Persistence of the T12 Vibrio cholerae O1 lineage in West Africa: Insights from a Regional Sequencing Workshop

We sequenced 46 Vibrio cholerae isolates from Cameroon, Niger, and Nigeria, 37 of which were from 2018-2019. These sequences belong to the T12 lineage observed in the region since 2009, suggesting continuous transmission. Data were generated during a workshop in Nigeria, providing a model for future regionally coordinated surveillance efforts.


Molecular characterization of pandemic Vibrio cholerae has led to new insights about global cholera transmission
and has highlighted the important role of transmission within and between Asia and Africa (1). Combining genomic 30 and epidemiological data may allow us to better understand the dynamics of ongoing outbreaks, and advances in 31 sequencing technology have recently made whole genome sequencing more feasible even in low-resource settings. 32 Although recent studies have used whole genome sequences of V. cholerae O1 to better understand the global 33 movement patterns of seventh pandemic cholera in sub-Saharan Africa and elsewhere (1-4), regional and local 34 dynamics in West Africa-which reports cholera regularly-are still poorly understood. Epidemiological data 35 suggest outbreaks across this region may be connected (5-7), but the nature of recurring outbreaks in the region has 36 yet to be understood. It is unclear if cases go unreported in years between outbreaks or if each represents a distinct 37 pandemic V. cholerae introduction from outside the region. Discerning between these two transmission scenarios is 38 important for the development of locally-adapted and effective cholera control and prevention strategies. (2,066, 3,083, and 32,752, respectively) (8,9) after several years of reported low cholera incidence (Fig 1A). Broad  Previous studies have shown that the T1 lineage was the predominant lineage circulating in Cameroon,Nigeria,and 48 Nigeria in 1970, followed by the T7 and T9 lineages in the 1990s and early 2000s (1,2). Since 2009, only T12 has 49 been observed in these countries, and this appears to be the predominant lineage in Western Africa and nearby 50 countries in Central Africa. In any given year, the circulating V. cholerae lineage was the same in Cameroon, Niger, 51 and Nigeria (1,2), providing additional evidence that outbreaks in these countries are connected. As five years had 52 elapsed since the last published V. cholerae O1 genome in the region, we aimed to generate a contemporary 53 snapshot of recent V. cholerae O1 outbreaks to determine if recent cases were due to a new introduction of the 54 pathogen, and to gain new insights into regional cholera transmission dynamics and spread of antibiotic resistance.

55
. CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. In October 2019, researchers from Cameroon, Niger, Nigeria, and the United States came together to discuss the 65 specific cholera surveillance questions in these African countries and how whole genome sequencing can be used to 66 address them. Simultaneously, researchers generated whole genome sequences from V. cholerae isolates collected 67 in these countries and discussed plans for building a regional cholera genomics network to help inform cholera 68 preparedness and outbreak response.

69
A key component of this workshop was bringing together detailed epidemiological data from the three countries  (Fig 1B, Appendix Table 1). 75 We sequenced extracted DNA from these isolates on the Oxford Nanopore MinION and assembled genomes by 76 aligning the resulting sequencing reads to the seventh pandemic O1 reference genome, strain N16961 (GenBank 77 . CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) preprint The copyright holder for this this version posted September 25, 2020. . https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.24.20199026 doi: medRxiv preprint 4 accession: AE003852/AE003853) (1,10). We also performed antimicrobial resistance (AMR) gene detection on 78 these sequences and compared the results to previously published sequences.

79
Forty-four genomes produced reference-based assemblies (covering at least 95% of the N16961 reference at >100x 80 coverage, Appendix Table 2). We aligned these genomes to 1280 previously-published V. cholerae O1 whole 81 genome sequences (1,2,11,12) and generated a maximum likelihood tree from these data, which showed that all 44 82 isolates belong to the T12 lineage. Two sequenced isolates did not align to the reference (NGA_148_2019, 83 NGA_252_2019), and we found that the reads did not map to the wbe or wbf gene clusters associated with the O1   (Fig 2). Within this sub-clade, the 2018-2019 sequences are distinct. In concordance with the epidemiologic 94 data, the high similarity between sequences (including shared mutations in known AMR genes, see Appendix 95 Table 3 and 4) from the three countries suggests that their outbreaks are linked.   Expanded surveillance and additional sequencing data will be necessary to understand the interconnectedness of 117 populations across countries and achieve global elimination goals such as those outlined in the GTFCC Roadmap.

118
For example, limiting cross-border movement is an ineffective strategy in the presence of a natural reservoir 119 responsible for repeated reintroduction. Additionally, sequencing data can be used to detect and track resistance to 120 antibiotic treatments, and to identify potential new resistance-conferring mutations present in local isolates (15). A 121 regional cholera surveillance network could facilitate efforts to gather isolates, build the local capacity needed to 122 generate sequencing data, and ensure that these data are interpreted within the regional context. As a result of the 123 workshop, scientists from Cameroon, Niger, and Nigeria have all been trained in V. cholerae sequencing with the 124 Oxford Nanopore MinION platform; expanding sequencing knowledge and capacity beyond these three countries 125 will make it easy to generate the data needed to control cholera outbreaks in the region.

135
. CC-BY 4.0 International license It is made available under a is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. (which was not certified by peer review) preprint The copyright holder for this this version posted September 25, 2020. . https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.24.20199026 doi: medRxiv preprint