The Influence of Contextual Factors on Maternal Healthcare Utilization in sub-Saharan Africa: A Scoping Review of Multilevel Models

Introduction Sub-Saharan Africa still bears the heaviest burden of maternal mortality among the regions of the world, with an estimated 201,000 (66%) women dying annually due to pregnancy and childbirth related complications. Utilisation of maternal healthcare services including antenatal care, skilled delivery and postnatal care contribute to a reduction of maternal and child mortality and morbidity. Factors influencing use of maternal healthcare occur at both the individual and contextual levels. The objective of this study was to systematically examine the evidence regarding the influence of contextual factors on uptake of maternal health care in sub-Saharan Africa. Materials and Methods The process of scoping review involved searching several electronic databases, identifying articles corresponding to the inclusion criteria and selecting them for extraction and analysis. Peer reviewed multilevel studies on maternal healthcare utilisation in sub-Saharan Africa published between 2007 and 2019 were selected. Two reviewers independently evaluated each study for inclusion and conflicts were resolved by consensus. Results We synthesised 34 studies that met the criteria of inclusion out of a total of 1,654 initial records. Most of the studies were single-country, cross-sectional in nature and involved two-level multilevel logistic regression models. The findings confirm the important role played by contextual factors in determining use of available maternal health care services in sub-Saharan Africa. The level of educational status, poverty, media exposure, autonomy, empowerment and access to health facilities within communities are some of the major drivers of use of maternal health services. Conclusions This review highlights the potential of addressing high-level factors in bolstering maternal health care utilisation in sub-Saharan Africa. Societies that prioritise the betterment of social conditions in communities and deal with the problematic gender norms will have a good chance of improving maternal health care utilisation and reducing maternal and child mortality. Better multilevel explanatory mechanisms that incorporates social theories are recommended in understanding use of maternal health care services in sub-Saharan Africa.

Current research shows that variations in individual healthcare outcomes are significantly accounted for by contextual-level variables [13]. In fact, individual and health systems determinants of health and healthcare may be symptoms of much more 'upstream' contextual factors imbedded within local communities and broader social institutions. For example, the influence of women's autonomy and decision-making authority on maternal healthcare have often been discussed within the framework of dominant masculinity ideologies or cultural beliefs in particular spaces [7]. The same may be true with inadequacies of the health systems, which may be a direct or indirect consequence of the failure of not the health systems per se but that of political and governance systems that oversee them.
There are many studies examining the relationship between contextual factors and maternal healthcare utilisation in continental SSA, but there are still inconsistencies relative to a) whether contextual factors influence maternal healthcare utilisation more is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint The copyright holder for this this version posted March 18, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03. 15.22272437 doi: medRxiv preprint gaps that this study intends to fill through a systematic review of multilevel models (MLMs).
MLMs have generally been regarded as 'gold standards' if the objective of the research inquiry is to examine the effects of high-level factors on individual-level outcome variables while controlling for other variables. This is because they are more suitable for determining the magnitude of variance in the outcome variable attributable to factors at different levels of operation [13]. Maternal healthcare utilization is underpinned by complex and interacting processes that may properly be explored by MLMs. Therefore, to examine the relative effect of contextual factors on maternal healthcare utilisation, we reviewed only multilevel studies that have included variables measured at two or more levels. This aspect distinguishes our study from previous reviews [26] [7][12] [27][28] which either were not entirely systematic, did not particularly focus on SSA, did not include all the indicators of maternal health care utilisation, or did not exclusively target studies using multilevel modelling.
Understanding the nature of contextual factors influencing individual women's utilisation of MHC is critical for implementing of policy strategies aimed at bolstering the use of MHC services, especially in low-resource countries. Contextual factors provide a holistic way of looking at determinants of health and healthcare outcomes. Additionally, they provide a better platform for theoretical developments aimed at understanding the relationships between the broader social structure and individual level outcomes. This approach provides the potential to explain the disproportionately sub-optimal utilisation of maternal healthcare and high maternal mortality in SSA.

Materials and Methods
. CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a perpetuity.
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint The copyright holder for this this version posted March 18, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.15.22272437 doi: medRxiv preprint As a matter of good practice, the protocol for this review was consistent with the Centre for Reviews and Dissemination (CRD) guidelines for conducting systematic reviews in healthcare [29]. The process involved searching the electronic literature, identifying articles corresponding to the inclusion criteria, and selecting them for extraction and analysis. As much as possible, this review adhered to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses Protocols (PRISMA-P) 2015 statement checklist [30].

Types of studies
Although previous studies have used a variety of techniques to examine the influence of contextual factors on health and healthcare variables, this review searched only for studies utilising MLMs designs. MLMs designs are relatively new advances in quantitative research methods and best suited to study the relationship the effects of contextual conditions on individual-level health outcomes because they allow for a simultaneous examination of the relative impact of individual level and group level variables on the outcome variable [31] [32]. They also accommodate an analysis of observations that are correlated or clustered along spatial, non-spatial, or temporal dimensions [33]. The application of MLMs in such data structures helps to model the extent of correlation in the outcome attributable to contextual factors while controlling for individual-level variables [13]. These properties of MLMs enabled us to determine contextual factors associated with maternal healthcare and how the impact of these factors differs from . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a perpetuity.
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint

Participants and setting
The review included studies that were implemented in any sub-Saharan Africa country, as defined by the World Bank Group [34], focusing on maternal healthcare utilisation.
This review excluded studies which targeted low and income-countries that included other sub-Saharan citizens in the diaspora.

Outcomes
Studies reporting maternal healthcare utilisation as the outcome variable of concern were included in the review. The indicators of maternal healthcare utilisation were restricted to contraceptive use, antenatal care, skilled/facility delivery care and postnatal care.

Determinants
Contextual-level determinants of maternal healthcare utilisation in MLM studies were considered suitable, and these included factors clustered at the household, community, . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a perpetuity.
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint The copyright holder for this this version posted March 18, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.15.22272437 doi: medRxiv preprint district, regional or national levels. Characteristics such as community socioeconomic status, social norms, social cohesion and national level economic development status, poverty levels and health expenditure were among eligible contextual factors.

Information sources
To avoid bias and to reflect the multidisciplinary nature of the subject of this review,

Literature search strategy
This review employed four sets of terms representing the outcome indicator variables, the contextual indicator variables, MLM filters and the filter for sub-Saharan African countries in the search strategy. Table 1 below reports an example of the search strategy adopted for this review. The search filter for sub-Saharan African countries was adapted from work by Pienaar, et al [35] who developed it for clinical studies conducted in an African environment. The filter comprised sub-Saharan African country names and truncated terms such as "Southern Africa". North African countries and language filters were removed from the original list accordingly.

Table 1. Example of search strategy
Maternal healthcare indicator terms "Maternal healthcare" OR "access to healthcare" OR "availability of healthcare" OR "utilisation of healthcare" OR "health service coverage" OR "contraceptive use" OR "skilled birth attendant" OR "skilled delivery care" OR "facility based delivery" OR "antenatal care" Contextual factors "Structural factors" OR "social determinants" OR "contextual factors" OR "determinants" OR "neighbourhood status" OR "community factors" OR "structural violence" OR "social structure" OR "social norms" OR "sociocultural factors" OR . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a perpetuity.
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint The copyright holder for this this version posted March 18, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.15.22272437 doi: medRxiv preprint "economic development" OR "governance" "gender inequality" OR "predictors" OR "health systems" Multilevel models filters "Multilevel" OR " multilevel models" OR "multilevel modelling" OR "MLM" OR " hierarchical models" OR "hierarchical linear models" OR "HLM" "Variance component" OR "Intraclass correlation" OR "ICC" OR "random effects" OR "mixed models" OR "mixed effects" Filter for sub-Saharan African countries ("Africa" OR Angola OR Benin OR Botswana OR "Burkina Faso" OR Burundi OR Cameroon OR "Canary Islands" OR "Cape Verde" OR "Central African Republic" OR Chad OR Comoros OR Congo OR "Democratic Republic of Congo" OR Djibouti OR "Equatorial Guinea" OR Eritrea OR Ethiopia OR Gabon OR Gambia OR Ghana OR Guinea OR "Guinea Bissau" OR "Ivory Coast" OR "Cote d'Ivoire" OR Kenya OR Lesotho OR Liberia OR Madagascar OR Malawi OR Mali OR Mauritania OR Mauritius OR Mozambique OR Namibia OR Niger OR Nigeria OR Principe OR Reunion OR Rwanda OR "Sao Tome" OR Senegal OR Seychelles OR "Sierra Leone" OR Somalia OR "South Africa" OR Sudan OR Swaziland OR Tanzania OR Togo OR Tunisia OR Uganda OR "Western Sahara" OR Zaire OR Zambia OR Zimbabwe OR "Central Africa" OR "Central African" OR "West Africa" OR "West African" OR "Western Africa" OR "Western African" OR "East Africa" OR "East African" OR "Eastern Africa" OR "Eastern African" OR "North Africa" OR "Southern Africa" OR "sub Saharan Africa")

Data extraction and management
A search was conducted in databases using the strategy above to identify potential records for the review. All extracted entries were screened by examining titles and abstracts and all relevant records with the potential of meeting the criteria for inclusion were exported to EndNote X7 for data management. Full texts were extracted using the EndNote platform and those, which could not be found, were searched manually through the university library and other sources. Full texts were assessed by two independent researchers against the inclusion criteria and disagreements, where there were any, were resolved by consensus. Studies excluded from the review at this stage, along with reasons for exclusion, were recorded and retained by the researcher. The search also included hand searching reference lists of relevant articles to identify other articles of value. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint Records fitting the inclusion criteria were then exported to excel to record the detailed general publication information (author(s), year of publication and type of journal), characteristics of studies (design, population, sample size and procedure, country, explanatory, and outcome variables of concern) and summary results (whether contextual factors significantly influenced maternal healthcare utilisation and recording the intra-class correlation ICC or variance partition coefficient VPC). The search was conducted on the 16 th of April 2018, and it was updated on the 14 th of June 2021.

Risks of bias and quality assessment
Poor quality assessment of studies has a considerable negative impact on the results of systematic reviews. As such, this review appraised all studies in accordance with the Quality Assessment Tool for Quantitative Studies developed by the Effective Public Health Practice Project [36]. Accordingly, the assessment considered selection, the appropriateness of study designs, whether there were stated confounders, whether there were variables which had been controlled for, whether blinding was applied, reliability and validity of data collection tools, the appropriateness of the units of analysis and the type of variables included. The way missing data were resolved was also part of the assessment procedures.
Just like the process of data extraction, two reviewers were involved in the quality assessment in the final processes of this review and in cases of disagreement, a third reviewer was enlisted to reach consensus. In cases of missing data, attempts were made to contact the primary authors of articles concerned. This was done in situations where, for example, study designs, explanatory or outcome variables were unclear or missing. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint The copyright holder for this this version posted March 18, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.15.22272437 doi: medRxiv preprint When there was no success in obtaining the missing data, data were reported accordingly, and the implication thereof explained in the discussion section of the review.

Data analysis and presentation
Heterogeneity in the study population, selected countries, outcomes, and the nature of contextual variables was observed. As such, meta-analysis was not appropriate for this synthesis. Instead, narrative scoping review was employed as the method of reporting

Search results
The electronic data search process from the research platforms above yielded 1,654 potentially relevant records. Twenty-seven additional records were identified from the reference lists and citation checks of included studies. After searching for duplicates, 996 were discarded and 658 records were screened using titles and abstracts. Following this stage, 591 irrelevant manuscripts were excluded from the review and the remaining 67 is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint The copyright holder for this this version posted March 18, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.15.22272437 doi: medRxiv preprint records were fully assessed with respect to the illegibility criteria and among these, thirty-nine were selected. The main reasons for exclusion included studies not focusing wholly on sub-Saharan Africa, not using multilevel modelling techniques, using primarily qualitative methods, not being published in a peer-reviewed outlet, and having an outcome variable other than one of the indicators of maternal healthcare. After quality assessment for confounding and applying the measurement of contextual variables requirement in MLM studies, five were excluded and the remaining 34 records were eligible for inclusion in the study. The figure below is a flow diagram, which reports the process from article identification to inclusion. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint

Study characteristics
Apart from a few entries [37] [38][39] [40] [41], almost all reviewed studies used the Demographic and Health Surveys (DHS) data from a standard survey that is implemented in several developing countries. McTavish and others [40] is the only study using the World Health Survey (WHS) and controls for the national level socioeconomic characteristics when investigating the relationship between national female literacy and maternal healthcare use. Table 2 reports the distribution of selected studies across nine sub-Saharan African countries, including some cross-national studies, which used a combination of SSA countries as a unit of analysis.
Sample sizes for included studies have a wide range because of heterogeneity in these studies. Some studies, for example, only focus on a relatively small rural population in one country [38] is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint Reviewed studies are mainly cross-sectional and utilized multilevel logistic regression analysis with a few making use of multinomial and structural equation regression analysis. This is plausible because of' lack of robust data infrastructure in SSA which prohibits the use of more comprehensive and advanced analytical techniques and could be the reason why studies using such methods as longitudinal multilevel analysis are missing. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint Elfstrom and Stephenson [44] and Masters [46] are examples of studies using a threelevel modelling technique in contrast with most studies using two-level models. Both studies assume that individual actors are nested within households which, are in turn nested within communities. They are interested in the influence of contextual factors on contraceptive use at the community level of analysis and they studied demographics and fertility norms, gender norms and health knowledge. These studies included household and individual-level factors, which were used as control variables.
Outcome variables in included studies are equally varied, covering the broader spectrum of maternal healthcare continuum of contraceptive use [44,48,52,53,61,62,66], antenatal care [43,45,51,54,56,67] skilled or facility delivery [24,37,40,42,47,57,64], and postnatal care [55,60]. Some studies included a combination of two maternal healthcare indicators as outcome variables of antenatal care and facility/skilled delivery [23,46,50,63,68] or three indicators of antenatal care, skilled delivery and postnatal care [38,39,59,63,65]. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint The copyright holder for this this version posted March 18, 2022. ;   The overarching nature of the relationship between health systems and maternal healthcare is such that women who live in communities that are proximal to wellperforming and high-quality health systems have higher odds of utilizing maternal healthcare services. It was unusual that a few studies either found a negative association between distance and maternal health care [61] or the relationship was non-significant

Contextual factors influencing maternal healthcare utilization
[37] [61]. Higher levels of facility delivery in these cases were explained by the quality of healthcare, which seems to supersede distance as an explanatory factor for facility delivery. Other health care-related factors that were found to increase the odds of utilizing maternal health care system included trust in the health care system [60] and the lack of payment requirements [37].
A host of socioeconomic factors were found to be associated with maternal healthcare utilization at the contextual level, and these included community education . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a perpetuity.
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint  [67], and gender norms [23] [44]. Most of these factors have a consisted and predictable relationship with maternal healthcare. For example, it is wellknown that women who live in communities or countries with higher levels of education or economic status have increased odds of utilizing maternal healthcare.
On the other hand, it is also established that women who live in rural areas have a lower propensity of using maternal healthcare services. The same applies to community media exposure, which has mostly been found to have a positive influence on maternal health care. Problematic gender norms such as tolerance towards violence hinder women from using maternal healthcare.
Relational factors are also found to be important predictors of maternal healthcare utilization at the contextual level. These factors mainly result from everyday relationships or interactions women have with men. These relations may significantly influence women's decisions to either use maternal healthcare or not. Community women empowerment [24][62], women autonomy [62], PSU household size [61], number of children per PSU [48] and small family norms [52] is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint The copyright holder for this this version posted March 18, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.15.22272437 doi: medRxiv preprint

Figure 2. ICC values by study
The ICC results reported in Figure 2 show that they are averaging 35%, which indicates that relative to individual-level factors, contextual level factors contribute less to maternal healthcare utilization but have substantial independent influence. There are a few studies which are above the ICC of 50% [24] is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint structures that may result in more autonomy for women and subsequently better use of health services.
Kruk and others have equally attempted to do so by demonstrating the role played by contextual social interactions as a mechanism through which women make decisions to utilize maternal health care services [37]. They argue that, as women interact within communities, they tend to share information about the quality of health care systems and these collective perceptions shape women's decision-making processes about use of health services. Furthermore, a few other studies that have used contextual social norms in explaining variations in health service utilization [23] [42] help to illuminate the role of the social structure and how it is distinctive of individual characteristics in influencing health behaviour. This is an insightful approach as it gives a broader picture through which the observed relationships are shaped by prevailing social and cultural factors in a particular society.
Most reviewed papers do not offer strong theoretical frameworks on the influence of contextual factors on maternal health care utilization. This may be partly because of inability to articulate the presence of emergent contextual properties that are distinctive from individual-level constructs [69]. Lack of clear-cut distinction between contextual and individual-level constructs can result in atomistic fallacy, whereby conclusions about contextual-level variables are made from individual-level data [70]. There are many instances among reviewed studies where researchers are discussing contextual effects with individual-level data. This is problematic, and it poses a challenge in grounding such studies in theoretical constructs.

Discussion
. CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a perpetuity.
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint This scoping review used multilevel models in sub-Saharan Africa to study the influence of contextual factors on maternal healthcare utilisation. Our synthesis involved 34 studies that met the criteria and controlled for some individual-level factors. Previous reviews focused on different indicators of maternal healthcare, did not particularly look at SSA or did not specifically target multilevel models [7] [12][26] [27]. Selected studies in this review reflected substantial heterogeneity in terms of contextual factors and outcome variables examined. Contextual factors are defined as structural-level factors constituted at the community or country levels and are mainly studied through multilevel modelling techniques. Contextual factors found to be commonly associated with maternal healthcare relate to the operations of health systems, socioeconomic positions of women, and the nature of relationships between women and men.
The health system factors show that women who live in areas that are proximal to health facilities, provide good quality healthcare, have full antenatal care coverage and, where more people trust in the health system, have a higher propensity to use maternal healthcare services. These findings imply that access and performance of health systems in SSA are important in facilitating optimal use of health services among pregnant women, mothers, and newly born babies. However, poor performance of health systems may be due to broader structural factors, such as the political and governance systems prevailing in specific countries of SSA. This is plausible because healthcare delivery capacity is considerably less in developing countries compared to developed countries. This may result from low health expenditure per capita, which in 2015, was approximately $37 in low-income countries compared to around $518 and $5,251 in upper middle-income countries and higher income countries respectively [16]. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint Consequently, the health professional to population ratio is also less impressive as it stands at 0.2 for physicians and 1.2 for nurses and midwives in SSA countries, while the corresponding figures for the developed countries are 2.9 and 8.6 per thousand population [16]. These phenomena may account for the suboptimal performance of health systems in SSA.
Urban residence or living in areas with more educated and wealthy women could enhance the propensity of using maternal health care [43] [24][56] [54]. Urban residence and high socioeconomic status are usually associated with good health outcomes because, on one hand, better amenities are usually found in urban areas. On the other hand, wealth and educated people are likely to live in urban areas and afford health insurance or out-of-pocket payments for health care [68][69] [70]. Media exposure, gender and family norms, women empowerment, female autonomy and community household size may equally be a function of culture, social networks and broader macrostructural underpinnings of society. Media saturation allows better access to information on the importance of antenatal care, facility delivery and postnatal check-ups for mothers and babies. Problematic gender norms and lack of female autonomy are functions of patriarchal systems, which privileges men with power over women and subordinates the status of women [76]. Accordingly, gender division of labour in patriarchal societies is often such that pregnancy and childbirth responsibilities are assigned to women without accompanying social status or access to resources. Thus, making it difficult for them to use available maternal health care services.
The systematic review provides substantial evidence regarding the contribution of contextual factors to maternal healthcare utilisation through the observed ICC measures. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint  is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint

Conclusion
This study was intended to review the research ecosystem studying the influence of contextual factors on maternal healthcare utilization in sub-Saharan Africa using multilevel techniques. It is foundational work that highlights the contextual factors that are mostly studied, as well as how contextual factor differ from individual factors in influencing maternal healthcare in sub-Saharan Africa. Access and quality of health care services are major determinants of utilization that relate to health systems. Education, . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a perpetuity.
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint The copyright holder for this this version posted March 18, 2022. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.03.15.22272437 doi: medRxiv preprint poverty, population density, media exposure, gender norms and empowerment at the community level are some of the other important contextual factors. It is important that policy strategies that are aimed at improving maternal health care are focused on these factors.
This study suggests that theoretical pathways of a multilevel nature should always be considered in studies using multilevel techniques to explain how factors operating at different levels interact to influence maternal healthcare utilization. We recommend strong reliance on social science theories and mechanisms to offer substantive explanations of observed relationships between contextual factors and maternal healthcare utilization in SSA.  is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in (which was not certified by peer review) preprint