Evaluating the Outcomes of Enhanced Adherence Counselling Intervention on Clients with High Viral Loads in Selected Health Facilities in Monze District.

To investigate the changes in Viral Load(VL) during Enhanced Adherence Counselling (EAC) sessions and its determinants among ART clients with unsuppressed VLs in Monze district. Method: A Cross-sectional study involving 616 HVL ART clients from 15 health facilities in Monze district which was conducted between October 1 2019 and March 30 2021. Out of 616 clients analysed, there was an improvement in viral load suppression following completion of EAC with a final outcome of 61% suppression. 28.7% remained unsuppressed. A total of 9.1% had no final viral load results documented and 0.2 % had been transferred out of their respective facilities and were not included in the study. Collection of repeat Viral loads was done on 84% of the clients with high viral load results while 16% had no record of sample collection. A total of 56 results were not received giving a result return of 89% from repeat samples collected. Females had a 40% likelihood of being unsuppressed at 95% CI (41% to 86%) compared to the males. Conclusion EAC improves the outcomes of HVLs and should be encouraged on all high viral clients. Programs should be developed to improve suppression in females on ART improvement in viral load suppression Luyaba

The first 90 being that 90% of all people living with HIV must know their status, 90% of them must be on antiretroviral therapy (ART) and 90% of them must be virally suppressed.
As indicated in a study in sub-Saharan Africa 2017, almost 22 million of 36·9 million people living with HIV globally have successfully initiated antiretroviral therapy (ART). 1 For the individual and public health benefits of ART to be realised, antiretroviral programmes, previously focussed on ART initiation, must retain patients in care and achieve high rates of viral load (VL) suppression. This requires optimizing management of those failing ART. The last further stipulates that 90% of those on ART treatment should have a suppressed VL in order to eliminate HIV transmission and prevent morbidity and mortality. 2 To be HIV virally suppressed means to have less than 1000 copies of viruses in the body. Other than that an individual is defined to have an elevated or high viral load. 3 According to UNAIDs, there is no definite answer to how long a person needs to take Antiretroviral (ARVs) medicines before they are virally suppressed. Regular viral load testing is therefore, necessary to ensure proper treatment monitoring on the success of the regimen. Routine viral load (VL) monitoring is the most important tool for assessing a patient's response to treatment, and assessing adherence to antiretroviral therapy. 4 The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends a VL test six and twelve months after starting ART and every twelve months thereafter. According to the Zambian national ART guidelines 2020, an unsuppressed Viral load result (HVL) which is as a client on ART whose viral load is above 1000 copies must undergo enhanced adherence counselling to identify CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) preprint virus and it is for that reason that monitoring the change in viral load count among clients is useful for both clinicians and the nation at large as EAC reduces the chances of being switched to a second line ART regimen which is more costly. The information is needed to decide whether a significant viral load suppression before switching to a second-line regimen.
A study similar to ours in Swaziland reviewed that there is a lack of evidence on the sociodemographic and clinical determinants of change in viral load count after EAC sessions among patients who enrolled in the EAC program (PLHIV with high viral load count). 2 Therefore, it is important to evaluate the change in VL count during EAC sessions and its determinants among PLHIV with unsuppressed VL count.
The District health information system reports shows that Monze district has one of the highest people on ART a total of 18330 as of march. 6 According to the MER report, in the past six months, the district reported 723 new HIV positives from the health facilities. This is an alarming number which shows that there is still a continuous spread of infection despite the prevention measures being undertaken. This is why the study aims at assessing the outcome of EAC sessions on ART clients with high viral load in monze district, so as to identify gaps and provide recommendations in the management of these clients.

Study design and settings
This was a cross-sectional study that was used to review clients with high viral loads from health information systems and facility high viral load registers. The process of data collection involved reviewing the high viral load registers from 15 high volume facilities in Monze for clients presenting with high viral load from a period of 1 st October 2019 to 30 th March,2021. The information in these registers was then compiled and computed on an excel spreadsheet for data analysis.

Study participants and sample size
Participants were selected from among persons with a viral load of 1000 copies or greater and were accessing treatment from a particular health facility with a current on treatment of 170 clients or greater. This was from a period of 1 st October 2019 to 30 th March 2021. A cluster sampling method was used, the clusters being geographic areas then simple random sampling was done in these clusters. This was done in order to get a sample that would be . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) preprint

Demographical data
The data consisted of clients of clients both male and female across all age groups with a minimun age of 5 years old and the oldest age being 77years old. Out of the 616 clients analyzed, the mean age for unsuppression was 29.5, median age was 29. 57% (n=315) of the clients were female whereas 43% (n=265) were male. 28% of the the clients were below 15 years old (n=145) whereas 78% (n=441).
Comparison of suppressed and unsuppressed viral load before and after EAC.

Figure 1: Percentage of unsuppressed clients before and after EAC
The graph shows a comparison in the suppression levels of ART clients per facility, showing a general reduction in the percentage of unsuppressed following EAC. Facilities such as    . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.   is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review) preprint
The copyright holder for this this version posted December 21, 2021. ; The table above shows missed EAC sessions per facility. With a high missed appointments been seen by Hakunkula rural health centre.  8 . Even though our findings were not statistically significant, which could be attributed to the fact that our study faced challenges arising from incomplete data and only complete and well documented EAC sessions were included in the logistic regression. These studies also reviewed the challenge of no collection of repeat viral loads post three months of EAC sessions, a finding that is similar to that of our findings. 8,9 Females had a 40% likelihood of being unsuppressed at 95% CI(41% to 86%) compared to the males. The finding is consistent with a study in Mozambique that had a 61.2% likelihood of females to be unsuppressed. 10 The finding could also be debated on as the majority of clients on treatment are females as compared to male, hence the need to open up more differentiated service delivery models that will encourage male clinical attendance. The median age for un suppression was 29.6 years, which was similar with a finding in study that showed with 36.6% of those unsuppressed being paediatrics while 60.3% being adults (above 15years of age). 9

Logistic regression output
Out of the 616 clients with High viral loads analysed, only 23% of them were documented to have been switched to second line. This could have been attributed to both a gap in attributed to poor counselling skills from health care providers. 13 The shortfall of our study however was lack on quality data to assess the effectiveness of Enhanced adherence counselling which could be a direction for future studies. Additional barriers could have been from incomplete data in registers which were the primary data collection tools in this study.

Conclusion
We can conclude that there was an improvement in the outcomes of high viral load clients undergoing enhanced adherence counselling. Though this was not statistically significant under a 95% CI and this can be attributed to the various limitations in the study which included: incomplete post Viral load result documented in the register, incomplete EAC sessions and poor documentation of the client's final outcome. There is therefore need for the district health team to provide technical support to health facilities so as to improve the outcomes of Enhances adherence counselling especially in resource limited countries such as Zambia were the costs of second line treatment is high, re-suppression as a result of EAC sessions will be useful.

Limitations
The limitations to this study were the incomplete filling in of high viral load registers in most health facilities in Monze which led to limitations in analysis of some data elements such as the outcomes of EAC. Another limitation was missing data on variables such as age, ART start date that limited the analysis of other variables that could have made the study broader.
There was also a challenge of missing high viral load registers at facilities such Monze and Manungu urban clinics and this prevented us from using the high viral load registers in certain periods in which the timeframe corresponded to the prescribed period in the study methodology, this could have led to the leaving out significant of data elements that may have not affected our study outcomes. The study also did not include any competency . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) preprint assessments for the health care workers providing EAC, this could have also affected the outcomes and can be added to future studies.

Ethical considerations
Approval was obtained from the University of Lusaka. Additionally, approval was obtained from the National Health Research Authority. All participants in the study were required to participate voluntarily by providing informed consent, they were assured that no harm would come upon them should they decide not to take part in the study and they were not required to provide their personal identification information.

Conflict of interest
There was no conflict of interest

Funding
This research received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial or nonprofit sectors

MK
• Work conception. Data acquisition, analysis and interpretation.
• Approval of final manuscript.
• Accountable for all aspects of the work regarding its accuracy or integrity.

TS
• Work conception, Data analysis and interpretation.
• Approval of final manuscript.
• Accountable for all aspects of the work regarding its accuracy or integrity.
• Critical revisions for intellectual content.
• Data interpretation • Approval of final manuscript.
. CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) preprint The copyright holder for this this version posted December 21, 2021. ; • Accountable for all aspects of the work regarding its accuracy or integrity.
• Critical revisions for intellectual content.
• Data interpretation • Approval of final manuscript.
• Accountable for all aspects of the work regarding its accuracy or integrity.
• Critical revisions for intellectual content.
• Data interpretation • Approval of final manuscript.
• Accountable for all aspects of the work regarding its accuracy or integrity.