Toward a geography of community health workers in Niger: a geospatial analysis

Background Little is known about the geography of community health workers (CHWs), their contribution to geographical accessibility of primary health care (PHC) services, and strategies for optimizing efficiency of CHW deployment in the context of universal health coverage (UHC). Methods Using a complete georeferenced census of front-line health facilities and CHWs in Niger and other high resolution spatial datasets, we modelled travel times to front-line health facilities and CHWs between 2000-2013, accounting for training, essential commodities, and maximum population capacity. We estimated additional CHWs needed to maximize geographical accessibility of the population beyond the reach of existing front-line health facilities and CHWs. We assessed the efficiency of geographical targeting of the existing CHW network compared to modelled CHW networks designed to optimize geographical targeting of the estimated population, under-five deaths, and plasmodium falciparum malaria cases. Results The percent of the population within 60 minutes walking to the nearest CHW increased from 0{middle dot}0% to 17{middle dot}5% between 2000-2013, with 15{middle dot}5% within 60 minutes walking to the nearest CHW trained on integrated community case management (iCCM) -- making PHC services and iCCM, specifically, geographically accessible for an estimated 2{middle dot}3 million and 2{middle dot}0 million additional people, respectively. An estimated 10{middle dot}4 million people (59{middle dot}0%) remained beyond a 60-minute catchment of front-line health facilities and CHWs. Optimal deployment of 8064 additional CHWs could increase geographic coverage of the estimated total population from 41{middle dot}5% to 73{middle dot}6%. Geographical targeting of the existing CHW network was inefficient but optimized CHW networks could improve efficiency by 55{middle dot}0%-81{middle dot}9%, depending on targeting metric. Interpretations We provide the first high-resolution maps and estimates of geographical accessibility to CHWs at national scale, highlighting improvements between 2000-2013 in Niger, geographies where gaps remained, approaches for improving targeting, and the importance of putting CHWs on the map to inform planning in the context of UHC.


KEY QUESTIONS
What is already known?
• Previous studies have estimated geographical accessibility (as travel time) to CHWs for subnational areas only 1-4 and have assessed efficiency of the distribution of hospitals in low and middle-income countries. 5 What are the new findings?
• The percent of the population within 60 minutes walking to the nearest CHW increased from 0·0% to 17·5% between 2000-2013, with 15·5% within 60 minutes walking to the nearest CHW trained on integrated community case management (iCCM) -making PHC services and iCCM, specifically, geographically accessible for an estimated 2·3 million and 2·0 million additional people, respectively.
• An estimated 10·4 million people (59·0%) remained beyond a 60-minute catchment of front-line health facilities and CHWs in 2013, with important variation across subnational geographies, training of CHWs, and availability of essential commodities.
• Optimal deployment of 8064 additional CHWs could increase geographic coverage of the estimated total population from 41·5% to 73·6%, providing physical access to PHC services for an additional 5·7 million people not covered in 2013.
• Optimized CHW networks increased efficiency of geographical targeting compared to the existing CHW network by 55·0%-81·9%, depending on targeting metric.

What do the new findings imply?
• Geographical accessibility to primary health care services, including iCCM, improved in Niger between 2000-2013 with important contributions by CHWs.
• Gaps in geographical accessibility remained as of 2013 but scale-up of the CHW network, using the scale-up approach described in this study, could substantially increase geographical accessibility of PHC services.
• The efficiency of geographical targeting of the existing network of CHWs was suboptimal. The approach for optimizing efficiency of geographical targeting described in this study could be used to improve geographical targeting of CHW deployment in Niger and other countries.
• This work is a first step toward establishing a geography of CHWs in Niger and is a call to action to put CHWs on the map globally to inform health system planning and maximize geographical accessibility, efficiency, and impact of investments in the context of UHC.
. CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted February 3, 2021. We defined geographic coverage as the theoretical catchment area of a health service delivery 1 1 5 location, within a maximum travel time, accounting for the mode of transportation and the 1 1 6 maximum population coverage capacity of the type of health service delivery location. 29 We 1 1 7 used the "geographic coverage" module of AccessMod 5 (v5·6 ·48) 29 to estimate geographic 1 1 8 coverage for the CSI and CS-ASC networks in 2013 at 1km x 1km resolution for the two 1 1 9 travel scenarios. The maximum travel time was set at 60 minutes. The maximum population 1 2 0 capacity was set at 10000 for CSI and 2500 for CS-ASC based on norms of the MOPH of Niger. 18 The maximum extent of a catchment was therefore delimited by the maximum travel the maximum population capacity of the health service delivery location -in which case the 1 2 4 extent of the catchment was smaller than the maximum travel time and was defined by the 1 2 5 area containing the estimated population, up to the maximum population capacity. Assessing geographic coverage of a hypothetical scale-up network of RC 1 2 7 . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted February 3, 2021. ;https://doi.org/10.1101https://doi.org/10. /2021 To estimate the number of RC needed to maximize geographical accessibility of the 1 2 8 population beyond the geographic coverage of the existing CSI and CS-ASC networks, we 1 2 9 simulated a hypothetical network of RC in grid cells with at least 250 people in 2013 located 1 3 0 beyond the geographic coverage of the existing CSI and CS-ASC networks at 1km x 1km 1 3 1 resolution, using a ratio of 1 RC per 1000 population (with a minimum threshold of 250 1 3 2 people to allocate 1 RC). We conducted a geographic coverage analysis at 1km x 1km 1 3 3 resolution to estimate the percent of the estimated residual population that could be covered  We assessed the efficiency of geographical targeting of the CS-ASC network, using the  We assessed the potential effect of uncertainty of the estimates for under-five deaths and Pf  We did not involve patients or the public in this study. . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted February 3, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10. 1101/2021 Accessibility coverage of the ASC network increased from 0·0% to 17·5% between 2000-1 5 9 2013, with large variation at subnational levels, given a 60-minute cutoff and walking Appendix 1). Accessibility coverage of the ASC network trained on iCCM was 15·5% in 1 6 7 2013, given a 60-minute cutoff and walking scenario (Table 1, Figure 2D). The estimated  . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted February 3, 2021. and Supplementary Figure 3A-G, page 7 of Supplementary Appendix 1). Accessibility Geographic coverage of the estimated total population in 2013 by the CSI network was 1 9 0 22·1%, assuming a walking scenario with a 60-minute catchment and maximum population 1 9 1 capacity of 10000 per CSI (Figure 3 and Supplementary Appendix 3, tab "Summary"). Over 1 9 2 one-third (347) of the CSI realized less than 30% of their maximum population capacity,  CS-ASC realized less than 30% of their maximum population capacity, indicating   existing CSI and CS-ASC networks, could cover 54·9% of this estimated residual population 2 0 7 -providing physical access to PHC services for an estimated 5·7 million additional people in    Our results indicate that geographical accessibility of PHC services improved in Niger is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted February 3, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.02.21250043 doi: medRxiv preprint 1 2 under-five deaths and malaria burden -but could be improved through the targeting approach 2 4 6 used in this study. To our knowledge, this study provides the first estimates and high-resolution maps of 2 4 9 geographical accessibility to CHWs at national scale for any country. We used a bespoke 2 5 0 modelling approach with a complete national georeferenced census of front-line health 2 5 1 facilities and CHWs in Niger, other high resolution spatial datasets, and realistic assumptions. transportation used by Weiss and colleagues 34 are higher than those used in our model. colleagues 34 allowed for swimming across water barriers, whereas we did not but we allowed 2 6 5 travel over road bridges. Another study, Blanford and colleagues, 30 found that 39·1% of the 2 6 6 population were within 60 minutes walking of the nearest health facility in 2009. However, 2 6 7 their model used an incomplete network of hospitals and CSI (n=504) dating from 1995. We 2 6 8 consider our results, while imperfect, to be more useful for national planning in Niger than  Our scale-up analysis provides a useful roadmap for the MOPH to consider as it plans to 2 7 3 scale-up the RC network to fill gaps in physical access to PHC services, for example, by identifying optimal RC locations and enabling the prioritization of bins/groups of RC (the first 2 7 5 500 RC, next 500 RC and so on) that would maximize geographical accessibility, allowing a 2 7 6 phased approach to scale-up. Lastly, our analysis highlights important inefficiencies in 2 7 7 . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted February 3, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.02.21250043 doi: medRxiv preprint 1 3 geographical targeting of the existing CS-ASC network relative to estimates of the spatial suggests alternatives to guide fine-tuning of the network, and provides an approach that could 2 8 0 be used in future planning efforts to maximize efficiency of geographical targeting.

8 1
We acknowledge that, in addition to physical accessibility, it is important to consider social 2 8 2 and economic barriers to care seeking (e.g. social norms, intrahousehold power dynamics, response to contextual factors (e.g. the lockdowns due to COVID-19 in 2020).

8 8
There are important limitations to this study. First, we did not include secondary or tertiary 2 cover layer 15 in our merged land cover layer. We also conducted a sensitivity analysis using kind, but we acknowledge this is an important limitation and area for improving future 3 0 7 modelling. Fourth, our analysis does not account for national parks or other "no-go" zones 3 0 8 (e.g., military bases) due to lack of access to the geography of these objects for 2013. Fifth, 3 0 9 our travel speeds were based on similar analyses for Niger and other countries in sub-Saharan 3 1 0 . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.

(which was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted February 3, 2021. ;https://doi.org/10.1101https://doi.org/10. /2021 1 4 Africa 29,30 but could be improved through a country-led consensus-building process with 3 1 1 national experts to derive subnational travel speeds and validate other data inputs. Our travel 3 1 2 speeds do not account for differences in travel speeds by season 30 which may be relevant in 3 1 3 the Sahel, possible group differences (e.g., pregnant women, people with illness, and 3 1 4 caregivers carrying sick children may walk slower), river transportation, and our walking plus under-five mortality rates 27 and Pf malaria incidence 28 used in our targeting analysis is targeting approach could be used to confidently identify bins/groups of health service delivery 3 2 5 catchment areas that are relatively more efficient at geographical targeting than other 3 2 6 bins/groups -and that this information could be used in planning to enhance scale-up and 3 2 7 geographical targeting of CHWs.

2 8
We understand that rational decisions on scale-up and targeting of CHWs, like with health 3 2 9 facilities, cannot be addressed purely through modelling, as there are many factors involved in 3 3 0 the political economy of health system planning and decision-making. 40,41 Nonetheless, we 3 3 1 think our results provide novel insights for policy makers, practitioners and researchers and 3 3 2 future efforts can build on and refine this work through collaborative, country-led processes. geographical targeting of the RC network, using approaches to optimize deployment as 3 4 0 described here, could make an important contribution toward increasing geographical 3 4 1 accessibility to PHC services in Niger. These approaches could be adapted to meet planning 3 4 2 needs in other contexts. As Niger works toward UHC, developing a geography of the health 3 4 3 . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted February 3, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.02.21250043 doi: medRxiv preprint 1 5 system -as part of a broader spatial data infrastructure 42 -will be critical. Developing a 3 4 4 geography of CHWs within this broader context will be equally important for these purposes 3 4 5 and for maximizing efficiency, impact, and equity of investments in quality PHC within the 3 4 6 context of UHC. This study is one step toward a geography of CHWs in Niger and a call to 3 4 7 action for establishing a geography of CHWs globally. The views expressed in this article are the authors' views do not necessarily represent the  NR provided supervision and overall guidance. All authors contributed to reviewing and 3 6 0 editing the manuscript.