empathy as more than 90% clients got dedicated attention during 508 consultation, enough consultation time and HSP were able to meet the need of clients. It was 509 in contract to other study done in Dhaka, which showed clients did not get full attention and 510 enough time to consult [30,34]. From our finding, clients reported average waiting time was  is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint wanted in all UPHCs. Findings also suggested that, even though UPHCs were supplying free 523 medicine, clients were not getting it. Around 30% had to buy medicine from their out of 524 pocket money. However, more than 65% of clients suggested that quality of services was 525 good in all UPHCs, best being Nari Maitree (75%). In all categories (behavior of HSP, 526 service and management), KMSS clients were less satisfied than other health facilities. Most 527 satisfactory thing of three UPHCs was behavior of HSP, maximum being in Nari Maitree.

537
Our study concludes that, all UPHC's HSP gave good informative except knowing whether 538 patient understand or not the suggestions given by HSP during consultation. HSP were very 539 friendly but poor in building rapport, which needs some improvement. Sometimes misbehave 540 by HSP, business-oriented attitude, not providing emergency contact number had reduce trust 541 on HSP. Improper use of tangible items and incomplete history taking had increase side 542 effect during treatment. Though patient expect basic respect from HSP, they were not getting 543 it but rather facing discrimination during provision of services.

544
Quality of services when provided to clients was very satisfactory in terms of reliability, 545 assurance and empathy domains in all health facilities. Writing on OPD records was poor in 546 KMSS. Use of gloves, thermometer, stethoscope, measuring tape and sterile instrument was 547 very low in three facilities. Some services, medicine, diagnostic tests were not available in 548 UPHCs. People had to pay out of pocket money to buy medicine and services. Clients were 549 mostly satisfied with behavior of doctor. Services and management of UPHC satisfied them 550 in some instance. Long waiting time was the most dissatisfactory experience for clients.

551
Comparatively clients were highly satisfied with the services of Nari Maitree. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint    578 We used two data collection method (exit interview and observation) and triangulated it to 579 find the similarities to capture as much as variability in responses. With the time constrains 580 and feasibility of the study, we have some limitation in our study. We had planned to take 581 two UPHCs from each DNCC and DSCC but since one UPHC took more time to give 582 permission, we had to manage with one UPHC from South City Corporation. Since our . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a perpetuity.

Strength and Limitation
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint The copyright holder for this this version posted March 31, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.28.22273063 doi: medRxiv preprint 21 583 sample size was calculated to be 384, we could collect only 257. In UPHC, their services 584 were focused to both gender but as community believe that the service were only for female, 585 we were bound to select 98% of female in our exit interviews. During analysis, since we 586 planned to analyses by multivariate methods, due to limited resources to do exploratory 587 factorial analysis, we only presented descriptive analysis in our study. Since observation and 588 exit interview clients were not same and were conducted in different time, criterion validity 589 could not be ensured. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint The copyright holder for this this version posted March 31, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.28.22273063 doi: medRxiv preprint 10.