A mixed methods study of community-based health insurance enrollment trends and underlying challenges in two districts of northeast Ethiopia: a proxy for its sustainability

Background Community-based health insurance initiatives in low- and middle-income countries are plagued by persistently low coverage due to their voluntary orientation. In Ethiopia, the schemes membership growth has not been well investigated so far. This study sought to examine the scheme's enrollment trend over a five-year period, and to explore the various challenges that underpin membership growth from the perspectives of various key stakeholders. Methods The study employed a mixed methods case study in two districts of northeast Ethiopia: Tehulederie and Kallu. Quantitative data was collected by reviewing the databases of schemes. Key informant interviews and in-depth interviews were conducted face-to-face with 19 key stakeholders and nine community members, respectively. Study participants were purposely selected using the maximum variation technique. Interviews were audio recorded, transcribed verbatim, and translated into English. Thematic analysis was employed with both deductive and inductive coding approaches. Results Enrollment in the two districts has shown an inconsistent trend over the study period (2017 to 2021). The scheme in Tehulederie has a relatively better enrollment trend, particularly in terms of membership retention, which could be due to the strong foundation laid by a rigorous public awareness campaign and technical support during the pilot phase. The challenges contributing to the observed level of performance have been summarized under four main themes that include quality of health care, claims reimbursement for insurance holders, governance practices, and community awareness and acceptability. Conclusions The scheme experienced negative growth ratios in both districts with inconsistent trends, showing that the scheme is not functionally viable. It will regress unless relevant stakeholders at all levels of government demonstrate political will and commitment to its implementation, as well as advocate for the community. Interventions should target on the highlighted challenges in order to boost membership growth and ensure the viability of the community-based health insurance.

7 130 institutions as long as they follow the right procedure. At a Kebele level, the key players for 131 membership enrollment, renewal, and premium collection are Kebele leaders and HEWs. One of 132 the HEWs' responsibilities as community health workers is to persuade people for enrollment.
133 Study design 134 The study employed a mixed methods case study, in which both the quantitative and qualitative 135 data were collected concurrently. The mixed approach intends to converge the results for enhanced 136 understanding of the scheme's performance in terms of membership development. The 137 quantitative part was applied to describe enrollment trends using key performance indicators, while 138 the qualitative part explored underlying challenges that hindered the scheme's membership 139 development. The study approach considered each of the two districts as a separate case study of 140 the scheme's performance. We used purposive sampling to select the two study districts.
141 Tehulederie was the sole early adopter of the scheme in the zone, serving as a pilot district, hence 142 selected as an outlier case. The second case (Kallu), was selected as a typical case since it is the 143 zone's largest district that shares a variety of geographical features with other districts (37).
144 Participant selection 145 Participants in both study sites were purposely selected using the maximum variation technique 146 in order to gain insight from a diverse range of viewpoints and to chronicle important shared 147 experiences that cut across the various stakeholders participating in the CBHI scheme 148 implementation (37). Key informants were selected among key stakeholders based on their active 149 participation in the scheme's implementation and their ability to provide a wealth of data. A total 150 of 19 key informant interviews (KII) were conducted by considering the different sectors, that 151 included two scheme personnel, one district health officer, four health center directors, five health . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted March 25, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.24.22272882 doi: medRxiv preprint 152 care providers, three Kebele leaders and four health extension workers (HEWs). Nine community 153 members were selected by HEWs for in-depth interviews (IDI) based on their insurance status 154 (current and previous members), and their ability to provide useful information. The final sample 155 size at each study district was determined based on data saturation, with no new information 156 emerging from participants (38).
157 Data collection 158 The data was collected between February 8 and May 2, 2021. Quantitative data was gathered 159 by reviewing the databases of the two CBHI schemes retroactively using checklists developed 160 based on key performance indicators. Although we intended to examine all years of the scheme's 161 implementation, we were only able to get complete data from 2017 to 2021.

162
Qualitative data were collected using KIIs, IDIs and informal field interviews (IFI) (37). The 163 IDI was conducted with current and previous members of CBHI to explore their views and 164 experiences concerning health care quality, community willingness to participate in the scheme, 165 claim benefits, and scheme services. In-depth interviews were conducted at Health Posts (HEW's 166 office). The KIIs intend to explore the views of different stakeholders regarding community 167 understanding and acceptability of CBHI, health care quality, and claims management. Key 168 informants were interviewed at their offices based on a pre-specified schedule. Informal interviews 169 were also made during our health facility and home-to-home visits to capture important 170 information that could triangulate with the formal interviews.

171
All interviews were conducted face-to-face by the lead investigator in convenient locations 172 using an interview guide that was designed to elicit the participants' views via open-ended 173 questions which were further probed to trigger more discussions. Interviews were conducted in . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted March 25, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.24.22272882 doi: medRxiv preprint 174 Amharic, the local language, and lasted between 10 and 40 minutes. All conversations were audio 175 recorded using a digital voice recorder with the permission of the participants. Field notes were 176 taken during informal interviews. Every person we approached agreed to take part in the study.
177 Two of the respondents were coworkers of the lead investigator as health care providers in one of 178 the study districts.
179 Data analysis 180 Quantitative data obtained through document review were analyzed using the performance 181 indicators selected for this study, which include membership growth ratio, coverage ratio, and 182 renewal ratio.

232
. CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

235
While each case study site is assessed as a unique implementation of the CBHI, integrating 236 findings from the two case studies allows for the identification of key common themes. Four main 237 themes were identified, which are quality of health care, claims reimbursement for insurance 238 holders, governance practices, and community awareness and acceptability of CBHI (Fig 2). Sub-239 themes are described under each main theme. Availability and perceived quality of medicines 245 Availability of medicines was the most frequently discussed issue in all interviews. Due to the 246 unavailability of medicines in contracted health centers and hospitals, insured patients were usually 247 given prescriptions to buy from private pharmacies, and made to spend OOP or forgo treatment if 248 they were not able to afford its cost. In addition to health service users, health care providers and 249 health center directors from both districts were well aware of the depth of this problem. The two 250 main reasons for medicine stock outs at health centers were a lack of budget and limited capacity 251 of the government's pharmaceutical supply agency. Especially, key informants emphasized the 252 pharmaceutical supply agency's limited capacity to meet the demands of health facilities in its 253 catchment area. Because the government's supplier agency frequently runs out of medical supplies, 254 health facilities have been compelled to procure from private vendors, which requires a lengthy 255 process and higher price markups. One of the main causes of the budget deficit is a delay in claims 256 settlement by the health insurance scheme.
. CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted March 25, 2022. ; Health care providers admitted that they may not demonstrate excellent interpersonal 282 communication or spend enough time examining and discussing patients' health concerns due to 283 increased workload associated with insurance coverage. They disagreed, however, on the assertion 284 that insured patients are treated differentially in favor of paying patients. According to them, 285 insured individuals associate everything that happens in health facilities with their insurance status.
286 They believe that health care providers have abandoned them and that paying patients are given 287 higher priority, based on the notion that insured clients attend health facilities for every minor 288 ailment because of free health care. This is perceived discrimination, most of which did not really 289 happen, and such issues were common during the early stages of CBHI, when health care providers 290 were unfamiliar with the program, as most key informants stated.

291
"The problem now is that health workers prioritize paying patients and delay insured patients Furthermore, some participants believed that health care providers in health centers lacked the 300 skills and experience to manage their conditions. They claimed that the prescribed medicines do 301 not much the disease, providers treat patients without physical examination or laboratory tests and 302 those working in rural areas are inexperienced. As a result, most insurance holders distrust health 303 care providers and believe they are not there to assist them. As stated by health care providers, 304 insured patients are not willing to accept professional advice and suggestions because they believe 305 that providers are in opposition to them.
. CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted March 25, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.24.22272882 doi: medRxiv preprint "The health center is structurally sound, but it is devoid of competent personnel. It's possible 307 to conclude that it's empty." (IDI-6, Current member).

308
"Insurance subscribers are frequently blamed by health care providers. As a result, we assume 309 they have an unfavorable attitude toward us and treat us badly." (IFI-19, Current member).

310
"When you advise them, they will not believe you." ( . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)

353
According to the majority of the in-depth interview participants, another concern they faced 354 regarding pocket money reimbursement was claims rejection. They expressed their dissatisfaction 355 by alleging that, despite submitting all required evidence, the scheme rejected their appeals for a 356 variety of reasons. Scheme personnel also acknowledged that claims rejection is common for a 357 number of reasons, most of which stem from clients' misunderstanding of the kind of paperwork 358 they should submit with their claims. They also disclosed that members of the scheme were 359 unwilling to accept the rejection decision, regardless of the cause.

360
Presenting with illegal bills from private pharmacies, presenting bills from private pharmacies 361 without attaching prescription papers from contracted facilities, mismatch between medications 362 prescribed by physicians and those dispensed by private pharmacies, the prescription paper lacking 363 the required signature and stamp, submitting claims after a deadline has passed, receiving 364 treatment from a health facility that did not make a contract agreement with the scheme, receiving 365 treatment in hospitals without being referred by health centers, and loss of submitted documents 366 were some of the main reasons for claims rejection. One reason for the loss of submitted 367 documents, according to a health care provider, is that documents presented by clients are likely 368 to be disguised on purpose, especially for larger claims, because in some cases, there are players 369 between the scheme and its members.

370
"Last year, the referral hospital refused to sign a contract agreement with the scheme. 396 key informants believe that the current structure poses challenges to the scheme's performance.
397 They claimed that a single sector should not be both a provider and a buyer of health care, because 398 it creates accountability concerns. They proposed that health insurance be organized as a separate . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted March 25, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.24.22272882 doi: medRxiv preprint 399 autonomous sector with clearly defined roles and responsibilities, as well as a mechanism that 400 allows active engagement of other sectors in the district. The service seller would be accountable 401 for the quality of health care provided to the insured, while the service buyer would be accountable 402 for claim reimbursements in their interaction.

403
" Insured households are also unable to receive the full range of CBHI benefits due to a lack of 441 awareness of the procedure they should follow. Community members who took part in the . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted March 25, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.24.22272882 doi: medRxiv preprint 442 interviews claimed that they were not aware of important directives when it came to their benefits. 443 This is the main reason for the high claims rejection ratio that has been reported.

444
"The goal of health insurance is to be profitable. The   . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)

491
Most of the interviews indicated that health insurance is not well accepted in the community.
492 Certain members of the community did not value the benefits of health insurance. For some of 493 them, CBHI is a political instrument that isn't being used for the community's benefit. . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)

507
Another concern that prevents people from joining or adhering to the scheme is the spread of . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted March 25, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.24.22272882 doi: medRxiv preprint Surprisingly, the community, including those who have left out and are criticizing the scheme 526 do not want health insurance to be abolished, since they know they will be able to rejoin and benefit 527 from it at a later point in time.

529
This study examined the scheme's enrollment trends using key indicators and explored its 530 performance challenges from the perspectives of various stakeholders. The enrollment of CBHI in 531 the two districts has shown an inconsistent trend over the study period. The scheme in Tehulederie 532 has a relatively better enrollment trend, particularly in terms of renewal ratio. This could be due to 533 the strong foundation laid by a rigorous public awareness campaign throughout the pilot period, 534 as well as the technical assistance provided to the district's relevant stakeholders (30). The low 535 renewal ratios along with an erratic membership growth in Kallu suggests that the scheme is 536 experiencing internal movement, with some households leaving and others joining, potentially 537 exposing it to adverse selection. This will result in a higher claims ratio, lower net income, and 538 maybe bankruptcy if the problems are not fixed (8).

539
To remain viable, a micro-insurance program must have a minimum growth ratio of zero (7). is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted March 25, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.24.22272882 doi: medRxiv preprint 547 absence of good interpersonal interactions, and lack of trust in the competency and caring attitude 548 of health care professionals were the main health care quality issues. The common complaints with 549 respect to hospital services include long waiting times, long appointments for non-emergency 550 conditions, and the inability to access emergency care free of charge without a referral letter.

551
The findings on medicine availability basically corroborate what has been documented in the 552 literature, which has linked it to low enrollment and renewal rates in the scheme. In Ethiopia, the 553 quality of health services, notably the availability of most essential medicines in public facilities, 554 influences household decisions about whether or not to enroll or renew (42). A study comparing 555 the performance of two districts based on membership enrollment in Tanzania found that the high-556 performing district had better medicine availability (43). Overall, scarcity of medicines at 557 contracted service provider facilities was a common problem experienced by insured patients in 558 different settings, leading them to pay for medicines in private pharmacies (24, 44-48). The 559 perceived low quality of medicines was also identified as a major barrier to insurance subscription.
560 For non-subscribers, a major factor for not to participate in the scheme was the low quality of 561 medicines provided to insurance members (15, 49). It was also revealed that the insured who were 562 given generic medicines thought the care they received was of inferior quality (50).

563
Insured households were also dissatisfied with the way health care providers dealt with them.
564 Many felt discriminated against because of their health insurance status, and they expressed their 565 frustration with the disrespectful behavior and uncaring attitude of care providers. This was 566 highlighted during the CBHI pilot phase in Ethiopia, where health care providers did not treat 567 insured patients appropriately, believing that most insured people came to the health facility with 568 minor medical issues due to the free service (24). For the insured, health care providers were less 569 likely to take their weight and temperature, use a stethoscope, physically examine them, and inform . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review)

587
The findings also revealed that some scheme members had little faith in the overall quality of 588 health care provided by CBHI-affiliated health facilities. This was primarily because of their 589 preferences, expectations, and level of awareness. As a result, people with financial means choose 590 to go to private clinics and pay for their own care. If health care is of poor quality, membership 591 will be less attractive, and expanding membership coverage will be challenging for the relevant 592 stakeholders. It has been documented elsewhere that low perceived quality of care was a major . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted March 25, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.24.22272882 doi: medRxiv preprint 593 reason for low enrollment and renewal of subscriptions (12, 18). In India, insured households 594 claimed that hospitals turned them down for unknown reasons when they sought medical treatment 595 (53).

596
Despite the fact that quality of care is vital to the success of UHC initiatives, governments have 597 paid little attention to it, which Ridde and Hane described as a "known but often ignored challenge" 598 (54). Quality of care will continue to be a major bottleneck to the scheme's sustainability unless 599 the government devotes significant resources to health system strengthening, particularly human 600 resource development and pharmaceutical supply, in order to meet the rising health care demand.
601 The scheme was launched without first strengthening the health system's capacity to handle the 602 increasing patient flow and workload without compromising the quality of care, which was the 603 main root cause for the existing problem.

604
Members of the scheme are entitled to reimbursement for any medical services they bought in 605 private institutions due to a lack of availability in CBHI affiliate health facilities, as long as they 606 follow the appropriate procedures. The scheme's performance in this regard can be assessed using 607 the timeliness of reimbursement and the rejection ratio of submitted claims. The effectiveness with 608 which claims are processed has a direct effect on subscriber satisfaction, which in turn has an 609 impact on membership growth (8). The findings revealed that claims settlement for out-of-pocket 610 spending was another source of dissatisfaction among insured persons. While OOP is a problem 611 in and of itself, clients are not properly reimbursed for their expenditures. Both the delay in 612 reimbursement and the rejection of claims were major complaints. Scheme participants must wait 613 a long time for their claims to be processed, with repeated appointments and long queues at the 614 scheme office. For insured households who reside in remote areas, the cost of traveling to the 615 scheme and the opportunity costs of following up on claims processing outweigh the benefits of . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted March 25, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.24.22272882 doi: medRxiv preprint 638 Most of the time, scheme members remain in the dark about what they must do in order to receive . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted March 25, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.24.22272882 doi: medRxiv preprint 659 mutual trust with the community should be a priority, according to best practices learned from a 660 high-performing village. Those who have direct contact with the community during membership 661 enrollment, such as Kebele leaders and HEWs, should demonstrate commitment to assisting . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted March 25, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.24.22272882 doi: medRxiv preprint 681 the study districts, as well as other areas with similar setups that would like to initiate 682 improvements. It will be an essential input for policymakers as they strive to establish higher-level 683 pools and revise scheme designs.
. CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted March 25, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.24.22272882 doi: medRxiv preprint